Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think private rent increases should be limited to inflation only

141 replies

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 11:06

We are currently applying to rent a 2 bedroom house for £785 a month. The same house was up for rent previously 2 years ago for £695.

The seems like a massive increase, and other houses for rent on the area seem to have gone up by the same or even more. We're currently in a 3 bed for £850, but it has a dreadful damp problem. No doubt our landlord will paint it and put it back up for £900/£950.

Aibu to think private landlords should be limited in how much they increase rent? I understand that there is limited supply, so landlords are taking advantage of this to put up prices, but like most people my wages are not increasing on real terms and having a somewhere to live is quickly becoming unaffordable!!

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 29/09/2021 13:36

4 years ago, I paid just over £1.2k in tax in my property. I now pay over £5.5k. I have not increase the rent and appear to be letting the property £250 a month under market rate. I am make no profit on it when I account for all the costs and it would take the tenants not to pay for one month for it to become a liability.

You are naive OP to make it a war against landlords. 4he one party that gains from the arrangement is the government with the money, hopefully, being redistributed to society.

You mention selling. Well that is exactly what many landlords have done recently, causing a serious problems with demand being much higher than supply. How is that helping tenants?

There are no winners in this, except to hope that indeed, a fraction of this tax is redistributed to the NHS, social care and housing.

girlmom21 · 29/09/2021 13:35

Your attitude is foul. I, like the majority of tenants, have never trashed a house I have lived in.

Fair - I'll take take back the comment about the luxury of a fully functioning home. That is a basic right.

However this ^ about tenants trashing houses isn't foul. Just because you haven't done it doesn't mean thousands haven't. I know lots of people who've spent a lot of money on repairs due to damage caused by tenants.

SionnachRua · 29/09/2021 13:29

The luxury of a fully functioning home Grin Grin

That's not a luxury, it's a basic human right to have a roof over your head and for the rental property to be maintained to standard. Christ.

SionnachRua · 29/09/2021 13:28

I also think vacant property taxes are crucial. Some landlords (mostly the large entities) will happily hoard loads of empty properties in order to lessen availability and make people desperate (and thus willing to pay huge rents). This should not be possible.

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 13:27

@girlmom21

Why should I foot the bill for the landlord to replace the boiler in the future when I possibly don't even live there anymore? The landlord owns the house, and it is theirs to maintain as an asset that they can cash in for a huge profit.

But they can't necessarily cash it in for a huge profit.

You're not paying for a new boiler. You're paying for the luxury of a fully functioning home.

Why should they let you live in their property, and risk you trashing it, with absolutely no incentive for them?

They can sell the house, with the mortgage having been covered by tenants. In what world is that not a profit?

Having a home is not a 'luxury', it is a basic need that I am happy to pay for on a reasonable manner, where I am not being exploited. At the end of a tenancy, the tenant should only have paid for the use of that property, not for future repairs and to pad out the landlords savings.

Your attitude is foul. I, like the majority of tenants, have never trashed a house I have lived in.

OP posts:
simitra · 29/09/2021 13:22

If youve been in the property some time and are a good paying tenant you can always attempt to bargain.

When my LL attempted to raise my rent by £50 a month I told her that I couldnt afford that and offered £20 a month. I had done my homework and looked on the land registry to find out how much the original morgage had been and knew it was paid off. I did remind her that the kitchen and bathroom were below standard in decor and little had been spent on the house over all. If I left she would have to spend a lot of money on the house to relet or sell it. I was prepared to throw the information about the mortgage into the pot too, but we settled on £30.

MakingM · 29/09/2021 13:17

@MintJulia

We live in a market driven society. Prices are linked to demand.

But even if we didn't, the amount LLs charge has to cover all their costs, so for example, if his mortgage has risen, and his buildings insurance has risen, and the cost of boiler servicing has risen, then the rent has to cover all of those costs.

Or suddenly we wouldn't have any private landlords and people who don't want to buy, or who can't buy due to credit problems etc, would all be out on the streets.

Some kind of compromise with rent controls is long overdue in the UK.

“We live in a market driven society. Prices are linked to demand.”

We certainly do and the main problem is housing supply controlled as it is by and in the vested interests of large developers and landowners. Landlords don’t create the rising prices caused by insufficient supply, they simply ride the wave to profit from it.

Neither rent controls nor monstering landlords actually solves the problem, but agreed, it is necessary to have controls to prevent the profiteering going too far as it compounds an already dangerous problem.

NotDavidTennant · 29/09/2021 13:17

Rents are going up because there is more competition for rental properties at the moment, so some people are willing to pay more to secure a property and therefore landlords will put up their prices to capitalise on this.

Questions about fairness about who pays for void periods or replacing the boiler or whatever are irrelevant, because even if the landlord has comfortably covered all their costs at a rent of £800/month say, they are not going to rent it out at that price if there are people out there willing to pay £900/month or £1000/month or more.

The root problem is that we have a housing shortage in ths country and unless we embark on a programme of mass house building then housing costs are going to continue to go up and up.

girlmom21 · 29/09/2021 13:17

Why should I foot the bill for the landlord to replace the boiler in the future when I possibly don't even live there anymore? The landlord owns the house, and it is theirs to maintain as an asset that they can cash in for a huge profit.

But they can't necessarily cash it in for a huge profit.

You're not paying for a new boiler. You're paying for the luxury of a fully functioning home.

Why should they let you live in their property, and risk you trashing it, with absolutely no incentive for them?

MintJulia · 29/09/2021 13:11

We live in a market driven society. Prices are linked to demand.

But even if we didn't, the amount LLs charge has to cover all their costs, so for example, if his mortgage has risen, and his buildings insurance has risen, and the cost of boiler servicing has risen, then the rent has to cover all of those costs.

Or suddenly we wouldn't have any private landlords and people who don't want to buy, or who can't buy due to credit problems etc, would all be out on the streets.

Some kind of compromise with rent controls is long overdue in the UK.

PinkGinny · 29/09/2021 13:08

In any business you generally set your prices at the cost of provision plus target profit.

In a rental business the cost of provision includes the myriad of things listed above - i.e. capital improvements, void periods, repairs, insurance, cost of debt, etc. so of course any sensible private landlord will factor those into the rent they set. If they don't it is not a viable business proposition. It is not a case of not accepting the risk of being in that line of business but mitigating them by pricing appropriately.

PlanDeRaccordement · 29/09/2021 13:03

I agree that being a LL is a business venture and so it needs to generate some income for the LL. So rent should be at a level to cover any mortgage, insurance, and operating costs- to include savings towards long term repairs (new roof, boiler, etc).

Many LLs lost money due to tenants not paying rent during the pandemic, and I think that some of the rent increases are an attempt to recoup these past losses. This I think is monumentally unfair. A new tenant should not be paying extortionate rent to make up for a prior tenant who did not pay their rent. The tenants that have been paying their rent during the pandemic have often struggled very hard and home without to do so. Many have seen their savings for a home deposit dwindle to nothing. To punish these tenants for other tenants’ inability to pay is plain wrong. LLs take on the risk of a nonpaying tenant, they should not be passing those costs on to a later paying tenant.

MakingM · 29/09/2021 13:03

The especially good thing about restricting rent rises to inflation is that it prevents landlords chasing the market too. When other landlords see how fast rents are rising, by quite large amounts, they are currently incentivised to evict their current tenants who will normally have a contract that limits annual rises and get new ones in at the new rate. There is no lack of people looking for rental property so they can do it easily without fear of being left tenantless.

Porcupineintherough · 29/09/2021 13:02

If rent levels rise to the point that they become unaffordable then landlords wont be able to find tenants and prices will fall again.

All businesses pass their running costs on to their clients @Maverickess

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 13:00

@Chloemol

YABU. For some it is a business , therefore they need a profit to live of themselves

For some they fell into being a landlord, may only have one property they are renting out as a investment for retirement. They may not be able to afford to ‘absorb’ the costs mentioned, and why should they?

Rent needs to cover not only the mortgage, but also to be able to save towards costs of replacement boilers, repairs and maintenance, why should the6 be out of pocket to let you live there?

If you don’t like it then don’t rent, but your own place, live with family, other options are out there

Why should I foot the bill for the landlord to replace the boiler in the future when I possibly don't even live there anymore? The landlord owns the house, and it is theirs to maintain as an asset that they can cash in for a huge profit.

Also do you honestly think I'd be private renting if I had a choice!?

OP posts:
raspberrymuffin · 29/09/2021 13:00

You're not wrong but as long as so many older Tory voters are relying on unearned income from buy to lets proper rent controls aren't looking likely.

The rent increase stuff you've seen will be about existing tenancies - unfortunately there's nothing to stop landlords advertising to new tenants at a higher rent than the last ones. In Scotland councils have the power to bring in rent controls in high pressure areas but I'm not aware of any of them having had the balls to actually do it yet.

QuitMoaning · 29/09/2021 12:58

We own a house that we rent out and we do not have a mortgage on it, we own it outright, so we cannot link any increased to mortgage payments. Now will be let someone live in it rent free, what an utter ridiculous suggestion.

However we haven’t raised the rent at all in 7 years, even told the agents not to recommend raising the rent. When (if?) the current tenant leaves, we will refurbish and set the new rent at an average for market in that area. Until then, no increases. We want this tenant to stay as she is a good tenant so we will not do anything to make her life more expensive or difficult.

MakingM · 29/09/2021 12:57

Sounds fair to me. Family homes shouldn’t be investor-fodder. Lots of people will come up with reasons why neither this nor anything else should be done. They usually have a vested interest.

Maverickess · 29/09/2021 12:52

@TheHouseILiveIn

I think this is the issue - landlords expect the money they receive from rent to cover all of these things - which imo is completely unfair. I do not think I should have to pay more money becauseof void periods for example. The landlord should be prepared to absorb the cost of this.

Also I don't agree with rent being expected to pay for long term damage and repairs. The landlord is the owner of the property, and is ultimately responsible for those costs. Renting should be cheaper than owning a house, but that really doesn't seem to be the case.

But it's a BUSINESS not a charity, so why should the landlord absorb the costs? If the figures don't add up then landlords will leave the market and in that case good luck finding somewhere to live!

The tenant isn't a charity either, and nor should they be expected to cover all the costs of the business that the landlord is running to maximise their profit and reduce their outgoings and risk.

Running a business is a risky venture and if you choose to do so, you also choose the risks and outlay that go with that. Why should a tenant pay more so that a landlord can cover future possible costs they may encounter, or improve and expand their business, or improve their profits, how does that benefit the tenant in any way? They're not getting more for their money. Because they're paying to cover the costs of a business the landlord chose to enter into, rather than paying for the use of a property for an amount of time.

But that's the way the renting business is in reality, reap the rewards when things are good, pat yourself on the back for your shrewd business acumen and hard work, but pass on the costs and responsibilities when things take a turn for the worse and say you're not a charity, and regardless of the reason there's a downturn in income and that it's just a part of being a business, refuse to acknowledge that as the owner of the business, it's what you entered into in the first place.

SionnachRua · 29/09/2021 12:52

Yanbu but I'd add that it should be either at inflation rate or at a set low rate (say 2%), whichever is lower. In order to protect tenants against soaring inflation.

Chloemol · 29/09/2021 12:50

YABU. For some it is a business , therefore they need a profit to live of themselves

For some they fell into being a landlord, may only have one property they are renting out as a investment for retirement. They may not be able to afford to ‘absorb’ the costs mentioned, and why should they?

Rent needs to cover not only the mortgage, but also to be able to save towards costs of replacement boilers, repairs and maintenance, why should the6 be out of pocket to let you live there?

If you don’t like it then don’t rent, but your own place, live with family, other options are out there

girlmom21 · 29/09/2021 12:44

YABU. Most landlords want to make a profit, not just cover the cost of their mortgage. If demand is higher in an area, of course they'll charge more.

They also need to take into account costs of repairs, loss of earnings if they lose a tenant, etc.

ChampagneLassie · 29/09/2021 12:39

On a more positive note I have a very lovely landlord who has just offered to gift me a nursing chair (on finding out I'm pregnant)

ChampagneLassie · 29/09/2021 12:38

The housing situation in this country is ridiculous and is a result of poor government policy over the last 20+ years. B2L landlords exploit the situation. A proper Labour government would offer real ways to tackle this. As others have said other countries have rent controls and restrictions such that becoming a landlord doesn't look like some sort of massive money spinner. I'd vote for that

PhillMcCann · 29/09/2021 12:28

Not sure if still the case or even standard, but when I lived and rented in the UK, the lease agreement had a clause in it stating that at annual renewal of lease any rent increase would be limited to RPI index published on a certain website

My tenancy limits rises to 5% on each renewal.