Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So you let your kids whatch 12/15/18 programmes when they are only 10???

161 replies

Cantcook842 · 29/09/2021 07:35

AIBU here or not? I'm not a complete rule follower. I'm sure my child has watched the old older thing occasionally.
But I'm hearing from family members and school friends about what they watch and play and it just confuses me. Do people not want their kids to be kids anymore? Are they quite happy to expose them to violence etc from a young age?
Some recent examples :
Kids in my sons class are age 9 and 10. For at least two years a lot of the boys have been playing Grand Theft Auto. This is a 17+ game due to violent content /crime /rape/prostitutes. My son constantly asking to play and join in. We say no. His cousin also plays it who is 8 years old.

Watching films such as deadpool (15) contains sex and violence. Horror films such as IT, Halloween and Chucky.

The girls in the class are all on tik tok adult accounts and most of them have phones that they bring into school and show each other very grown up videos whilst walking home.

The new recent Netflix programme Squid Games is also 17+. My husband and I watched it and enjoyed it, but it is full of violence and death. Son goes into school, kids all talking about it because they've watched it. My 7 year old daughter loves to play on Roblox, she shows me that there have been squid games created on there, aimed at very young children!

Girls at school watch love Island and think that's a good example for a how a woman to be and aspire to be influencers.
Am I the mean one for not letting my 10 year old watch adult rating programmes and games?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Needhelp101 · 01/10/2021 02:44

@Figgygal PG in the 90s was a different kettle of fish!
Reminds me also of watching The Mask and the amount of smoking in it, you'd never see that today.
Quite literally, "Smooooking!" Grin

reluctantbrit · 30/09/2021 18:48

It depends on the content and why it has the age rating.

I found that DD at 10 was often mature enough to see 12/12As which had a more complex storyline and the age rating was to a point where a good discussion about the point and watching it together meant she would understand it.

When she was 13 we moved in 15 movies but again depending on content. Similar set-up, we had to know the movie or watch it together.

Figgygal · 30/09/2021 18:21

@Needhelp101

Interesting thread.

I've allowed my 11 year old DS to watch some 15 rated films. The sort of which would definitely be a 12 if they'd just cut the swearing out a little. Incidentally,
we watched Men in Black the other day (PG) and I was astonished at how much swearing there was!

Same With a 9 and 5 year old and thought wow this is so 90’s!! The casual swearing id totally forgotten it
Hamster1111 · 30/09/2021 12:08

I don't allow my kids to watch / play any of those things. They are 10 and 7. We have watched the occasional 12 rated film once we've watched it first. Also like common sense media for guidance. Not all kids are doing these things.

Needhelp101 · 30/09/2021 10:15

Interesting thread.

I've allowed my 11 year old DS to watch some 15 rated films. The sort of which would definitely be a 12 if they'd just cut the swearing out a little. Incidentally,
we watched Men in Black the other day (PG) and I was astonished at how much swearing there was!

Idontbelieveit14 · 29/09/2021 18:47

My DD will be 15 next week, she watches most things now but can’t cope with watching certain things. For example she loves gogglebox but if it’s an episode with naked attraction or something on we have to fast forward 😂 she’s a terrible scaredy cat too so horror films are a no-no!

DS is 13 and has been finally allowed GTA recently after asking for about 2 years. I found that once he was allowed it he didn’t actually want to play it that much! He loved watching Line of Duty, loved Benidorm last year during lockdown. He doesn’t actually watch much TV, again he hasn’t watched any horror films.

Coronawireless · 29/09/2021 18:26

@Ylvamoon

It's a difficult one for sure. And I don't have the answer at all. My dilemma: DS just moved school and is busy making new friends. A lot of stuff is happening via video games... and to fit in / have half a chance he will want to have that 16+ or 18+ game. Or he hangs out with the other strange kid that is still in the dark ages ane be "marked forever" (=his words not mine).
“Marked forever”…. that’s so sweet! Though I’m sure he doesn’t think so.
pisspants · 29/09/2021 17:48

I allow mine the next one up, so at 12 can watch 15s and from 15 allowed to watch anything. If being asked for something more than one above then I check common sense media and try to get a general consensus from there.

GotToGoBye · 29/09/2021 17:44

Mine don’t so you are not on your own OP

Ylvamoon · 29/09/2021 17:39

It's a difficult one for sure. And I don't have the answer at all.

My dilemma:
DS just moved school and is busy making new friends. A lot of stuff is happening via video games... and to fit in / have half a chance he will want to have that 16+ or 18+ game.

Or he hangs out with the other strange kid that is still in the dark ages ane be "marked forever" (=his words not mine).

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 29/09/2021 17:38

Ive been saying just because so and sos parents let them doesn't mean you can for 20 odd years now (dcs 26,18,10,8) you get used to it

Pazuzu · 29/09/2021 17:36

Would I let my 11 yo watch a 12A? More likely than not yes. A 15? Far less so, Deadpool for example would have been an 18 all day when I was that age.

An 18? Absolutely not. The distributors of some films now would have been prosecuted as virtually none of the "video nasties" came even close to some of the stuff out there now. The boundaries have definitely shifted over the last 20 years and then some.

As for games, GTA V is apparently one of the most popular primary age games but there is no way on this planet that DS1 is playing it.

However, I'm happy for him to play PEGI 16 games in the main as the age rating system is quite harsh compared to film (probably because in game you're the one doing rather than passively watching characters in films)

I know my kid and get involved in what he's watching etc. It's not rocket science.

Kanaloa · 29/09/2021 17:28

Well there’s obviously other issues in these families and the problem isn’t really letting a 10 year old watch a movie with an age 12 rating.

Cantcook842 · 29/09/2021 17:27

This seems to be the problem with some of these children. There is no parental judgement. There is no parental involvement at all. They just let them do what they want!! And then my kid has to listen all about it and wonder why we don't let him! I hope when he's older and looks back he will thank us for trying to maintain some innocence of childhood

OP posts:
Coronawireless · 29/09/2021 17:07

@Midge75

You have to watch stuff yourself. Commonsensemedia is really helpful, but kids watch all sorts these days, and have very different ideas of what is appropriate. My 13-yr old's classmates are all watching Squid Games and Scream Queens, Sex Education, etc. Thankfully, she is very open and honest and is asking permission, with puppy dog eyes, to watch these, things, but she accepts my decision if I say no. She watched the first season of Stranger Things at a sleepover when she was 10, which I was horrified about, because I had seen it - and loved it - but it is scary. Thankfully, she just loved it for the 80s vibe and the characters and storyline. She has since watched the other two seasons and a few other series and filme that have an older age rating, but I am picky. I will watch first and then decide. Ginny and Georgia, which all the 13 yr olds are talking about apparently, was a hard no from me - when a random boy this 15 yr old girl has barely met climbs through her window and she lies down on the bed with him and asks if she can take two fingers - NOPE! Watch and judge for yourself. Not all 12s/15s/18s are equal.
Ginny and Georgia would be a no from me too even though Squid Games is allowed. G&G normalises and glamorises casual underage sex. In Squid Games you know who is making poor life decisions.
MajorCarolDanvers · 29/09/2021 17:05

12s yes
15s would depend on the film
18s not a chance

Midge75 · 29/09/2021 17:03

You have to watch stuff yourself. Commonsensemedia is really helpful, but kids watch all sorts these days, and have very different ideas of what is appropriate. My 13-yr old's classmates are all watching Squid Games and Scream Queens, Sex Education, etc. Thankfully, she is very open and honest and is asking permission, with puppy dog eyes, to watch these, things, but she accepts my decision if I say no. She watched the first season of Stranger Things at a sleepover when she was 10, which I was horrified about, because I had seen it - and loved it - but it is scary. Thankfully, she just loved it for the 80s vibe and the characters and storyline. She has since watched the other two seasons and a few other series and filme that have an older age rating, but I am picky. I will watch first and then decide. Ginny and Georgia, which all the 13 yr olds are talking about apparently, was a hard no from me - when a random boy this 15 yr old girl has barely met climbs through her window and she lies down on the bed with him and asks if she can take two fingers - NOPE!
Watch and judge for yourself. Not all 12s/15s/18s are equal.

Coronawireless · 29/09/2021 16:36

But I totally understand why wouldn’t be for everyone!

Coronawireless · 29/09/2021 16:36

@HungryHippo11

Even squid games explores themes of whether you should look after yourself or others and shows the pros and cons of these decisions As if a 9 year old is understanding these messages from Squid Game. I'm pretty sure they would be saying "oh its a show where loads of people get shot and killed" not "its a programme where people got killed but only because they made bad decisions so next time I'll think before gambling or signing an unknown contract"

Also I'm certain they could find a programme with those messages which doesn't include massacres.

We have discussed these very issues with our DC. Because we watch with them.
HungryHippo11 · 29/09/2021 16:35

Even squid games explores themes of whether you should look after yourself or others and shows the pros and cons of these decisions
As if a 9 year old is understanding these messages from Squid Game. I'm pretty sure they would be saying "oh its a show where loads of people get shot and killed" not "its a programme where people got killed but only because they made bad decisions so next time I'll think before gambling or signing an unknown contract"

Also I'm certain they could find a programme with those messages which doesn't include massacres.

HungryHippo11 · 29/09/2021 16:08

@Sirzy

I think by rushing through things like HP before old enough to actually understand it actually spoils the overall enjoyment of them because you may be watching it but your not actually “getting it”
Totally agree. Its wasted on a 6 year old.
HungryHippo11 · 29/09/2021 16:04

@SheWoreYellow

I look on common sense media and judge from that.

But generally I let them watch a couple of years ahead of their actual age.

My DD had friends aged 11 who were allowed to watch the series Chernobyl which I thought was Shock

Surely they wouldn't have even understood it, like the political and scientific stuff would have gone over their heads and it was hardly a "fun" watch

OP I second Common Sense Media as a good source of information.

I doubt you're the only one who doesn't let your kids watch that stuff. I certainly wouldn't. Probably the type of kids who are allowed to watch that sort of thing are also the type to show off about it.

HarrietsChariot · 29/09/2021 16:03

It depends on the film or game. Generally I'd be more strict with games because there is the interactive element. GTA and RDR aren't suitable for children, end of story. Films though depend on what they are and why they got a particular rating. Schindler's List for example I would rate more as a PG, provided the child watching it understands the context. How the hell is Lock Up (Stallone prison romp) an 18 whilst Threads is only a 15? Threads fucked me up when I viewed it for the first time aged 35!

The BBFC ratings are only enforceable in the sense people cannot buy them below that age - it's up to the parent to view something and decide whether it is suitable for a child.

maddening · 29/09/2021 16:01

We allow some 12s for our 10 year old, but we pre-watch. We have watched some entry level horror films, but based on reviews and research as to what is appropriate, so poltergeist and 6th sense for example.and stuff like Jaws and the Meg.

We watch all the marvel and star wars films with ds, but have not touched deadwood (too violent and too much bad language etc) and obviously not joker or the suicide squad stuff (again too old).

We are currently watching the james bond films from the start with ds, mostly as there are alot of cultural references to James Bond and it is interesting to see change in popular culture from the 60s to now. Also want to watch Austin powers with ds but you def need to see James bond first 😂🤣.

You may not agree but we def make sure we are comfortable as parents that the films he sees are not too much or too old.

But even outside of films you have to be careful, for example he is doing ww2 at school, I recorded a couple of documentaries, but on review some are v graphic and poss too old right now.

fantasmasgoria1 · 29/09/2021 15:57

I allowed mine a bit of leeway such as some 15 films when they were 13. I remember being allowed to watch hammer House of horror when I was 8! I never thought it gruesome it just made me chuckle. Looking back though in the 80s when I watched it it was just really badly done and not particularly horror like.