Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the ambitions for Net Carbon Zero are utterly impossible for most households?

142 replies

backoffice · 29/09/2021 08:06

I’ve been looking at some of the suggestions that are supposed to be “normalised” for consumers to adopt as we move towards lower carbon: heat pumps, solar power, electric vehicles etc.

To adopt any of these is going to cost a family thousands of pounds! Not to mention the practicalities of e.g. heat pumps in tiny houses with little gardens/small roof. It seems utterly unreasonable to expect consumers to adopt these technologies unless they have a lot of money and large properties, but it’s basically what the government seems to expect people to do. AIBU?

OP posts:
Laughsaminute · 30/09/2021 08:24

I’ve never understood why concrete homes are not promoted for their energy efficiency.

We live in a 1950s concrete home, it’s incredibly energy efficient- cool in summer and very well insulated in winter. We have gas central heating and barely use it in winter- the temperature doesn’t drop below thermostat for many days of the year (admittedly we do have it set lower than probably most people do). As a consequence our gas bills are very low. In comparison our electricity use is huge-family of 4 with adults wfh.

Another benefit is noise reduction. Semi D and can’t hear our neighbours. Previously we lived in concrete terrace and couldn’t hear neighbours either. I’m always shocked how noisy friends brick houses are -can hear neighbours tv/ baby cry/ sneezing

Surely concrete is an answer?

Oblomov21 · 30/09/2021 08:14

I too have big problems with this.

Government arranged a consultancy, which will have cost a fortune, on how to reduce farming emissions. Eat less red meat. This is fine.

But farming only accounts for 10%. Said this consultancy.
I don't even know what the other 90% is according to the this program, but presumably it's ......gas and oil production, huge companies, hs2 and trident. Etc.

So focusing on this 10% where we all use the stems of broccoli to make soup, is fine.

But no one wants to talk about the 90%.

SoundBar · 30/09/2021 08:06

YANBU it's ridiculous.

No one wants to admit that a drastic decline in living standards will be required for the majority of households.

The 1% will be fine though, they can just pay their way out of it.

If you want your mind to be blown, look at the district heating coverage in Denmark. Cost, environmental impact. The infrastructure we have for UK cities (gas/electric heating; individual boilers and per-household responsibility to purchase and maintain; high cost per kW esp electric) is a scam plain and simple. It should never have been built this way. But a lot of companies are making a fortune so.. yay. Capitalism.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 30/09/2021 07:57

I’m also concerned that my HA property will replace my gas boiler (fitted in 2017) for electric heating which I really really don’t want

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 30/09/2021 07:56

I will be looking at more environmentally ways of owning a car when I change but I won’t be giving up my car completely, I work in rural community nursing covering 40-50 miles at work only some days then add on school pick up/drop off (on way to work) as school isn’t anywhere near my village. I don’t want to move to more built up areas either so I’ll be keeping a personal car

Lovinghannah · 30/09/2021 06:55

Earlier this year a government scheme paid to install an oil fired central heating system in my house. It doesn't seem likely they will want to replace that any time soon?

DdraigGoch · 29/09/2021 22:44

@XingMing

Well whatever solution any urban facing government comes up with, is not ever going to work properly in rural areas. The majority of the population/voters live in towns, so clearly those are going to occupy any government's priority slots. But we also need to be part of the grid, and because I live on a tidal estuary, I am going to add tidal power generation to the list of green options available. There is nowhere in the UK that is further than 80 miles from the coast. There is 7,500 miles of coast, all of it tidal. The tide comes in and out twice a day, every day. In some places it's hugely powerful, but it is always rising and falling apart from the slack periods which are at most one hour at high and low points, so it should be a primary sustainable source of energy. I am not suggesting that it can power all our energy requirements, especially at moments of high demand, but it could and should be better used. In preference to wind power. I know politicians generate lots, just not enough.
They need to concentrate on urban pollution, firstly because urban dwellers are more numerous so changes have a bigger impact, secondly because particulate pollution in towns is a big concern.

However, the gas companies are prioritising the most remote homes for connecting up to hydrogen supplies. Sounds daft given that they're the most expensive to reach but there is method in their madness: remote houses are the biggest polluters because they are usually heated using oil, coal or wood.

DdraigGoch · 29/09/2021 22:08

@bluebeach

I agree, these changes are beyond those on lower wages but for wealthier middle earners they are probably affordable. We have a joint income of about £50k and with gvnt subsidies have afforded solar panels and an air source heat pump in the last few years. We don’t have a second car, we don’t have expensive Foreign holidays, we tend to buy most things second hand... all things that, as well as being better environmentally have meant we have the money for the panels and the pump. It’s often about life choices.
Sadly most people would rather have their three holidays per year (flying, of course) and a new SUV.
DdraigGoch · 29/09/2021 22:01

@Notcontent

I think dealing with heating in London is an issue. In my street, for example, our terrace houses have tiny gardens so I don’t think there is enough room for heat pumps. Also, even if every house did somehow manage to fit a heat pump in their garden the noise would be pretty horrendous I think - it would make living here extremely unpleasant.
For terraces, it would make more sense to have a communal heating system
XingMing · 29/09/2021 20:57

Well whatever solution any urban facing government comes up with, is not ever going to work properly in rural areas. The majority of the population/voters live in towns, so clearly those are going to occupy any government's priority slots. But we also need to be part of the grid, and because I live on a tidal estuary, I am going to add tidal power generation to the list of green options available. There is nowhere in the UK that is further than 80 miles from the coast. There is 7,500 miles of coast, all of it tidal. The tide comes in and out twice a day, every day. In some places it's hugely powerful, but it is always rising and falling apart from the slack periods which are at most one hour at high and low points, so it should be a primary sustainable source of energy. I am not suggesting that it can power all our energy requirements, especially at moments of high demand, but it could and should be better used. In preference to wind power. I know politicians generate lots, just not enough.

DecadentlyDecisive · 29/09/2021 20:12

Nah, I'm not playing for 20 years at least...

I can afford to run the cars & motorbikes we have with the money I'm not spending on an Electric Vehicle.

I can afford to pay for my gas boiler with the money I'm not spending on the massively increased electricity costs from running a heat pump.

In 20 years time all the early adopters will have been the guinea pigs & most of the problems will be ironed out.

Then I can buy a nice cheap electric car & retire......

Lockdownbear · 29/09/2021 20:03

It's certainly cheaper to put them in before the car park is completed than to dig it back up later. Even if its the same type they use in public carparks rather than something operating of an individual flats electric supply.

onlychildhamster · 29/09/2021 19:59

@Lockdownbear Most flats have some form of parking even if not allocated. would it be very expensive to install electric chargers.

Lockdownbear · 29/09/2021 19:44

Certainly in Scotland houses need some form of renewable energy, solar, heat pump etc.

Nothing happening with car chargers but it makes sense if a house has a drive and flats with parking they should install them too.

Theunamedcat · 29/09/2021 17:51

But we are building thousands of houses without thinking of technology? The government should insist new builds include solar panels and charging points for cars

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 29/09/2021 17:44

I live in a ground floor flat with solid brick walls so I can't see how a heat pump will benefit me as they are less efficient without insulation which we don't have. If anyone wants me to change this boiler before it dies they can pay for it in full, and any other work necessary to fit the replacement, not give me a grant towards it!

I've just ordered a new petrol car and I'll be driving that until it dies. We only have on street parking, first come first served, so I'm not going to change to electric when it'll be a hassle to charge it!

backoffice · 29/09/2021 17:41

Fair enough @bluebeach - I think that’s fab but there aren’t many subsidies now and realistically not many people will be so altruistic as to spend their money on these things.

OP posts:
bluebeach · 29/09/2021 16:01

I agree, these changes are beyond those on lower wages but for wealthier middle earners they are probably affordable. We have a joint income of about £50k and with gvnt subsidies have afforded solar panels and an air source heat pump in the last few years. We don’t have a second car, we don’t have expensive Foreign holidays, we tend to buy most things second hand... all things that, as well as being better environmentally have meant we have the money for the panels and the pump. It’s often about life choices.

TuftyMarmoset · 29/09/2021 15:51

@seaandsandcastles how is it unpleasant to put your paper and tin cans in one bin and everything else in another? It doesn't even take any more time.

indistinct · 29/09/2021 15:19

@NotDavidTennant

They did it successfully with CFCs and the hole in the ozone layer, they need to take a similar legislative and industrial change approach to address climate change.

CFCs are a very spefic group of artificially-created chemicals that had a narrow range of uses for which less harmful alternatives were available. CO2 is a naturally occurring by-product of any process that involves the combustion of carbon-containing fuels (which covers pretty much all combustable fuels other than hydrogen). You can't simply legislate CO2 out of existence.

Agree that CO2 emissions are a much more difficult problem (by an order of magnitude or 2) but the CFC issue is a demonstrable case of government and industry working together (internationally) to resolve a global environmental issue quickly.
Agree also that legislation alone is not enough (in fact on its own its probably counterproductive) but most people can't alter their lifestyles sufficiently to become independently carbon neutral without support. They need to be given the products and services by industry to make being carbon neutral (or carbon minimal) easy and not too expensive.
This is already happening as the demand for less carbon intensive products and services has been consistent for decades. A good example of this is the green energy suppliers (e.g. Octopus) that push through the green-demand signal to energy producers (and produce their own green energy). Another is electric cars (not just Tesla now - many manufacturers producing all-electric vehicles - supported by phasing out of petrol from 2030). It is likely that more companies will offer more products and services to help individuals reduce their carbon footprint (e.g. you could imagine someone like Octopus offering an electrification or heat-pump package to replace your gas boiler). It's already happening and will accelerate.
onlychildhamster · 29/09/2021 15:16

@seaandsandcastles you just get a pedal bin with two compartments- 1 for normal rubbish and 1 for recycled products. Rinse glass bottles before you throw them away.

I don't know anyone who 'sorts' their rubbish...

Nonamesleftt · 29/09/2021 15:14

I 100% agree that there needs to be a coordinated government effort rather than leaving it up to individuals.

However, I do think people sometimes forget the personal cost / inconvencience of doing nothing. Sure, currently, charging an electric car is a hassle if you can't charge it on yoru drive. But once things start to shift, not only will charging facilities become more widespread, but most likely, conventional petrol pumps will start to disappear.

In Norway about 80% of all new cars sold are now electric. There are of course plenty of petrol vehicles still in use, but in 10 years there might be barely any petrol cars left. Where will they get their fuel? Will you have to drive 30 minutes just to find a petrol station? Will petrol become twice as expensive when there are no economies of scale anymore? I genuinely don't know, but I think people forget that as societies are changing, the fossil fuel based infrastructures that we are accustomed to will not necessarily remain unchanged.

seaandsandcastles · 29/09/2021 15:12

@BigHeartyTruffle

How come you don’t recycle *@seaandsandcastles*? Out of interest
I’m not sorting through my rubbish. It’s unpleasant.
onlychildhamster · 29/09/2021 15:08

@backoffice I guess that is assuming energy prices don't significantly inflate which is unlikely. i mean my direct debt for gas and electricity has doubled from £80 to £160 and I am in a 2 bed flat!

backoffice · 29/09/2021 14:58

I agree @Noseylittlemoo - a friend recently installed solar panels which she said were “saving a fortune” but when I pressed her on the figures, it was saving £30 a month and she had spent 9k on the panels - so it would take 25 years to see any benefit!

OP posts: