Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think public schools/boarding schools have fewer problems with bullying?

106 replies

PostingOnMN · 28/09/2021 19:14

AIBU? To have the opinion that top public schools and boarding schools have fewer problems with bullying than non-public schools or boarding schools? Top boarding schools I mean places like Cheltenham Ladies College, Perse Upper School, or even Eton College?

Also as someone who is black or BAME I guess, meeting people who attended those schools while I was at university, I felt completely comfortable around them and their parents were really nice! Even though they had travelled to foreign countries, had multiple homes around Europe and even holiday homes in the UK! They were really down to earth and didn’t comment on my skin colour at all or make me feel any different, which is something I cannot always say. I also went to a summer course in Eton College and the teachers there were really helpful and even recommended me for a different course and helped me prepare! I found the same thing at a well known university in London.

I’m now wondering if I would like to send kids to schools like that but wondering if I’m being naive based on limited experiences?

OP posts:
NotTheMrMenAgain · 29/09/2021 09:53

The only person I know who went to a supposedly 'top' boarding school is a nice chap who was horribly racially bullied due to the fact he's of Chinese descent. He's not even that old - still a young man - but the impact of the bullying remains, despite years of counselling/therapy.

Open days etc are just for show, you see the glossy bits and meet the pupils who've been specifically selected (as per my own private school experiences). With boarding school I think you just couldn't be entirely certain wether you were dropping your DC off at a caring, supportive, inclusive learning environment, or if you were simply throwing them to the wolves. If it's the latter, then you probably won't know until some damage has already been done.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 09:10

Everyone’s Invited did put a spot light on schools

Although not sure it included general bullying. Something like that could work but students won’t use personal SM to expose it

DillonPanthersTexas · 29/09/2021 08:57

Problem with threads like these is that much of anecdotal contributions are from people who attended an independent school quite literally decades ago. Things have moved on a bit since then (as it has with state schools as well) with much more emphasis on pastoral care with accusations of bulling being taken more seriously. With the rise of social media it is much harder for schools to bury their heads in the sand.

Stifledlife · 29/09/2021 08:37

My sons went to a top boarding school and left within the last 5 years.
Bullying was nipped in the bud. The introduction of girls changed the dynamic immensely a few years ago and housemasters and matrons are engaged and proactive, and the pastoral net has very small holes and manages to catch more than I could believe.

The teachers and the pupils are much more closely bound together than at day schools. If fact one of my sons still regularly meets up with his entire A level english class (including the teacher) for drinks. Because of this the teachers understand the quirks of a child at a more indepth level and this really becomes evident at parent/teacher evenings.

The ethnicity, wealth and religion of other pupils became irrelevant pretty quickly as far as I could see. My sons brought a united nations of kids home for weekends (were allowed home every weekend although not weekly boarders) and it wasn't unusual to have 4 extras for sunday lunch.

Post school, they keep in touch pretty closely with school friends and meet-ups are regular and phone calls and message groups are frequent.

They have had an easy confidence with adults for many years, a pretty well developed sense of obligation (if they promise, they deliver), and even if I say so myself, are charming.

If you choose the the right fit for your child then it can be the best choice, and you can't compare the experience of 30 years ago with the experience of today.
Boarding schools, and the world, have changed.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 08:07

These posts are very sad

Especially if it’s changing that much from a generation ago

Neew789 · 29/09/2021 05:52

@MrsAvocet

I've just remembered that the friend I mentioned in my earlier post wasn't even allowed to use his own name at school as it was "foreign". He was allocated a British name which he had to use at all times. I'd like to think that things have improved now, but this was only the 1980s not the time of Tom Brown's Schooldays. I was shocked when he told me.
My husband boarded in the early 2000’s at a very well known boarding school, all students had an ID number and it was on their soap dish, uniform etc. Children who weren’t white, or who were different like my husband (he has a physical disability) we known by their number rather than their name.
LaBellina · 29/09/2021 04:27

Bullying happens everywhere and has nothing to do with social class. When I attended public school I stuck out like a sore thumb because I studied hard and was seen as a nerd. The smoking, swearing girls were seen as the cool ones. Those same nerdy qualities were seen as something admirable at the private school that I attended later and those that were deemed ‘too common’ were bullied there. No environment is bully free I’m afraid.

Kanaloa · 29/09/2021 03:49

It seems a bit naive to presume there is no bullying in boarding schools because an adult you knew who was at boarding school as a kid (and whose parents have multiple holiday homes) was polite to you. Or because a teacher at a summer programme helped you as they were being paid to do.

I mean if you come to the supermarket I work at (in an area of extreme social and economic deprivation) I’ll be nice to you. But that doesn’t mean there is no bullying at the local high school.

mikulkin · 29/09/2021 01:15

Unfortunately our experience with public boarding school is many children were bullied openly and this was not nipped in the bud, just swept under disagreement umbrella unless official written complaint was made (which doesn’t happen often). Almost every house and every class will have their victim. You would also be surprised at some teachers there - you might have read now and then a scandalous story about a teacher fired from top boarding schools due to racism/sexism etc - well I would say these are only the ones somebody had courage to complain about…
Day private schools generally are much better.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 29/09/2021 01:09

As far as I’ve always understood they have a worse problem with it.

My experience of being at university wher ea vast majority were private/ public school, although I wasn’t bullied myself , supports that idea.

Charmatt · 29/09/2021 00:30

I would suggest that you look at Everyone's Invited to see how high class private schools deal with peer to peer abuse

SheilaWilcox · 28/09/2021 23:55

My DD is mixed race and now goes to a private school. She doesn't board, but there is the option there. I moved her from the local state school, so have seen both sides.
One of the things I love about it is that they have kids from many different countries, ethnicities and religions there.
Some of the parents are obviously loaded, but many are just normal working parents.
I'm sure bullying must go on there as it does at every school, but I've not come across it or heard of it at all. One of the things I've noticed, is that if there are any friendship issues or something you want to talk about, it's fine to email the teachers. You always get the impression you are taken seriously. This is not because the teachers are necessarily any better than state schools, it's just that they have smaller classes and more time. The other thing is that parents tend to be more engaged, so the general level of behaviour is better.

I think every school is different, so you have to visit and see which is the best fit for your child. Ask about bullying. A good school won't mind talking about how they deal with any issues. If they claim it doesn't happen at all, alarm bells should ring!!

I went to state school myself, but moving my daughter was the best thing I did.

MrsAvocet · 28/09/2021 23:44

I've just remembered that the friend I mentioned in my earlier post wasn't even allowed to use his own name at school as it was "foreign". He was allocated a British name which he had to use at all times. I'd like to think that things have improved now, but this was only the 1980s not the time of Tom Brown's Schooldays. I was shocked when he told me.

Soundofshuna · 28/09/2021 23:29

Steppemum guess we were at the same school!

Jangle33 · 28/09/2021 22:57

My husband was a day boy at a boarding school. Bullied every single day for 7 years. Private schools are hotbeds of this!

You wouldn’t know it for the charming children and their parents you meet but don’t be fooled OP!

PileOfBooks · 28/09/2021 22:56

You've seen Everyone's Invited right?

NotSoNewAndShiny · 28/09/2021 22:54

Oh OP, bullying happens everywhere and probably worse in boarding schools. Worse because you don't even get to escape after school and take a break, like day students.

I never went, thankfully, even though we'd wanted to. But I know many who did. Terrible experience for many. I know it's not the same for everyone.

steppemum · 28/09/2021 22:48

I went to one of the schools you mentioned.

To be fair, with respect to racism, I think it was ok.

But every other type of bullying was rife.
Boarding schools can be the most horrific places for bullying. There is no getting away from it, no going home, same girls during the day, evening and night time.
You don't tell, because then you are a snitch and that makes it 1000 x worse.

I am ashamed that I didn't stand up for some of the girls who were bullied. At the time, it was self preservation.

LittleMissGlum · 28/09/2021 22:42

@PostingOnMN unfortunately BAME students are often subjected to far greater bullying at these schools (speaking from experience).
Apologies, haven't read the rest of the replies so probably repeating what has already been posted.

Soundofshuna · 28/09/2021 22:28

I went to one of the schools in your list. Bullying was rife!

PostingOnMN · 28/09/2021 22:19

That’s the thing @dontbenastyhaveapasty, they have a way of coming across as so charming when you meet people them (the men especially) that it’s almost hard to imagine they would be capable of doing those things you’ve described (although I do believe you).

OP posts:
Kindleswitchface · 28/09/2021 22:10

Don't forget the sexual abuse and drug problems too OP.

High school is hell for so many kids. The worst thing in the world is to send kids to live there without their families.

Autumngoldleaf · 28/09/2021 22:05
  • caveat now that is.

Yes sadly it is seems boarding schools for some have been horrific prisons of abuse of all kinds

Autumngoldleaf · 28/09/2021 22:04

People often travel within work and their dc get sent to private schools so yes in that respect there can be far more diversity than local schools.

If one child is causing so many issues that that kids complain then I guess there is more motivation to be keep the mass happy

trumpisagit · 28/09/2021 21:44

The only person I know who went to one of the big public schools, has ongoing trauma that has affected the rest of his life, from severe and unrelenting bullying.