Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Furlough ending and lots of jobs available

112 replies

MLMbotsno · 30/09/2021 12:19

Ex colleague on furlough since the start moaning that furlough ends and may lose job. Had a whole year of staying at home paid furlough and knew this was a possibility did nothing to train or look for alternative to travel industry role of cabin crew.

Some sectors are calling out for staff but feels since cabin crew not all back should keep being paid. In normal times excess staff are laid off redundancy etc and have to go source another job.
In my opinion furlough has gone on long enough aibu? Cannot pay people to sit around anymore look fir another role.
Yabu furlough should continue for cabin crew etc to wait until sector fully recovers.

OP posts:
notimagain · 01/10/2021 22:16

@MarbleRunaway

I think it's time to let unviable business / jobs go now.

So we leave airport terminals shut, planes grounded and accept that long haul travel to Africa, South America, most of Asia is unviable now and we just let it go?

I don’t think exactly that will happen because I’m not quite sure those keen on the demise of the aviation industry have really thought this through Hmm….

I suspect if one or two major UK airlines go under, maybe because of Uk government action or inaction, most if not all the movement slots they lose at places like Heathrow, Gatwick and Manchester will be gobbled up by foreign airlines many of whom are or have received support from their own governments, many of whom are now not quite so hamstrung with Covid regulations and restrictions on international travel as the Uk continues to be.

That means most likely European, American operators and/or the ME3 will step in to serve Uk airports by extending their route networks ..good news for foreign airlines and their employees, good news for Brits who still want to travel, bad news for those who thought they were headed for a quiet life.

In the meantime another x thousand skilled jobs will have gone from Britain, along with the associated NI and income tax contributions from many relatively high earners….

But seeing as recent events have shown some in a position of influence in the UK don’t really understand logistics/the transport industry I guess anything is possible.

Ploorfuzzle · 01/10/2021 22:10

Seems crazy to keep it going when there are so many vacancies across many industries to keep paying people in sectors that might not recover for a long time.

Sleepdeprived42long · 01/10/2021 22:07

I would work in any job I could if it paid the bills and kept a roof over my head-even if it wasn’t the one I trained for. Life is unpredictable. If it hadn’t been COVID it could have been something else. Time for furloughed staff to start looking at other jobs if they can’t go back to their previous role-it’s been too long paying furlough and we’re already all going to be paying back the bill for many years to come.

MarbleRunaway · 01/10/2021 21:42

I think it's time to let unviable business / jobs go now.

So we leave airport terminals shut, planes grounded and accept that long haul travel to Africa, South America, most of Asia is unviable now and we just let it go?

MarbleRunaway · 01/10/2021 21:40

For the travel industry, furlough shouldn’t end until international travel is fully open. We still have vast numbers on the red list, many without justification to be there.

If your friend loves travel, has a career in travel and will continue to have a career in travel once things reopen then why should they retrain and do some they don’t necessarily like or are suited to just because the government has chosen to not support the one industry still shut

PixieLaLa · 01/10/2021 21:36

Cannot pay people to sit around anymore

I agree it’s time for furlough to end but isn’t this essentially what happens with all the people who can work but claim benefits. MN can be very double standards!

StellaCinnamon · 01/10/2021 21:24

Why would anyone sit around waiting for redundancy?? Surely furlough was the best chance to get out and prepare. Yanbu

What…really?

I mean I’m not saying I wouldn’t be looking around or doing some training etc. But if I’d been with my employer for several years and was due a decent redundancy payment what would I have to lose by waiting it out?

BitterTits · 01/10/2021 20:52

I think it's time to let unviable business / jobs go now. Society has given people on furlough their best shot. As for 80% I pay a good 15% of my income on transport and more on childcare, so I don't think they've done badly at all.

Sometimeswinning · 01/10/2021 20:35

Why would anyone sit around waiting for redundancy?? Surely furlough was the best chance to get out and prepare. Yanbu.

postingfortraffichere · 01/10/2021 20:07

YANBU, completely agree OP - what did some people think was going to happen?

MorganKitten · 01/10/2021 12:54

You are allowed to work n another job whilst on furlough though so need not be on 80% 'waiting ' as you say fir redundancy.

Not true for every job, it depends on what your contract states. At work ours said if you take another job you lose furlough and will be more likely to be made redundant before others.
This happened to several employees.

It was better for me to be on my 80% and be able to pay my bills and just about eat than risk not having anything to return to. I didn’t sit around though, I made sure to be busy everyday to stop being bored and judged by people like you saying we all just sat around.

TheKeatingFive · 01/10/2021 11:23

But you can’t be both redundant and receiving furlough. Once you’re redundant, furlough ends. Which is probably why companies are holding out as long as possible before taking that step.

Theflamingnerd · 01/10/2021 11:04

@TheKeatingFive that was meant to be a Rey to you, the quote didn't work!

Theflamingnerd · 01/10/2021 11:03

You can be made redundant whilst you're on furlough. You get paid your usual notice period, it's up to the company if they want you to work during this period or remain on leave. Once your notice period ends you get your redundancy payout and final payslip

StellaCinnamon · 01/10/2021 10:43

You’d be bonkers not to hold out for redundancy though.

TheKeatingFive · 01/10/2021 09:50

But you can’t be both furloughed and made redundant at the same time.

Presumably many companies are holding out until the furlough scheme is finished before making people redundant. And naturally as an employee you’d hold out for that because there may be a redundancy package.

Ylvamoon · 01/10/2021 09:44

The bottom line is, if you are made redundant from your job, you have no income. (Furlough or no furlough) Naturally, you'd have to look for an other job in order to live.

notimagain · 01/10/2021 09:36

@justasking111

Get a hospitality job to keep his hand in and keep looking for an opening in his field again
In the case of the OP the situation was said to be:

Ex colleague on furlough since the start moaning that furlough ends and may lose job….

So they it appears are still hanging onto the flying job and if they’ve got any sense they’ll carry on hanging on as long as possible, right to the bitter end if it gets to that.

Reason is most/many airlines have a seniority based system for crew and voluntarily leaving now with a view to perhaps rejoining in the future at the bottom end of the scale wouldn’t be the smartest move…

OTOH Having a second job, if it’s permissible and fits in with any work the airline is still rostering, makes sense…

justasking111 · 01/10/2021 08:58

Get a hospitality job to keep his hand in and keep looking for an opening in his field again

Theflamingnerd · 01/10/2021 08:22

@bebanjo

Fruit and veg is rotting in British Filds because no one want to pick it. When the prices go through the roof those unwilling to do the shit job short term will no it was nothing to do with them. Social care is in crises, bed blocking in hospitals because there are no cares so cannot go home, but when hospitals can’t admit anymore, those unwilling to do a shit job will know it’s nothing to do with them. The haulage industry in in crises, but when there is no food in the shops and the prices go through the roof, those unwilling to do a shit job will no it’s nothing to do with them. It’s funny how the government should bail out people who have up to now been quit fortunate but those same people do not see them self’s as part of a wider community that has jobs that need doing now, even if they are shit. Or maybe we should have a new underclass of humans, the scum of the earth maybe who can be tasked with the shit that the privileged don’t want to do.
Ah, but when fruit picking is suggested for benefits claimants we're told by the MN screaming hordes that it's demeaning, the hours don't fit in around childcare, it's not enough to live on.

When social care is suggested for benefits claimants the MN screaming horde tell us that we don't want unqualified people looking after our grannies. Nobody should be forced into social care because it will affect the quality of care.

So we can't expect people who actively choose a lifestyle of unemployment into these roles, but we can judge people who were working, expecting to go back into their roles, have worked their entire lives, contributed significant amounts of tax and NI and expect them to pick up these roles? (I'm aware those on benefits pay NI, but as it was never their money, they haven't actually paid it, the govt has just taken some of their own money back, and as benefits are generally lower than salary the contributions would be less than someone who is employed)

Furlough can't go on forever, but that doesn't mean we can't sympathise with people who have found themselves stuck on it in the anticipation of going back to their job.

notimagain · 01/10/2021 08:17

@SaltySheepdog

They should utilise their skills another way until the travel industry picks up. However who knows, this could be years and there maybe permanent changes as much business is done over zoom now and will remain that way
With the US opening shortly to non citizens and announcements tha5 Australia may relax requirements at the end of the year there are signs it is picking up.

As for employees (particularly crew) utilizing their skills in another way..it’s a two edged sword for the employers….they have an interest in keeping people on the books and working to some extent because the costs and time required to retraining qualify crew whose clearances and tests have expired can be considerable.

SaltySheepdog · 01/10/2021 08:08

They should utilise their skills another way until the travel industry picks up. However who knows, this could be years and there maybe permanent changes as much business is done over zoom now and will remain that way

bebanjo · 01/10/2021 08:05

At least 3 haulage companies near me are offering £1000 just to take the job, they are paying all trading cost, they are paying £15 an hour.
Things are changing.

bebanjo · 01/10/2021 08:02

Fruit and veg is rotting in British Filds because no one want to pick it.
When the prices go through the roof those unwilling to do the shit job short term will no it was nothing to do with them.
Social care is in crises, bed blocking in hospitals because there are no cares so cannot go home, but when hospitals can’t admit anymore, those unwilling to do a shit job will know it’s nothing to do with them.
The haulage industry in in crises, but when there is no food in the shops and the prices go through the roof, those unwilling to do a shit job will no it’s nothing to do with them.
It’s funny how the government should bail out people who have up to now been quit fortunate but those same people do not see them self’s as part of a wider community that has jobs that need doing now, even if they are shit.
Or maybe we should have a new underclass of humans, the scum of the earth maybe who can be tasked with the shit that the privileged don’t want to do.

Theflamingnerd · 01/10/2021 07:58

For anyone insisting that furloughed/redundant staff simply just become a HGV driver, please actually read up on what that entails. It's not something you just decide to do and enter into on a whim.

I'll save you the trouble of googling, start here -
mobile.twitter.com/infofoundationx/status/1441738825575768069?s=19

Now explain to me how someone on reduced, or now possibly no wages will be able to enter the profession? Explain to me why people with previously favourable working conditions would want to trade that in for the shit show that being a HGV driver entails?

Yes furlough absolutely needs to end, but I have nothing but sympathy for people who were hoping to return to roles they loved, were qualified for, trained their entire lifetimes for.