Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my DSis to keep something confidential from her DH

267 replies

Whatamoraldilema · 28/09/2021 13:23

Last week I told my Dsis something in confidence about my young DS. In hindsight I'm not sure if that is a fair thing to ask. Do you think it's reasonable to ask your sibling to keep something confidential from their partner?

OP posts:
ShaneTheThird · 29/09/2021 12:13

I don't think it's fair to tell someone to keep something from their spouse. If I tell my dsis anything I tell her assuming bil is going to know and vice versa she will tell me something in the knowledge dp will know it too.

saraclara · 29/09/2021 12:09

@seaandsandcastles

This happened to me and I told 3 of my best friends who all kept my confidence and to this day hardly anyone knows what happened. I’d have been distraught if they had told anyone at the time and would be feel upset/awkward if they told them years later.

You’d never know, really. My DH wouldn’t tell anyone what I’d told him.

You think he wouldn't tell anyone. Your friend thinks YOU wouldn't tell anyone. She was wrong. So might you be.
Frogsandsheep · 29/09/2021 11:56

@SuperstarDog

That doesn’t make it right.
If you were my friend and knew you were going to tell my most personal secrets to your dh, I’d rather you told me in advance that you were not fully trustworthy and I could choose whether to tell you stuff or not.

Frogsandsheep · 29/09/2021 11:54

@seaandsandcastles
@nokidshere

Of course I’d never know if they’d actually told their dh but I’d be very sad to think they’d betrayed a confidence.
Having a dh that wouldn’t let it show that he knew isn’t anything to be proud of.

I have some trust issues and I’m pretty sure my closest friends would respect that.

I actually sneakily telling your dh is disgusting. At least if you’re going to betray your friend’s confidence be honest about it like some of the previous posters and tell your friends that you won’t keep a confidence.

VeganCheesePlease · 29/09/2021 11:47

@SleepingStandingUp

Agree with Alexa.

If a friend told me to keep it private but her and DH are having problems in the bedroom / contemplating divorce / want a baby etc it's easy to keep the confidence because there's no emotional toll.

If a friend told me to keep it private but she was dying of cancer, I wouldn't want to go to her with my emotions but I'd need someone

Totally agree with this.
SuperstarDog · 29/09/2021 11:39

You’d never know, really. My DH wouldn’t tell anyone what I’d told him.

Exactly.

seaandsandcastles · 29/09/2021 11:26

This happened to me and I told 3 of my best friends who all kept my confidence and to this day hardly anyone knows what happened. I’d have been distraught if they had told anyone at the time and would be feel upset/awkward if they told them years later.

You’d never know, really. My DH wouldn’t tell anyone what I’d told him.

AryaStarkWolf · 29/09/2021 11:17

@SleepingStandingUp

For those who share everything where so you draw the line?

OK some secrets might need support - if I tell my best friend I have cancer or was raped I get she might need to share. Some might be juicy or exciting - if I'm shagging the milkman or pregnant.

But if we're talking "we tell each other everything" then presumably you'd also tell him about my UTI / Thrush, how snotty my kids noses are, my struggle to find a hairdresser etc. Does he actually give a damn? Does he really want to sit there whilst you share the boring crap of my life that I've shared with you out of friendly natter?

Exactly. If your friend told you she had an STD for example, it would be embarrassing for her to think your husband now knows too and in all likelihood he probably doesn't care/want to know anyway.
nokidshere · 29/09/2021 11:08

This happened to me and I told 3 of my best friends who all kept my confidence and to this day hardly anyone knows what happened. I’d have been distraught if they had told anyone at the time and would be feel upset/awkward if they told them years later.

In reality, unless their husbands/partners said anything, you wouldn't know if they had been told or not.

Plumtree391 · 29/09/2021 01:11

I would have thought the same, saraclara. However it is amazing how much 'pillow talk' goes on.

My work involved confidentiality and I never divulged someone's secrets at work or at home. There are times when you need to discuss but there are confidential avenues available.

Quite honestly, most husbands wouldn't want to know personal things about others anyway.

saraclara · 28/09/2021 23:42

When I shared confidences, it never occurred to me to say "can you keep this to yourself, and that includes not telling your husband". I was naive enough to think that the first half of that sentence was all that was needed.

CorianderAndCream · 28/09/2021 23:30

Yes but you have to specify that he's not to be told

Lightswitch123 · 28/09/2021 23:17

@AnneLovesGilbert

Is it something upsetting that she’d likely want his support in dealing with?

Why don’t you want him to know?

I’m very close to my sister. If she explicitly asked me not to tell DH something I’d respect it, as I’m sure would she vice versa, but it’s never happened yet. We trust each other’s husbands as we do each other and if something was up with either of our children we’d share it.

This
steppemum · 28/09/2021 23:15

I do think it is interesting. Dh and I pretty much share everything.
I would usually discuss it wiht him.
A few times I have needed to discuss it, when someone has poured their heart out, it is like a counsellor needing a supervisor to decompress after a difficult conversation.

But I am really careful. If someone asked me to keep it confidential, or it was obvious that I couldn't share it, that they would not want me to, then I wouldn't.

I guess that other side of it is that my dh is the master of discretion and know one would know that he had been told!

Branleuse · 28/09/2021 23:14

Absolutely fine to ask her to keep it confidential. Hopefully it goes without saying.

Merryoldgoat · 28/09/2021 23:07

I am definitely scarred emotionally!

Somuddled · 28/09/2021 22:57

[quote Merryoldgoat]@Somuddled

I’m not an ‘I tell DH everything’ person but I did say the phrase ‘I just did a poo so massive it scared me’ earlier this evening.[/quote]
I miss-read that as scarred!

Merryoldgoat · 28/09/2021 22:52

@Somuddled

I’m not an ‘I tell DH everything’ person but I did say the phrase ‘I just did a poo so massive it scared me’ earlier this evening.

Somuddled · 28/09/2021 22:47

I bet all these 'I tell my husband everything' people only actually mean the gossip (aka things told to them in confidence) I bet they aren't detailing their latest poo consistency to their beloved. Hmm

RobertaFirmino · 28/09/2021 22:38

YANBU. If someone tells me something in complete confidence then I will keep quiet. They have put their trust in me and I would respect that. I certainly do not need to tell DH everything.

SleepingStandingUp · 28/09/2021 22:19

If there is something in my life I am inclined to keep from DH, I think long and hard about why that should be. It's often been something I am ashamed of, or at least not proud of but that's when the secret is about YOU. If I tell you I had an abortion at 14 or was sexually assaulted at 17 or I feel like a failure as a mother, the reason you are inclined to keep it from your husband is because its got stuff all to do with him and your life together.

notacooldad · 28/09/2021 21:44

If there is something in my life I am inclined to keep from DH, I think long and hard about why that should be. It's often been something I am ashamed of, or at least not proud of

My sister td me a massive secret that she held on to for 55 years. It came out when she was drunk and emotional and me and her were going down memory lane.
She told me that mum and dad forced into having an abortion when she was 16. It caused her a lot if sadness and she was shocked at how cold our parents were towards it.
She hadn't meant to tell me it came out with drink and upset thoughts. There is no need for Dh to know that. It's my sisters business and I wasnt even supposed to know about it.
Dh always asked me if Ive had a good chat with my friends/ sister/brother and doesn't pry any further.

Downton57 · 28/09/2021 20:41

But if it's not your story to share, and you share it, that's not honesty. That's gossiping, tattling, telling tales. It's not one bit nice.

FinallyHere · 28/09/2021 20:09

DH and I are not a single entity, but he is my sounding board. I process my innermost thoughts by talking to / telling him stuff.

If someone said they had a secret they wanted me to keep from DH, I would ask them not to tell me. To be fair to DH, he has never shown the least interest but he knows I value being able to talk about anything.

If there is something in my life I am inclined to keep from DH, I think long and hard about why that should be. It's often been something I am ashamed of, or at least not proud of.

I used to lie at the drop of a hat. I have learned to value honesty in my marriage.

PatchworkElmer · 28/09/2021 19:51

As others have said, it depends on what it is. One friend dumped a huge, huge secret on me and then told me not to tell DH. It was a significant issue and I really struggled with the knowledge and nobody to talk to… she’d obviously dumped it on me as her ‘person to talk to’. I wouldn’t make that mistake again and would tell the person that I would need to tell DH, but that it wouldn’t go any further.

Swipe left for the next trending thread