Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the ambitions for Net Carbon Zero are utterly impossible for most households?

142 replies

backoffice · 29/09/2021 08:06

I’ve been looking at some of the suggestions that are supposed to be “normalised” for consumers to adopt as we move towards lower carbon: heat pumps, solar power, electric vehicles etc.

To adopt any of these is going to cost a family thousands of pounds! Not to mention the practicalities of e.g. heat pumps in tiny houses with little gardens/small roof. It seems utterly unreasonable to expect consumers to adopt these technologies unless they have a lot of money and large properties, but it’s basically what the government seems to expect people to do. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 03/10/2021 14:37

@LobsterNapkin yes good points re living nearer to where you work but there are always going to be people, like myself, who were born, grew up and still live in a rural village. I would hate to be forced to live in a built up town or city and we have built our lives around this, my career in community nursing isn’t going to change either and will always be covering a wide rural area

Daftasabroom · 02/10/2021 13:10

As it's a wet and rainy afternoon, if anyone wants to get into the data on climate change this is a great site: ourworldindata.org/emissions-by-sector

There is a lot of science here: skepticalscience.com/

And some genuine experts on green building here: www.greenbuildingforum.co.uk/newforum/

BigWoollyJumpers · 01/10/2021 17:18

[quote Daftasabroom]@LobsterNapkin you make some really important points, local conditions are really important. The difference between a piece of beef imported from Brazil fed on rainforest soy, compared to an Argentine pampas prairie fed meat, compared to a Scott's Highland longhorn will be vastly different.[/quote]
And not all "meat" is equal either. Welsh lamb, grazing on grass, year round on the Welsh hills is a very sustainable meat source. The land can't be used for anything else, so why not for a good high quality, low carbon, protein source.

HotPenguin · 01/10/2021 17:15

Infrastructure for electric vehicles is developing all the time, in my area there's a pilot trying ways of charging cars where there is no private off street parking. There is already technology to install chargers in lampposts. At the moment EVs are quite new so they are pricey, but prices will come down as there are more second hand. You can already get a Nissan leaf quite reasonable price. Though I agree if your mileage is lowish it's better to wait for your current car to conk out.

anothermansshoes · 01/10/2021 17:10

But more people probably eat meat than do long haul flights

Daftasabroom · 01/10/2021 16:56

@LobsterNapkin you make some really important points, local conditions are really important. The difference between a piece of beef imported from Brazil fed on rainforest soy, compared to an Argentine pampas prairie fed meat, compared to a Scott's Highland longhorn will be vastly different.

LobsterNapkin · 01/10/2021 16:37

On a personal level, if one person went meat free, they would save around 0.8 tonnes of CO2 per year. If that person instead decided not to have an annual transatlantic return flight they would save 1.6 tonnes. If instead they gave up their car, they'd save 2.4 tonnes.

The other thing that drives me crazy about this is that while most westerners eat an unsustainable amount of meat, meat free agriculture isn't actually a great agricultural choice. Animal husbandry plays an important role in sustainable agriculture. So you get people buying their lab-made fake meatbased on products grown in an industrial agriculture setting, and thinking that makes it better than any kind of animal-based products.

It's style over substance again.

LobsterNapkin · 01/10/2021 16:30

It's probably most useful to look at suggestions like these as a work in progress, and as something that happens over time. Oil furnaces have to be replaced every so often, and when they are, people often contemplate a switch to another type of heating, for example.

Some of the suggestions will be really useful and widely adopted. Quite a lot will work for some but not others, but it will be enough to make a difference. Some will be useless and fall out of favour.

I would really hate to see a widescale destruction of older homes in order to facilitate this stuff and I am not convinced it would be widely accepted.

The thing all of these groups don't emphasis enough is change in lifestyle and expectations. City/community planning is going to have to be a huge one. If people can find housing near their employment, not only could we reduce car use altogether, we wouldn't need the same amount of public transport infrastructure. Yes, that reduced "choice" but we all live within a set of defined choices anyway. When the choices available don't include easy access to a car, it will change what we consider normative. But we need to get away from the planning decisions that mean it's reasonable to expect people to commute an hour to a low paying job to be able to afford housing.

Daftasabroom · 01/10/2021 16:23

@Thevoiceofreason2021 there are indeed a national body of engineers working towards a more sustainable future they are just really useless at PR check out catapult.org.uk/

Daftasabroom · 01/10/2021 16:16

@MelissaDances China per capita emissions are about 1.5x the UK, India is 1/3, USA is 3x. China has committed to net zero by 2060.

Daftasabroom · 01/10/2021 16:11

@EvilRingahBitch it is unlikely that the current gas infrastructure could be upgraded to cope with 100% H2. Hydrogen embrittlement, leaks, and volumetric energy density at sensible pressures make it very challenging to implement.

@Theteapotsbrokenspout putting Solar PV on domestic roofs is not as simple as many people think, the "grid tie" equipment is a much higher proportion of the cost compared to large commercial arrays, maintenance is also harder.

Air source heat pumps are relatively expensive to install but are 3x more efficient standard electric heating. High levels of insulation and air tightness require careful consideration of ventilation, mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR) is the usual route and is legal requirement in Canada and some States in America.

The government could, and should, update building regulations that could massively reduce home energy requirements for both new build and extensions.

Theteapotsbrokenspout · 01/10/2021 14:00

I’m a bit suspicious of the EPC system, we were given one when we were buying this house but looking online there was a more recent one registered with a better rating that I had no idea existed. However, some of the items listed, including increased loft insulation, do not actually exist Confused .

XingMing · 01/10/2021 12:35

I've just had an EPC done for our house and the recommendations for improving its efficiency rating would be well over £23K, to save about £1200 per year, while barely altering the rating. The payback is too long to make the changes economically viable. So, we shall leave that decision for anyone who buys the house to make.

DdraigGoch · 30/09/2021 22:54

@MelissaDances

The world's biggest polluters (China, the US and India) need to get their act together. The felling of an entire football field of trees every day in the Amazon needs to stop. I would have more respect for the climate change protesters if they spoke about that. But no, it's the rest of us who are supposed to spend money we don't have on things that won't make a massive difference while all that's still going on.

And some people are making a lot of money out of this. Virtue signalling while raking in the cash, nice for them.

Who buys all of that crap made in China?

We do. We're responsible for a chunk of their pollution.

BigWoollyJumpers · 30/09/2021 22:33

The biggest thing most people can easily do is just to keep stuff for a long time and in fact not change or renew it. Yes, even your car. It's all very well saying build new houses, change your car, your boiler etc but all the replacements have to be made, using vast amounts of power and resources. Much better to keep things going as long as possible, fix, mend, re-use, buy second hand, retrofit old buildings rather than tear down and build new.

MelissaDances · 30/09/2021 11:41

The world's biggest polluters (China, the US and India) need to get their act together. The felling of an entire football field of trees every day in the Amazon needs to stop. I would have more respect for the climate change protesters if they spoke about that. But no, it's the rest of us who are supposed to spend money we don't have on things that won't make a massive difference while all that's still going on.

And some people are making a lot of money out of this. Virtue signalling while raking in the cash, nice for them.

DdraigGoch · 30/09/2021 11:31

@Oblomov21

I too have big problems with this.

Government arranged a consultancy, which will have cost a fortune, on how to reduce farming emissions. Eat less red meat. This is fine.

But farming only accounts for 10%. Said this consultancy.
I don't even know what the other 90% is according to the this program, but presumably it's ......gas and oil production, huge companies, hs2 and trident. Etc.

So focusing on this 10% where we all use the stems of broccoli to make soup, is fine.

But no one wants to talk about the 90%.

On a personal level, if one person went meat free, they would save around 0.8 tonnes of CO2 per year. If that person instead decided not to have an annual transatlantic return flight they would save 1.6 tonnes. If instead they gave up their car, they'd save 2.4 tonnes.

All of this focus on meat production is a distraction from the bigger polluters. Fossil fuels remain the big problems, at every stage from the oil rig/coal mine to the car exhaust pipe/power station chimney. The world's biggest polluters are oil and coal producers, think about that when you're next queuing for petrol - they wouldn't be producing it if we weren't buying it.

Thevoiceofreason2021 · 30/09/2021 10:34

There is soo much bullshit and green washing…. It makes my blood boil…. Stop buying cheep tat from China and other nations who pollute the planet would have a much greater impact on the environment than a heat pump installation! Incinerated rubbish produces far less green house gasses than shipping our household recycling half way round the planet to be dumped on a land fill….hydrogen is very energy intense to produce, electric cars contain lithium ion batteries which are not recyclable and are extremely poisonous to the plant. We need a cross party body of engineers and scientists / technocrats to put together a 50 year policy and to educate the public. Insulate Britain , Extinction Rebellion and such the like talk utter nonsense and are a constant source of misinformation. This obsession with carbon is bonkers - nuclear energy is low carbon but it’s certainly not renewable. As a stem professional I’m tearing my hair out every time I open the paper!

Keladrythesaviour · 30/09/2021 10:19

It's tough but I think the regulations are important - especially regarding new build houses. The idea that houses can be built in this day and age without solar panels or heat pumps is criminal.

We've got an EV and a plug-in hybrid. Electric cars are becoming more and more accessible, though still too expensive and I recognise if you don't have driveway parking the logistics are much harder.
We use Octopus Green so all our energy consumption comes from green sources.
Our main negative is we are on an old oil boiler as there is no gas supply to the village. We desperately want a heat pump and have had various quotations etc but we can't get a quite cheaper than about £12k, with all funding etc counted in- there's no way we can afford that! We don't want to take out a loan because we hope to have children soon and will be paying through the nose for nursery fees etc.
We're hoping to get solar panels but again the up front cost is a real problem. We've got a decent monthly income but it takes us a long time to save for anything substantial.

Lockdownbear · 30/09/2021 09:43

@TheUnbearable

DH workplace has had electric car charging points for at least six years. At first it was completely free to charge your car, not sure if this has changed.
I think that's probably changed.

At one point it was illegal to re-sell electricity. So a company connecting a charger to their meter couldn't then charge the people to use it as that came under reselling electricity.

I can't imagine that councils will happily be paying for public charge points and the power to charge everybody's cars.

Laughsaminute · 30/09/2021 09:35

@Nonamesleftt fair enough- I didn’t know that. However, our surveyors have said our house is so solid it will outlast most of the housing stock in our town. So perhaps it’s a more sustainable long term option. Our house was apparently made in a factory and transported to site in large pieces and then stapled/glued together!

Anyway if we decide to move I would be very wary of brick buildings because they seem to haemorrhage heat and feel very drafty.

TheUnbearable · 30/09/2021 09:20

DH workplace has had electric car charging points for at least six years. At first it was completely free to charge your car, not sure if this has changed.

Nonamesleftt · 30/09/2021 08:39

@Laughsaminute One of the issues with concrete is that it has very high embodied emissions (a lot of CO2 is emitted in the process of making concrete).

Nonamesleftt · 30/09/2021 08:36

@Oblomov21

I too have big problems with this.

Government arranged a consultancy, which will have cost a fortune, on how to reduce farming emissions. Eat less red meat. This is fine.

But farming only accounts for 10%. Said this consultancy.
I don't even know what the other 90% is according to the this program, but presumably it's ......gas and oil production, huge companies, hs2 and trident. Etc.

So focusing on this 10% where we all use the stems of broccoli to make soup, is fine.

But no one wants to talk about the 90%.

But that's the thing there is no one thing that counts for 90% of emissions. Just over 25% of emissions are from transport, and by far the most of that is from passenger cars, that's one of the reasons why we're shifting to electric cars, buses, etc.

Just over 20% is energy supply, and that's one of the ones that has been reducing the quickest (mostly by closing coal plants and increasing production of renewable energy).

Then there are emissions from businesses, which have also been coming down. Then there's residential (15%) and that's obviously what this thread is about - so we are talking about it & slowly tackling it.

And then there's agriculture in fifth place.

Although not enough, quite a bit is being done in trying to reduce emissions in the other sectors, and it's now simply time to start focussing on agriculture as well. Especially since emissions from agriculture are largely methane, which is a far more potent greenhouse gas than CO2 (but has a shorter lifespan).

EvilRingahBitch · 30/09/2021 08:27

We need a mix and match approach. Too many people are rejecting various solutions on the grounds that they won't work for absolutely every situation. District heating won't work for large detached houses in the countryside but heat pumps will. Heat pumps won't work for urban terraces, but district heating can. Hydrogen boilers have drawbacks but there are some areas where they may be the most efficient solution.

Ditto transport. Better/cheaper public transport or car sharing or improved cycling infrastructure is never going to be the answer for a Shropshire district nurse, but it would help a lot of people move away from cars (probably along with increasingly draconian congestion charging). For the Shropshire district nurse a privately owned electric car will probably always be the answer.