Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be incapable of making friends

57 replies

sotired6 · 29/09/2021 18:25

I had very few friends at school because I was so shy and lacking in confidence. Then went to uni and made no friends at all - literally not one - because I was so afraid to reach out to people. I’m now 38, a FTM to a two year old boy and am still struggling. I go to many different toddler groups but never seem to gel with anyone - not to the point where I can ask them for their number. I did join an NCT group when pregnant but all the other women seemed to split off quite quickly into cliques and I was the only mum who wasn’t part of any of them.

I’m desperate for friends but there is clearly something wrong with me as I’m just not capable of making any.

Is there any hope for me or do I just need to accept that I’m going to remain friendless for the rest of my life?

OP posts:
Pinkdelight3 · 30/09/2021 09:25

Doesn't cross my mind to be honest.

Same here, and not in an arrogant way, just that it's best to keep busy and have other irons in the fire so you don't have time to worry about if you're bothering people. Chances are she's in that boat and busy with life and meeting up isn't realistic right now, so I'd text her if something came up ('saw x and thought of you' or 'y is happening want to come?') but otherwise I'd focus on other people/activities. I'm not in touch regularly with some really good lifelong friends and that's fine on both sides. Others where contact tails off will have drifted away for good. But new people will have come into view too - friends of friends, people you meet at social events or new people at work etc - so once you're in that headspace, it doesn't become a big deal about one person not replying.

leavesthataregreen · 30/09/2021 09:20

There's nothing wrong with you OP, but clearly there is something very wrong with your social technique and that is something you can change, so that you learn how to make overtures that will develop into friendship. Making friends is a confusingly subtle process with so many unwritten rules, but some of them can be learned.

Why not make a project of developing and overcoming your shyness and then after you've worked on it, try it out very gently on some new people in social situations you sign up for or find yourself in? There are books and loads of free online resources. There's also a paid course by a man called David Morin who has the advantage of having been cripplingly shy himself and says lots of the advice given by extroverts just makes truly shy people curl up and die inside, so he knows how to approach this from the POV of shyness (I haven't done his course but have looked at lots of his free material online on behalf of someone and thought he looked good.)

As PPs have said, getting involved in a hobby you truly love for its own sake will really help. Do a couple of things each week because you genuinely want to - crafting, sport, furniture restoration - anything at all. And stick at it. It can take at least a year before anything like friendship evolves from a hobby class. I've been going to two fitness classes for over a year and just this month both of them tipped over from 'bye' at the end of the session as people shot out the door in different directions, to people standing chatting, going for coffee, giving each other small gifts. It took that long for people to switch from stranger to familiar. Give it time.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 30/09/2021 09:16

@Fadingout

For those with friends….how do you know you’re not being too pushy? I’m very hesitant as I don’t want to text loads. I made a friend at a playgroup years ago and meet ups and now messages have dropped off (it takes her three months to return a message though it’s always long and lovely). I don’t like to think I’m bothering people.
Doesn't cross my mind to be honest.
Bombaloorina · 30/09/2021 09:12

Finally - some people making the stunningly obvious point.

You’re married (or at least seriously partnered-up). How did you make that deep connection with another human being, and why do you think friendship is any different?

citycitycity · 30/09/2021 09:11

I read a piece of advice on here recently (I think it was in a thread about moving to a new area) that you should spend a year going to absolutely everything in the local area and meeting new people, trying new things, etc. After that you can drop the things you don’t enjoy but you should have made some new friends and interests.

I have just moved house and am going to try it - I am an introvert but would love to make some local friends/join some groups.

Another piece of advice is to do things consistently so that people get to know you and you become part of the group ie make sure you go t badminton/netball/football every week and join the league, volunteer to help at matches etc.

Fadingout · 30/09/2021 09:08

For those with friends….how do you know you’re not being too pushy? I’m very hesitant as I don’t want to text loads. I made a friend at a playgroup years ago and meet ups and now messages have dropped off (it takes her three months to return a message though it’s always long and lovely). I don’t like to think I’m bothering people.

SalsaLove · 30/09/2021 09:03

How did you meet your partner? There must have been initial if awkward conversations? It’s really the same principle of getting to know someone.

Spaceman1 · 30/09/2021 09:01

I am just the same, being sociable just doesn't come naturally to me and I find small talk a bit pointless and tiring! I think even the most hermit like people want some sort of social interaction even if you have to fake it.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 30/09/2021 08:59

Is there anyone you regularly talk to at playgroup ? I have moved a lot over the years and even though people would describe me as confident I'm not really and feel just the same as you do but I have to really treat the whole thing like a PR excercise. Only one person has declined the invitation for a coffee and she was a bit odd to be honestGrin People are usually as bored as you and would love to have a coffee and a natter with someone new.

If you're little one is playing with a child you could say to the mum " Oh look, aren't they playing nicely, fancy coming to mine for a coffee one day next week so the little ones can see each other again, shall we fix a day, you know what it's like if I do t get something in the diary another week zips by etc etc...?"

NOBODY knows you're shy unless you tell them,they just think you're a friendly mum with a baby.

TheUnbearable · 30/09/2021 08:56

We all get nervous sometimes but I do think depending on how much it is shown that it can make others feel ill at ease.

I look at friendship like this.

You meet 100 people, how many will you really have much in common with? probably not that many and friendships need an anchor or something in common to make them long lasting.

I did a voluntary job for two years and made two friends through it, I certainly met dozens of people but these two had more in common with me and we clicked. Both myself and one woman were avid hockey players when young and we both still love hiking.

It’s a numbers game really. We met some people on holiday recently, in the next door holiday cottage. They were at a completely different life stage to us and young enough to be our dc. But in our couple of conversations, they loved gardening and DH and the woman work in the same field. She also loved cats, so whilst we were much older than them I saw connections.

I would look at the advice in previous posts on how to tackle your anxiety. But then remember it’s a numbers game.

Spindrifting · 30/09/2021 08:45

I think @Pinkdelight3’s second paragraph is key (though I admit to being also always fascinated by what she says in her first paragraph, as so many friendless people who post about it mention that they’re married or in a committed relationship — why does this require different skills to making friends?)

Thinking of yourself as ‘shy’ is a self-protective mechanism but a very limiting one. For me, what emerges very strongly from so many similar posts on here is the effect of self-consciousness on social skills.

To be blunt, if you’re in a social situation and someone is talking to you, and all you’re thinking is ‘Oh, God, what should I say when she finishes talking?’ or ‘Was the last thing I said stupid?’ or ‘What will I ask her next?’ the effect is that you’re not really listening to or engaging with the other person. You’re thinking about yourself the whole time. And the effect on the other person is much the same as if you were an arrogant arse who has zoned out because you’re just waiting for the other person to draw breath you so can break in with your anecdote about yourself.

If you’re visibly planning your next line in your head while I’m talking, I’m not necessarily going to know whether it’s because you’re shy and nervous or a self-obsessed pain — the effect is similar, in that I can tell you’re not really listening or seeing me.

Do you see what I mean?

CounsellorTroi · 30/09/2021 08:44

I find it difficult making friends too. I didn’t go to university or have children and have never been part of a friendship group. I think I may be on the spectrum too.

Irish993 · 30/09/2021 08:43

I'm in the same situation after a big move. I'm looking to the in laws for friendship since everyone back home has drifted off. It's so hard. I'm a SAHM so I just don't talk to any adults all day.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 30/09/2021 08:40

Your child is of the age where you have loads of opportunities to get involved with things and make connections. Toddler groups are usually volunteer run - so volunteer. Get yourself on the committee, offer to makes the coffees, stay behind and help clear up. Having been involved on committees for more years than I care to remember, they will bite your hand off.

Pinkdelight3 · 30/09/2021 08:25

These posts are on here quite often so you're not alone, even though you must feel it. The thing that always perplexes me is that there's almost always a DH - so you've made the most important friend somehow. How did you meet him? What did you have in common? Obviously it's not completely the same but it's testament to the fact that you do have it in you to connect with people and forge a relationship. Also, does he have friends? Do you socialise as a couple? What about work? Have you never got on with any colleagues? It's having shared experiences in common as much as interests, so work has generally been a good source of friends, much more than the randomness of baby groups etc.

So that's the more practical side, but on the bigger point, for me it seems to come down to being interested in other people - the reaching out you mention is about getting past your self-consciousness with the trick of making it not about you but about helping others to feel liked and valued. Easier said than done, I know, I used to be very shy and awkward and still can be in some situations, but generally as I've got older I've cared less about myself and it's definitely helped draw people together. Perhaps the life coach is a good idea as it's so much about the story you tell yourself about who you are. As long as you define yourself as being incapable of making friends, it's likely to be a self-fulfilling prophecy. You can unwittingly put out 'I'm not likeable' vibes and the answer may be less about 'I'm likeable vibes' than finding an 'I like you' vibe that you can warm up other people with - yet not take it personally if you get a few knockbacks. Saying that almost makes it feel like a sales trick, but then they do say con(fidence) tricks are all about giving people your confidence first.

CaptainChannel · 29/09/2021 21:47

You might find as your DC gets older you make friends through regularly taking them to a hobby, particularly sport. My DD does competitive swimming which involves a lot of hanging around the pool. The day she trialled there was another boy trialling so me and his mum chatted a bit, then sat together for the first few sessions. Fast forward and we are now good friends, sometimes take a run together when the kids are swimming or just grab a coffee and chat. Work is also a good place for friends if you have a job

Walkingalot · 29/09/2021 20:02

I don't make friends naturally as am on the spectrum and and severely hard of hearing. But, that's an excuse - as far as I want it to be!
I had my DS at 41. I realised that unless I kicked my arse into gear, we would end up quite isolated. My DS was diagnosed with ASD at 5. Yey! Two awkward fuckers to try and navigate the world of friendships.
Wanting to nurture my DS has killed my own anxiety to a certain extent. It's a lot of 'fake it til you make it'. You really have to make the effort. I can't stress that enough.

wildery · 29/09/2021 19:51

If you’re in England I’m pretty sure you can get CBT for social anxiety through IAPT. Google it! Not sure how easy to access at the moment but it should help. I’ve always been shy. Less so now. I do agree you have to fake it to make it to an extent and be proactive about making friends and actually asking people for their number etc. Try to focus more on them than overthinking how you’re coming across. Join a group or club so you can gradually get to know people over the weeks before asking if they fancy a coffee etc. These are things that have helped me.

FlowerArranger · 29/09/2021 19:23

@Mistyplanet

You probably just lack the social skills which are needed in order to make friends- which you could learn. I think being smiley and light hearted helps in those initial conversations. I used to be more serious and a bit too direct with people and on reflection i think that put people off. You'll need to do some self reflection. Is it your appearance which is putting people off? For example are you very scruffy? Or are you very self conscious and appear nervous which also puts people off. Try looking at people who have friends and examine them in social situations. I think you'll find them to be experts in those initial small talk interactions and from then it leads onto friendship.
THIS, especially "being smiley and light hearted" and not self-conscious or nervous. Plus having a few easy/non-controversial topics to talk about - maybe listen to Radio 4's Women's Hour for inspiration.

And I bet there are TED talks about making friends on YouTube.

For what it's worth, I have only few friends I met through work or via my kids' schools. Many I found via MeetUp groups or special interests of mine.

Sometimes all it takes is to ask "would you like to go for a drink/coffee afterwards?" What's the worst that can happen - they might say "not today" or "I'm sorry I cant". But then again, they might be so happy to be asked because they were too scared to do so themselves!

sotired6 · 29/09/2021 19:22

That’s what I did, also I listen too much and don’t tell enough stories about myself which people seem to like. I’m never going to be a social as some people but I have definitely improved and you definitely can too!

I’m terrible at telling stories about myself - I often get jumbled up and when I get to the punchline, nobody laughs because of the crappy way I’ve told it Blush Then that knocks my confidence even more.

OP posts:
sotired6 · 29/09/2021 19:19

You probably just lack the social skills which are needed in order to make friends- which you could learn. I think being smiley and light hearted helps in those initial conversations.

I do make a real conscious effort to be smiley, but I’m very nervous underneath - perhaps people can sense that and it puts them off?

OP posts:
rubytubeytubes · 29/09/2021 19:14

It’s difficult but you can turn it around. You need to get rid of the thought that you are shy, it’s not serving you well and becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Often telling yourself that you are shy can be a way of protecting yourself, e.g it’s not my fault I’m shy….. etc.
I was very similar, unfortunately you may be coming across as uncomfortable (I was) which makes other people a bit nervous. You sometimes have to fake it and tell yourself that you are confident and act like you are.
That’s what I did, also I listen too much and don’t tell enough stories about myself which people seem to like. I’m never going to be a social as some people but I have definitely improved and you definitely can too!

Crimsonripple · 29/09/2021 19:05

I'm the same. I don't have a best friend or a group of friends. I have people I chat too and would consider friends but don't really socialise with. I think despite being bubbly and chatty I'm quite socially awkward!

Mistyplanet · 29/09/2021 19:01

You probably just lack the social skills which are needed in order to make friends- which you could learn. I think being smiley and light hearted helps in those initial conversations. I used to be more serious and a bit too direct with people and on reflection i think that put people off. You'll need to do some self reflection. Is it your appearance which is putting people off? For example are you very scruffy? Or are you very self conscious and appear nervous which also puts people off. Try looking at people who have friends and examine them in social situations. I think you'll find them to be experts in those initial small talk interactions and from then it leads onto friendship.

Fadingout · 29/09/2021 18:59

Making friends is tough. I’ve found it really hard. Two of my children are autistic so haven’t really been able to meet people through them as they’re both at specialist schools and it was very difficult when they were small. I work part time but those I work with are spread in different places and are significantly older. No words of advice other than maybe hobbies or work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread