Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think public schools/boarding schools have fewer problems with bullying?

106 replies

PostingOnMN · 28/09/2021 19:14

AIBU? To have the opinion that top public schools and boarding schools have fewer problems with bullying than non-public schools or boarding schools? Top boarding schools I mean places like Cheltenham Ladies College, Perse Upper School, or even Eton College?

Also as someone who is black or BAME I guess, meeting people who attended those schools while I was at university, I felt completely comfortable around them and their parents were really nice! Even though they had travelled to foreign countries, had multiple homes around Europe and even holiday homes in the UK! They were really down to earth and didn’t comment on my skin colour at all or make me feel any different, which is something I cannot always say. I also went to a summer course in Eton College and the teachers there were really helpful and even recommended me for a different course and helped me prepare! I found the same thing at a well known university in London.

I’m now wondering if I would like to send kids to schools like that but wondering if I’m being naive based on limited experiences?

OP posts:
borntobequiet · 28/09/2021 20:21

Really? No way.

wingsandstrings · 28/09/2021 20:20

My DH went to Eton and there was a considerable amount of bullying - he escaped intact but it was miserable for many of his friends.
My cousin went to Cheltenham Ladies and was removed by her parents half way through her GCSE year because she was about to have a breakdown because of school academic pressure and a toxic atmosphere.
In general at Uni the people who I knew from top public schools seemed more likely to have been bullied than me and my grammar school friends.
What makes bullying even worse in boarding schools is that you can't escape and be with people who love you.

Pinkyxx · 28/09/2021 20:17

I was educated in independent schools, and my daughter is at one having moved from a state school. My own experience of independent schools , and bar one school which I attended for a year, they were all on a par with the school my daughter is at now. In my view much depends on the ethos, values and culture espoused by the school - important to understand all independent schools all unique.

While in a state school, my daughter was horribly bullied by staff and pupils in the state school and labelled a ''problem child'' . The bullying was never addressed. 2 children in her class were removed by their parents due to bullying that wasn't addressed. Bar a minority, the parents weren't very pleasant & judgmental in a way that honestly shocked me. She's now in an independent school and thriving on all levels. Interestingly, she hasn't been bullied at all. From what she tells me any unpleasant behavior is swiftly and fairly dealt with before it can escalate. There is a strong expectation of respectful behaviour. The parents are lovely, from varied backgrounds and cultures. I've limited experience of state schools so prepared to accept my experience is not representative.

Shelddd · 28/09/2021 20:15

@PostingOnMN

Thanks *@Yarboosucks* Smile however it seems like most people feel that I am being unreasonable and seem to have the opposite opinion
I think a lot depends on your social class in society. I don't think you want to put your kid into a school where they are in a vastly different social class than those around them.

So if you're doing well, (you mentioned you're university educated that's a positive) there is a good chance they will be fine and it's probably a good move but if you are going to struggle to pay their tuition and also pay for other things in life than it might not be the best move.

Also realise that most people doing these polls will not be people in upper social classes in society (as there is less people obviously) so the poll will skew.

As always my post will offend 10+ people.

Witchlight · 28/09/2021 20:12

Every school has bullying, whether you experienced it or not. What matters is how it’s dealt with.

Private schools have more resources and flexibility to deal with bullying. That does not mean they do, but when they do it is likely to be more effective.

State schools have far fewer resources and often have their hands tied. They are more likely to try to deal with it.

So from the above,

Best results will be those schools who really want to tackle bullying.
Then state schools who prioritise dealing with bullying.
Then the rest of schools who just pay lip service.

TheHateIsNotGood · 28/09/2021 20:10

No - one of my best friends was harmed in a lifelong way from his Private Boarding School experiences; although my DS (ASD) suffered within the State system, the harm caused is not so deep and lifelong.

MrsAvocet · 28/09/2021 20:06

If the experience of just about everyone I know who attended schools of this type is anything to go by I would say that the opposite is true.
I actually cried when a University friend related his experiences at a famous public school, and the teachers don't sound to have been a lot better than the pupils to be frank.

MarshaBradyo · 28/09/2021 20:02

I don’t know about now but bullying was crazy at our boarding school

A hierarchy and poor kids at the bottom of it got the brunt daily and couldn’t escape to go home

Might have improved I hope so.

PostingOnMN · 28/09/2021 20:01

lol I said I have limited experience with these kinds of schools, that’s why I’m asking for more opinions @Starrycolors23

OP posts:
Rummikubfan · 28/09/2021 20:00

I was hideously bullied in private school. From what I hear the bullying in our local girls independent schools is relentless. It’s not physical but lots of nastiness, alienating girls, getting into arguments and other friends siding with the bully

Happens everywhere.

Starrycolors23 · 28/09/2021 19:58

Hahahahahahah this has to be a windup

DobbyTheHouseElk · 28/09/2021 19:56

@Panicmode1

There was bullying at my all girls boarding school which wasn't dealt with..some of it was even done by the staff to the girls.

Friends of mine at nearby boys boarding schools (a couple of which are very well known) also suffered horrendous bullying.

All schools, private or state, have bullying to a greater or lesser extent. It is how it is dealt with that makes the school a good one or not IMO.

I wonder if you went to the same school as me. The staff bullied me worse than the other girls.
BitterTits · 28/09/2021 19:56

State schools have a mandate to prevent peer on peer abuse and it's becoming increasingly important. I don't know if that's the case in independents.

I've been so impressed with the way Y7 DD's school have come down hard on the beginnings of racist bullying experienced by her best friend. It makes it so much easier for both girls to stand up to it. I'd never send mine to a private school (professionally too, I've worked in one).

OverTheRubicon · 28/09/2021 19:54

Unbelievable bullying at boarding schools, and what's more you have to live with your bullies, and don't have someone who loves you to make sure you are seen and give you a hug.

miltonj · 28/09/2021 19:52

Sorry to clarify I mean no, as in that is 100% not the case.

miltonj · 28/09/2021 19:51

No

notanothertakeaway · 28/09/2021 19:51

I'm sure bullying happens in all schools. As a day pupil, you can escape overnight

Panicmode1 · 28/09/2021 19:50

There was bullying at my all girls boarding school which wasn't dealt with..some of it was even done by the staff to the girls.

Friends of mine at nearby boys boarding schools (a couple of which are very well known) also suffered horrendous bullying.

All schools, private or state, have bullying to a greater or lesser extent. It is how it is dealt with that makes the school a good one or not IMO.

DancingDog · 28/09/2021 19:49

Agree with PP though a lot of these schools have massive problems with substance abuse particularly boys schools. A lot of kids with big allowances and nothing to spend it on. From my primary school of 20 kids there were 3 expelled from senior school for dealing drugs, one of my friends brothers is an addict from school.

My school it was eating disorders, probably 10% of my year had anorexia or bulimia, it became almost competitive and a lot of them still have issues around food 25 years on.

PurBal · 28/09/2021 19:47

Bullying happens in all schools

esloquehay · 28/09/2021 19:46

I boarded at the school the DoC was purportedly bullied at and I was bullied the fuck out of and those teen years haunt me to this day.
Hopefully, things have moved on since the '90s, but I heard a lot of racist and xenophobic views in my time there.

bookworm14 · 28/09/2021 19:45

You’re extremely naive. The bullying may take different forms/be about different issues, but it’s still there. My DH was bullied mercilessly at one of the top public schools in the country.

AnotherNewt · 28/09/2021 19:45

Any school can have a bullying problem occur.

The measure of the school is how they deal with it.

Private schools can certainly expel pupils far more easily than state schools can. But it still requires leadership with principles and standards, and a willingness to act,

PostingOnMN · 28/09/2021 19:44

Wow, I guess because I never experienced boarding school myself @MitfordBlisters I can only base my opinions on people I met after we all left school, like @Notthemessiah said. Thank you for sharing your experience though. Do you think day students face similar things?

OP posts:
DancingDog · 28/09/2021 19:42

I boarded, there wasn’t a major problem with bullying it was nipped in the bud pretty quickly. Where there was, it tended to be directed towards the girls on a bursary rather than different ethnicities. They would suspend you for bullying, where you didn’t get on (just clash of personalities rather than bullying) they used to put you in a dorm together so you learned to get on and be polite to people you perhaps wouldn’t naturally chose to socialise with.