Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

following today's news...to say police should not be allowed to arrest women when operating solo

267 replies

RBKB · 29/09/2021 18:36

Just that.... what tragic and terrifying news regarding Sarah Everard's murder. I am so angry as I gather the force minimised earlier reports of sexually deviant behaviour by this appalling man.

OP posts:
nosafeguardingadults · 30/09/2021 01:33

If you cared about women not being murdered, more important than extreme thing like what you suggest is more help and safe housing for victims of domestic violence.

Don't think most people care really about women cos several killed every week by violence but cos domestic violence people think we not important.

Yoursaintlyglowofconcern · 30/09/2021 01:15

Yes double crewed.
The terrifying thing is that any man could pretend to be police and do this to lure a woman into a car. At least if we knew there had to be two people we would have a heads up something was wrong if it was a lone ‘policeman’.

IndigoC · 30/09/2021 01:07

Maybe only women should be allowed to be police officers. 😁

Gothichouse40 · 30/09/2021 00:52

I hear you but female police officers are very few in number.

Resilience · 30/09/2021 00:44

Police officer here (not in the met).
I am beyond horrified at what happened to Sarah Everard and incredibly shamed that the man who murdered her was a serving officer paid to protect people like Sarah. I am angry for what he's done to Sarah and the damage he's heaped on public confidence in the police, particularly among women.

I would love police to be double crewed. It would lead to a lot better decision making IMO (chances of 2 officers making a bad decision much reduced). It would also reduce the number of steadily rising assaults on police officers. Not going to happen though. The area I police is staffed with 4x fewer officers than 20 years ago and we're failing to meet demand as it is. There's no money or political/public will to uplift numbers.

I also don't think it would help. My force, and most others, already have a policy that 2 officers have to transport to custody. 1 officer may attend and arrest but another will then be needed before anyone can leave the scene. This is because the driver can't monitor the prisoner (there have been cases where prisoners have died en route). Most members of the public don't know this even though it's been in place years.

Most people (and especially those with typical female socialisation and those who don't have previous interaction with the police to draw on) would just see the warrant card and capitulate. In a country where we police with consent, that's actually how it should be - with the caveat that the police absolutely must be acting with integrity and relied on to keep people safe. That wasn't the case here which is why it's so, so awful.

There will always be rare exceptions of incredibly clever sociopaths, but what's actually needed (and shouldn't be beyond the wit of forces to achieve) is a robust vetting process, regular, mandatory psychological assessments for officers (which doesn't currently happen but IMO should, which would not only pick up red flags but might also help with their decreasing mental health levels) and some accountability. We already have a Code of Ethics making those who had concerns about Couzens duty bound to report him. Whether they did, and what was done about it, remains to be seen but that's where the real questions about preventability lie in my view.

In the meantime an innocent young woman lost her life, for which I am truly sorry.

BlueBellsArePretty · 30/09/2021 00:37

So to summarise from some of these comments: it would take too many resources/require the giving up of too many 'freedoms'/mean that women just want special treatment not equality/would hurt men's feelings too much, therefore there's no point in attempting to change anything. So if a lone male police officer attempts to arrest you, a woman, on the flimsiest of pretexts then your duty is to just submit in good faith.

Jeez the absolute state of some of the views on this thread. 🤬

DdraigGoch · 30/09/2021 00:13

Again, the only real way that this might have been prevented would be for the police to start taking "minor" sexual offences seriously again. Indecent exposure is a gateway crime.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 30/09/2021 00:08

@mathanxiety

I’m sorry, what freedoms are you willing to give up for safety. Because last I checked you can’t have it both ways. You are either protected and treated differently or treated the the same with risk.

Conundrum isn’t it?

I'm lucky enough to live in a place that funds its police, and police patrol in pairs or have backup to summon for immediate help, whether dealing with male or female offenders.

I do have to pay for the proper staffing of the police force through my taxes, but I don't see a problem there. I get what I pay for. Other people get what I pay for too. I care like that.

So you this doesn’t apply to you at all. Or you are deluded in the thought ta 2 men ca’t commit a violent act together or you live in a mythical place where the police force is split 50/50 between men and women.

So umm great if one of those above is the case. It isn’t for the rest of the world.

DdraigGoch · 30/09/2021 00:06

@middleager

Have you seen what West Midlands Police have posted? Women are not responsible for what men do FFS!
Looking out for one's mates isn't just for women. It's good advice for a multitude of reasons, many of which apply to men too - some cities have seen far too many lone drunks drown in rivers.
FOJN · 30/09/2021 00:03

We need to change the thinking within the male population. The instant you start saying “we can’t trust any men” you are going to get men coming out and saying things like “not all men are like that,” which is true. And instantly you lose support.

We need to get to the point where men don’t have to express that “not all men” are like that. We need to get to a point where those men who aren’t like that want something done about the men who are, and acknowledge the fact that male on female violence is more common than the other way around.

Given that men are more at risk of violent crime than women and still the "men that aren't like that" continue to be more interested in their personal reputation than their personal safety I think it's reasonable to say dick pandering makes no difference at all and we'd be waiting a long time for them to stop saying "not all men are like that".

WeeM · 29/09/2021 23:59

Police Scotland officers always work in pairs as corroboration is still required. So, as someone from north of the border, it’s an alien concept to me that officers down south can work alone.

EmeraldShamrock · 29/09/2021 23:54

Look at this tragedy from another perspective. An off duty police officer sees a woman trying to abduct a child, goes to the child's aid, but is unable to arrest the woman because he's on his own. The next day the woman tries again and succeeds and the child is killed.
He could arrest her, cuff her, call for back up.
Why would he have to let her go the first time?

EmeraldShamrock · 29/09/2021 23:52

www.rte.ie/news/2020/0617/1148139-garda-shooting/
A detective overpowered and shot with his own gun in a sleepy quiet county town if he was a city garda he couldn't patrol alone.

Changechangychange · 29/09/2021 23:52

@x2boys

So your a, women on your own, and somebodys trying to break into your house, you ring the police and they only have a lone male officer to despatch, what are you going to do say no thanks?
Like fuck would the Met ever send a lone police officer out to an active burglary in progress. Way too risky. They don’t go about on their own.
EmeraldShamrock · 29/09/2021 23:48

how does that work in, say, a vigilante mob? Does the officer provide the mob with a sitting target whilst waiting for back-up
The government should be protecting an officer doing a job dealing with the most dangerous in society by doubling up crews.

If it means higher taxes or cuts to political parties wage packages.

Probably one of the worst money saving ideas.

Most people would take a bigger risk dealing with one officer if their pal was been arrested.

2Two · 29/09/2021 23:48

Look at this tragedy from another perspective. An off duty police officer sees a woman trying to abduct a child, goes to the child's aid, but is unable to arrest the woman because he's on his own. The next day the woman tries again and succeeds and the child is killed. Is that really what we want to risk?

DdraigGoch · 29/09/2021 23:45

If they did have to work in pairs, and that was common knowledge, Sarah Everard might still be alive.

I don't think it would work. The main lesson to be learned from this case is to do with why an officer with such a reputation internally was allowed to continue serving. Never mind why he wasn't suspended pending investigation after that indecent exposure.

DrSbaitso · 29/09/2021 23:45

@Kindleswitchface

Are domino's drivers also not allowed to deliver single crewed to females?
This isn't comparing apples to oranges. It's comparing apples to golfing umbrellas. Are you feeling well?
mathanxiety · 29/09/2021 23:43

I’m sorry, what freedoms are you willing to give up for safety. Because last I checked you can’t have it both ways. You are either protected and treated differently or treated the the same with risk.

Conundrum isn’t it?

I'm lucky enough to live in a place that funds its police, and police patrol in pairs or have backup to summon for immediate help, whether dealing with male or female offenders.

I do have to pay for the proper staffing of the police force through my taxes, but I don't see a problem there. I get what I pay for. Other people get what I pay for too. I care like that.

jcyclops · 29/09/2021 23:42

If I may add to the half-baked ideas - Police horses would have to be very strong if each had to carry two officers. Motorcycle officers could also ride 2up - which might also work for pizza deliveries.

DdraigGoch · 29/09/2021 23:41

I think AIBU but I also think all officers should wear body cameras (and have them on obviously) when on duty.
I thought they did always use them (uniformed officers anyway).

DdraigGoch · 29/09/2021 23:39

@Kindleswitchface

Would you like to pay the extra taxes to fund the additional police officers required to ensure double crewed patrols? If yes, crack on.
Most police officers would prefer to go back to double crewing anyway. If you arrest a suspect, there's no van available, and the car doesn't have a barrier separating the driver from the prisoner in the rear, you need two officers. One to drive, the other to watch the prisoner. So you end up abandoning a car while the two officers go to central custody in the other.

Never mind that when you are in a scuffle, it feels like it takes forever for assistance to arrive.

SopaDeThistle · 29/09/2021 23:38

I can imagine this would end with some clown world scenario of lone male police officers having to ask perpetrators what their gender identity is before they could proceed to arrest them.

Namechangeapologies · 29/09/2021 23:33

Why is it that police officers are allowed to arrest even when they are not on duty.
But qualified nurses are not permitted to adminster (potentially life altering) medical assistance in (what they perceive is) an emergency situation.

Because - and please do correct me if I am wrong here (and i may well be) - there is no threshold in terms of seniority of rank in the police force where an off duty policeman can make an arrest. And there is no right under criminal law for the person being arrested to ask to see (at the point of arrest) evidence of the status of the policeman to make that arrest.

I might be making serious errors in the above assumptions (please correct me).

I hear that the Met police really struggle to recruit full stop. So anyone willing to do the job (suitable or not, criminal record or not, mental health issues or not etc etc) is likely to be considered sooner or later. And if they have required skills and do not evidence performance problems, are likely to be promoted/advanced quickly and without scrutiny.

SopaDeThistle · 29/09/2021 23:33

Lol wait till this policy met the real world. It would be a disaster. Not to mention you'd have to consider "gender identity" nonsense - what happens if a male criminal suddenly begins to identify as a woman?

Swipe left for the next trending thread