Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the ambitions for Net Carbon Zero are utterly impossible for most households?

142 replies

backoffice · 29/09/2021 08:06

I’ve been looking at some of the suggestions that are supposed to be “normalised” for consumers to adopt as we move towards lower carbon: heat pumps, solar power, electric vehicles etc.

To adopt any of these is going to cost a family thousands of pounds! Not to mention the practicalities of e.g. heat pumps in tiny houses with little gardens/small roof. It seems utterly unreasonable to expect consumers to adopt these technologies unless they have a lot of money and large properties, but it’s basically what the government seems to expect people to do. AIBU?

OP posts:
Nonamesleftt · 29/09/2021 14:56

@StarCat2020 The UK is not on its way to being the first to achieve net zero. Sweden's target is set for five years earlier (2045), while Finland's target date is 2035 (but not enshrined in law, unlike Sweden & the UK).

StarCat2020 · 29/09/2021 14:35

The UK is in a very precsarious position due to the aim of being the first to net zero.

Traditionally there should be 25% extra capacity in the electric generation to be considered secure.

Last year at times we had less than 2% capacity.

A lot of it a spin frpom Johnson as well. Nobody thinks closing coal power stations is a bad thing but nothing has replaced them.

The UK produces less than 1% of the World's CO2 so we are going to hurt the vulnerable and make UK lives difficult whilst other countries continue to pump out more CO2.

Oh and "environmentally friendly" Germany opened a new coal plant last year.

Noseylittlemoo · 29/09/2021 14:29

I have recently sold my one bed flat - part of a house built in 1910. We insulated under the floor and double glazed the windows I keeping with the style of property. The EPC rating was still only D . The recommendations to make it more efficient were estimated to cost £10-20k and would apparently save £75 per year and still only improve the rating to C!
I can't imagine that many people have that much money to spend on a 1 bed flat especially for so little improvement or saving. We currently recycle, buy from a zero waste shop as much as possible and I rarely use my car using the train/ tube for work and walking a lot. But these bigger changes are prohibitively expensive.

EnidFrighten · 29/09/2021 13:58

I don't feel that negative. If there was a big drive for insulation, better boilers etc then costs would come down through economies of scale, people would find cheaper ways of doing things. It would also create a huge number of jobs.

politics4me · 29/09/2021 13:56

I think EVs will increase the number of vehicles on our roads, there will be a perception that they are easier to drive and they will be cheaper to maintain.
If commerce and industry are to be dispersed or decentralised around the country then more roads must be built and many existing ones including urban dual lane roads will have to be widened. Bulldozers to gardens and a row of houses through Chiswick for instance.

Notcontent · 29/09/2021 13:51

I think dealing with heating in London is an issue. In my street, for example, our terrace houses have tiny gardens so I don’t think there is enough room for heat pumps. Also, even if every house did somehow manage to fit a heat pump in their garden the noise would be pretty horrendous I think - it would make living here extremely unpleasant.

backoffice · 29/09/2021 13:50

I think that’s a really important point @Kosmoceratops. There’s no benefit for a government in being honest though. Eg the Tories will do nothing and then maybe labour will eventually get in and take action, and then the public will blame it on labour. Why should the tories be honest now when they’ve got no plan or intention to act?

But yes I am now starting to think not just about pensions saving but the higher cost of living in 20-30 years because of the massive costs of reducing our carbon emissions.

OP posts:
backoffice · 29/09/2021 13:46

We’ve had chaos locally with the rollout of fibre. You’d think it could be integrated with some sort of infrastructure rollout for EV charging as well.

OP posts:
CatKittyCatCatKittyCatCat · 29/09/2021 13:45

Government in Germany for retrofitting energy efficient measures a while back. I here will need to be something like that- this will be impossible without specific and adequate forms of financial support and some economies of scale achieved by high level purchasing and commissioning co-ordination.

Kosmoceratops · 29/09/2021 13:45

Governments of all political persuasions need to be a lot more honest with people about the huge cost of moving to zero carbon emissions. They are all avoiding doing this.

It is going to cost us all a lot of money and our life styles will need to change pretty fundamentally. We will have to pay for the pollution we are generating through our excessive consumption. So we will all be facing much higher bills for energy and everything else, we will all be wearing more jumpers in the winter and there will be no more Majorca!

We need to be honest about what all this entails.

RandomLondoner · 29/09/2021 13:42

Self-driving electric taxis should mean it wouldn't make sense to own cars, as using taxis would be cheaper than having your own car. They could drive themselves to wherever the chargers were, and it wouldn't inconvenience anyone, because no-one is dependent on a particular vehicle.

Wazzzzzzzup · 29/09/2021 13:42

@Lockdownbear

The only way I can really see electric cars really working for people who do long distance or who only have on street parking is to have some sort of removable battery. So you go into a "battery station" remove your empty battery. And pick up a fully charged one. Bit like refillable gas bottles you buy the gas not the bottle.

But it will only work if batteries were small enough to lift in and out and all cars had the same batteries.

There is a scooter with that and apparently the cost of the battery is extortionate. Plus as you say, the size of the battery, yeah
DeepaBeesKit · 29/09/2021 13:41

Lockdownbear it's a good idea but it also relies on the batteries all being of same quality/age. Imagine if you had a brand new vehicle and went to swap your battery at a station and got some knackered old one that didnt hold charge well. It would maybe work if the batteries were separately owned and you paid a subscription or fee to access them. Good in a way as the pricing for a charges battery would take into account the life of the battery.

Lockdownbear · 29/09/2021 13:34

The only way I can really see electric cars really working for people who do long distance or who only have on street parking is to have some sort of removable battery.
So you go into a "battery station" remove your empty battery. And pick up a fully charged one.
Bit like refillable gas bottles you buy the gas not the bottle.

But it will only work if batteries were small enough to lift in and out and all cars had the same batteries.

DeepaBeesKit · 29/09/2021 13:34

The reality is we all simply need to use less.

New estates will be built taking into account requirement to implement green energy - and it will be easier to do it on a community basis for whole estates. But electric cars arent the only answer, we need to drive less too.

safariboot · 29/09/2021 13:31

I think it can happen with the right government support and direction. I'm just sceptical we'll get that.

Take charging for example. Streets have been dug up to run TV cable and broadband fibre, and of course street lights and signs that need replacing. Installing EV chargers is pretty much the same. One per on-street parking space, no reason it can't be done.

But of course the longer it is left, the bigger the shock when it's needed. And more wasteful. Replacing gas boilers at their end of life would have been much better than having to force their replacement all at once.

For gas no real reason we couldn't switch to renewable syngas. We made the switch before from coal gas to natural gas.

MintJulia · 29/09/2021 13:27

The important word here is gradually. I use gas central heating because my house has a three year old gas boiler installed. When that boiler becomes unserviceable, I will replace it with a ground source heat pump. I've already installed a log burner which allows me to delay putting on the central heating maybe four weeks each autumn, and to turn the heating off two weeks early each spring.

I wfh so have cut my car use from 25,000 miles a year to 6,000. When it dies I'll buy an electric one.

Yes, it will cost me, but being aware 10 years in advance, allows time to save/adapt, and for the market to invent small scale solutions.

backoffice · 29/09/2021 13:23

That is a great point @Lockdownbear. We’ve designed towns to force people to use their cars if they want access to decent shops.

OP posts:
Lockdownbear · 29/09/2021 13:10

To reduce car use we need to go back to town planning. Everyone wants stuff "out of town" cheap land plenty parking. But actually it makes it very difficult to then service with public transport.

Get back to the days of thing being in the town centres and within walking distance. Where I live you'd struggle to buy an apple in the town centre, we have about 6 supermarkets Inc Lidl and Aldi but they are all in edge of town retail parks. With poor bus services. Meanwhile the council wonder why the town centre is dying.

DdraigGoch · 29/09/2021 13:04

@anothermansshoes

I guess the no parking could be reduced ... but an ev and get given the space outside your home for personal parking might be popular
That'll bring a new dimension to parking threads.
DdraigGoch · 29/09/2021 13:00

@Stickytreacle

Hydrogen can be produced from microbes and water splitting methods too, (caveat that this into is from my Dr son who works in the field as an automotive research scientist, I haven't a clue, but I know he and his colleagues have quite strong views on it. !)
Electrolysis of water is only viable if you've got plenty of cheap electricity. That's why it only accounts for 4% of production. The other 96% is extracted from gas, oil and coal.
NotDavidTennant · 29/09/2021 12:58

They did it successfully with CFCs and the hole in the ozone layer, they need to take a similar legislative and industrial change approach to address climate change.

CFCs are a very spefic group of artificially-created chemicals that had a narrow range of uses for which less harmful alternatives were available. CO2 is a naturally occurring by-product of any process that involves the combustion of carbon-containing fuels (which covers pretty much all combustable fuels other than hydrogen). You can't simply legislate CO2 out of existence.

DdraigGoch · 29/09/2021 12:57

@backoffice

I don’t understand the hydrogen argument - how is it a good idea if it’s currently just coming from gas anyway?

Electric/nuclear is the only option isn’t it?

I’ve tried to look at improving my own home but I can’t afford it. With bills for university, subsidising elderly parents and saving for my own pension (all sensible things) there’s not the kind of money left over, although I want to make positive choices.

Am I being cynical wondering if the run-away energy bills are working in the governments favour to force people to use less energy?

Absolutely, at one point recently gas turbines made up 45% of our generation. Wood burning is 5% too so we've still got a huge way to go to decarbonise the grid. We need a substantial increase in nuclear capacity, somewhere in the range of 20GW.
BigHeartyTruffle · 29/09/2021 12:47

How come you don’t recycle @seaandsandcastles? Out of interest

seaandsandcastles · 29/09/2021 12:32

@TuftyMarmoset

I hope you don’t have children *@seaandsandcastles*!
I do Smile