Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think private rent increases should be limited to inflation only

141 replies

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 11:06

We are currently applying to rent a 2 bedroom house for £785 a month. The same house was up for rent previously 2 years ago for £695.

The seems like a massive increase, and other houses for rent on the area seem to have gone up by the same or even more. We're currently in a 3 bed for £850, but it has a dreadful damp problem. No doubt our landlord will paint it and put it back up for £900/£950.

Aibu to think private landlords should be limited in how much they increase rent? I understand that there is limited supply, so landlords are taking advantage of this to put up prices, but like most people my wages are not increasing on real terms and having a somewhere to live is quickly becoming unaffordable!!

OP posts:
dameofdilemma · 29/09/2021 12:24

Other countries manage to have rent controls and better protections for tenants without the entirety of capitalism breaking down and melting into a puddle of communism.

Take a long hard look at housing in this country - houses have become an investment vehicle rather than a home.

Noone forces a landlord to become a landlord but everyone needs (and deserves) safe, adequate, long term shelter.

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 12:23

@TheHouseILiveIn

I think this is the issue - landlords expect the money they receive from rent to cover all of these things - which imo is completely unfair. I do not think I should have to pay more money becauseof void periods for example. The landlord should be prepared to absorb the cost of this.

Also I don't agree with rent being expected to pay for long term damage and repairs. The landlord is the owner of the property, and is ultimately responsible for those costs. Renting should be cheaper than owning a house, but that really doesn't seem to be the case.

But it's a BUSINESS not a charity, so why should the landlord absorb the costs? If the figures don't add up then landlords will leave the market and in that case good luck finding somewhere to live!

It is still a viable business without rinsing the tenant for every single conceivable cost.

Expecting to put down a deposit to get a btl mortgage and then never put your own money into maintenance etc is just insanely greedy!

OP posts:
TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 12:17

I think this is the issue - landlords expect the money they receive from rent to cover all of these things - which imo is completely unfair. I do not think I should have to pay more money becauseof void periods for example. The landlord should be prepared to absorb the cost of this.

Also I don't agree with rent being expected to pay for long term damage and repairs. The landlord is the owner of the property, and is ultimately responsible for those costs. Renting should be cheaper than owning a house, but that really doesn't seem to be the case.

But it's a BUSINESS not a charity, so why should the landlord absorb the costs? If the figures don't add up then landlords will leave the market and in that case good luck finding somewhere to live!

Horst · 29/09/2021 12:13

Rents should be capped in some way but it would be a rather complicated system.

My 3 bedroom is worth much less than one a 10 minute drive away so rental prices would have to reflect that. Although at the same time I think it’s bonkers that some very standard plain Jayne houses in my area are renting for over £1,000 - £2,000 a month. They anit mansions with pools and marble floors just bog standard 3/4 beds with a drive.

seaandsandcastles · 29/09/2021 12:11

YABU. It’s a business; they should be allowed to have the rent as high as the market will allow.

Ie. If there’s someone willing to pay it, it’s acceptable.

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 12:09

@DeepaBeesKit

The problem is inflation isnt necessarily a reflection of what the landlords costs are rising by. Their costs will include:
  • rising capital costs of buying housing (pushes up mortgage payments)
  • interest rates/access to mortgages
  • the costs overall of void periods, tenants who don't pay, evictions
  • long term damage/repairs/maintenance

Covid will have hit incomes hard, meaning more tenants struggling to pay, but landlords couldn't evict. Landlords can't afford to just swallow those costs so it pushes rents up.

I think this is the issue - landlords expect the money they receive from rent to cover all of these things - which imo is completely unfair. I do not think I should have to pay more money becauseof void periods for example. The landlord should be prepared to absorb the cost of this.

Also I don't agree with rent being expected to pay for long term damage and repairs. The landlord is the owner of the property, and is ultimately responsible for those costs. Renting should be cheaper than owning a house, but that really doesn't seem to be the case.

OP posts:
Kettletoaster · 29/09/2021 12:07

‘HarrietsChariot

Rents shouldn't be based on inflation, no. They should be based on the monthly mortgage repayment the landlord has on the property, up to 90%. That way people who invest in property still benefit from price rises and only have to find a relatively small amount out of their own pocket each month, but they cannot exploit renters. Obviously once the mortgage is payed off, rent would decrease to zero.’

😂😂 god this comment made me laugh! Sure fire way to kill the entire private rental market.

ripples101 · 29/09/2021 11:57

@HarrietsChariot

Rents shouldn't be based on inflation, no. They should be based on the monthly mortgage repayment the landlord has on the property, up to 90%. That way people who invest in property still benefit from price rises and only have to find a relatively small amount out of their own pocket each month, but they cannot exploit renters. Obviously once the mortgage is payed off, rent would decrease to zero.
Haha, yeah ok
astoundedgoat · 29/09/2021 11:56

That's the current case in Ireland, in "rent pressure zones":

www.irishtimes.com/news/social-affairs/rent-increases-to-be-capped-at-inflation-in-pressure-zones-1.4608191

ODFOx · 29/09/2021 11:55

@HarrietsChariot

Rents shouldn't be based on inflation, no. They should be based on the monthly mortgage repayment the landlord has on the property, up to 90%. That way people who invest in property still benefit from price rises and only have to find a relatively small amount out of their own pocket each month, but they cannot exploit renters. Obviously once the mortgage is payed off, rent would decrease to zero.
Except that doesn't take in to account insurance, maintenance, void periods, preparation of contracts/legal fees and all the other myriad costs of being a landlord. It would also mean that landlords who own their house outright couldn't charge rent at all...
HarrietsChariot · 29/09/2021 11:52

Rents shouldn't be based on inflation, no. They should be based on the monthly mortgage repayment the landlord has on the property, up to 90%. That way people who invest in property still benefit from price rises and only have to find a relatively small amount out of their own pocket each month, but they cannot exploit renters. Obviously once the mortgage is payed off, rent would decrease to zero.

Lavender24 · 29/09/2021 11:48

Yeah it's insane. The house across from me has just gone up for rent for £595. I think that's a lot for a tiny 2 bed terraced house in the north east. Back when I lived in rented accommodation (pre 2018) I'd have paid no more than £450 pcm for a property of that size.

DeepaBeesKit · 29/09/2021 11:36

The problem is inflation isnt necessarily a reflection of what the landlords costs are rising by. Their costs will include:

  • rising capital costs of buying housing (pushes up mortgage payments)
  • interest rates/access to mortgages
  • the costs overall of void periods, tenants who don't pay, evictions
  • long term damage/repairs/maintenance

Covid will have hit incomes hard, meaning more tenants struggling to pay, but landlords couldn't evict. Landlords can't afford to just swallow those costs so it pushes rents up.

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 11:23

@PlanDeRaccordement

Not sure if still the case or even standard, but when I lived and rented in the UK, the lease agreement had a clause in it stating that at annual renewal of lease any rent increase would be limited to RPI index published on a certain website.

I think between tenants, they can raise or drop rent to whatever market will bear. But once you are a tenant, there may be a clause about rent increases like I had? Worth asking?

Thank-you, I shall look into this when signing the new tenancy.

Having a Google on citizens advice etc it says rent increases must be in line with current local rents, which seems a bit woolly.

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 29/09/2021 11:11

Not sure if still the case or even standard, but when I lived and rented in the UK, the lease agreement had a clause in it stating that at annual renewal of lease any rent increase would be limited to RPI index published on a certain website.

I think between tenants, they can raise or drop rent to whatever market will bear. But once you are a tenant, there may be a clause about rent increases like I had? Worth asking?

PersonaNonGarter · 29/09/2021 11:10

It’s hard but it is fair. The rent is going up according to market rates and the landlord will be paying increased bills on eg trades, goods, and so on as everything goes up.

There needs to be a better way. We need more homes fast.