Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bridesmaid Dilemma!

89 replies

sh5278 · 28/09/2021 21:52

So.. any advice would be HUGELY appreciated.

I have chosen my bridesmaids/flower girls: my sister (Maid of Honour), my fiancé’s daughter and his nieces. Originally, I only wanted my sister and fiancé’s daughter. But, knowing his brother and brother’s partner, if I didn’t have their children as flower girls, then we would be bad mouthed to the rest of the family. So, we stretched the budget, and said that we would have them included too. Problem solved. But.. no.

My fiancé’s brother’s partner had pulled me aside, and told me she can’t wait to plan my hen, and wants to buy her own bridesmaid dress, EVEN THOUGH SHE KNOWS THAT I HAVE ALREADY ANNOUNCED MY BRIDESMAIDS/FLOWER GIRLS. I laughed it off, but she has mentioned it AGAIN since then. We get along ok.. have had some arguments in the past, but I simply do not want her as a bridesmaid. My mum does not like her, and she’s overpowering. My fiancé claims she has a fear of missing out. I really don’t know how to approach this subject without being blunt. However, if I was blunt with her, she would make things VERY difficult.

Am I being unreasonable? Should I let her be a bridesmaid if she really wants to, and has said she will buy her own dress!?

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman · 28/09/2021 23:29

Here’s a thought - could you get flower girl dresses for the kids to try on in one colour, then buy them in another? That way if mad SIL is planning to ‘accidentally’ turn up the same colour as the bridal party, she’ll be in for quite a shock Grin

HeadPain · 28/09/2021 23:29

[quote sh5278]@SevenOldLadies
Yes, she’s the mother of 2 of the flower girls. One of her daughters will be 2 at the time of the wedding, and the other will be 7. The 7 year old is quite unruly, so I’m already worried about the day.[/quote]
I said YANBU and she shouldn't be a bridesmaid if you don't want her to be, but reading this maybe you should have her as one so she can look after/control the kids. Maybe she is concerned about leaving her 2 year old and the unruly 7 year old that you're worried about. I suppose she doesn't have to be a bridesmaid to do that though.

Boredhimtodeath · 28/09/2021 23:29

If she says about buying her own dress can you pretend to misunderstand and just say no they are my flower girls so I can sort them the same as fiancé’s daughter. Then if she corrects and mentions her own dress laugh and say I didn’t know people bought guest dresses- especially those only invited to the evening do!

Don’t tell her the colour or style of your bridesmaid dress!

TyrannosaurusRights · 28/09/2021 23:07

Just make sure you pre warn your photographer, hair and makeup people, florist and venue coordinator. Otherwise you’ll find she’s in all the ‘wedding party only’ photos and front centre of the rest. Good, experienced wedding staff will just manage her away.

Chloemol · 28/09/2021 23:05

No is a complete sentence

I am going to plan you hen

No ( although you could your moh will do this)

I am going to but my own bridesmaid dress

No

Etc etc

Alternatively your partner needs to have a word with his brother to tell the GF to stop, it’s not going to happen and if it continues you won’t have the lids as flower girls either

justmaybenot · 28/09/2021 22:49

@sh5278

So.. any advice would be HUGELY appreciated.

I have chosen my bridesmaids/flower girls: my sister (Maid of Honour), my fiancé’s daughter and his nieces. Originally, I only wanted my sister and fiancé’s daughter. But, knowing his brother and brother’s partner, if I didn’t have their children as flower girls, then we would be bad mouthed to the rest of the family. So, we stretched the budget, and said that we would have them included too. Problem solved. But.. no.

My fiancé’s brother’s partner had pulled me aside, and told me she can’t wait to plan my hen, and wants to buy her own bridesmaid dress, EVEN THOUGH SHE KNOWS THAT I HAVE ALREADY ANNOUNCED MY BRIDESMAIDS/FLOWER GIRLS. I laughed it off, but she has mentioned it AGAIN since then. We get along ok.. have had some arguments in the past, but I simply do not want her as a bridesmaid. My mum does not like her, and she’s overpowering. My fiancé claims she has a fear of missing out. I really don’t know how to approach this subject without being blunt. However, if I was blunt with her, she would make things VERY difficult.

Am I being unreasonable? Should I let her be a bridesmaid if she really wants to, and has said she will buy her own dress!?

Just say you always promised your sister she'd be your bridesmaid and always planned on just one adult bridesmaid, then thank her for letting her kids be the flower girls but of course you're looking forward to her being at your hen and wedding and so on. Job done!
selflove · 28/09/2021 22:47

I had the same situation.

BIL (to be) was DH's best man. Their two daughters were flower girls, and their son was page boy. BIL's partner asked me if she could be a bridesmaid too, because her kids & partner were, and she'd feel excluded if she wasn't, and they would look odd as a family if the dad & 3 kids were in the bridal party, it would look like she wasn't part of the family etc.

So I said no problem, added her as a bridesmaid. It just wasn't the hill I was willing to die on, I didn't care about adding an extra bridesmaid at the end of the day, whereas she really cared about the idea of "missing out" so it was fine with me

SevenOldLadies · 28/09/2021 22:41

If the youngest is 2, I can kind of see why she’d expect / want to also be a bridesmaid.

Second what others have said about getting her to look after the flower girls. Maybe get her to get a dress in your wedding colours if she wants to fit in.

steppemum · 28/09/2021 22:40

I think you should just laugh and say - but your girls are the flower girls, you can't be a bridesmaid as well, that would be silly!

Janaih · 28/09/2021 22:36

She wants to wear a princess dress. She'll most likely wear one even if you say no... please try and put her in her place though. Such people sail through life being a pita because people agree to their ridiculous demands for a quiet life.

Littleduck83 · 28/09/2021 22:33

Just smile and say “ohh I don’t think you need a special dress just to keep an eye on the flower girls”. Then tell her that your MOH is your only adult bridesmaid, and that’s exactly how you want it, but you’re so pleased that her beautiful girls will be taking part.

erictries · 28/09/2021 22:32

Just be consistent. If she says "I can wait to plan your hen" reply "my sister is planning it"
If she says "I'll buy my own dress" just reply with "that won't be necessary. We are all sorted thanks".
Don't invite her to bridesmaid dress fitting. Just go with your sister. Yes you'll need to involve her with the flower girls, but I'd keep it low key and buy off the rack if you can, therefore not making a big day of it, that she would hijack.
If she says " can I be your bridesmaid?" Just answer, "I asked my sister"
Don't engage and play it down around her every time it's brought up

sh5278 · 28/09/2021 22:31

@GloomAndDoom
I have 3 flower girls: my fiancé’s daughter, and his 2 nieces. Fiancé’s daughter will be 7, and is best friends with her cousin, who will also be 7. If I cut the flower girls to just my fiancé’s daughter, both girls would be upset as the mother (who the post is about) has already gone on about it to them both. My first thought was to cut it down to just having my sister as my MOH and fiancé’s daughter as the flower girl, but now the other child is too aware of what is going on, and I do not want to upset her.

It isn’t an over the top wedding, we aren’t having a wedding breakfast due to funds and my fiancé’s strong feelings towards not having one, but having 50 at the ceremony, and 130ish at the reception.

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 28/09/2021 22:27

However, if I was blunt with her, she would make things VERY difficult.

No she won't, unless you allow it. Fgs, it's time to make some boundaries and stand up for yourself. Do not allow people to emotionally terrorise you and hold you hostage with their bullshit. Tell her she is not a bridesmaid, and if she kicks off, you can exclude the lot of them from your wedding.

AnneLovesGilbert · 28/09/2021 22:25

However, if I was blunt with her, she would make things VERY difficult.

What would she do?

Hopefully she’ll stop her kids taking part. Win win.

I’ve got a two year old, you’re barking mad to have agreed to that.

Polmuggle · 28/09/2021 22:20

Just say 'no don't worry, one of the bridesmaids will plan the hen, that's their job!'

But equally if her daughter is 2 and a flower girl then she's goo to be involved in helping her go down the aisle, no?

freelions · 28/09/2021 22:20

I would just laugh off her comments and point out that you are only having one adult bridesmaid and that is your sister

GloomAndDoom · 28/09/2021 22:19

@SleepingStandingUp

Those asking how many bridesmaids, it's literally in the OP!
@SleepingStandingUp it's not clear to me how many nieces they are and if any of them are bridesmaids or if they are all flower girls. Is fiancé's daughter a bridesmaid?

My sister (Maid of Honour), my fiancé’s daughter and his nieces.

MaggieFS · 28/09/2021 22:17

Just flip it around and say you don't want more adults to detract from the flower girls. Obviously you have to have your sister as MOH, but aside from that there won't be any adults in the bridal party. All focus will be on the flower girls and you're so grateful she'll be keeping a close eye on them and making sure they are on their best behaviour.

2lsinllama · 28/09/2021 22:17

She knows full well that you don’t want her, that’s why she offered to buy her own dress. I had to be very firm with a friend who offered to sing at my wedding (she was classically trained) but then wanted a dress like the bridesmaids and was basically trying to become a bridesmaid by stealth. I told her no, she threatened to not sing, I called her bluff and she backed down. She still tried to make it about her on the day though, acting like she was Mariah Carey or something! We don’t speak much now.
At the end of the day, it’s your day so have what and who you want.

Chickychoccyegg · 28/09/2021 22:15

I have no idea why you would ask an unruly 7 year old and a 2 year old to be flower girls anyway!
who is going to look after them while you all get ready/before you walk down the isle/make sure they walk down the Isle? You might need their mum to be a bridesmaid to deal with her kids to be honest

SleepingStandingUp · 28/09/2021 22:15

Those asking how many bridesmaids, it's literally in the OP!

GloomAndDoom · 28/09/2021 22:14

Maybe she thought she'd be a bridesmaid to help look after the flower girls. I think your mistake was adding more flower girls. I'd tone down the whole thing and say it was getting out of hand so you're just having 2 bridesmaids.

LtDansLegs · 28/09/2021 22:14

YANBU! No one is owed a part in your wedding.

Could you do your best tinkly laugh and say "Oh no, you'll have your hands full in charge of the very important flower girls, you know how important that is to me that you are with them - I wouldn't dream of putting too much on your plate" or similar?

WomanStanleyWoman · 28/09/2021 22:13

Just keep up the hard, hard nos. Anything else just won’t go in - and she’ll hijack any consolation prize like a reading.

This is probably outing, but my best friend had a similar issue with her fiancé’s best man’s wife. She’d barely known her a year, but this woman kept trying to muscle in and appoint herself as a bridesmaid. When my friend finally got her to accept that she wasn’t going to be a bridesmaid, she said ‘Well maybe I could carry Pookie down the aisle for you on a velvet cushion’. Pookie was my friend’s dog.

Swipe left for the next trending thread