Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think private rent increases should be limited to inflation only

141 replies

Fancymice · 29/09/2021 11:06

We are currently applying to rent a 2 bedroom house for £785 a month. The same house was up for rent previously 2 years ago for £695.

The seems like a massive increase, and other houses for rent on the area seem to have gone up by the same or even more. We're currently in a 3 bed for £850, but it has a dreadful damp problem. No doubt our landlord will paint it and put it back up for £900/£950.

Aibu to think private landlords should be limited in how much they increase rent? I understand that there is limited supply, so landlords are taking advantage of this to put up prices, but like most people my wages are not increasing on real terms and having a somewhere to live is quickly becoming unaffordable!!

OP posts:
TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 23:47

@Tealightsandd

Even if people don't care about others, social housing will save the taxpayer money.

The current UK public health housing and homelessness emergency costs billions - both directly (eg. expensive homeless accommodation, very high housing benefit bill) and indirectly through the knock on affects.

Let's get rid of private landlords then! It would involve tax hikes to pay for the properties the government will need to buy. I don't think current landlords would be too upset...they'd just sell and get rid of the headache.
justasking111 · 29/09/2021 23:41

Friends work for a housing association they're doing their best within strict budgets which are improving they're buying within new estates but builders have to go through planning a long process it can take two years from inception to a front door key

ImNotDancing · 29/09/2021 23:38

@Tealightsandd

We need more social housing. Lots of it.

That is the solution.

Here here
Tealightsandd · 29/09/2021 23:37

Even if people don't care about others, social housing will save the taxpayer money.

The current UK public health housing and homelessness emergency costs billions - both directly (eg. expensive homeless accommodation, very high housing benefit bill) and indirectly through the knock on affects.

ImNotDancing · 29/09/2021 23:37

I prepare to be flamed for this but personally I don’t think property should be a profit exercise. I don’t believe it should be turned into a business. It will never happen but I’d prefer there not be so called private landlords and a better system put in place that prevents buy to let. I’d also be for a scheme that prevented second homes. I say this as a woman in her mid 20s who is unable to move out from home as there is simply nowhere affordable in the local area.

TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 23:35

What’s insane is that the eight similar properties to rent in my town are all £1200+ a month. Which is why so many adult children in the SE are still living at home.

If it was insane nobody would pay it. So the demand is there and the landlord who sunk £100k into the property will get a return on his investment. He could have put it into shares instead and received £10k a year and be stress-free.

Tealightsandd · 29/09/2021 23:34

We need more social housing. Lots of it.

That is the solution.

TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 23:31

House prices versus rent is usually a stable differential

Sorry, what I meant to say is that usually this is a stable differential, so when house prices go up new landlords (do the ones buying) get less return on their investment. Because of the way rental stock has reduced due to less landlords rent prices are going up. This is not usually the case and high house prices aren't usually what landlords who want to increase their portfolio want.

NovemberWitch · 29/09/2021 23:29

@Lavender24

Yeah it's insane. The house across from me has just gone up for rent for £595. I think that's a lot for a tiny 2 bed terraced house in the north east. Back when I lived in rented accommodation (pre 2018) I'd have paid no more than £450 pcm for a property of that size.
What’s insane is that the eight similar properties to rent in my town are all £1200+ a month. Which is why so many adult children in the SE are still living at home.
TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 23:21

The higher house prices are, the lower yields BTL investors receive.

TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 23:17

@willstarttomorrow

The UK's attitude to property is the problem. Renting is common in many places in Europe and people stay for several years in a property with legal protections in place. Being an amateur landlord in the UK was an option for far too long before some tax restrictions have made it less profitable. The whole 'market rate' arguement ignores the fact that house prices have been inflated by buy to let landlords who do not maintain their properties. Legal protection for renters in the UK is woeful. Of course lots of landlords will pile on and say how great they are and have horror stories about tenants. But surely that is the risk involved when you choose to become a landlord? Obviously it is not ok for tenants to trash a house but neither is it ok for boilers not to be fixed, cheapest possible fixtures and fittings and for tenants never being able to feel the space they pay for is their home.
Why do you think landlords are responsible for house price inflation? That doesn't make sense. Landlords only buy houses if they're cheap. Ask any estate agent and they will tell you BTL investors drive the hardest bargains. House prices versus rent is usually a stable differential and BTL investors need to buy the property cheaper than a buy-to-live buyer would. Lots of landlords have sold because of the new unfavorable conditions and yet house prices continue to increase.

House price inflation is because two-person mortgages are now the norm and interest rates are extremely low. When I first bought a house I remember thinking 5% interest rates are the norm and I should expect rates to be around that for the entirety of my loan.

willstarttomorrow · 29/09/2021 23:04

The UK's attitude to property is the problem. Renting is common in many places in Europe and people stay for several years in a property with legal protections in place. Being an amateur landlord in the UK was an option for far too long before some tax restrictions have made it less profitable. The whole 'market rate' arguement ignores the fact that house prices have been inflated by buy to let landlords who do not maintain their properties. Legal protection for renters in the UK is woeful.
Of course lots of landlords will pile on and say how great they are and have horror stories about tenants. But surely that is the risk involved when you choose to become a landlord? Obviously it is not ok for tenants to trash a house but neither is it ok for boilers not to be fixed, cheapest possible fixtures and fittings and for tenants never being able to feel the space they pay for is their home.

Newkitchen123 · 29/09/2021 22:46

@Shitfuckcommaetc

A few years ago my landlord gave us notice as they said they were selling up. Fine, no problem at all.

We'd been there 8 years and only had minimal rent increases over that time, we were paying £900pm when we left.

It was never put up for sale. 6 weeks after we left it was let out again at £1400pm.

that pissed me off a bit!

Are you sure it wasn't just a private sale to another landlord? A nearby property to me was sold without being advertised.
TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 22:36

In my area there are loads of houses for sale with tenants in situ. I have never seen this before...the odd one, yes, but not loads like there are now!

Newkitchen123 · 29/09/2021 22:14

@HarrietsChariot

Rents shouldn't be based on inflation, no. They should be based on the monthly mortgage repayment the landlord has on the property, up to 90%. That way people who invest in property still benefit from price rises and only have to find a relatively small amount out of their own pocket each month, but they cannot exploit renters. Obviously once the mortgage is payed off, rent would decrease to zero.
But when, say, the boiler breaks the landlord should just find this money out of thin air?
justasking111 · 29/09/2021 22:10

Friends in Italy Milan live in rented properties, the state of their place is shocking although rent controlled the landlords spend nothing on them nor are expected to. They're both in highly paid work live in slumlike conditions four days a week but own. A beautiful home in the mountains where they ski in the winter and walk in the summer n. They won't spend a penny on their cheap rental

SeasonFinale · 29/09/2021 22:04

You do realise that the landlord pays income tax on the rent too at whatever rate they pay so potentially higher rate tax.

littlebilliie · 29/09/2021 21:56

@dameofdilemma

Other countries manage to have rent controls and better protections for tenants without the entirety of capitalism breaking down and melting into a puddle of communism.

Take a long hard look at housing in this country - houses have become an investment vehicle rather than a home.

Noone forces a landlord to become a landlord but everyone needs (and deserves) safe, adequate, long term shelter.

I totally agree there are little controls. However having a BTL property comes with a massive amount of risk as the borrowing is help without the normal protections of a residential mortgage. We haven't seen banks fail but in Iceland people lost their property through banks failing.
justasking111 · 29/09/2021 21:55

Checked Rightmove last night five mile radius put on market in the last 24 hours almost all of them said SSTC I was stunned.

My friend put her 2 bed house on the market first viewer offered full price cash buyer. Second home for the moment, so they want to buy some of the furniture.

The housing market here is on fire still

littlebilliie · 29/09/2021 21:50

@ChampagneLassie

The housing situation in this country is ridiculous and is a result of poor government policy over the last 20+ years. B2L landlords exploit the situation. A proper Labour government would offer real ways to tackle this. As others have said other countries have rent controls and restrictions such that becoming a landlord doesn't look like some sort of massive money spinner. I'd vote for that
Sadly the last Labour government were pushing the whole BTL and let's not forget the PFP arrangements which the public sector will be paying off forever but never own.
stairway · 29/09/2021 21:49

I think if all landlords sold up, I think the government would be forced to address the housing crisis. It would mean a lot of misery to begin with but at least our children might have a better future overall.

kittenpeak · 29/09/2021 21:45

Haven't read all the replies but no, it shouldn't be capped at inflation: their costs increase in other ways. If / when they renew their mortgage it could go up, and they'll need to pass that to the tenant. Repairs and maintenance too: those costs are going up so will need to be passed on.

TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 21:43

@ShinyBeans

I'm a single, working parent. I work full-time and receive universal credit. I rent a 2 bedroom house for £925 that's just been sold and the new owner is happy for me to stay, but they want £1100 a month. My housing benefit is around £750, the maximum for 2 bedrooms where I live.

There's nowhere to move to in the current market. Landlords can charge that much because people are desperate, but it doesn't mean that they should or that the property is worth that much.

£1100 a month for a tiny house in not the nicest of areas. Madness. I don't know how I'm going to afford food.

This isn't good. But I don't know what the answer is If your landlord thought it wasn't worth it she would sell up and you would have to find somewhere else. But that would probably be difficult because a lot of landlords would be in the same position. Renting stock would decrease and competition would be intense. You wouldn't be able to find anywhere

Telling landlords to reduce rent when their costs are rising would just lead to less private rentals available

TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 21:39

@Holdingontonothing

The other consideration is the pensions crisis and extended life expectancy meaning people need to look at things like property investment to pay for their retirement.

It's all well and good blaming "greedy landlords " (not my view BTW) but if someone needs and wants to provide for their retirement in the absence of pre crisis pensions, can we really blame them?

Exactly!
TheHouseILiveIn · 29/09/2021 21:39

@stairway

TheHouseILiveIn The hatred of Landlords is because long term renting is ruining many people’s lives. Things were better in the past when there were at least council houses. Now many people have the prospect of giving all their salary to a landlord with little hope of owning their own homes. I think it’s more resentment than jealousy. The government allowed house prices to inflate and sold off council houses and some people have done very well out of this situation whilst others are suffering.
This is true but I think the anger at landlords is misdirected. They're not evil...they are just running a business and fulfilling a need. Council houses are non-existent and I don't see the government acquiring more! Punishing landlords leads to renters being punished. Honestly, if all landlords disappeared, what would happen to renters?