Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think private rent increases should be limited to inflation only

141 replies

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 11:06

We are currently applying to rent a 2 bedroom house for £785 a month. The same house was up for rent previously 2 years ago for £695.

The seems like a massive increase, and other houses for rent on the area seem to have gone up by the same or even more. We're currently in a 3 bed for £850, but it has a dreadful damp problem. No doubt our landlord will paint it and put it back up for £900/£950.

Aibu to think private landlords should be limited in how much they increase rent? I understand that there is limited supply, so landlords are taking advantage of this to put up prices, but like most people my wages are not increasing on real terms and having a somewhere to live is quickly becoming unaffordable!!

OP posts:
CatTerrier · 29/09/2021 21:33

Changes to rules regarding electrical safety testing are a new added cost (although a good idea). Plus not letting agents cannot charge big fees to tenants, they may be passing them on to landlords.

Nonamesleftt · 29/09/2021 21:29

I am a landlord and a tenant, and i agree OP. The place I'm renting has rent increases capped at 2% per year, which gives some security. I have no intention on raising my tenant's rent this year, even though the average rent has gone up enormously in my area this past year.

I also think it's ridiculous that landlords expect their mortgage + all other costs to be covered. No other business owner would expect to end up with an asset worth several hundred thousand pounds without putting in any of their own money.

Holdingontonothing · 29/09/2021 21:21

The other consideration is the pensions crisis and extended life expectancy meaning people need to look at things like property investment to pay for their retirement.

It's all well and good blaming "greedy landlords " (not my view BTW) but if someone needs and wants to provide for their retirement in the absence of pre crisis pensions, can we really blame them?

ShinyBeans · 29/09/2021 21:18

I'm a single, working parent. I work full-time and receive universal credit. I rent a 2 bedroom house for £925 that's just been sold and the new owner is happy for me to stay, but they want £1100 a month. My housing benefit is around £750, the maximum for 2 bedrooms where I live.

There's nowhere to move to in the current market. Landlords can charge that much because people are desperate, but it doesn't mean that they should or that the property is worth that much.

£1100 a month for a tiny house in not the nicest of areas. Madness. I don't know how I'm going to afford food.

Porcupineintherough · 29/09/2021 21:15

@stairway in the past most people didnt own their own homes and they didnt all live in counvil housing either. Private rental has alaays been the norm in the UK.

Its certainly true there was more council housing in the recent past, but the Tories sold it off and a lot of people support them in doing that (and still do).

stairway · 29/09/2021 21:06

TheHouseILiveIn The hatred of Landlords is because long term renting is ruining many people’s lives. Things were better in the past when there were at least council houses. Now many people have the prospect of giving all their salary to a landlord with little hope of owning their own homes. I think it’s more resentment than jealousy. The government allowed house prices to inflate and sold off council houses and some people have done very well out of this situation whilst others are suffering.

TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 20:55

Until something is done at government level you as a tenant need me more than I need you.
And I don't say that with any satisfaction.

This is so true. The new punitive tax rules, eg pretending a landlord has no mortgage interest and so taxing them on money they haven't received, and adding an extra stamp duty charge have made the numbers not stack up. No wonder there is such a shortage of BTLs. It's not helped FTBs be able to buy either, so what was the point?

I've rented many times over my life: as a student, as a new grad in a new city and even I moved cities for a job while I found somewhere to buy. I was GRATEFUL that someone had a private rental I could rent. What would have been the alternative?Confused

I think this hatred of landlords is fueled by jealousy, because as other PP have pointed out, nobody treats supermarkets or utility companies with this vitriol

Patapouf · 29/09/2021 20:47

@PersonaNonGarter

It’s hard but it is fair. The rent is going up according to market rates and the landlord will be paying increased bills on eg trades, goods, and so on as everything goes up.

There needs to be a better way. We need more homes fast.

But market rates aren't fair are they because we are in the midst of a housing crisis and demand is huge. Doesn't make it okay for private landlords to charge obscene amounts of money does it?
Nsky · 29/09/2021 20:38

Highly unfair your viewpoint, I have house rented ( and yes I need the money), with agents, requests granted and always treated well and fairly.
Plus interest rates for savers crap, not good idea.
Rates are set to areas too.

MadameMaxGoesler · 29/09/2021 20:32

More detail on why rent controls don't work.
www.iea.org.uk/sites/default/files/publications/files/DP_Rent%20ceilings.pdf

roarfeckingroarr · 29/09/2021 20:30

Well if you keep putting higher taxes and charges on landlords, rents are going to rise.

MadameMaxGoesler · 29/09/2021 20:28

Even the Guardian acknowledges that rent controls don't work.
www.theguardian.com/world/2015/aug/19/why-stockholm-housing-rules-rent-control-flat

BoredZelda · 29/09/2021 20:27

Sounds fair to me. Family homes shouldn’t be investor-fodder. Lots of people will come up with reasons why neither this nor anything else should be done. They usually have a vested interest

Anyone who disagrees with you must have a vested interest? What nonsense.

I don’t own any property other than my own and have no intention of doing so. I don’t believe the government should be dictating to private owners or companies how they must price their properties. That’s interfering with the market, and with a fundamental principle of how business works in the U.K. Next people will be suggesting they decide that supermarkets can’t charge over a certain amount for food.

If the government is to ensure security of affordable housing, they should be buying these properties or building their own and letting them for peppercorn rents. The answer to housing problems is not to pass the price on to private housing providers with whom they have no contract.

Let the market decide. If people can’t pay the price, the prices will come down.

C0ffeePe0ple638 · 29/09/2021 19:24

I allow people with benefits & pets

RandomLondoner · 29/09/2021 19:08

Oh yeah, as a New Yorker I can tell you those $800 p.m rent controlled 2 bedroom apartments in Greenwich Village, home of the 2k a month studio, are completely under occupied. No one wants them

Would the total number of people living in the currently rent controlled apartments be higher, lower or the same, if the rents on all of them doubled?

A US economist had said the number would be higher, what is your reasoning, if you think otherwise?

(I think he quoted a statistic that people are much more likely to live alone in these aparments than in non-rent-controlled areas. Possibly you didn't read my original post properly and haven't really understood what is meant by under-occupied?)

GalesThisMorning · 29/09/2021 18:44

There are still places in the USA with rent controls, e.g. New York, and to this day these properties are under-occupied compared to ones where a market-rent is required

Oh yeah, as a New Yorker I can tell you those $800 p.m rent controlled 2 bedroom apartments in Greenwich Village, home of the 2k a month studio, are completely under occupied. No one wants them Grin

RandomLondoner · 29/09/2021 18:28

I'd love to know what proportion of money paid in benefits goes into the pockets of private landlords.

This post is utter nonsense, unfortunately a lot of people do think like this.

People on benefits, in addition to paying for housing, probably also pay utilities, buy food, may own a smartphone?

I've yet to see anyone ask why Asda and Tesco should benefit from the taxpayers money that goes into their pockets.

I've yet to see anyone ask why British Gas, or Thames Water, or BT or Sky should be profiting from taxpayers money.

I've yet to see anyone demand that Samsung or Apple refund the government for taxpayers money that was spent on their products.

In what other area of economic activity does the taxpayer provide private individuals with an income and the ability to acquire an asset that seems to rise in value inexorably?

I have a lot of money invested. None of it is in housing, because the returns aren't high enough. It's true that in the past some people have made fortunes through leverage exposure, but that's not a game I've ever been interested in playing. I certainly wouldn't try it at today's prices.

vivainsomnia · 29/09/2021 18:27

It's disgustingly disingenuous
No it's not at all, it's the reality. It might not be one you are familiar with but still reality.

Why do you think so many landlords have sold up and there is now a rental crisis worse than ever?

RandomLondoner · 29/09/2021 18:10

Other countries manage to have rent controls and better protections for tenants without the entirety of capitalism breaking down and melting into a puddle of communism.

Recently I watched a youtube lecture by a US economist on the subject of rent control.

Apparently, after world war 2 there was a massive shortage of housing. People were living in tents, converting old trams into housing, etc.

This was strange, as there had been no housing shortage before the war, the population had not changed since then, and the housing supply had actually increased by 10%.

What had happened was that during the war, rent controls were brought in. This, unsurprisingly, caused people to consume more housing than they otherwise would. Young adults moved out of their parents homes sooner. Older adults were less inclined to downsize when their children moved out. Lots more people lived alone that had been the case previously.

People who didn't already have housing could not offer to pay more than the regulated rents, so they resorted to bribing people who controlled access to housing to bump them up the waiting list.

The rent controls were abolished, and very shortly afterwards, the shortage of housing vanished.

There are still places in the USA with rent controls, e.g. New York, and to this day these properties are under-occupied compared to ones where a market-rent is required.

NailsNeedDoing · 29/09/2021 17:31

@LakieLady

I'd love to know what proportion of money paid in benefits goes into the pockets of private landlords.

In what other area of economic activity does the taxpayer provide private individuals with an income and the ability to acquire an asset that seems to rise in value inexorably?

Rent controls would benefit both tenants and the public purse.

The taxpayer doesn’t provide private individuals with an income.

The taxpayer pays for people who can’t afford a home for themselves and their families to have a home so that they aren’t living in slums or on the streets.

It’s not the landlords claiming the benefits, the landlords are the ones doing their best to for themselves and their families.

They really can’t win on this one though, landlords are either discriminating evil bastards because they won’t let to someone on benefits, or they’re greedy evil bastards for allowing people with low or no incomes to rent their properties by using benefits.

BasiliskStare · 29/09/2021 17:14

Friend of mine is considering selling her BTL flat - she has kept the rent below market value as the tenants were and are lovely - but her increased costs are making it not worth it. Now thinking with other costs year she could be in deficit.

Private LL should behave properly but they aren't a charity - proper contracts / agreements etc should sort this out & if it suits neither party they can pull out ( given proper notices etc etc )

C0ffeePe0ple638 · 29/09/2021 17:02

I haven't increased the rent, at my choice for several years

However, as a landlord all my bills have increased

Some people are

C0ffeePe0ple638 · 29/09/2021 16:58

A landlord cannot charge zero rent, because they have to pay for things like the below. Example Do you think that landlord insurance has not increased each year ?

Landlord insurance
Maintenance & repairs
Gas & electrical safety checks
Agency fees or other costs if not managed by an agency
Council tax & utilities for times when the property is vacant
If it is a leasehold property, there can be extra charges
Tax on the income
RISK- know someone who had a "bad tenant" & it cost 20k to put things right

Being a responsible landlord is not easy money & takes time & effort !

Nobody runs a Business at a loss, because it makes zero financial sense

Auroreforet · 29/09/2021 16:25

@Fancymice
I am just aware of the reality of the situation that I am essentially purchasing an asset I will never own.

Yes. You are.
However the alternative if you can't get a mortgage is become homeless.

We spent 40 years paying our mortgage.
We sold our home and downsized.
We rent out our new home presently but expect to live there again in a few years.
In 3 years we haven't raised the rent.
We've bought a new washing machine and dishwasher, new shower screen, paid to have all the electrics checked ( new law) although they are less than 12 years old and we wouldn't have done it for ourselves, the boiler is checked annually, the chimney swept annually, brand new patio doors because the lock broke, guttering cleaned and now the front door has faded so I need to get it painted.
I estimate we spend £1500. a year on the house.
If we had a mortgage we'd be in debt!

The state of housing in the UK is dire.
Until something is done at government level you as a tenant need me more than I need you.
And I don't say that with any satisfaction.
I keep our house how I would want it for myself.
My tenant told me it's like Christmas everyday in our house.

Notadramallama · 29/09/2021 16:17

I have a house that I let. It has no mortgage on it. In the last financial year I made a profit of £5k. That was with no huge outlays eg new boiler, re-decorating etc. Again - this is without a mortgage. I am considering selling or leaving it empty as this level of profit isn't worth the risk of having tenants who might cause a high level of damage.