Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my DSis to keep something confidential from her DH

267 replies

Whatamoraldilema · 28/09/2021 13:23

Last week I told my Dsis something in confidence about my young DS. In hindsight I'm not sure if that is a fair thing to ask. Do you think it's reasonable to ask your sibling to keep something confidential from their partner?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 28/09/2021 15:13

For those who share everything where so you draw the line?

OK some secrets might need support - if I tell my best friend I have cancer or was raped I get she might need to share. Some might be juicy or exciting - if I'm shagging the milkman or pregnant.

But if we're talking "we tell each other everything" then presumably you'd also tell him about my UTI / Thrush, how snotty my kids noses are, my struggle to find a hairdresser etc. Does he actually give a damn? Does he really want to sit there whilst you share the boring crap of my life that I've shared with you out of friendly natter?

rwalker · 28/09/2021 15:13

Of course it's reasonable but it may be too late now you told her last week .
If I was told something off a friend in confidence I would tell no one .

godmum56 · 28/09/2021 15:12

@Gazelda

So do those who tell their spouse everything, even confidential info, think that their relationship is closer than those of us who wouldn't break a confidence?

My husband is my best friend, soulmate, rock etc etc. I am currently privy to 2 bits of info that I've been asked to keep confidential. Neither affect him. Neither affect our home life. I trust him 100% and know that if I did tell him it'd go no further.

Does that mean my marriage isn't as strong as I thought?

I genuinely do not know. I know (knew) about my marriage and nobody else's
WannabeMathematician · 28/09/2021 15:09

@Frogsandsheep Possibly? But tbh no one tries to tell me their secrets and I do feel much lighter. People still talk to me if they have tradgies in their lives or gripes. Maybe it's cut down on the gossip that people tell me? For example no one has ever told me they are having an affair!

As for the work question, I don't work in an area where I need to talk to people about their personal details. I don't work patients or anything like that so it hasn't come up. I think though the role a friend who needs me completely is different from the role of a collegue. As part of a buisness I would never be alone in being resposible for someone in the same way so I don't think it's a fair comparison in my case.

Also for the record. I really hope you are doing better. I'd hate to have been your friend and have let you down in such a way and to break your trust. I think that's one of the reasons I'm so upfront about the whole thing.

SirChenjins · 28/09/2021 15:09

@BrendaBubbles

This is the whole reason you have a husband rather than a boyfriend. You are both a unit and anything can flow back and forth between the two as a joint entity, financially, legally, and that includes secrets as well. If you want to be totally independent, don't get married
No, it's really not the whole reason I'm married to DH. If not keeping anything from your DH is the whole reason you married him then knock yourself out, but don't try and tell others what the whole reason 'should' be for getting married.
Alwaystrappedunderababy · 28/09/2021 15:06

@SickAndTiredAgain

I think it depends if it’s something that, now she knows it, she’ll be required to outright lie to her husband about it. As opposed to something she could just not mention.
I agree with this. I have no problem not mentioning something to my husband but I could not lie to him for somebody else.
FrangipaniBlue · 28/09/2021 15:05

@Gazelda

So do those who tell their spouse everything, even confidential info, think that their relationship is closer than those of us who wouldn't break a confidence?

My husband is my best friend, soulmate, rock etc etc. I am currently privy to 2 bits of info that I've been asked to keep confidential. Neither affect him. Neither affect our home life. I trust him 100% and know that if I did tell him it'd go no further.

Does that mean my marriage isn't as strong as I thought?

That seems to be the insinuation from some posters.

Utter bollocks.

Gazelda · 28/09/2021 15:04

So do those who tell their spouse everything, even confidential info, think that their relationship is closer than those of us who wouldn't break a confidence?

My husband is my best friend, soulmate, rock etc etc. I am currently privy to 2 bits of info that I've been asked to keep confidential. Neither affect him. Neither affect our home life. I trust him 100% and know that if I did tell him it'd go no further.

Does that mean my marriage isn't as strong as I thought?

godmum56 · 28/09/2021 15:03

@saraclara

I dont think it is ever fair to ask someone to keep something from their partner. If you tell one person in a marriage, you have told both

That is such bollocks. Have some respect for yourself. You're a person in your own right, as is your partner. This is not some test of a relationship "oh were so close I couldn't possibly keep anything from him. If you do, you can't possibly be as close as us"

But most of all have some respect for your friends and relatives. It's their stuff they've told you. You're not lying by not sharing it with your husband. You're just respecting their privacy.

People in jobs where confidentiality is paramount don't go telling their spouses official secrets or other people's medical information.

Just keep your mouth shut and stop using this ridiculous excuse to blab other people's troubles.

yes I am a person in my own right and that person has a right to the kind of marital partnership that I choose. people who know me well enough to confide in me know this and confide in me accepting it. so far as medical confidentiality goes ( i just answered this) I would say i had had a bad day because death/relapse and so on but no detail. Its intersting you mention the Official secrets act. My late husband had to sign this as part of a promotion at work. he came home and told me as it would be the first time either of us had had to keep a secret from the other and he wanted to be sure that I would be ok with it.
FrangipaniBlue · 28/09/2021 15:02

To those saying they tell their husbands - why?

This genuinely perplexes me!

Ok I get that if your best friend told you she had cancer you'd be upset and need someone to talk to, but that's just one extreme example.

If your friend told you she was pregnant and considering a termination? Or that her husband was having an affair and she was contemplating how to deal with the situation? None of these examples affect either you or your husband so why on earth would you need to tell him?

gogohm · 28/09/2021 15:01

Depends what it is, something very personal then it's fine to keep a secret especially female issues.

Noworneverever · 28/09/2021 15:00

My Dsis will tell me things and expect me not to tell DH, I don't if she expressly states not to. But if I ever say for her to do the same it's not reciprocated. Such a double standard, but it is what it is, so now I tell her hardly anything and she moans about that.

Frogsandsheep · 28/09/2021 15:00

@godmum56

I think that completely fair enough.
Ive heard things in my work that have made me come home and cry all evening. It’s fine for dh to know I am carrying a huge burden but not ok for me to tell him what.

Bobsyer · 28/09/2021 15:00

I think it’s fine.

I know things about my sister that would hideously embarrass her to know my husband knew about, and they wouldn’t change or enrich his life to know so I don’t share.

I don’t think this is any different.

Whatamoraldilema · 28/09/2021 14:58

Thanks everyone - it's interesting to see people have such differences of opinion. I still can't decide if I was reasonable or not 😆.

OP posts:
Frogsandsheep · 28/09/2021 14:58

@BrendaBubbles

What about work related stuff? No one seems to be able to say whether that counts……
If I told my husband stuff from work I’d lose my job!

Frogsandsheep · 28/09/2021 14:57

@WannabeMathematician

It is good for you to have those clear boundaries but not great for your friendships.
Your situation is extreme and totally understandable as to why you wouldn’t want to keep a secret again. But in general I think having trust in friendships is really crucial. Most friendships are not unhealthy and trust is a good thing.

BrendaBubbles · 28/09/2021 14:55

This is the whole reason you have a husband rather than a boyfriend. You are both a unit and anything can flow back and forth between the two as a joint entity, financially, legally, and that includes secrets as well. If you want to be totally independent, don't get married

godmum56 · 28/09/2021 14:55

[quote Frogsandsheep]@scarpa

Of course it’s fair enough to say that but it’s also a shame that people will then feel they can’t open up to people they are close to.

I assume work related things don’t count? I can’t imagine someone in a caring profession getting away with saying ‘I’ll have to tell my husband’[/quote]
I never told my husband detail but would confide in him that I had had a bad day because death, relapse and so on

godmum56 · 28/09/2021 14:53

@Orangejuicemarathoner

I dont think it is ever fair to ask someone to keep something from their partner. If you tell one person in a marriage, you have told both
I agree. And to make it clear, I don't think that partners SHOULD tell each other everything (although we did till the day he died) I do think its unfair to ask them not to.
WannabeMathematician · 28/09/2021 14:53

@Frogsandsheep. But the thing is I don’t you would have told me about your circumstances as basically I’m saying I can’t cope with secrets and then you would have found someone else to talk to. I’m just saying to stop a repeat of the isolation and being made to feel like I was the sole person responsible for someone else that I go into all friendships with the fact that I can’t hold that level or secret myself. Isn’t that good? Then you can make an informed choice to tell me or not knowing what I’ll do afterwards?

Frogsandsheep · 28/09/2021 14:53

@scarpa

Of course it’s fair enough to say that but it’s also a shame that people will then feel they can’t open up to people they are close to.

I assume work related things don’t count? I can’t imagine someone in a caring profession getting away with saying ‘I’ll have to tell my husband’

girlmom21 · 28/09/2021 14:52

I wouldn't go and immediately tell DP if I'd been asked to keep something to myself but I wouldn't lie to him if he'd worked something out and asked me about it.

Frogsandsheep · 28/09/2021 14:51

@WannabeMathematician

Also I’d say that if someone was in danger then confidences arguably should be broken. I keep confidences all the time at work but if there is a risk of danger then I tell someone.
is an extreme situation and I am genuinely sorry you went through that.
Most scenarios of friends sharing secrets are not this extreme.

saraclara · 28/09/2021 14:50

@seaandsandcastles

No, I don’t think that’s fair. Anything I get told people should assume my husband will know about too.
So do you tell your DH everything your friends tell you? What they had for dinner? That they've got a bit of a headache? That they're trying to decide whether to paint their walls magnolia or Jasmine white?

Or is it just the juicy stuff?