Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think private rent increases should be limited to inflation only

141 replies

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 11:06

We are currently applying to rent a 2 bedroom house for £785 a month. The same house was up for rent previously 2 years ago for £695.

The seems like a massive increase, and other houses for rent on the area seem to have gone up by the same or even more. We're currently in a 3 bed for £850, but it has a dreadful damp problem. No doubt our landlord will paint it and put it back up for £900/£950.

Aibu to think private landlords should be limited in how much they increase rent? I understand that there is limited supply, so landlords are taking advantage of this to put up prices, but like most people my wages are not increasing on real terms and having a somewhere to live is quickly becoming unaffordable!!

OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 29/09/2021 16:11

@Fancymice on the one hand you are saying that you dont object to a fair rent but on the other you dont want to be covering half the costs associated with providing decent housing.

Im a landlord and I do think there is a good case to be made for more regulation of the rental market but, if rental properties are to be kept safe and in good repair, then the cost of those things is going to have to be figured into the rental cost. In the same way, if you should ever be in a position to buy a house you'll find your costs run way beyond your monthly mortgage payments even though you dont actually have to keep it to nearly such a high standard as a rental property.

Shitfuckcommaetc · 29/09/2021 15:57

A few years ago my landlord gave us notice as they said they were selling up. Fine, no problem at all.

We'd been there 8 years and only had minimal rent increases over that time, we were paying £900pm when we left.

It was never put up for sale. 6 weeks after we left it was let out again at £1400pm.

that pissed me off a bit!

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 15:49

@vivainsomnia

Some of the replies are insane: housing is a human right ffs. BTL has fucked an entire generation of young people Your human right is not my responsibility. Or are you suggesting that I should make a loss every month to support a stranger who for all I know just can't budget right?

Or I should sell? And then what? As many predicted, landlords selling has had no impact in reducing house costs (surprise surprise) and left with even less option for those who need to rent!

Why do people always jump to the argument that if there were controls on rent landlords would be making no money and would all immediately sell up etc etc.

It's disgustingly disingenuous. I would never expect to live rent free or on a very low rent at the expense of someone else. I am just aware of the reality of the situation that I am essentially purchasing an asset I will never own.

OP posts:
stairway · 29/09/2021 15:40

Housing is terrible in this country. A whole generation is stuck in very expensive often poorly maintained rental properties with little rights and freedoms seeing all their earnings going to someone else. Whilst the other half profit from soaring house prices. We need more housing schemes for low earners but this will never happen under a conservative government who want the poor to fund the well off.

vivainsomnia · 29/09/2021 15:25

Why is that I wonder?
Because food retailers don't have something they wish they had themselves.

vivainsomnia · 29/09/2021 15:24

In what other area of economic activity does the taxpayer provide private individuals with an income and the ability to acquire an asset that seems to rise in value inexorably?
And here we go! Many landlord don't go to buy a BTL. They become a landlord because they move with a partner. They take ownership of their parent asset. Or they do buy for family member.

Most landlords who own 1 or 2 properties, that is the very majority do NOT get much of an income out if it. Not any longer. Why would they be so desperate to sell if it was such a good and easy money earner?

The tax payer provides an income that pays for they accomodation and go back to society in tax.

justasking111 · 29/09/2021 15:20

Insurance on rentals has gone up above inflation rates. Annual boiler inspections doubled in five years. Costs of redecorating, etc have risen enormously plus loss of rent while workmen are in. Estate agents handling fees have risen substantially

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 29/09/2021 14:55

All businesses pass their running costs on to their clients this basically.

Being fed is also a human right isn’t it? Funny how people love attacking private landlord who are often individuals but never claim that supermarkets are monsters for making a profit when selling us our food. Why is that I wonder?

LakieLady · 29/09/2021 14:55

I'd love to know what proportion of money paid in benefits goes into the pockets of private landlords.

In what other area of economic activity does the taxpayer provide private individuals with an income and the ability to acquire an asset that seems to rise in value inexorably?

Rent controls would benefit both tenants and the public purse.

vivainsomnia · 29/09/2021 14:45

Not an expert but I remember a landlord tax came into effect in the last few years so it might be accounting for that
Of course it dies but tenants are in denial and don't want to hear it!

vivainsomnia · 29/09/2021 14:43

Some of the replies are insane: housing is a human right ffs. BTL has fucked an entire generation of young people
Your human right is not my responsibility. Or are you suggesting that I should make a loss every month to support a stranger who for all I know just can't budget right?

Or I should sell? And then what? As many predicted, landlords selling has had no impact in reducing house costs (surprise surprise) and left with even less option for those who need to rent!

MilduraS · 29/09/2021 14:43

Not an expert but I remember a landlord tax came into effect in the last few years so it might be accounting for that.

DixonD · 29/09/2021 14:42

@simitra

If youve been in the property some time and are a good paying tenant you can always attempt to bargain.

When my LL attempted to raise my rent by £50 a month I told her that I couldnt afford that and offered £20 a month. I had done my homework and looked on the land registry to find out how much the original morgage had been and knew it was paid off. I did remind her that the kitchen and bathroom were below standard in decor and little had been spent on the house over all. If I left she would have to spend a lot of money on the house to relet or sell it. I was prepared to throw the information about the mortgage into the pot too, but we settled on £30.

What relevance does an outstanding or redeemed mortgage have to do with what level of rent you pay?

It’s none of your business if your landlord has a mortgage or not.

Porcupineintherough · 29/09/2021 14:41

@MsMoody

Some of the replies are insane: housing is a human right ffs. BTL has fucked an entire generation of young people.
So is food and so is water and we pay for those too.
DixonD · 29/09/2021 14:36

@HarrietsChariot

Rents shouldn't be based on inflation, no. They should be based on the monthly mortgage repayment the landlord has on the property, up to 90%. That way people who invest in property still benefit from price rises and only have to find a relatively small amount out of their own pocket each month, but they cannot exploit renters. Obviously once the mortgage is payed off, rent would decrease to zero.
You’re joking?
MsMoody · 29/09/2021 14:28

Some of the replies are insane: housing is a human right ffs. BTL has fucked an entire generation of young people.

vivainsomnia · 29/09/2021 14:21

If I can afford £800 or whatever a month rent I can afford the £400-£500 mortgage and stash the rest for repairs/extra insurances
You could now, because interest rates are so low and been for a while. Many forget that it wasn't always like that and might indeed not remain so for the next 25 years.

Noone forces a landlord to become a landlord but everyone needs (and deserves) safe, adequate, long term shelter
So why are you complaining now that so many landlords have sold up. Has it made it better? Can renters get better or cheeper accommodation? Oh wait, no, it's got worse.

You can't kick landlords for running a business and then kick them again when they give it up!

Upamountain43 · 29/09/2021 14:12

@dameofdilemma

Other countries manage to have rent controls and better protections for tenants without the entirety of capitalism breaking down and melting into a puddle of communism.

Take a long hard look at housing in this country - houses have become an investment vehicle rather than a home.

Noone forces a landlord to become a landlord but everyone needs (and deserves) safe, adequate, long term shelter.

This ^^ and nothing more needs to be added to the conversation.

There are many other ways to run a society. The vested interests in this country are keeping us locked into this madness and have convinced the majority of the population that it has to be this way.

It does not.

Porcupineintherough · 29/09/2021 14:10

@SionnachRua youre right, a fully functioning home should be a basic requirement for a rental property. It's a luxury for a lot of home owners though. And I do think quite a few renters are naive about the costs associated with keeping a home fully functional, hence the posts claiming that rent doesnt need to cover more than mortgage payments.

MintJulia · 29/09/2021 13:46

@Fancymice The central heating is as much part of a house as the roof. A typical boiler cost about £1800, it will last about 10 years. So the annual cost of the boiler is £180 + £75 annual service = £255 a year. The landlord covers his costs by including an annual boiler amount in the rent.

A tenant contributes the cost related to how long they used the thing for. Then if the landlord sells the house, it's in roughly the same condition it was in when he first rented it out. He hasn't gained or lost on the boiler. You've just paid for the bit you've used.

DownToTheSeaAgain · 29/09/2021 13:41

It costs a lot of money to keep a home in good repair and have everything working. Although I know most renters would rather not be renting it is easy to make the comparison between the monthly rental cost and the mortgage cost but it is not a valid one.

If you rent you are generally not paying for things like a new roof, new carpets or the various insurances and safety checks that may be required. You are paying not to have to worry about these things.

Whether making money from rental property is morally right is another issue altogether. It has however been going on since humans owned property and looks set to continue. Crying unjust or unfair isn't going to improve the situation and forcing landlords to restrict potential profit (when they are a business) is only going to reduce the available housing stock.

Redcart21 · 29/09/2021 13:39

YABU. It’s often a myth that LLs are rolling in money. Many are just breaking even after paying all the insurances, interest, tax, maintenance etc. Especially those with 1 or 2 properties- which are the majority of landlords.
BTL is a business. Like all businesses, all expenses are calculated and rent set accordingly. Sorry you seem to have no idea about the costs of being a LL and what your property is costing them.

GiraffeClimber · 29/09/2021 13:39

What is needed is a plentiful supply of decent social housing, a good size with gardens, and secure tenancies and without the right to buy.

girlmom21 · 29/09/2021 13:38

They can sell the house, with the mortgage having been covered by tenants. In what world is that not a profit?

LL will have paid the deposit.
The house may well also not have any equity in it.

Horst · 29/09/2021 13:37

Also a bug bear of mine. Rent payments should count as proof of being able to pay for a mortgage.

If I can afford £800 or whatever a month rent I can afford the £400-£500 mortgage and stash the rest for repairs/extra insurances.

But on £800 I can’t afford to save for a deposit.