Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Furlough ending and lots of jobs available

112 replies

MLMbotsno · 30/09/2021 12:19

Ex colleague on furlough since the start moaning that furlough ends and may lose job. Had a whole year of staying at home paid furlough and knew this was a possibility did nothing to train or look for alternative to travel industry role of cabin crew.

Some sectors are calling out for staff but feels since cabin crew not all back should keep being paid. In normal times excess staff are laid off redundancy etc and have to go source another job.
In my opinion furlough has gone on long enough aibu? Cannot pay people to sit around anymore look fir another role.
Yabu furlough should continue for cabin crew etc to wait until sector fully recovers.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 01/10/2021 07:56

The cabin crew on my Facebook all got other jobs working at the covid site they are back on planes now

Seymour5 · 01/10/2021 07:47

Furlough actually meant a bit more than 80% in income. NI, income tax and pension contributions would be proportionally lower, and no travel costs.

I volunteer alongside paid staff who were furloughed when non essential retail was closed. That was their experience. Also working outside the home meant sometimes paying for lunches and having to replace clothes or shoes, all of which cost. In general, they weren’t any worse off and quite enjoyed the break!

choixx · 01/10/2021 07:37

You keep saying hgv driver, but there are so many other jobs open right now, from delivery driving and supermarkets to cybersecurity and social media.

You mentioned lorry driving but I this shortage is nothing new in that area.

Re the other part of your post and as pp has said many of these jobs are not f/t etc. Crucially people have moved into other industries eg hospitality, around 40% have moved into other areas.

JustLyra · 01/10/2021 03:42

My SIL has been turned down for every job she’s applied for and the ones that have given feedback have all said that they don’t want to take in cabin crew as they feel they’ll just have to recruit again when travel picks up.

It’s not as simple as just finding another job. While she was furloughed she wasn’t allowed to work elsewhere either.

Timeforachangetoday12 · 01/10/2021 00:44

Furlough had to have an end point-it was never going to go on forever!

The people i know that had been furlough the majority of them had already got new jobs (in some cases better) a friend who loved working in the hotel industry started a new job last year, a friend who was cabin crew now works in the doctor’s surgery. They couldn’t afford to stay on 80% for a length of time so have now used their skills in other ways to find new jobs. They were also bored!! Another friend demanded to be kept on furlough till after the summer holidays and promptly quit her job when they asked her to return.
Speaking to others like people have said they want FT hours but retail places only offering 16 hours. Promise of more but I guess that’s just for Christmas! They can’t take the risk to live on 16 hours!

sandgrown · 01/10/2021 00:32

Many retail jobs only offer a few contracted hours but there is scope for lots of overtime. People who only earn low wages may still be able to claim Universal Credit . I know a lady who works as cabin crew but wasn’t too proud to take a waitressing job to top up her furlough pay.

Chersfrozenface · 01/10/2021 00:12

I walked past a shop on a retail park this morning and in the window was a notice saying jobs were available. Out of curiosity I looked for these jobs online. There were 16, the most hours being offered were 16 hours per week, and 11 were under 10 hours per week.

So there may be vacancies, but are the jobs worth having? Could you live on the wages?

JudgeJ · 01/10/2021 00:05

@ohnotanotherusername

I'm with you OP. I know too many people on furlough who have been lording it up, some even boasting about being paid to not work.
A firend of mine was due to retire in May 2020 but she decided to 'stay on' when furlough was offered so she had over a year of still being paid.
OverTheRubicon · 30/09/2021 23:50

@choixx

However we are now in a position where for the entire summer there have been huge numbers of jobs available, and people often not taking them because it risked them losing benefits or their furlough money. I do appreciate that this is mostly the fault of a crappy benefits system that puts people at massive risk of not being able to sign back on if they take a summer job or try out a new job.

However the end result is a lot of people being paid not to work, while hospitality venues and shops couldn't run a full service and recoup lockdown losses, for lack of employees, and there are masses of jobs out there in so many sectors.

But is this actually true statistically, I mean a waitress isn't go to become a HGV driver & a cabin crew person isn't necessarily be able to work as a chef.

Lots of hospitality workers have got other jobs with better pay/conditions so don't want to go back. Supermarkets for example have recruited more people.

That's mad, and in the long run, will likely hurt the people it's supposed to be helping right now, by letting them hold onto hope when a good number of them could have done a course in JavaScript, or lorry driving, or contacted the number in the window of the local shop, and be earning a salary by now.

There are thousands of people in this country who have HGV licenses & don't want the job & Im not sure it's so easy to train as one.

If I lost my job tmw I wouldn't be a HGV driver either.

You keep saying hgv driver, but there are so many other jobs open right now, from delivery driving and supermarkets to cybersecurity and social media.

The waitress (/waiter) wouldn't need to change jobs, the demand is absolutely massive. Cabin crew may not be suited to every job out there, but nor have the hundred of thousands of other people who were made redundant in recent years pre-covid, but I can only imagine the outcry if a factory was moved overseas and after an extended period of leave at public expense, former workers announced that they didn't fancy working in care homes or doing deliveries, but wanted to stay a bit longer being paid while waiting for a new factory that might never come. And cabin crew have very transferrable skills that should land them something considerably more comfortable than those jobs.

choixx · 30/09/2021 21:47

However we are now in a position where for the entire summer there have been huge numbers of jobs available, and people often not taking them because it risked them losing benefits or their furlough money. I do appreciate that this is mostly the fault of a crappy benefits system that puts people at massive risk of not being able to sign back on if they take a summer job or try out a new job.

However the end result is a lot of people being paid not to work, while hospitality venues and shops couldn't run a full service and recoup lockdown losses, for lack of employees, and there are masses of jobs out there in so many sectors.

But is this actually true statistically, I mean a waitress isn't go to become a HGV driver & a cabin crew person isn't necessarily be able to work as a chef.

Lots of hospitality workers have got other jobs with better pay/conditions so don't want to go back. Supermarkets for example have recruited more people.

That's mad, and in the long run, will likely hurt the people it's supposed to be helping right now, by letting them hold onto hope when a good number of them could have done a course in JavaScript, or lorry driving, or contacted the number in the window of the local shop, and be earning a salary by now.

There are thousands of people in this country who have HGV licenses & don't want the job & Im not sure it's so easy to train as one.

If I lost my job tmw I wouldn't be a HGV driver either.

Crikeyalmighty · 30/09/2021 21:35

It’s all very well people saying lots of jobs available— in certain sectors yes but I too wouldn’t have exactly rushed out there if I was cabin crew to go and pack vegetables etc, unless I really needed the money. Also some flight crew ‘will’ be coming back— easyJet for instance haven’t started a great many of their routes till November 1st. Unfortunately though I do know it’s more likely they will retain more staff with EU passports - and we know why that is and it’s not covid.

OverTheRubicon · 30/09/2021 21:35

[quote choixx]@OverTheRubicon but you aren't comparing the same situation. This was millions of people whose jobs were stopped by the government in order to reduce the spread of a virus. They wanted to keep millions of people complacent & at home & they wanted to keep companies & jobs going where possible once things reopened.

Of course the system wasn't perfect & I agree that the SE were hit hard. However in terms of the economy & reducing the spread furlough was a good thing. I can see that despite working the whole time. [/quote]
Yes, absolutely agree with this, during the early stages of lockdown and uncertainty. However we are now in a position where for the entire summer there have been huge numbers of jobs available, and people often not taking them because it risked them losing benefits or their furlough money. I do appreciate that this is mostly the fault of a crappy benefits system that puts people at massive risk of not being able to sign back on if they take a summer job or try out a new job.

However the end result is a lot of people being paid not to work, while hospitality venues and shops couldn't run a full service and recoup lockdown losses, for lack of employees, and there are masses of jobs out there in so many sectors.

That's mad, and in the long run, will likely hurt the people it's supposed to be helping right now, by letting them hold onto hope when a good number of them could have done a course in JavaScript, or lorry driving, or contacted the number in the window of the local shop, and be earning a salary by now.

choixx · 30/09/2021 21:21

Sorry to hear that @Twentypast

Twentypast · 30/09/2021 21:06

This is a bit outing but I am an airport manager for an airline with no flights because our home country has shut its borders. On furlough I got a lot less than 80% of my salary because of the cap. I applied for a few jobs but I'm in my early 60s and I'm sure my age explains why I couldn't even get a minimum wage job. One company told me straight out I was over qualified and they felt sure I would leave as soon as aviation recovered so wouldn't hire me. At 62 my options are limited.

Weepingwillows12 · 30/09/2021 20:25

2021 sorry

Weepingwillows12 · 30/09/2021 20:25

I just checked some IATA stats and global flying is 50% of rpks in August 2031 Vs 2019 and that reflects a wide range between countries with China being almost back to normal but the UK still very down year on year.

Weepingwillows12 · 30/09/2021 20:23

Less people flying for business is definitely a possibility but the border closures and traffic light system and testing regimes are the main issues. When they lift a more realistic view of long term impact on business travel can be seen.

choixx · 30/09/2021 20:11

@OverTheRubicon but you aren't comparing the same situation. This was millions of people whose jobs were stopped by the government in order to reduce the spread of a virus. They wanted to keep millions of people complacent & at home & they wanted to keep companies & jobs going where possible once things reopened.

Of course the system wasn't perfect & I agree that the SE were hit hard. However in terms of the economy & reducing the spread furlough was a good thing. I can see that despite working the whole time.

hellsbells99 · 30/09/2021 20:10

Airlines are not back to normal at all. My DH works for one and has continued to work due to his role but has had to take a forced pay cut. There are less flights running and less passengers flying. One flight he went on last night only had 40 passengers on - the airline would be making a loss on that flight.

OverTheRubicon · 30/09/2021 20:01

@choixx

This might sound harsh but claiming that their training has to be paid for by taxpayers when they had more than a year with no work to do is not really fair.

But why is it fair that I worked & didn't get a salary cut & have a fairly secure job?

If you're going to take that view, then why is it ever fair that some people have more pay than others? Why is it fair that someone who lost their job right before covid due to a factory moving overseas gets only job seekers, while someone who lost their job 3 months later gets 18 months pay? None of this is fair, and I did have sympathy for those on furlough, especially if only on min wage to start with, but none left now.

I, like many others, had to both work and manage childcare before then being made redundant during the early stages of covid and was left to manage on £74.70 per week and seeking single-parent-friendly jobs that didn't exist, while running down the savings that were meant to be a house deposit. Many self employed people got not even that much.

Anyone without a job after furlough should of course have access to unemployment benefits, but that's enough.

Lightswitch123 · 30/09/2021 19:51

@ThinWomansBrain

I was speaking to someone the other week, furloughed since the start of all this, has been working elsewhere whilst still getting furlough pay - and whinging that it is ending.

Not all jobs require retraining. Most people still on furlough have had eighteen months to assess their skill set and work out (and apply for) alternative employment paths that their existing skills and experience could be useful for - and the cushion of being paid while they do that.

Exactly.. furlough should have been ended in June 2020
ThinWomansBrain · 30/09/2021 19:47

with many people being concerned about global warming, maybe airline traffic will not retunn to prepandemic levels.
There will still be some business travel, but probably less as people realise that a lot of meetings can be covered remotely, and maybe people will now appreciate that they don't have to fly off on holidays and minibreaks every month.

sst1234 · 30/09/2021 18:39

I agree about the point that aviation should be protected. Aviation suffered artificially when travel was shut down. There was and will be demand for travel, and it will become expensive as supply goes down because people are leaving the sector.
For some other sectors though, they have been i decline for a long time and the Pandemic just speeded it up. Anyone working on the high street, for instance, or in a pub had a year to look for an alternative industry. Both areas have been in decline for a couple of decades.

notimagain · 30/09/2021 18:32

They are BU, if they haven't been unfurloughed by now (let's face it flights have been running for months)

No they mostly haven’t, certainly as far as the UK airlines are concerned.

Yes there has been a bit of an upturn in the last few weeks, especially on short haul routes, and most especially on holiday routes but the frequency of flights between most destinations is still massively down on what it was maybe two years.

It’s even worse on many Long haul routes, entry requirements to many places are such that many flights are still carrying belly freight only, no passengers, so often zero requirement for cabin crew.

Looking ahead the likes of BA and Virgin are really still up against it until the States open up fully on a month or so…..so all in all not everybody flying at some UK airlines are going to back at work on anything like a full time roster for quite some time yet.

Given the time it takes to get people trained or requalified the airlines have probably have to try harder than many companies in other industries to hold onto staff, for fear of being shorthanded if demand returns in a hurry - there are more than a few UK airlines trying to do as in Minfilia describes..keeping staff on as long a possible on reduced (sometimes very reduced) T&Cs.

choixx · 30/09/2021 18:16

Yes that's another problem, staff need to be retained somewhat so that when they are needed you have them to cope with demand.