Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be narked by this woman’s attitude? Working parents v child free employees

244 replies

SJaneS49 · 28/09/2021 16:07

Not a biggie, at the moment I’ve got a lot going on in the background and am generally hacked of with the world .. but this response has generated a real ‘oh ffs’ reaction in me just now.

Expectations of working parents, especially women as typically (but not obviously always ) we have to date carried more of the childcare burden and been the ones taking the compromises has always been of interest to me & something I think we have got wrong in Britain. I posted something on LinkedIn earlier about how society expects parents to work as if they don’t have children and to parent as if they don’t work. Until I started working from home 14 years ago, that was my experience as a professional working in London, working all hours in the office while also being the sole parent at home, getting in about 7.30/8pm & going straight into helping out with homework.

So I put out a question on LinkedIn, asking parents if their recent experience of working in the new normal had changed what they themselves would be looking for in their next role in terms of flexibility of hours worked when or where they carried out their work. Plenty of employers are currently offering flexibility..but are pretty woolly & vague on what the expectations will be in the longer term. Quite possibly as a number haven’t really worked that out themselves yet! As well as interesting me on a personal level, as I advise my clients on how to make their roles more attractive, I wanted to gauge what changes 2020/21 had made to attracting candidates who if they were parents might not now (having experienced the opportunity to be more ‘present’) want to go back to how it was. Potentially!

Anyway. I have had a reply from someone who is child free who I worked with on a project years ago basically saying special measures should not be made for parents and therefore burdening their childless colleagues. Flexibility if it was being offered should be for all.

While I completely agree with her that parents should not be offered special measures or more flexible options than others, I wasn’t suggesting that at all! Which has me wondering whether this would read like this to others? This particular woman seems to spend a lot of her time writing ranty comments on LinkedIn posts judging by my feed so feeling a bit 🙄 about implications made in her post that the child free ‘carry’ more workload than working parents.

Basically, is she being a knob? Or was it fair enough! Just brought back memories of some of the attitudes around years ago of some of the women I worked with, making bitchy comments about women who had to head out at dead on 5 to relieve the childminder.

OP posts:
SofiaMichelle · 28/09/2021 21:34

@Willyoujustbequiet

I think most people who dont have kids/ other caring responsibilities really don't have a clue how hard it can be. I absolutely feel that they should get priority re flexibility. Lone parents in particular.
The thing is, it's not childless people's problem and shouldn't be made their problem. Why should they know or care care 'how hard it can be'? An employer is employing you not your family.

So no, your personal choices shouldn't mean you get priority over someone else.

An employer is employing you, not your family.

Witchcraftandhokum · 28/09/2021 21:26

Willyoujustbequiet fortunately it seems from this thread the majority don't agree with you.

Feedingthebirds1 · 28/09/2021 21:13

There is a difference between the question you asked on LinkedIn and the question you asked on here, which was Basically, is she being a knob? Or was it fair enough! Asking if she was being a knob wasn't great, for starters. You could have found another way to phrase it rather than denigrating her.

There are plenty of examples on MN, as PPs have said, where flexibility for parents = non parents picking up the slack. Holiday choices significantly reduced. Expected to do the overtime, come in early. Maybe she's been on the receiving end of that recently hence her response.

And while I know I'm going to get blasted by posters saying how dare you, can ALL parents who have greater flexibility honestly say that they do all the work they're supposed to do? That they don't take time out here and there to go to school meetings, school plays, or if they do, they make up ALL the time they've taken?

While you may not have intended it, I can see how it may have been taken as flexibility only for parents, particularly by anyone who has been on the wrong end of that flexibility.

sillysmiles · 28/09/2021 21:02

@ohgiveup and @sjxoxo i misread that quote and thought the OP was now saying that parents should have more flexibility which wasn't what she had written on her OP. Apologies to @SJanes49 !

Willyoujustbequiet · 28/09/2021 21:01

I think most people who dont have kids/ other caring responsibilities really don't have a clue how hard it can be. I absolutely feel that they should get priority re flexibility. Lone parents in particular.

Witchcraftandhokum · 28/09/2021 20:58

In theory yes flexibility should be available to all. In practice though as a childless woman who has worked all her life I've been expected to pick-up work for parents who suddenly need to be at home for childcare, been penalised for being genuinely poorly twice in 6 months whilst pregnant colleagues go, unbothered to numerous appointments and been denied holidays at Christmas be because I don't have "family".

Rubytinsleslippers · 28/09/2021 20:52

I think it boils down to the expectations of the workplace. If the job is x amount of hours why is there any bitching that people leave on time? Working over summers etc should be shared/ rota type same with Christmas or whatever. I hate this ridiculous notion that unless you stay over extra or start first you are not commited or good at your job. Work is part of life not living to work and that should be for all employees.

VladmirsPoutine · 28/09/2021 20:45

In one job I had I might have made more of the role I played in my niece's life than was strictly true Blush

Holskey · 28/09/2021 20:44

I have a little one. He has taken over my life in the best way and I want to spend time with him. It's also what he deserves.

I was infertile for many years before having him and I worked as others took priority for holidays and never had to stay late because of their choice to have children.

Having children is absolutely a choice and any benefits bestowed upon parents should also be reaped by non-parents. It's only fair and it doesn't matter at all if the childfree only use their free time drinking and watching Netflix whilst parents are cleaning vomit. As someone who had to go through a lot to get my little vomiter, I know it was my choice and nobody else should have to pick up the slack for it.

Ozanj · 28/09/2021 20:40

From 16-39 I was childless & I have to say yes I definitely covered for colleagues who had young kids. But these same women covered for me
when I needed to care for my parents, supported me through ivf & are now covering for me after having a baby. So it’s swings and roundabouts. As long as the workplace allows everyone support eventually then its ok.

Bollocks989 · 28/09/2021 20:33

I get you OP.

It seems like it is a can of worms tho, like you might have hit a raw nerve, without meaning too

Perhaps we should turn our discussion back to whether we are allowed to call ourselves women or vaginas?!

Ploorfuzzle · 28/09/2021 20:33

@MrsSkylerWhite

Fair enough, I think. Before we had children, I was frequently expected to just pick up someone else’s work because they had to leave by 5 pm. Christmas was a nightmare too, it was assumed that people without children had no caring responsibilities, commitments or just wanted to spend time with their loved ones too.

Flexibility for all, or no-one. I think specifically putting it in terms of parents needing allowances made is likely to irritate people without children.

Yes holiday was a nightmare- Christmas and summer was pretty much a no go because everyone with children would cause such a fuss. Mostly bad management though to be fair, I have since worked in places with a much fairer attitude. I feel well supported as a parent, and so do my colleagues who are childfree but also have a life, responsibilities and plans outside of work!
BobMortimersPetOwl · 28/09/2021 20:29

It's quite simple really. A better work life balance is more attractive to people. It doesn't matter why, or what priorities people have in their personal lives. There's absolutely no need at all to create division between parents and non parents.

Aside from that, non parents have often been on the shitty end of the stick when it comes to who has to pick up the slack, so I can understand the prickliness.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/09/2021 20:25

Fair enough, I think. Before we had children, I was frequently expected to just pick up someone else’s work because they had to leave by 5 pm. Christmas was a nightmare too, it was assumed that people without children had no caring responsibilities, commitments or just wanted to spend time with their loved ones too.

Flexibility for all, or no-one. I think specifically putting it in terms of parents needing allowances made is likely to irritate people without children.

Ploorfuzzle · 28/09/2021 20:20

I think what she said was reasonable, it comes across a bit as parents are the only ones fussed on or attracted by a job offering flexibility when that obviously isn't the case. Her comment was fair as well, if a workplace offers flexibility to parents then they should be ensure that it doesn't burden others in the team, im sure most have experienced not being on the other side of this, which isn't always the case. I guess perhaps her annoyance was that the question was around flexibility, yet excluded a lot of the workforce who would have useful and valuable input- it sort of suggests that they don't matter.

Hardbackwriter · 28/09/2021 20:15

@ColorMagicBarbie

Tbh, I used to get pretty pissed off being the one expected to finish work when my colleagues would swan off at 3pm to get the kids. One even used to say that everybody should be prepared to make sacrifices for the future generations. Fuck that. Not my kids, not my problem!
Were they 'swanning off' even though it was still their working hours, or did they work part-time or a different work pattern and so left earlier than you? Either way any anger should be directed at your employer who was either failing to enforce basic standards in employees or agreeing working patterns that weren't actually practical because they left work undone.
OhGiveUp · 28/09/2021 20:13

@Wewereliars Nothing rude and ignorant about it.
Child free doesn't always mean never had children. I'm child free by the virtue of mine being married adults.
If you choose to have children and work, then that's a choice, just as some women choose to have children and not work.....choice.
It's not my choice to pick up the slack for women who chose to have children and work.
That's why the rules should apply to everyone, parents or not.

ColorMagicBarbie · 28/09/2021 20:08

Tbh, I used to get pretty pissed off being the one expected to finish work when my colleagues would swan off at 3pm to get the kids. One even used to say that everybody should be prepared to make sacrifices for the future generations. Fuck that. Not my kids, not my problem!

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 28/09/2021 20:03

@ConstantlySeekingHappiness

But it does seem to bend some folks out of shape

I think it’s the entitlement and attitude of some parents that “bend some folks out of shape” tbh.

This Equality for all should be exactly this. So many problems are caused because those that have this entitled attitude,obviously a small minority of parents believe they should be treated as special compared to all other employees.
VladmirsPoutine · 28/09/2021 20:03

But I find it offensive that people call having children a lifestyle choice, how ridiculous. Without people having children the human race dies out, simple as that.

Ummm, I reckon if 'people' don't have kids the human race won't be budging any time soon.

SJaneS49 · 28/09/2021 20:02

@OverTheRubicon, you’re probably not wrong! But it’s the increasingly Facebookalike ‘I’m so proud of my 16 year old..’ type posts that annoy me.

OP posts:
SJaneS49 · 28/09/2021 19:59

Apologies @MeAndDebbieMcGee, that was actually @Aprilx I was replying too

OP posts:
PizzaCrust · 28/09/2021 19:59

Oh, and I don’t think during the regular working year others should pick up the slack for me having kids. I work part time hours so I can be flexible and make it work around my life. I’d never get a job and then demand others bend so I can do x, y and z because I have kids. With the nature of my job there isn’t work to bring home as all work must be done in the workplace and the work can’t be left for others to pick up. It’s very much “you work 8-6, there are x jobs to do in this time, ensure they’re done during this time”, and then someone else will start, say at 3-12, and they’ll have their own tasks to do in this time frame. Obviously sometimes there’s an overlap of what needs done and we’ll help each other, but there’s definitely no case of me leaving my workload for someone else to do on top of their own while I pick up the kids, for example. That’s just being a dick.

SJaneS49 · 28/09/2021 19:58

@MeAndDebbieMcGee, I think I know what I asked (certainly better than you do!), I asked parents whether having experienced a different work set up and having had the chance to be more physically present whether jobs offering flexible working patterns and the opportunity to wfh/partially from home would now be more attractive ..or not.

It was about their preferences when it came to job searching and what they would give priority too.

Any job advertised as flexible is open to everyone.

OP posts:
LastStarfighter · 28/09/2021 19:55

And while I’m here, I’ll weigh in on the wider debate too.

I think flexible working should be prioritised for those with caring responsibilities. I don’t think there is an equivalency between someone having to care for their mum with dementia, and someone who just fancies more time to get their nails done. I think if there has to be a choice, then it should be in favour of community, not in favour of individuals.

Of course ideally workplaces would be staffed sufficiently for it not to be an issue and to be available for all.