Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the ambitions for Net Carbon Zero are utterly impossible for most households?

142 replies

backoffice · 29/09/2021 08:06

I’ve been looking at some of the suggestions that are supposed to be “normalised” for consumers to adopt as we move towards lower carbon: heat pumps, solar power, electric vehicles etc.

To adopt any of these is going to cost a family thousands of pounds! Not to mention the practicalities of e.g. heat pumps in tiny houses with little gardens/small roof. It seems utterly unreasonable to expect consumers to adopt these technologies unless they have a lot of money and large properties, but it’s basically what the government seems to expect people to do. AIBU?

OP posts:
MakingM · 29/09/2021 09:33

YANBU

Having looked some of the Net Zero plans, I’ve come to the conclusion that our government resides in cloud cuckoo land and the populace are more likely to vote for an Uber-Farage type figure before we get anywhere near achieving the Net Zero goal, however desirable it might be.

I I mean look around - there are people fighting with knives over petrol ffs.

EvilRingahBitch · 29/09/2021 09:33

Our neighbours in our terraced street used to charge their electric car through the letterbox over the pavement (with a good quality ramp over the cable so it didn't seriously inconvenience anyone). Now of course they charge it by plugging it into the street light.

Once all the cars on the street are electric then there will be etiquette problems with who gets first dibs on the limited number of street lights (although there's a set of communal chargers a few minutes walk away). If etiquette doesn't manage it then the camera technology to impose a limited max time at the charging place is not too tricky. But relatively few cars have an full charge's use every single day, and a lot of those will spend the day in a carpark with a charger at the other end.

heldinadream · 29/09/2021 09:32

Governments the world over have spent the last 50 years AT LEAST pretending none of this was happening and neither informing the populace of the facts nor planning for change and now the world over they are all gung ho with 'We can do this', except for the ones that now openly don't give a shit (Bolsonaro and his ilk). 'We can do this' is frankly still a continuation of the simplistic messages that really amount to more lies. I agree with Greta - it's all blah blah blah.
It's all too little, too complex, too difficult and too late.
Just live your life and do your best. It's never going to be anything better than - at best - a muddle and - at worst - a series of disasters and catastrophes.

FreedomFaith · 29/09/2021 09:30

[quote onlychildhamster]@FreedomFaith what if it's a requirement of your mortgage? I see that as the only way they can 'enforce it', posted a link upthread.[/quote]
That will likely only really affect the really bad homes, like at g rating to maybe e. My home is at c/d, can't remember which. The mortgage lenders will refuse some if it affects their average score, not going to reject all. The worse your score is, the more likely you are to be rejected. Hopefully won't affect us being at average already.

backoffice · 29/09/2021 09:30

I don’t think most people have a clue about the massive changes that are needed/planned.

OP posts:
backoffice · 29/09/2021 09:30

I can’t help but think that the “mini nuclear power station” option won’t be very popular with the public - the plan is for them to be EVERYWHERE.

OP posts:
Stickytreacle · 29/09/2021 09:28

Even the materials needed for EV's are in short supp!y and child Labour is used in the supply, so they aren't as green as people seem to think.

We need investment in viable alternatives, including hydrogen and synthetic fuels to be able to reduce carbon. Bearing in mind that the mini nuclear power stations proposed by government won't be ready until 2050.

backoffice · 29/09/2021 09:24

The technology not being there is also so true. I was sold my condenser boiler 7 years ago as it was the greenest option apparently. Now it needs replacing?

OP posts:
backoffice · 29/09/2021 09:23

Just wondering how much those who have voted IABU have spent on these upgrades? What is reasonable in terms of £x,000?

OP posts:
backoffice · 29/09/2021 09:22

I don’t understand the hydrogen argument - how is it a good idea if it’s currently just coming from gas anyway?

Electric/nuclear is the only option isn’t it?

I’ve tried to look at improving my own home but I can’t afford it. With bills for university, subsidising elderly parents and saving for my own pension (all sensible things) there’s not the kind of money left over, although I want to make positive choices.

Am I being cynical wondering if the run-away energy bills are working in the governments favour to force people to use less energy?

OP posts:
Shuffalo · 29/09/2021 09:21

DH’s work (a big corporation) are trying to figure out what to do to reduce emissions and reach zero net carbon. The trouble is the technology just doesn’t exist yet. They’ve got the money to invest in the issue but nowhere viable to put it. The only options seem to be carry on pumping out carbon until the technology becomes available, or cease operating. They can take some steps but the impact will be minimal until the technology is there. By which point it will be too late.

Wazzzzzzzup · 29/09/2021 09:20

There is a thread on twotter with pics of car charging. Most people don't have off road parking so it's on pavements. Let's just say that groups which post pics of people psrked on pavements to shsme them are now adding charging cars to it.

but the government is banning the sale of new petrol cars after 2030
That will get pushed again, 100%, then used ones will be sold for decades, new cars will be used elsewhere or under rental if allowed which will turn them into used and so on. The infrastructures dtill isn't really there for everyone to have electric and will not be for a looooong time.
I don't think i will have an issue tio buy good quality petrol/diesel cadr in my lifetime. I am 30 and a bit...

araiwa · 29/09/2021 09:19

I havnt figured out how people who park on the street are going to charge their electric car yet, and that is the farthest ahead of all those technologies.

Do you have a petrol station at home?

anothermansshoes · 29/09/2021 09:14

I feel quite negative

I suspect that many people will be stuck with cold homes they can not sell or rent out with the running expense of 20 year old petrol cars

Just see how they treated leaseholders. with flammable cladding

Further , carbon savings are like pensions , what you save early has most impact . If we hit net zero in 2049 , climate change will be devastating, think starvation and water shortages here like we have seen in Africa

The government should have mandated heat pumps and solar panels for all new builds 10 years ago but didn't . That's lots of unnecessary carbon released

even here people are saying" hydrogen is better"

We haven't got the time to develop and deploy green hydrogen infrastructure

SantiagoSky · 29/09/2021 09:13

We (in Switzerland) got a government grant for our new heat pump that meant it was the same price as a new oil or gas based system.

GoldenOmber · 29/09/2021 09:08

Agreed, you can’t expect people to fund all of this themselves. Governments will need to support with grants and subsidies and other changes to make changes easier (like if you want to get people out of cars, make public transport cheaper/better and make active travel a more appealing option)

onlychildhamster · 29/09/2021 09:06

@Clymene but the government is banning the sale of new petrol cars after 2030. Almost all properties in my area are terraced houses or flats, cheapest house with a drive in my area is £1.4 million. However, there are some electric charging points and in nearby Muswell hill, I walked through a fairly expensive street (all terraced, no parking, most homes £2 million and up) and it had an electric charging station on the same street. And I expect most people in urban areas to give up their cars

There would be some people caught in no man's land- can't afford a house with drive further out but also can't afford to live in an area with good public transport. That is worrying.

Theteapotsbrokenspout · 29/09/2021 09:05

Absolutely agree @FeatheredHope there is a new build estate here (built over the last two years) with many prestigious south facing properties which could have had solar panels included in the build.

Clymene · 29/09/2021 09:01

We're never going to bulldoze all the old housing stock. 5 million properties were built pre 1919.

No one has come up for a solution for electric vehicles where there is limited off street parking.

Public transport is heinously expensive and ridiculously fragmented with nearly 30 different rail operators across the U.K.

There needs to be enormous infrastructure investment and a complete about face to renationalise all the different elements that need to work together.

I can't see it happening in my lifetime. We have a Tory government which doesn't care and a Labour Party that isn't fit for purpose.

onlychildhamster · 29/09/2021 09:00

'BEIS recommended that lenders consider energy efficiency as part of their mortgage assessment criteria, and review rules to encourage green mortgages.

It also proposed that lenders be encouraged to offer additional borrowing to existing customers to improve the energy performance of their homes'

Humph.

onlychildhamster · 29/09/2021 08:59

@Theteapotsbrokenspout that would be very strange as currently Victorian homes carry a premium at least where I live in London!

FeatheredHope · 29/09/2021 08:58

If the government actually gave a shit about any of this, they would have introduced legislation years ago requiring all new builds to have eco-saving tech as part of them.

onlychildhamster · 29/09/2021 08:56

@FreedomFaith what if it's a requirement of your mortgage? I see that as the only way they can 'enforce it', posted a link upthread.

Theteapotsbrokenspout · 29/09/2021 08:54

I can’t understand how this will work on older homes where some of the measures required will likely be detrimental to the property. For example a Victorian detached house with solid brick walls, lime rendered / plastered to ensure the house can breathe as originally intended. Rooms are too small for internal insulation, external insulation - as well as being prohibitively expensive - will alter the properties ability to breathe. Ground source heat pump extremely expensive and likely not enough land to install this, air source heat pump not recommended for this age property as it lacks the extreme insulation required for it to work effectively (see above).
In addition loft insulation is recommended to be a wool product, again to help the house breathe, is this more expensive option going to be covered by the government?
Will this house ever get a rating above D? Therefore will all properties from this era become unsaleable?

FreedomFaith · 29/09/2021 08:52

If they want me to do these things, they can pay for it. I'm not wasting my money on that, I've got you know, higher bills to pay now. Hmm Will not be able to produce the money needed unless I start shitting it.