Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cheater's wedding- to go or not to go?

210 replies

VeryOldPoster · 30/09/2021 11:24

Old poster, but don't want to be found out.
I am married to a lovely man, he is from a foreign country. His family member lives here too, married to a lovely woman. She doesn't want children, whereas he does. Somehow, family back home think that it is perfectly fine for him to 'marry' somebody else back home. I said to my DH I don't want to go to this wedding as it is so against any common decency. He thinks 'it is just a party' and we should go 'to show respect'. Absolutely have no desire to go and thinks that 'respect' is not the word I want to use in this situation.
We know his wife here, go to see them all the time.
Funnily enough, few of my friends said I should go to a wedding as it will be lovely experience- they are organising really big, posh wedding, which I have never been to. This took me by surprise. AIBU to think I would rather chop the groom to a police for bigamy and tell his english wife, rather than go and 'enjoy' myself at this mock-of-a-wedding party?

OP posts:
BudrosBudrosGalli · 30/09/2021 18:24

Think only one other poster asked what about money! Besides the moral and legal side of things, where is the money to support the second wife and children supposed to come from?! That would probably be thieving joint marital assets, unless they keep their finances totally separate.

Sciurus83 · 30/09/2021 18:17

You have to tell her!! Usually I'm of the keep out of it let people be school but this is way way over the line. You talk about children as if that's the justification for this? That English wife doesn't want them so it is what, expected he would have an Indian wife and children with her? That is just so far into not ok. Are you afraid you will be blamed for the fallout? I don't think you should mess about trying to tell his parents he is already married, they have much less to lose. Please tell her. She should get to decide what she wants from her life.

GreatPotato · 30/09/2021 18:15

Is he planning to come back?

Nc4post99 · 30/09/2021 18:14

@VeryOldPoster

He is married legally here, we went to a Registry wedding in the Uk, lovely party afterwards. I don't really want to ask my PILs if they know anything about cousin's marriage situation now. They certainly know he is married in the UK. There were some family members of my DH and his cousin at the wedding, although, not his parents- the reason at the time was given that they were too old to travel to the UK, but it might have been that they did not want to attend the wedding. Who knows now. Cousin is 34 now, is not like he is some youngster, just relenting to his parents' wishes. I think is him, it's just him- cheating b*d with no morals.
Am I right assuming they are Muslim?

Is there a chance they are just doing a nikah back home and not registering it there either? I’m not sure how Indian law works re marriage but unless he plans to divorce wife 1 he wouldn’t be able to bring wife 2 to the country so I’m really unclear what the point is of marrying someone so far away from where he lives. If it’s a case of cheating or taking a second wife to have kids with them surely there are easier ways in the Uk and already many ‘suitable’ girls here

RampantIvy · 30/09/2021 18:05

Someone should tell his parents that he is legally married.

Twizbe · 30/09/2021 17:41

@VeryOldPoster

He is married legally here, we went to a Registry wedding in the Uk, lovely party afterwards. I don't really want to ask my PILs if they know anything about cousin's marriage situation now. They certainly know he is married in the UK. There were some family members of my DH and his cousin at the wedding, although, not his parents- the reason at the time was given that they were too old to travel to the UK, but it might have been that they did not want to attend the wedding. Who knows now. Cousin is 34 now, is not like he is some youngster, just relenting to his parents' wishes. I think is him, it's just him- cheating b*d with no morals.
His parents don't know he's married or believe it's a 'wild oats' situation and not a real marriage.

Please, tell his wife. She's going to find out sooner or later.

ProfessionalWeirdo · 30/09/2021 17:30

I do wonder if, rather than his current marriage having only been a religious ceremony rather than a legal one, it’s the opposite - he had a registry office wedding and is justifying his bigamous marriage to himself on the basis that his first one didn’t count, as it wasn’t recognised in his religion.

Slightly off-topic, but I seem to remember our very own Prime Minister recently using this excuse to justify having a Roman Catholic wedding in Westminster Cathedral, despite already having been married and divorced - twice. He claimed that as his previous two marriages were both secular, neither of them were recognised by the Roman Catholic church.

HannaHanna · 30/09/2021 17:06

@VeryOldPoster

I know what you mean but in our case I suspect no matter what DH did the outcome would be the same. At least he can live with his conscience this way. She does not want to look at the truth of her situation, so instead is being mean to other people who know about it.

I would not be able to participate in this charade and would absolutely tell the BIL and your DH - 'If you don't tell her, I will have to do so.' I would be raising hell with your DH if he is willing to abide this - because it means that marriage means nothing to him.

VeryOldPoster · 30/09/2021 16:48

He is married legally here, we went to a Registry wedding in the Uk, lovely party afterwards.
I don't really want to ask my PILs if they know anything about cousin's marriage situation now. They certainly know he is married in the UK. There were some family members of my DH and his cousin at the wedding, although, not his parents- the reason at the time was given that they were too old to travel to the UK, but it might have been that they did not want to attend the wedding. Who knows now.
Cousin is 34 now, is not like he is some youngster, just relenting to his parents' wishes. I think is him, it's just him- cheating b*d with no morals.

OP posts:
UltimateBugKilla · 30/09/2021 16:44

If his wife is as lovely as you say, she doesn't deserve to be dragged into all this, poor girl, give her the truth and allow her to choose herself if she wants to be involved in this or not.

WomanStanleyWoman · 30/09/2021 16:39

@Nc4post99

Because *@GreatPotato* they could have had just a religious marriage.

From the sounds of it, they are muslim or at least the husband is, not all of these weddings are civilly registered (same goes for Hindu and other ‘minority’ faith weddings).

The woman may have had a wedding and may well consider herself to be married but it doesn’t mean she legally is. I married my husband religiously before I did legally, it’s very very common. In my ILs I’d say actually those married legally are a minority. I’d also say if the husband is looking my to marry from back home, the girls family from back home will be banking on the fact she is brought to the UK, so as a result that marriage will be the legal one. I wish I didn’t have experience of this but FIL has done the exact same thing.

I would also be interested to know if the marriage is legal. Is the OP even 100% sure of the cousin’s marital status? Maybe he publicly refers to her as his ‘wife’ in the UK, but has spun her some line about how he can’t legally marry her because of cultural reasons etc. It still makes him a piece of shit, but being a piece of shit is not a criminal offence.

That’s just one reason why those saying ‘Call the police, he’s a bigamist!’ are wide of the mark. Even if he is legally married to his current partner, the OP can’t call the police and say this man is planning to commit bigamy. All she knows is that he’s planning a wedding. There’s no law against becoming engaged to someone whilst still married to someone else - as far as the police are concerned, he could be divorced by the time the wedding comes around. (The OP may believe there is no chance of this, but the opinion of the potential bigamist’s cousin’s wife doesn’t have a legal standing.)

I do wonder if, rather than his current marriage having only been a religious ceremony rather than a legal one, it’s the opposite - he had a registry office wedding and is justifying his bigamous marriage to himself on the basis that his first one didn’t count, as it wasn’t recognised in his religion.

WomanStanleyWoman · 30/09/2021 16:39

@Nc4post99

Because *@GreatPotato* they could have had just a religious marriage.

From the sounds of it, they are muslim or at least the husband is, not all of these weddings are civilly registered (same goes for Hindu and other ‘minority’ faith weddings).

The woman may have had a wedding and may well consider herself to be married but it doesn’t mean she legally is. I married my husband religiously before I did legally, it’s very very common. In my ILs I’d say actually those married legally are a minority. I’d also say if the husband is looking my to marry from back home, the girls family from back home will be banking on the fact she is brought to the UK, so as a result that marriage will be the legal one. I wish I didn’t have experience of this but FIL has done the exact same thing.

I would also be interested to know if the marriage is legal. Is the OP even 100% sure of the cousin’s marital status? Maybe he publicly refers to her as his ‘wife’ in the UK, but has spun her some line about how he can’t legally marry her because of cultural reasons etc. It still makes him a piece of shit, but being a piece of shit is not a criminal offence.

That’s just one reason why those saying ‘Call the police, he’s a bigamist!’ are wide of the mark. Even if he is legally married to his current partner, the OP can’t call the police and say this man is planning to commit bigamy. All she knows is that he’s planning a wedding. There’s no law against becoming engaged to someone whilst still married to someone else - as far as the police are concerned, he could be divorced by the time the wedding comes around. (The OP may believe there is no chance of this, but the opinion of the potential bigamist’s cousin’s wife doesn’t have a legal standing.)

I do wonder if, rather than his current marriage having only been a religious ceremony rather than a legal one, it’s the opposite - he had a registry office wedding and is justifying his bigamous marriage to himself on the basis that his first one didn’t count, as it wasn’t recognised in his religion.

MissMarpleRocks · 30/09/2021 16:31

Both women about to be stitched up good & proper.

cabingirl · 30/09/2021 16:15

Do you have a printed or digital wedding invitation? I'd send it to the wife - let her take it from there.

But I definitely wouldn't be travelling for the wedding. And I'd find it difficult to be married to someone who thinks bigamy is okay.

Nc4post99 · 30/09/2021 16:14

Because @GreatPotato they could have had just a religious marriage.

From the sounds of it, they are muslim or at least the husband is, not all of these weddings are civilly registered (same goes for Hindu and other ‘minority’ faith weddings).

The woman may have had a wedding and may well consider herself to be married but it doesn’t mean she legally is. I married my husband religiously before I did legally, it’s very very common. In my ILs I’d say actually those married legally are a minority. I’d also say if the husband is looking my to marry from back home, the girls family from back home will be banking on the fact she is brought to the UK, so as a result that marriage will be the legal one. I wish I didn’t have experience of this but FIL has done the exact same thing.

ProfessionalWeirdo · 30/09/2021 16:14

@FrogFairy

Also, given your husband’s acceptance of this, in your shoes I would be looking over my shoulder and wondering if this could be me in the future.
Or even in the present...
FrogFairy · 30/09/2021 16:03

Also, given your husband’s acceptance of this, in your shoes I would be looking over my shoulder and wondering if this could be me in the future.

FrogFairy · 30/09/2021 16:02

Aside from the moral implications of cheating/bigamy there is also the fact that the second wife and any children will need to be supported emotionally and financially by this man.

This could potentially have a big impact on his first wife whether they stay together or split up. In her shoes I would be divorcing and taking my share of the assets now.

Twizbe · 30/09/2021 16:01

@GreatPotato there are a few things that make a wedding legal here in the uk. Lots of people don't realise that not all religious marriage ceremonies are legal. It's very easy to find yourself in a situation where you're not legally married.

VeryOldPoster · 30/09/2021 16:01

@HannaHanna

My DH was unwillingly dragged into a situation like this in the US. It was beyond bizarre - the man came to him for advice once he returned home and decided he had made a mistake. He feared legal trouble here. I suspect the second wife found out he's useless and threw him out, then later found out he was already married.

DH told him "If you don't tell your wife by this weekend, I am going to tell her." He did tell her, and she decided to "work on her marriage" and thanked my DH for encouraging him to confess. Told him of course she already knew something was up. She soon shipped him back to his country of origin.

However, within a few months the US based wife, who had been a friend of ours, took him back and sent money to pay off the other wife. Loads of drama and now she is really quite unpleasant to my DH and anyone else who knows about her very unhealthy situation.

That's what I am trying to avoid. I don't want to be blamed for, inevitable, fall out!
OP posts:
GreatPotato · 30/09/2021 15:56

@Nc4post99

People need to stop saying it’s bigamy and the man can go to jail. It sucks as it’s a gross situation but it’s probably quite unlikely that he and his British wife are legally married.

If they aren’t legally married then it’s not bigamy and no legal crime has occurred (i say legal because it’s clearly a moral one). So calling the police is a waste of time it won’t do anything because it’s basically adultery which isn’t a criminal matter.

If his English believes she had a wedding in England why wouldn't it be legal?
GreatPotato · 30/09/2021 15:55

What exactly about this situation does DH think you need to respect?

Did groom not have any family at his actual wedding?

Do weddings in India have the bit where people are asked about just impediments?

DismantledKing · 30/09/2021 15:43

Your husband doesn’t sound like a ‘lovely man’. He sounds like a misogynistic bellend.

HyacynthBucket · 30/09/2021 15:41

It is hard to believe you are actually asking the question here, OP. Of course you do not go. And of course you tell the UK wife what is going on. The fact that you even have to ask indicates that you or your values have been badly compromised by living with your DH's cultural mores. What on earth does he understand by the term "respect"? Do you really go along with deceit and overturning or twisting a basic concept such as honesty or respect?

HeadPain · 30/09/2021 15:34

And no don't go, obviously