Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School undecided - private or state?

37 replies

Confused4313 · 28/09/2021 13:53

I’m hoping someone can please help me as I’m really confused and don’t know what to do. DD is in a primary school as my plan was always to keep her there till year 2 and put her in a private school from year 3. The private school near us only takes kids from year 3 that’s why I thought this.

I’m just really confused what to do and feel overwhelmed with all the decisions I have to make alone. DH is no help he just keeps saying yes we can afford it so put her in why even think about it. I keep thinking maybe it’s best to wait till secondary and then put her in private. The only decent state primary in our area has a huge waiting list and admissions in the borough told me it’s no point even waiting as there are hundreds on list before us waiting for a place even if we wanted to transfer her there.

Even tho DH tells me we have the money I have severe anxiety thinking about the huge costs involved especially as we have 2 kids who will both have to go. I’m also thinking maybe secondary will be best to spend money on. Plan initially was year 3 to year 6 private then try to get into grammar school which will be free.

Please be kind as I suffer from extreme anxiety and this feels really overwhelming for me incase I’m making a huge mistake.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
popconcern · 09/11/2022 21:45

DeborahAnnabel surprised no one has asked but what primary school is this?

SkankingMopoke · 29/09/2021 09:37

I agree with PPs that you are just looking for confirmation and permission for the decision you've already made, albeit dithering with the finance aspect.
FWIW, if she's settled and progressing then I'd leave her where she is. Moving schools is incredibly stressful for DCs especially if they aren't naturally gregarious and confident. You need to be completely sure you can cover the fees if your circumstances change too, otherwise she would have to move yet again (ie you need wealth, not just a high income). I'd channel some of the money saved into tutoring, extra curricular activities, and culturally enriching holidays, then bank the rest in readiness for secondary (if you miss out on the grammar) and uni.

Biscuits1 · 29/09/2021 09:08

DS has just started year 7 in a private school after attending a state primary. We don't have lots of money but have saved up over the years so that we could send him in secondary. He has high functioning ASD and is doing fine and is already one of the top academically even though there are some who went to the private primary school. I'm glad he didn't go to the primary as these children have millionaire parents and I feel this may have disadvantaged him in making friendships in primary as he would have been the odd one out. I feel the money spent on primary education for us would not have been worth what we would have got out of it. Could you not just top up whatever you feel is missing with out of school activities.

Newlooo · 29/09/2021 08:38

24 is a lot for private I feel. I imagined 15 kids at most. It is more than some private classrooms, but if it were much smaller there’d be fewer options for friends.

HiJenny35 · 29/09/2021 00:36

Move now. You need to be working towards the 11 plus from year 4, in private schools they will start to head towards these levels and cover areas related to it. You may still need an additional tutor however if you stay in the school you are currently in you will need to cover extensive work to get up to the level of a good grammar school entry exam with several nights tutoring outside of school simply because otherwise she won't cover the level or range of maths or independent writing needed.

Bunnycat101 · 29/09/2021 00:12

Does the private actively prep for the grammar and how selective are the grammars? That would be the thing that might swing it for me. There are some preps that have grammar prep as their selling point. Others that have a senior school attached may well not do quite the same level of prep for you.

DeborahAnnabel · 28/09/2021 22:57

*private

DeborahAnnabel · 28/09/2021 22:56

I can only speak of my own experience. I had intentions to do state til 8 but my daughter is in a phenomenal state primary which sends about 70% private to the likes of JAGS, WHS, SPGS etc. (London girls schools) The education is superb and is well supplemented by sport, music, arts and languages. We will tutor as necessary when necessary but I'm told that state applicants get preferential treatment. Not sure how true that actually is though but I don't believe that stage + tutoring has any disadvantage, personally. Especially since half the state school kids are also getting tutored.
However, if my daughter wasn't in the outstanding school she is in, I'd be moving her private in a heartbeat. I feel very luck and not displeased to be saving myself £20k a year.
In your case, and it sounds like her primary isn't great, yes, I'd be moving her.

Confused4313 · 28/09/2021 22:33

Thank you all. It’s just so much to think about. We planned early on to send to private but now I’m doubting as other issues are coming into it such as she doesn’t really have many friends in her current school (could be my fault as I’m not quick to socialise with mums due to my anxiety) so I’ve been doubting whether I’m moving her for reasons that might still exist in new school (even though I had planned to send her - I know my thoughts make me loopy so must be difficult for others to follow) or am I sending her for academic success. Then if she doesn’t enjoy it will it be a waste of money as she won’t learn if unhappy. We can afford it as long as we both work. Every decision is hard for me even if it seems I’ve already made my mind up.

Hope it makes sense - think I need to sleep and take out if my mind got tonight. Maybe I’ll post a new thread asking questions I really need clarity on rather than waffling snd not making sense. I’ve been told her class will be 24 kids, now is 31. 24 is a lot for private I feel. I imagined 15 kids at most.

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 28/09/2021 22:13

My daughter is in an all girls school, she joined year 7. Shes 12. She's thriving in the small classes (she has adhd and a little ASD)

My plan was always to leave her in her local primary school then move her which I did. But honestly I wish I'd moved her earlier although it's great she has all her local friends still.

I think you have to make the decision that's best for your child, some kids thrive in the state system some kids are better of in private where they benefit from smaller classes and better pastoral care.

Autumngoldleaf · 28/09/2021 22:00

Op your post isn't about the private school bring right for her. You already seem to think it is and smaller classes in themselves are so worth it for the right child.
. What we say makes no difference because your anxiety is coming from what you think you can afford?

So either share all your income /out going /savings and fees with us.
Or go through it all and pin it down with dh.

Newlooo · 28/09/2021 21:45

Op it doesn’t sound like you’re undecided, it sounds like you want people to tell you you’re making the right choice. We can’t do that, we’re not there. I know anxiety makes this hard, but you’ve made up your mind: send her to the private school.

Getyourownback · 28/09/2021 21:40

@Rannva

You're obviously, like, crazy rich, so why is this even an issue?

For us we didn't think frittering tens of thousands was worth it. Living near a good school helps; if you have squillions, why not do that? If you live near only terrible schools... why, when you're rich? Move near a decent state high school? If you're then so concerned she's 'behind', pay for additional classes/clubs where she can make different circles of friends.

There’s always, like, one isn’t there?
Cocomarine · 28/09/2021 17:28

@Rannva

Why does he have to tell you 'you can afford it'? Don't you already know if you can or can't by being aware of the family figures yourself?
That was my first thought.

If you have a strong preference for the grammar, on a £ basis, I’d keep her in primary and invest in tutoring from early on for the best chance of grammar. Checking what percentage that is.

If you want private and you’re anxious about affording for 2 if circumstances change, then do some planning around worst case scenario. For example, how much can you save now as a buffer? Do you have lots of equity which you could release by - worst case scenario - down sizing?

In my experience, smaller groups don’t make it easier to make friends. The larger primaries all splinter off into small groups anyway, and it just increases the chances that she’ll find someone who is a good fit. Many many children go through school with just one friend, simply because that’s the person they fit with - don’t worry if she doesn’t have a big group.

VladmirsPoutine · 28/09/2021 17:24

My position has always been if you can afford it go private. I've found as an adult money talks and sometimes sheer grit and merit won't get you very far alone.

Confused4313 · 28/09/2021 17:20

The private primary would go up to year 6 then most kids go to one of the grammar state schools or the independent secondary one. I know it’s no right answer but my gut is telling me she will be happier. She doesn’t have many friends. I might be wrong but I’m a smaller setting she might make more friendships. I think she’s happier in smaller groups and talks more that I’ve noticed. There’s so many options here where we live for independent schools are they obviously don’t take into consideration the catchment areas do we have so much choice whereas the state primaries we have no choice as catchment area is not where our home is

OP posts:
Orangejuicemarathoner · 28/09/2021 15:29

dont move a happy child for no reason

Rannva · 28/09/2021 15:26

Why does he have to tell you 'you can afford it'? Don't you already know if you can or can't by being aware of the family figures yourself?

Rannva · 28/09/2021 15:25

You're obviously, like, crazy rich, so why is this even an issue?

For us we didn't think frittering tens of thousands was worth it. Living near a good school helps; if you have squillions, why not do that? If you live near only terrible schools... why, when you're rich? Move near a decent state high school? If you're then so concerned she's 'behind', pay for additional classes/clubs where she can make different circles of friends.

Scaffoldhell · 28/09/2021 15:25

I wouldn’t assume she will get in to the grammar. In my area the grammar is hotly contested and most private parents don’t even try , preferring to go to private secondaries instead. If she goes to the school at year 3, can she stay until GCSEs or will she need to do an 11+ and move on ?

LaikO · 28/09/2021 15:22

I can't speak for your finances, if it's finances only then I'd do as @CecilyP suggests.

We'll all feel differently I imagine, but I won't be sending my children to private school (we could afford it) and have declined to work at them as I don't think they should exist. If you would prefer one and can afford it, go for it. I suppose it also depends, as you've mentioned, on what the state schools near you are like.

CecilyP · 28/09/2021 15:09

DH does say we can afford it and we both are working full time but my anxiety makes me think the worst such as if anything happens then we can’t afford it.

Forget what your DH tells you, can you work out if you can afford it? Reassuring words are not enough, you have to be sure you have the money to pay the fees with a certain contingency fund as a backup for minor set backs.

SeasonFinale · 28/09/2021 15:09

My son was also perfectly happy in the state village school from R to y2. However we did move him at y3 and he knew that he would be going to that school. He then went to an independent prep that went from Nursery to 18 so had the option of staying all the way through. However when it became obvious he was quite clever we then looked at a different more selective prep from y9 onwards.

If you can afford it for both of your children then go for it. We were originally going to go from y7 but he would have missed out on playing some of the sports offered and he was in first teams by the time he got to that age which he wouldn't have been if he had stayed in his primary. The same with MFL. He would not have had them to the level that he had in the indie at his primary.

But other children did join at y7 and y9 (and indeed in year admissions all the way through the school).

Dixiechickonhols · 28/09/2021 15:07

It’s hard if no one to speak to.
I’d visit all the schools. Look at their ofsted reports.
Is she happy? I’d be very reluctant to move a happy child.
Are the private schools viable and reasonable class sizes eg not 3 children in a class.
You mention grammar schools are you in a super selective area (highest mark gets in) or in an catchment area where a pass gets you a place.
It’s very area dependant.
I’m in Lancashire. A private primary starts at £7,000 a year (a year not a term!), secondary £12,000 a year. Obviously in some areas you are looking at a lot more.
Only you know how affordable it is. Will it affect holidays. What if you lose job. Would it be better spent on Uni/house deposit.
We chose private primary then state grammar and no regrets.

Bumpsadaisie · 28/09/2021 15:00

Does it help to think there isn't a "right" answer so therefore there you can't really make a "mistake"?

There are just two different options, each with pluses and minuses.

Swipe left for the next trending thread