Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So you let your kids whatch 12/15/18 programmes when they are only 10???

161 replies

Cantcook842 · 29/09/2021 07:35

AIBU here or not? I'm not a complete rule follower. I'm sure my child has watched the old older thing occasionally.
But I'm hearing from family members and school friends about what they watch and play and it just confuses me. Do people not want their kids to be kids anymore? Are they quite happy to expose them to violence etc from a young age?
Some recent examples :
Kids in my sons class are age 9 and 10. For at least two years a lot of the boys have been playing Grand Theft Auto. This is a 17+ game due to violent content /crime /rape/prostitutes. My son constantly asking to play and join in. We say no. His cousin also plays it who is 8 years old.

Watching films such as deadpool (15) contains sex and violence. Horror films such as IT, Halloween and Chucky.

The girls in the class are all on tik tok adult accounts and most of them have phones that they bring into school and show each other very grown up videos whilst walking home.

The new recent Netflix programme Squid Games is also 17+. My husband and I watched it and enjoyed it, but it is full of violence and death. Son goes into school, kids all talking about it because they've watched it. My 7 year old daughter loves to play on Roblox, she shows me that there have been squid games created on there, aimed at very young children!

Girls at school watch love Island and think that's a good example for a how a woman to be and aspire to be influencers.
Am I the mean one for not letting my 10 year old watch adult rating programmes and games?

OP posts:
Theoldprospector · 29/09/2021 09:37

They are not actually having sex though. It isn’t porn.

purpleneon · 29/09/2021 09:36

@WimpoleHat

Depends what it is and why it has the rating. Swearing? Meh. Sex? If it’s in context and everyone’s an adult and having a good time, I don’t worry. Violence? Hard no.

But isn't the whole point that the sex is between consenting ADULTS... why would your child need to watch it?

FrangipaniBlue · 29/09/2021 09:35

Age 9/10 DS was allowed to watch 12 rated movies mainly these were the Marvel films.

He was allowed to watch rated 15 from about 12/13 but this depended entirely on the film, whether I had already seen it and deemed it ok and/or what common sense media said.

He is approaching 14 and we've only just started to consider the odd 18 rated film, but he knows better than to ask for GTA and he knows why aswell!

I find that game morally reprehensible, he will not be getting it before he is 18 and even then if he wants it he can buy it himself, although I'd hope I'd taught him better to be honest.

Triffid1 · 29/09/2021 09:34

I'm not sure I understand why not Fortnite for an 8 year old? It's all very clinical and is really just about winning - there's no real sense of actually "killing" someone. Frankly, it doesn't feel any different to the way my DS tries to beat his opponents in his actual karate class. And it definitely is a useful tool for children to interact with each other when at home.

MrsMiddleMother · 29/09/2021 09:27

At 10 I'd let my kids watch most 12s but not 15s and definitely not 18s! We've had the GTA, horror films etc chat as we get 'but my friends can' I say well I feel sorry for them that they're being exposed to adult things they shouldn't and their parents should be looking after them better.

BananaPB · 29/09/2021 09:24

My kids watched 12A stuff like Marvel and Star Wars when they were 9/10 which is fine imo.

I find it interesting how certificate 12 became a 12A so kids just under could watch with an adult if it was deemed suitable.

Are the kids watching whole movies or are they getting clips off YouTube of the worst bits and acting like they've seen it ?

Theoldprospector · 29/09/2021 09:23

‘YANBU, I find it shocking too. I know 13 yo girls who’ve watched all of Bridgerton, including that oral sex scene.’

I would let a 13 year old watch that. It isn’t graphic. It is just a man going down on a woman while both are fully clothed isn’t it? And it is only a couple of seconds long.

LindaEllen · 29/09/2021 09:22

@Cantcook842

I've never heard of that website. Just had a look, it's very useful.

Description on there of squid games :

"WHAT PARENTS NEED TO KNOW

Parents need to know that the level of violenceis very intense inSquid Game. Characters are systematically tortured and killed for the sadistic pleasure of a game master. Adults have sex, and there are threats of sexual violence -- women are grabbed by the hair and beaten. Themes concerningthe highs one gets from gambling, winning, or conning money are a main focus." so absolutely not appropriate for a 9 year old who still believes in santa and the Easter bunny!

I'm 31 and I've been watching it with my partner and honestly I can't imagine even wanting to watch it with our teenager, never mind a 9yo.
Jellycatspyjamas · 29/09/2021 09:21

I tend to use common sense. GTA, Fortnite and Tik Tok are a hard “no” for my 8 and 10 year old. They’re too much of a time sink, to easy to get into stuff I don’t want for them and some of the values they promote aren’t ok. My DD loves anime, which can be tricky in terms of content so I keep a close eye on that.

They both have watched the Marvel movies with me and DH, and things like Cruella and Malificent, fantasy violence is ok for them both but more realistic violence isn’t. Very mild, consensual sex references are ok (though they’re both at the “yuck, smooching” stage).

I think knowing your kids, good supervision and being able to chat about what you’re watching makes a huge difference. I do pay attention to age ratings and would pre-watch anything of an older rating first to see if I thought it was suitable. I also check with parents about movies on sleepovers etc.

JustAReflektor · 29/09/2021 09:20

My kids are 8 and 5. They have Roblox but I don't allow Fortnite, much to the absolute disgust of the 8 year old. I'm becoming increasingly torn on this because, whilst I've always been very firm in my boundaries and not backed down just because other kids are allowed to do something, so many of his friends play it now, and they are all online together playing after school every day that it's affecting his friendships.

As for films, I use Common Sense Media for guidance and I don't think the ratings can always be relied upon, as what affects one child won't affect another. For example we let the 8 year old watch certain 12s with us (such as Marvel stuff) and he's absolutely fine, but he was really traumatised by ET, which is a U!

Not a chance we'd let him watch any 15 or 18 for a long time yet though.

Triffid1 · 29/09/2021 09:20

I think it entirely depends on the child and the situation, and importantly, how parents interact/engage with it. DS has definitely watched things that I consider a bit hardcore - but him and DH watch them together and there's a lot of chat about issues etc.

Ironically, DS has more freedom than a lot of his friends in what he does and watches etc, and yet he's far more questioning of misogynist or homophobic attitudes etc than many of his friends and peers. Not only at home, but at school - we have had teachers comment to us on interactions they've observed where DS has told off other boys for behaving unkindly to girls or similar and I have had at least one girl's mother approach me to say that DS had been very kind/helped her out when other boys were being mean.

But I think it's because while he might be allowed more, there's also a LOT of supervision and discussion of these things as they come up. If he's watching something we don't like, we discuss why we don't like it and the issues rather than making him just turn it off, for example.

It does help that he's quite mature. I suspect that with DD we'll do it slower as although she is academically much more advanced, she's far more sensitive and less mature than he was at the same age.

Coronawireless · 29/09/2021 09:15

For me it’s about not keeping them in a complete bubble. I am strict with mine physically…they’re not allowed to go anywhere without supervision. The same for most of their peers where I live. So I feel that I should allow them to explore some of the world’s many dangers from the safety of their living room, and see how strong characters deal with troubling situations. I would like them to have an awareness that bad things do happen and give them a chance to process how they might ever deal with such issues.

Kanaloa · 29/09/2021 09:10

Depends on the thing. We watched His Dark Materials (a 12 I think) over lockdown with the oldest two (10 & 11). Didn’t find it to be too bad and they both had read the first book already.

Ditto several things like Stranger Things (they watched with DH), Hamilton, the Lost Boys etc. I prefer to watch it then decide whether or not I think it’s suitable rather than go by age ratings.

I don’t let mine video game regularly though. It’s just what suits for different families. Obviously we all know a 10 year old watching 18 rated horrors isn’t good, but generally I’m not a slave to age ratings.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 29/09/2021 09:07

Not any of the ones you've mentioned but my 10 year old has watched stranger things and like a pp hot fuzz and most of the rest of the films

I use common sense and game wise let his 18 year old brother decide as I'm not into gaming

purplesequins · 29/09/2021 09:07

depends
we look at common sense media
we live in fortin and the ratings here are different than in uk.

having said that, dc have read harry potter around that age and we allowed them to watch the films after they have finished the books.

Ginger1982 · 29/09/2021 09:07

I think parents believe themselves 'cool' if they allow certain things. 'Oh yeah, my 7 year old watched IT and it didn't affect him.' 🙄 Ratings are there for good reasons. I remember watching old Bond movies with my dad as a kid and being mortally embarrassed every time Bond got it on with some woman 😂

I think it's fine to allow them to watch things a little older than they are but to be blasé about it is just stupid.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 29/09/2021 09:04

I think sometimes there is a subconscious competiveness.... older rating = more advanced. Tv, games, books, toys...

Figgygal · 29/09/2021 09:02

I’m amazed at how relaxed some people are with this
I Don’t know if it’s just shitty and lazy parenting or people thinking they’re cool

Coronawireless · 29/09/2021 09:01

Supervision is key imo.

Schulte · 29/09/2021 09:00

Thing I don’t understand is… there’s enough age appropriate content for them to enjoy, so why the rush to let them watch ‘older’ things? Children should be children, not mini teenagers.

Coronawireless · 29/09/2021 08:59

What’s wrong with Roblox? Am I missing something???

Coronawireless · 29/09/2021 08:58

I do think the underlying message is very important. Hunger Games is violent and sad but has a heroine who is a fantastic role model for girls. Likewise stranger things which emphasises kindness and loyalty to family and friends, including people who are marginalised or quirky. Even squid games explores themes of whether you should look after yourself or others and shows the pros and cons of these decisions. There is thought behind these stories. As opposed to many 12 rated teen shows where the girls seem to do nothing but shop and buy clothes to attract boys.

ShinyGreenElephant · 29/09/2021 08:58

I let dd watch some 12s at 10, now shes 13 I let her watch some (not all) 15s. Nothing with graphic sex or violence, not bothered about rude jokes or swearing as she heard worse in school. Similar to what @Coronawireless has said - not sure about squid games though I would have to watch an episode first. Definitely wouldn't let her on roblox though even now. My dsd was on that from about 7 which I think is awful

foxgoosefinch · 29/09/2021 08:57

I certainly wouldn’t, and am lucky that most of DD’s friends’ parents don’t either. I really worry for our daughters in particular growing up with a generation of boys who have been allowed to watch content and play games with extreme sexual violence - and the kinds of ways women are represented in social media.

No wonder they are all obsessed with daft social media gender identity crazes, when the alternative in mainstream media for young women is to look like an “influencer”, stick clumps of fake lashes on and spend hours “contouring” and be an object for men to perve over.

DrBlackbird · 29/09/2021 08:50

I fought for years to keep my DCs tv and film viewing age appropriate. However, it seemed everyone around us allowed their DC to watch anything.

At her Infant school, mothers took their 5yr old DDs to Ma Mia because it was a ‘mother-daughter’ film… by yr 1, boys playing GTA, my SiL took her 8 yr old DD to see Hunger Games and by 11 she and her school friends was watching horror films that in turn she’d show to my DC… Friends at her school watching AHS at age 12 etc etc

Now at 16, the stuff she watches on Netflix makes me feel sick, but this is our bright shiny world of streaming. I didn’t realise that Squid Games was so violent. She’s watching that now.

The more twisted (American Horror Story), the more violent, the more ‘out there’ the better to drive ratings. This is simply about making money. It sounds so old fashioned, but I strongly believe that our children and young people will suffer the price of those violent sexual images staying in their memory and in the subtle and insidious ways affecting their thinking and values.