Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

following today's news...to say police should not be allowed to arrest women when operating solo

267 replies

RBKB · 29/09/2021 18:36

Just that.... what tragic and terrifying news regarding Sarah Everard's murder. I am so angry as I gather the force minimised earlier reports of sexually deviant behaviour by this appalling man.

OP posts:
SquareYellow · 30/09/2021 09:31

Also what about the evil men who buy police uniforms and pretend to pull over women, or those who pretend to be doctors or delivery drivers or an electrician sent by the council etc. Safety comes into play everywhere but it doesn’t make everyone evil.

SquareYellow · 30/09/2021 09:30

The police officers I know don’t like single crews and I was under the impression if they arrested a female then a female officer was called to accompany when available?
I don’t think all police officers are this person. I think there are evil people, men and women in every job. I want my children to still feel safe to go to a police officer if under attack or scared. I trust the police more here than in the US and other countries where they are run by religious organisations.

zafferana · 30/09/2021 09:29

@DrSbaitso sadly I'm sure that's right - and no doubt that's what made Sarah comply and get into her killer's car - even though she probably had serious misgivings about doing so Sad

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 30/09/2021 09:27

if the police themselves don’t like single crews who are we to suggest otherwise?
As someone else has mentioned the Police Federation have been campaigning against increased single crewing for years. It's never safe. You never know when a "routine" job might turn dangerous. See PCs Fiona Bone and Nicola Hughes who were lured to Dale Cregan's ambush. Most officers hate being single crewed, sometimes it's fine reality of policing is that you never know what awaits you the other side of the door.

Single crewing is used by politically motivated senior police leaders to hide the gaps in staffing caused by underfunding. Directed by the PCCs who are in turn directed by their political masters.

However, double crewed or single crewed would this have made any difference to Sarah Everard ? As a law abiding member of the public she probably trusted what she was being told was true.

LaBellina · 30/09/2021 09:26

I also think lone women should have the right to request waiting at the scene for a second officer if their arresting officer is a lone male.

^^ this in spades

Why this is a reasonable request has sadly been proved by what happened to Sarah.
If we give women the right to a female chaperone during intimate check ups by male doctors because they might abuse their power, why not do the same thing when women are actively restricted in their freedom by a male who has a gun, handcuffs etc. and the authority to use them? Women are typically not undressed in this situation but I would feel a lot more vulnerable in this situation then with a male doctor even when (partly) undressed.

DrSbaitso · 30/09/2021 09:23

@zafferana

YANBU. I bloody wouldn't get in a police car with one policeman too. I'd scream the place down rather than do that. The police can explain away this man's behaviour all they like - one on the news last night was saying 'We don't consider him to be one of us' - yeah well that's okay mate but every single woman in this country does!
Presumably if you're under arrest, he could force you. And if you're under arrest, people probably aren't going to take your screaming as anything more than evidence against you.
zafferana · 30/09/2021 09:16

YANBU. I bloody wouldn't get in a police car with one policeman too. I'd scream the place down rather than do that. The police can explain away this man's behaviour all they like - one on the news last night was saying 'We don't consider him to be one of us' - yeah well that's okay mate but every single woman in this country does!

Iggly · 30/09/2021 09:13

Also I would hope that this case would also make people realise just how our culture including violent porn - which we turn a blind eye too - has a huge part to play in this.

Iggly · 30/09/2021 09:12

@HarrietsChariot

Daft idea because it would cause many more problems than it solved. How many cases have there been of single police officers falsely arresting a woman so that they can abduct, rape and murder them? One? I can't think of any other similar cases, and they're the sort of thing that gets a lot of attention on the news.

If you say single officers can't detain women, it's the start of a slippery slope. What if the officer is homosexual, should he avoid arresting men too? Perhaps the officer is racist, so no single officer should arrest BAMEs. Look out, here comes a female officer, she can't touch that gangster in case she sexually assaults him?

The problem with the Everard case, the problem with the Nessa case, is that the publicity they (understandably) receive makes women more nervous than the reality suggests they should be. This leads to daft suggestions like men shouldn't be allowed out after 6pm and police officers shouldn't carry out an arrest if they are alone. We need to assess risk based on facts and evidence. The facts are:
a) I'm much less at risk of being attacked and murdered than a man (men account for about 80% of murder victims).
b) I'm much less at risk outside in public than I am at home (the vast majority of murders of women happen in the home or other "safe" place).

The perception of women being at greater risk is just that, a perception that is not bourne out by the facts. If you see a lone policeman walking towards you in the street the chances are he's exactly that, a lone policeman who happens to be headed in your direction. If a man walks behind me in an alley, great - I know that most men aren't going to attack me, and any would-be attacker hiding in the bushes will be put off by the fact a man is behind me.

Seeing bad things on the news doesn't make them more likely to happen to you - and neither does risk vary by the amount of coverage a story might receive.

Officers should not act alone. If the police themselves don’t like single crews who are we to suggest otherwise?
Iggly · 30/09/2021 09:11

@hangrylady

I was absolutely sickened when I read what that bastard did to Sarah Everard but it's one deviant who just happened to be a police officer. This isn't commonplace and the police need to be able to do their jobs, which includes arresting women committing crime.
The problem is that his behaviour escalated. It’s a known pattern. People around him would have seen his escalating behaviour and did nothing to call him out on it. Just let it slide.

I remember being subject to a flasher when I was with my baby ds. I called the police, back when we had more police and they took it seriously and explained it was likely that this person may end up carrying out a serious sexual offence. As it was, more incidents did happen and there was a local attack. I don’t know if it was the same person.

The police should know the patterns of behaviour of sexual criminals and come down hard on it.

Easy to say it’s one bad apple but one bad apple does spoil the cart.

HarrietsChariot · 30/09/2021 09:02

Daft idea because it would cause many more problems than it solved. How many cases have there been of single police officers falsely arresting a woman so that they can abduct, rape and murder them? One? I can't think of any other similar cases, and they're the sort of thing that gets a lot of attention on the news.

If you say single officers can't detain women, it's the start of a slippery slope. What if the officer is homosexual, should he avoid arresting men too? Perhaps the officer is racist, so no single officer should arrest BAMEs. Look out, here comes a female officer, she can't touch that gangster in case she sexually assaults him?

The problem with the Everard case, the problem with the Nessa case, is that the publicity they (understandably) receive makes women more nervous than the reality suggests they should be. This leads to daft suggestions like men shouldn't be allowed out after 6pm and police officers shouldn't carry out an arrest if they are alone. We need to assess risk based on facts and evidence. The facts are:
a) I'm much less at risk of being attacked and murdered than a man (men account for about 80% of murder victims).
b) I'm much less at risk outside in public than I am at home (the vast majority of murders of women happen in the home or other "safe" place).

The perception of women being at greater risk is just that, a perception that is not bourne out by the facts. If you see a lone policeman walking towards you in the street the chances are he's exactly that, a lone policeman who happens to be headed in your direction. If a man walks behind me in an alley, great - I know that most men aren't going to attack me, and any would-be attacker hiding in the bushes will be put off by the fact a man is behind me.

Seeing bad things on the news doesn't make them more likely to happen to you - and neither does risk vary by the amount of coverage a story might receive.

category12 · 30/09/2021 08:55

@BoredZelda

You want to change an entire nation's policing strategy because of one case?

It is important to remember this case, whilst shocking and tragic, represents one off duty police officer.

No, it doesn't. There are other cases, not murders, of police officers using their position to target vulnerable women. Example: PC Chris Wilson who sexually exploited a domestic abuse victim.

It's a fact that a certain type of predator is drawn to professions where there is access to the vulnerable. We need to be far hotter on worrying behaviours in candidates and ongoing checks throughout careers.

And saying it's one officer, ignores the sexist culture in the police service, and the fact this officer had a reputation as "the rapist" yet continued to serve until he murdered Sarah.

Iggly · 30/09/2021 08:51

@BoredZelda

You want to change an entire nation's policing strategy because of one case?

It is important to remember this case, whilst shocking and tragic, represents one off duty police officer.

Do you think that this was the only incident of a police officer abusing his privilege?

Do you think that this could happen again?

Do you think that the police operate in a way that is seen as consistently above reproach? Consistently?

Maybe it’s easier to write this off as a “one off” shocking case. But this is the result of a journey - a slippery slope towards the rape and murder of someone. If that slippery slope is stopped by improving police practices then absolutely change is needed.

This guy was not an anomaly. His behaviour in the run up to this was normalised and it wasn’t until it was too late that people finally question if our police force is fit for purpose.

BoredZelda · 30/09/2021 08:41

You want to change an entire nation's policing strategy because of one case?

It is important to remember this case, whilst shocking and tragic, represents one off duty police officer.

Oldandcobwebbed · 30/09/2021 07:57

The police have been campaigning about reducing single crews for years to no success. Single crews have meant an increase in arrests stats (as each can arrest separately rather than 1 arrest being shared), and an increase in response times (responses to petty crime are quicker bringing the average down, while IMO responses for jobs that need 2 take longer) . Its allowed staffing gaps to hidden and your force look twice as big.

Some areas operate on single crews alone, some stats say the 80% of officers across England said they were always alone or often alone. Freedom of information requests have shown (particularly in response policing) that single crews are the default for many forces.

Obviously the take has been on the impact it has on police assaults etc, risk to public they can't respond to big incidences if their back up is far away rather than risk to the public from police

The reality is that the system isn't built to allow for double crews consistently any more, and there would need to be a long term recruitment and funding plan
The worry for me is that if there is finally political will now to sort it then there will be a knee jerk of putting officers together without then any plan of how to fill the gaps it leaves

Here's some examples of years of police federation campaigns, research, news articles and even questions to mayor's of London etc

www.london.gov.uk/questions/2020/2824

www.readingchronicle.co.uk/news/15917045.chairman-thames-valley-police-federation-warned-officers-greater-risk-assaulted-single-crew-measures/

www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10439463.2017.1417990

www.change.org/p/amber-rudd-stop-single-crewing-police-officers

www.theargus.co.uk/news/10712996.sussex-detective-warns-single-crew-cars-could-see-officers-stand-by-as-crimes-are-committed/

hangrylady · 30/09/2021 07:49

I was absolutely sickened when I read what that bastard did to Sarah Everard but it's one deviant who just happened to be a police officer. This isn't commonplace and the police need to be able to do their jobs, which includes arresting women committing crime.

Heronwatcher · 30/09/2021 07:28

@TrishM80 why an earth is this a ridiculous question? As others have said it’s what happens in Scotland? And many police officers have said on this thread that they would prefer it. This idea that the first time someone suggests an idea the best thing to do is dismiss it or pick holes in it is what’s causing half the problem here. Why not read the thread with an open mind? What’s your suggestion to ensure that someone bring “arrested” can check if it’s legitimate or if they’re about to be raped, murdered and set fire to?

SquareYellow · 30/09/2021 07:26

@Kindleswitchface

Are domino's drivers also not allowed to deliver single crewed to females?
This sadly. Evil men who will kill are in all professions, doctors police delivery men gardeners etc. you can’t monitor every one in a genuinely god profession for one person. Just like shipman would have still passed the new doctor checks with revaluation and still killed. This isn’t a police are bad issue, it’s a fucking evil cunt was bad issue. I want the police to still come out if needed and there still to be a service although low everything it’s underfunded. But questions need to be hugely asked about why his flashing wasn’t taken seriously
EmeraldShamrock · 30/09/2021 07:23

They’ve been underfunded for years like all of our public services.
It is disgraceful risking the officers life and public safety.

TrishM80 · 30/09/2021 07:05

Ridiculous question from the OP

Iggly · 30/09/2021 05:59

If police can't afford to operate in pairs, then we must be seriously underfunding them. I know people are shouting about how the police are corrupt and we should cut off their funding, but actually, I think the solution might be to invest more in them

They’ve been underfunded for years like all of our public services.

Boomshakalakaaaaa · 30/09/2021 04:38

Haven't RTFT. The fact that police officers can arrest women alone is a red herring here.

This bastard would have found a way to do what he did regardless of what rules are designed to prevent it / make it more difficult.

People impersonate police officers. It just so happens that he was a real one. Realistically, how many of us would be able to spot a counterfeit warrant card? If he hadn't been a real copper he could have easily pretended to be one. If he didn't do that, he'd have found another way.

Unfortunately the million dollar question of how we tackle violence towards women still goes unanswered but I don't think it lies within sending two cops out to arrest women just in case.

mathanxiety · 30/09/2021 04:32

@BlueBellsArePretty, agree.

mathanxiety · 30/09/2021 04:29

So you this doesn’t apply to you at all. Or you are deluded in the thought ta 2 men ca’t commit a violent act together or you live in a mythical place where the police force is split 50/50 between men and women.

No, it's not split 50-50, not even close, and there are parts of the country where policing is not the priority it is in my area; the problem of appropriate funding applies to me because I can and do travel.

Women have responded to the danger posed by harassment and physical attacks by taking precautions that frequently involve curtailing their lifestyles - staying in after dark, avoiding parks and other areas where they might be alone, not taking outdoor exercise at convenient times, and in general leading lives that are circumscribed by fear. Women's safety is not a priority in a country where police funding is decreasing. The right of half the population to personal safety is clearly not considered all that important. If you want policing then you have to pay the sort of taxes that result in adequately funded and staffed forces. If the will to properly fund the police isn't there, you have to ask why.

Now, with the death toll mounting, the inadequacies of policing are becoming more apparent, and maybe one good thing that will come from repeated preventable crimes is a commitment by the powers that be to protection. Women are constituents after all.

Yes, of course two men could get together and kidnap and murder women, but what usually happens when more than one man is involved is a heist of some sort. Rape and murder of the sort seen in the Everard case tends to be the work of lone wolves.

themidnighttrain · 30/09/2021 03:54

I hadn't really thought about it before, because I always see police in groups here, but I'm surprised it's normal for police to arrest on their own. I'd have thought operating in pairs was better, not just for our safety, but for theirs - gives them a credible witness and backup for if things go south.

If police can't afford to operate in pairs, then we must be seriously underfunding them. I know people are shouting about how the police are corrupt and we should cut off their funding, but actually, I think the solution might be to invest more in them.

In an ideal world, police would operate in pairs, and there would be a big push on gender/race equality, so more of those pairs weren't just two white men. In some parts of the UK, I can see how that just won't be possible, but it would be nice to aim for that. More diversity, and no to working solo where possible.