Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the ambitions for Net Carbon Zero are utterly impossible for most households?

142 replies

backoffice · 29/09/2021 08:06

I’ve been looking at some of the suggestions that are supposed to be “normalised” for consumers to adopt as we move towards lower carbon: heat pumps, solar power, electric vehicles etc.

To adopt any of these is going to cost a family thousands of pounds! Not to mention the practicalities of e.g. heat pumps in tiny houses with little gardens/small roof. It seems utterly unreasonable to expect consumers to adopt these technologies unless they have a lot of money and large properties, but it’s basically what the government seems to expect people to do. AIBU?

OP posts:
Wbeezer · 29/09/2021 12:30

This guy (Just Have a Think) is very good at explaining the technology and issues:
<a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3D7iazrwLr030&ved=2ahUKEwit5Mb8iaTzAhWegf0HHRJRDp0Qxa8BegQIChAF&usg=AOvVaw3Ow_-j1sHN29Fowd4G0B4R" rel="nofollow" target="blank">www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3D7iazrwLr030&ved=2ahUKEwit5Mb8iaTzAhWegf0HHRJRDp0Qxa8BegQIChAF&usg=AOvVaw3Ow-j1sHN29Fowd4G0B4R

TuftyMarmoset · 29/09/2021 12:29

I hope you don’t have children @seaandsandcastles!

Clymene · 29/09/2021 12:27

Tbh whatever we as consumers do or don't do in the U.K. is going to have a negligible impact when a quarter of the G20 are doing fuck all

Wbeezer · 29/09/2021 12:26

Hydrogen will increasingly be made using renewables, ie wind and wave and hydro power, nuclear if we have to. Hydrogen boilers or the new electric heat storage boilers (they are like one big super hot, super insulated storage heater that releases its heat as needed to run radiators etc. see vids on YouTube).
My 1850s house will never be able to be insulated to the standard required for a heat pump to heat it, it needs to be able to breathe for a start or the fabric of the building will deteriorate. Its a listed building and i wouldn't be allowed to cover it in a thick layer of exterior insulation covered in render (what the government schemes in Ireland seem to be doing).
Its going to be a mixture, hydrogen boilers and cars for those in flats, heat pumps, heat storage boilers bio fuel and plug in cars for houses with space.
Government grants and subsidiesfor new windows and insulation and boilers. Also good old active travel, public transport and wearing of jumpers in the house.
The amount of carbon released building new energy efficient homes is massive and would outway the savings from knocking down old houses.

seaandsandcastles · 29/09/2021 12:24

I don’t even recycle so am I fuck doing any of that unless it benefits me 😂

BigHeartyTruffle · 29/09/2021 12:22

@LarryTheLurker

There is a lot I disagree with here, but just on a technical point. Yes CO2 is required at certain levels to sustain life, however it is a very fine balance and only needs a small increase in CO2 levels to become hazardous. Eg in the oceans where increased CO2 causes increased acidity, rendering it uninhabitable.

EvilRingahBitch · 29/09/2021 12:19

Yes we're a long way from where we need to be on electric car infrastructure but it's a distance that should be manageable within 5-10 years.
This is the answer to your Alton Towers example.

To think the ambitions for Net Carbon Zero are utterly impossible for most households?
indistinct · 29/09/2021 12:14

You are not being unreasonable however note that it is entirely with government and industry's gift to substantially support us in minimising carbon footprint (e.g. through tax incentives, electrification of domestic heating and cooking, etc ...). They did it successfully with CFCs and the hole in the ozone layer, they need to take a similar legislative and industrial change approach to address climate change.

PeonyTime · 29/09/2021 12:10

I'm guessing its showing in a rich/poor divide again. As there are people on the thread who cant see an issue, and I just cant see how it will happen. BUT, if there is a plan for the sort of quantity of chargers that you are talking about - public car parks, supermarkets, transport hubs, street chargers, big attractions (I guess places like Alton towers are going to need chargers?) then it becomes possible. I just can't see how it works when a town with around 50 filling PUMPS (each offering 3 fuels), drops to home or 2 alternatives..... the infrastructure just isnt around here yet. FWIW, I also looked at work availability of electric chargers. There is nothing within 5km, and I work in the centre of a small town.

LarryTheLurker · 29/09/2021 12:07

First things first, not only is 'net zero' impossible, it is completely unnecessary. On a global scale the UK produces a negligible amount of CO2, which in any event is not a pollutant but vital for life on Earth. It will be quietly abandoned over the next few years.

We can move to electric cars and home heating - not the useless ground source heat pumps, either - but it will take half a century if civil war is to be avoided. We need to stop all building and subsidising of wind farms, suspend any planned closure of gas or coal powered generators (and switch Drax back to coal rather than burning American trees while we are at it) and start fracking immediately. It is madness that we have billions of pounds worth of gas under our feet and yet have to buy gas from Russia. If this means facing down Big Wind, various Gazprom shills and their useful idiots, so be it.

In the longer term the only answer is nuclear, built and owned by the UK government rather than foreign multinationals, but that will take 20 years and a degree of political will our governments seem to have been incapable of for many years.

EvilRingahBitch · 29/09/2021 11:47

I quite agree Peony, people for whom it's currently inconvenient will understandably wait to switch until the infrastructure is more evolved.

But there are people who are arguing that banning the sale of ICE cars from 2030 is unacceptable because some people will never have a convenient local charging option that fits into their routine. When it comes to it those people will have to spend an extra 25 minutes at filling stations.

PeonyTime · 29/09/2021 11:38

Or, I stick with petrol until my street gets charging points or my supermarket gets charging points or my workplace gets a charging point (ive just checked, the station doesnt have one either). There are 2 public charging points in my town of 10,000 people. Why would I jump now?

EvilRingahBitch · 29/09/2021 11:20

What it comes down to is that if you don't have off-street parking, or local on street charging points and you don't park your car during the day at a workplace carpark or a public carpark, or the station carpark while you commute, and you use your car sufficiently that a weekly charge at the supermarket while you do your big shop won't be enough, and you definitely need a car and can't switch to public transport or pedal power. In that case you'll need to spend half an hour filling up your car at an ultra fast charge point rather than five minutes at a petrol pump. Sorry.

TuftyMarmoset · 29/09/2021 10:37

Where I live there is only on-street parking so there is an electric car charging point in a lamp post. The more powerful ones are also in various car parks around town.

We need a new cooker, our current one is dual fuel but I’m thinking of replacing it with an electric one with induction hob as they are meant to be more efficient and I imagine gas cookers are also in line to be banned eventually. We also need to replace our bathroom so are going to add extra insulation when we do that. Stuff breaks and needs replacing on a regular basis so people need to make the right decision (but with regard given to their home’s specifics) each time the opportunity comes up - it’s an expense either way. I say the home’s specifics as we don’t have space for a heat pump - side return is too narrow, and there are pipes off the back of the house, and garden is too small for ground source. But that doesn’t mean that we can’t make the most eco choice we can when we need to replace other things.

What I think is good as well is that there is a minimum EPC rating for rental properties, although I think it needs to be higher. It’s a good way of putting the cost of improvements on wealthier people ie landlords. If I won the lottery I think I’d buy up loads of houses with rubbish EPCs, make them eco friendly and then sell them on at a loss.

YouTubeAddict · 29/09/2021 10:36

We’re only getting an electric car because it’s on motability. Otherwise it would be way too expensive! We try to cut down our plastic use etc but as for things like solar panels, it’s just not happening 😢

PeonyTime · 29/09/2021 10:31

@araiwa

I havnt figured out how people who park on the street are going to charge their electric car yet, and that is the farthest ahead of all those technologies.

Do you have a petrol station at home?

Nope, but I can fill up in 5 mins. Charging a battery takes considerably longer than that.
anothermansshoes · 29/09/2021 10:26

I guess the no parking could be reduced ... but an ev and get given the space outside your home for personal parking might be popular

onlychildhamster · 29/09/2021 10:13

@Heronatemygoldfish Its often like that for families. The houses further out from the station and need a car are larger and cheaper, so many families pick them. Many have drives so electric cars are possible BUT there aren't enough of them to go around and every NIMBYer would be protesting against any development of abandoned fields. Also larger properties would often be older and it may be very costly to make energy efficient.

The properties near the town centre or in cities are likely to be terraced or flats unless they are very expensive. so those properties might be good for public transport if you are in London or the surrounding towns but they are not good for electric cars.

Its a catch 22 either way.

BigWoollyJumpers · 29/09/2021 10:12

When the US and the Russians in particular invest in Hydrogen technology you can safely bet it will become mainstream. Russia in particular wants to dominate the EU energy market, and that will include Hydrogen.

JCB here in the UK have developed a "standard" combustion engine, modified to run on hydrogen, for use in heavy machinery and buses. It's quite interesting.

Heronatemygoldfish · 29/09/2021 10:05

This all makes me want to cry. I would so love to be off-grid.

We live away from the road so cannot plug our cars into the household supply. The garages are not on electricity as the block is nowhere near the houses. A couple of people on the road now have electric cars but they are the ones who have drives/level street access. I work for an organisation which wants to build on all the car parks and have us all use public transport, never mind the school runs en route or the distances some of us have to travel without a public alternative. No chance of them putting in charging points - and even so, until all of those are a) fast and b) standardised, which ones would they install?

My town has about 6 slow charge points, period. They've not added any more in years.

I can't afford solar panels and since we're overshadowed by (council) trees and a block of flats (which also have nowhere to charge their cars) they wouldn't work properly anyway. We are considering solar water heating though. More efficient.

I looked into a windmill a while back. No go. They make a lot of incidental noise and are also only able to work if they are plugged into the mains - can't power a house if there is a power cut!! Irony... Maybe that's changed now. I hope so (though the noise would stop us as we have a teeny garden so can't put one out of earshot of everyone)

Truly the thinking is back to front in all areas.

*disclaimer: we are on the Tube network and DC go to school on that now they are old enough. But on the outer part, and if I want to get to work I've got 40 minutes of walking at either end of the day on top of the commute because of where the stations are. Just like many people... Of course I could buy a folding bike, but it would be of limited use because of the hills - I'd still have to walk one way...

Wazzzzzzzup · 29/09/2021 09:52

Or the government could work on train travel costing less than flying through another country. No one will go and take a train when,even including upkeep costs, car travel will work out cheaper....

MakingM · 29/09/2021 09:46

@DdraigGoch

No, mass electric vehicle ownership won't work. Too costly for many and still produces a considerable amount of pollution during manufacture. They also don't solve congestion, so you still need to build new roads (causing more pollution).

We need to wean ourselves off our automobile addiction.

In order to wean people from their vehicles the government would have to find a way to incentivise this while allowing people to make their own arrangements to suit themselves - to do otherwise would be to cause massive resentment.

They could, for instance, work out the total miles travelled and how much they want it to be reduced by to create a personal allowance. Anyone purchasing road tax (as an individual, not for their car) would gain a miles allowance with “countryside” or disability allowances extra - the opposite of London weighting. People could then freely trade their allowances - if you live in a city and are happy to catch the bus, you get to sell your allowance to someone who needs to travel more, or just wants to and can afford to buy extra miles.

If they start banning things, it’ll all end in tears.

EvilRingahBitch · 29/09/2021 09:46

Hydrogen comes in 3 types
Green: electrolysed from water using renewable power and effectively used as a battery to store inconsistent wind power. Expensive but definitely green

Blue: extracted from natural gas leaving CO2 which is then pumped back into the original gas reservoirs so it doesn't reach the atmosphere. Challenging and controversial but theoretically green. The UK is geologically well placed to do this.

Grey: extracted from natural gas without capturing the CO2 or electrolysed from water using fossil fuel power. Worst of both worlds although it can still power cars with zero tailpipe emissions.

Most modern gas boilers and cookers can comfortably cope with a mix of 20% hydrogen 80% North Sea gas. But if we wanted to go 100% hydrogen we'd all need new boilers and bits of the infrastructure would need upgrading. Significantly less work than changing all the Victorian terraces of the UK to heat pumps though.

Stickytreacle · 29/09/2021 09:37

Hydrogen can be produced from microbes and water splitting methods too, (caveat that this into is from my Dr son who works in the field as an automotive research scientist, I haven't a clue, but I know he and his colleagues have quite strong views on it. !)

BigHeartyTruffle · 29/09/2021 09:35

It will be impossible to reach net zero if the cost is placed on us as individuals. The government needs to fund it. Heat pumps are great in theory but they are expensive to buy and expensive to run. I believe government are bringing in a “clean heat grant” for things like heat pumps so that’s worth keeping an eye out for.

Hydrogen is a distraction - the government has set an ambition but the technology required to make low carbon hydrogen (ie using renewable electricity in a process called electrolysis) is not proven and not available at scale. Also no one is manufacturing fuel cell cars.

Basically the current government are all talk no action and need to put their money where their mouth is if we are going to reach this ambition. Which we absolutely have to for the sake of the planet and every creature living on it.