Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So you let your kids whatch 12/15/18 programmes when they are only 10???

161 replies

Cantcook842 · 29/09/2021 07:35

AIBU here or not? I'm not a complete rule follower. I'm sure my child has watched the old older thing occasionally.
But I'm hearing from family members and school friends about what they watch and play and it just confuses me. Do people not want their kids to be kids anymore? Are they quite happy to expose them to violence etc from a young age?
Some recent examples :
Kids in my sons class are age 9 and 10. For at least two years a lot of the boys have been playing Grand Theft Auto. This is a 17+ game due to violent content /crime /rape/prostitutes. My son constantly asking to play and join in. We say no. His cousin also plays it who is 8 years old.

Watching films such as deadpool (15) contains sex and violence. Horror films such as IT, Halloween and Chucky.

The girls in the class are all on tik tok adult accounts and most of them have phones that they bring into school and show each other very grown up videos whilst walking home.

The new recent Netflix programme Squid Games is also 17+. My husband and I watched it and enjoyed it, but it is full of violence and death. Son goes into school, kids all talking about it because they've watched it. My 7 year old daughter loves to play on Roblox, she shows me that there have been squid games created on there, aimed at very young children!

Girls at school watch love Island and think that's a good example for a how a woman to be and aspire to be influencers.
Am I the mean one for not letting my 10 year old watch adult rating programmes and games?

OP posts:
BigWoollyJumpers · 29/09/2021 15:55

Interesting thread. I watched things like The Godfather, Good, the Bad and the Ugly, when I was pre-teen. Absolute classics, but both 18's.

I remember not being able to see Alien or Apocalypse Now though. I suppose each generation has its limits.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 29/09/2021 15:49

I was watching 18 certificate horror films from age 11. Not done me any harm. Some kids are more sensitive than others. My 8 year old doesn't scare easy and I'd let him watch a 12 or even a 15 certificate film (depending on how violent it was and it had no sex or nudity it). He's watched Lord of the Rings and Gremlins.

I wouldn't let him play GTA.

PussInBin20 · 29/09/2021 15:49

I’m with you. My DD (11) moans that all her friends have seen X, Y, Z but when I look at the reviews/programmes I am horrified!

All her friends think I’m strict but why would you want to subject your child to this stuff. It’s been shown to have an effect on them, even if they don’t realise.

I mean if some grown adults think Corrie is real, then what are the kids to think?

Stokey · 29/09/2021 15:42

@JaninaDuszejko books are a challenge as obviously not rated in the same way as films. I do think that if there is something you don't understand in a book, you skim over it and it doesn't stick in your mind in the same way as a violent or sexual image in a film would.
My 11 year old reads a lot of YA, some of which is possibly a bit unsuitable for her. I do try and read ones that I'm really not sure about first so I can either say no, or explain bits that I think I need to.

WoodchipNightmares · 29/09/2021 15:39

I'd be relaxed about the idea of a 13 year old watching Bridgerton.

It's steamy (particularly the end of episode 5, and episode 6, if I remember rightly) but it's consensual, romantic, and while you're left in no detail as to what they're up to, it's hardly pornographic. There are depictions of female pleasure (hurrah!) rather than just being male focussed as so many of these things are.

The sexual politics are of their time - men and women are held to wholly different standards of sexual morality - but that was the reality and it's no worse than what is depicted in Downton.

If it depicted graphic violence or rape then I'd be much more concerned. It doesn't. I'm also not naive enough to think that a 13 year old girl doesn't know what masturbation or oral sex (probably worth noting that it's him performing it on her) are.

Rannva · 29/09/2021 15:38

Only scummy parents do that. You can tell the effect it has on their kids, who are revolting to be around.

RandomWordGenerator · 29/09/2021 15:37

Mine are 10 and 11.

They are generally ok to watch a 12, but not if it’s too scary/violent - some of the older films have very questionable ratings!

Have you ever seen Labyrinth? It’s a U!!! My children watched it about age 8 and were terrified.

I think they’ve seen a couple of 15s, but where it is 15 for swearing or for innuendo which goes over their head. I don’t care about the swearing, they know what is and isn’t allowed, and they probably hear worse walking down the street. I won’t let them watch anything violent or any horror. Definitely not grand theft auto and the like.

Comefromaway · 29/09/2021 15:28

I used my judgment.

I'd have let my 10 year old watch most but not all 12 certificates and I'd have let my 13 year old watch most 15 certificates. But I wouldn;t have gone any higher.

JaninaDuszejko · 29/09/2021 15:24

I have only ever let them watch 1 rating above their age so my 9 yo DS has watched a couple of 12s but generally he doesn't want to thankfully because I hate the violence in superhero movies and his gaming is all free games on cbbc/the beano and minecraft. My 12&13 yo DDs watched 12s from about the age of 10 (things like Doctor Who or Harry Potter or Call the Midwife) but I would use common sense media and the BBFC description of the classifications to decide. Like PPs I don't mind swearing but they have only recently seen any films with anything sexual (dirty dancing was the first and is a 12 so consensual sex and not a higher age rating than their age) and I really don't like violence so that's a hard no. The 13 yo is beginning to ask to watch 15s so we've seen Ferris Beuller's Day Off (swearing) and Lady Bird (swearing and sex). DH and I don't watch 18 films so they won't get access to them.

Books are interesting, the DDs are reading stuff I wouldn't want to (YA stuff like Maze Runner) but I think kids are less able to imagine themselves in these situations so find it more enjoyable than I would, I think with reading I am happy to let them read what they want. By the time I was 13 I was reading gothic books like Flowers in the Attic and bonkbusters like Lace (the goldfish!), DD1 asked about The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo recently so I read it to see how graphic it was and was much tamer than the things I was reading at that age (but I suspect it'll be too 'boringly' adult for her - I loved it!).

BrendaBubbles · 29/09/2021 14:48

My strategy is if they watch something rated much older, then watch it with them and provide context, reassurance, explanations, and even turn it off if it's too much for them. Leaving them to just get on with it is a recipe for disaster but it's good to stretch them too within a safe context.

Hankunamatata · 29/09/2021 14:20

I tend to stick to guidelines. Bit shocked deadpool is 15. My kids moan quite a bit bit. The odd film like star wars or jumanji we have let them watch after watching ourselves. 10 year old cracks up everytime at zoology b×tch but nothing he hasn't already in the playground Hmm

Bobsyer · 29/09/2021 14:13

My kids watch some stuff above the age they are, but they are things I have already watched.

We did take them to see Ready Player One which having read the book I thought would be fine - I didn’t realise they’d replaced a scene with something from The Shining! It was rated a 12a so I took a punt - likely they were all ok with it but it was a bit of a shock!

Mine don’t play GTAV but I would allow them to drive around on it under my close supervision. You’re right the storyline is completely inappropriate.

Polkadots2021 · 29/09/2021 14:11

(the horror film my folks showed us was an 18. What the hell they were thinking I dont know)

Polkadots2021 · 29/09/2021 14:10

@Cantcook842

AIBU here or not? I'm not a complete rule follower. I'm sure my child has watched the old older thing occasionally. But I'm hearing from family members and school friends about what they watch and play and it just confuses me. Do people not want their kids to be kids anymore? Are they quite happy to expose them to violence etc from a young age? Some recent examples : Kids in my sons class are age 9 and 10. For at least two years a lot of the boys have been playing Grand Theft Auto. This is a 17+ game due to violent content /crime /rape/prostitutes. My son constantly asking to play and join in. We say no. His cousin also plays it who is 8 years old.

Watching films such as deadpool (15) contains sex and violence. Horror films such as IT, Halloween and Chucky.

The girls in the class are all on tik tok adult accounts and most of them have phones that they bring into school and show each other very grown up videos whilst walking home.

The new recent Netflix programme Squid Games is also 17+. My husband and I watched it and enjoyed it, but it is full of violence and death. Son goes into school, kids all talking about it because they've watched it. My 7 year old daughter loves to play on Roblox, she shows me that there have been squid games created on there, aimed at very young children!

Girls at school watch love Island and think that's a good example for a how a woman to be and aspire to be influencers.
Am I the mean one for not letting my 10 year old watch adult rating programmes and games?

I'm with you OP my parents showed us a particular horror film when we were v young way before 10 I think, didn't bother me so much and I watched loads of horrors at my grans when I was young too, but I think it messed my brother up looking back. It'll be a cold day in hell before my boys watch that stuff early.

I think it messes with boundaries to be honest, it's not just the film rating it's that feeling that.boundaries and stuff can be blurred or don't really matter which when you're young can be a dangerous idea.

3scape · 29/09/2021 13:57

It would be looked at if there were other safeguarding concerns. It's not always raised in itself as one.

It's sloppy to just allow anything without reviewing it yourself because the certification is not at all consistent or reliable.

MigAndMog · 29/09/2021 13:44

I also wish that parents who let their kids watch 18 films at age 8 would make sure that they don't discuss the plot at school with other 8 year olds. My daughter had nightmares for months because a kid in her class told her what he had watched. Unfortunately the choice of a parent doesn't only affect their child.

Generallystruggling · 29/09/2021 13:36

You sound a bit uptight tbh. I don’t allow social media because I want them to steer clear of that for as long as possible. I tend to watch things first and if I deem it suitable, I let them watch it. My 11 year old DS is extremely mature for his age so I can trust him to watch adult content and have some understanding. He loves Stranger Things for example which I believe is rated 15.

As for games, they’ve all played Roblox for about 5 years now. They know not to speak to strangers on there, it’s quite an innocent game really.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/09/2021 13:32

I'm not too fussed about age guidances that run a few years ahead because of language or fighting but I would put a stop to something which is in range which is misogynistic.

kittenkipping · 29/09/2021 13:00

Hmm. I'd agree with the other poster that said that in a house where children are watching constant tv, unsupervised and not with the guidance of the parents, that's reflective of an overall home life which isn't good. The actual tv content is less alarming and likely less impactful than the ignorance/ neglect of the parents. And that is something I do witness- we have problems in our school where children are playing games at all hours- children unsupervised and unmonitored playing online with strangers and neglecting to self monitor the amount they play, the appropriateness of who with, who watch and absorb adult aimed movies without any guidance or context , who have free internet access to ask their questions of, who don't get required sleep etc. It's those same children who have little impulse control, and poor reading skills. It's not what they are playing and watching necessarily (although yes- whilst mine can watch any age rated show that I've watched and deemed appropriate- I don't allow extreme violence or graphic sex) it's an overall pattern. If a parent doesn't care or know what their child is consuming, it's reflective of a bad parent imo.

Theoldprospector · 29/09/2021 12:59

‘Giving your kids informed guidance as to what they should and shouldn’t watch or read isn’t the same as trying to shield them from everything though, is it?’

No, absolutely not. It is part of being a parent to make those decisions and provide guidance.

DD loved horror films as a teen but there were some where I would say not until she is older, and some where I would advise never watch it, not even as an adult.

Schulte · 29/09/2021 12:31

Giving your kids informed guidance as to what they should and shouldn’t watch or read isn’t the same as trying to shield them from everything though, is it?

In our house we openly discuss everything and when the kids have a question, they always get an honest answer. They have always been pretty clued up as a result.

But, when they wanted to watch the last Harry Potter film, I told them to wait until they were a little older because it is very bleak and darker and more brutal than it needs to be IMO. And they had read the books, sure, but their imaginations wouldn’t have stretched to something quite as grim.

Waiting a couple of years didn’t do them any harm.

wendz86 · 29/09/2021 12:23

My 10 year old watches stranger things and we have watched a few 12 rated films. She has heard swear words and doesn't swear herself so that doesn't bother me. She is also not the kind of child to be scared of what she watches, probably less than me! I definitely saw 12's and 15's before i was that age so don't think it's a new thing. Remember my mum taking me to see Notting hill when i was 12 (it was a 15) and trying to make me dress older .

Snoozer11 · 29/09/2021 12:15

I am much more sensitive to violence now than I was when I was a child.

Snoozer11 · 29/09/2021 12:14

I agree with all those using their own judgement and common sense when it comes to things like this.

All 12s, 15s and 18s aren't made equal. Something like Saw would be an obvious no.

I can never take parents who ardently stick to the age ratings seriously and in some ways I think it's worse than those who allow their kids to watch more adult programs.

The reality is that kids will always see things that are "old" for them. When I was a kid it was American Pie and Blair Witch Project. With my grandparents, it was A Clockwork Orange and it's novelization.

I think preparing them for the world and for seeing things they might not be ready for is more important than the ultimately fruitless attempts to shield them from everything.

I think as adults we see things from a different perspective, and gratuitous is not always the same as explicit. There may be an "explicit" sex scene of two people dry humping. But to me that's much less explicit than the scene of Susanne Jones wiping her fingers in Gentleman Jack.

Coronawireless · 29/09/2021 12:07

@Cantcook842

Lots of comments Smile I will always let my kids watch things within reason. But I'm talking specifically about things containing extreme violence and full on sex scenes. I'm talking about children who aren't even 10 years old here. From what I can gather, most of them are not watching them with their parents. I don't even know if their parents are aware! They are watching Netflix in their rooms etc. And obviously the parents aren't controlling or checking on what they are watching. I always say to my son that he has a very short time of being a child and a very long time being an adult, and that there will be plenty of time for all of that.

My concern is how quickly you become desensitised go violence etc when you watch it alot. If is worrying for the future

I would say that in a childhood where the child watches TV all day long, alone and unsupervised because the parents are unavailable or uninterested, what they actually watch is only part of the problem.