Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that the political left is hamstrung by it's obsession with purity of thought?

83 replies

Echobelly · 29/09/2021 18:34

To be clear - I think intersectionality is vital, I think awareness of privilege and balances of power when talking about the needs of different people is massively important. These things have value.

But it also seems to me that one reason the Left is struggling against the populist Right is that this expectation that everyone who doesn't get everything about the things I mentioned above exactly 'right' the very first time they encounter them or every time they mention them in company is a total pariah, a 'bigot', is 'erasing' or 'silencing' another group with what they do or say etc. When they're trying to the right thing but have maybe got it wrong, they're basically treated link c*nts.

People are well intentioned, but not everyone has a degree in sociology or whatever and not everyone, especially if they haven't had a privileged education, has a nuanced understanding of every political and social issue. Often one encounters people who are quick to label anyone who they see as less left-wing than them as 'fascist' (I was called this for discussing exactly the issue I am raising here on a LW group, though TBF, the guy was a bit of a out-there weirdo and was called out by lots of other people for saying it!)

I imagine one doesn't often see people chucked out of right wing groups for being 'not right wing enough' or 'not intersectional'. These groups, while lacking in self-awareness usually, are at least welcoming to all parties that want to join on the whole and won't chuck them out for 'saying the wrong thing'. Basically, it's easy to be part of the Right. It's hard to be part of the Left.

And that in part is because there is more self-awareness and care about it on the Left and that is valuable, but God, can't people sometimes cut people a bit of a slack?! It just seems that the Left spends its time tearing itself apart to prove who is the most pure and virtuous, and while it does this RW is making all sorts of gains in the popular consciousness and screwing up the world.

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · 29/09/2021 19:09

And of course it's all virtue signalling. If they get in power they will be self serving like all politicians are. It's all hot air.

LemonTT · 29/09/2021 19:08

Their other problem is this purity means they simply can’t see that voters are politically complex. Conservative (small c) on some issues and progressive on other issues. Meaning voters are fickle and these days far less tribal.

The Conservatives (big c) are far more willing to compromise orthodoxy and principles to win elections.

Newrumpus · 29/09/2021 18:58

Those who occupy what used to be the left no longer value much of the traditional progressive left values. That is the main issue as far as I can see it. Solidarity, community and class have been taken over by identitarianism and regressive ideologies.

NantesElephant · 29/09/2021 18:57

Yes, agree with everything so far

NantesElephant · 29/09/2021 18:55

It’s almost like displacement activity or procrastination for Labour, the Green Party and Lib Dems. That feeling when you know you have to write that tricky report (e.g prepare the UK to tackle climate change, or sort out NHS healthcare), and suddenly there is an urgent need for you to walk the dog or clean the oven (play around with identity politics).

There’s also arrogance, which does not allow them to set aside their differences to work together and bring a credible and electable alternative to the tories.

nosyupnorth · 29/09/2021 18:46

I agree, it's no conindence that a right wing party stays in power when (bar a brief breakaway to UKIP) the right have one big umbrella party in the conservatives.
Meanwhile there are half a dozen parties on the left scattered from central to extreme plus various nationalist leftists -- all of who are too occupied with fighting among themselves and too unwilling tolerate views slightly outside of their individual version of the one correct way to find the compromises needed to enact positive change or have a chance at foruming a government.

And I say this as somebody with fairly left leaning views.

NantesElephant · 29/09/2021 18:45

I agree with what you’ve written. It’s important to be aware of privileges and lack of, totally agree, but at the moment it comes across from the more left wing parties as almost an obsession that is more important than issues such as people going hungry in a rich nation, the housing crisis, healthcare provision, the climate crisis… it’s madness.

bungaloid · 29/09/2021 18:43

My issue is that for me, being left wing is about society and looking after one another. The current left wing just endlessly pontificating on subtle definitions that average voters don't give a shit about. It's a stupid trap of their own making. What ever happened to looking out for the low paid and vulnerable?

Swipe left for the next trending thread