Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't trolls allowed?

116 replies

Moneysavvymam · 28/09/2021 12:09

I bloody hate reading a thread and then half way through, when its just getting juicy, it turns out its been deleted for being a troll. Honestly the trolls are better than real life and I'm here for the drama anyway. Aibu? Lighthearted!

OP posts:
knittingaddict · 28/09/2021 13:22

@LaBellina

Because you have to draw the line somewhere. The undisturbed presence of trolls can lead them to take it further and deliberately post stuff to wind up and provoke, basically turning this place into a complete bun fight. So I understand why MNHQ has a blanket no trolls rule in place.
Agree with this. I quite like playing spot the troll game and the anticipation of waiting for the delete message.

I think it's necessary because some people do believe everything they read, post really personal replies and get very upset when it's a troll. At least the deletions might make them a bit more wary next time.

Namechangehereandnow · 28/09/2021 13:20

The thread I commented on was nothing like that, nothing vile. Just normal mundane life .. mnhq deleted my post saying it was troll hunting, when all I had done was point out op said this, then said that, now says the other, so not sure what the true scenario is. If it is actually true, then this is an awful situation, can you do this OP, would this help OP etc. I never said OP was lying, and I still offered help and advice. I was really offended at mnhq calling me a troll hunter when I absolutely wasn’t - but interestingly, others said the same things as I did, some blatantly called the op a liar, yet their comments weren’t all deleted. 🤷🏼‍♀️

So I now understand what an actual troll is (I think) and that’s really horrible and vile. But troll hunting I’m still on the fence. Sometimes I see situations where they may be justified, but often I just see personal opinions being branded as troll hunting.

Lockheart · 28/09/2021 13:14

No, you can't just let trolls run rampant on a site.

MN is full enough of:

  • obvious beggars (who have great success, judging by certain past threads - one poster once admitted to sending a scammer £100. Said scammer was posting about a very sensitive topic).
  • perverts. Hey ladies, tell me about the times you've embarrassed yourself by having to piss in public (and hundreds of idiots fall for it to share their stories).
  • journos fishing for article fodder. Tell me about your worst interviews!
  • racists
  • complete fantasists
  • and so on and so forth.

If you want juicy drama, watch a soap. Otherwise, accept that threads will disappear and stop being so gullible.

Geamhradh · 28/09/2021 13:09

@Namechangehereandnow

Yes sorry, I probably do mean troll hunting. So can someone please explain what troll hunting actually is? To me it means someone actively going through threads looking for posters they recognise to have ‘form’ for deliberately misleading threads, or rooting through previous threads to find inconsistencies with the sole intention of bullying the OP.

Literally, all I did on a thread, after reading the thread so far, noticed OP had changed their story a few times within the thread, and things just didn’t ring true. So my response was to point out the changes which made the scenario in the thread a bit questionable, but then said, if the post is true then gave my advice based on if the thread was actually true despite it sounding odd. My response was helpful to the actual OP, despite not knowing if it was a true post or not, and despite it seeming to not ring true.

I don’t think what I did was in any way troll hunting. I genuinely get very confused when troll hunting is mentioned.

That is technically what it is. On here however it is thrown around when the Aunties who are busy on PayPal sending money to scammers or praying for pretend dead babies etc get arsey because someone says "come on, this is a troll" Interesting they never hold their hands up afterwards and say "yep, I was taken in my that one" They just say "troll-hunters are worse" I mean, just READ that. There are actually people, presumably intelligent adults who think SOMEONE POINTING OUT THE RAPE OR THE DEAD HUSBAND AREN'T REAL is worse than the person lying about being raped. Or about a loved one dying. That, IMO, makes them sicker if anything than the original troll
Namechangehereandnow · 28/09/2021 13:03

Yes sorry, I probably do mean troll hunting. So can someone please explain what troll hunting actually is? To me it means someone actively going through threads looking for posters they recognise to have ‘form’ for deliberately misleading threads, or rooting through previous threads to find inconsistencies with the sole intention of bullying the OP.

Literally, all I did on a thread, after reading the thread so far, noticed OP had changed their story a few times within the thread, and things just didn’t ring true. So my response was to point out the changes which made the scenario in the thread a bit questionable, but then said, if the post is true then gave my advice based on if the thread was actually true despite it sounding odd. My response was helpful to the actual OP, despite not knowing if it was a true post or not, and despite it seeming to not ring true.

I don’t think what I did was in any way troll hunting. I genuinely get very confused when troll hunting is mentioned.

PearLime · 28/09/2021 13:00

I think the thread you were talking about was really interesting - about whether pressuring someone for sex in a relationship is acceptable.

Very Interesting discussion around consent / coercion / abuse.

I think that the thread should have been allowed to run because despite being started by a troll it was super interesting!

Flunked · 28/09/2021 12:57

Sometimes people troll about sensitive subjects (child death, domestic violence, rape etc.) and that is so bloody harmful. It is sickening and leads to people not believing genuine posts.

There are also the pervert trolls that want women to share stories of certain things so they can use it as wank fodder. Repulsive.

Geamhradh · 28/09/2021 12:57

@Moneysavvymam

I bloody hate reading a thread and then half way through, when its just getting juicy, it turns out its been deleted for being a troll. Honestly the trolls are better than real life and I'm here for the drama anyway. Aibu? Lighthearted!
The fake dead babies and husbands are very dramatic. Shall we leave them too? The scammers? The fake domestic violence and rape ones? They're good for drama. (Sadly might stop women reporting their own rapes, but as long as you get your kicks eh?)

And no, you don't get away with shit by writing "light-hearted"

Ihopeyourcakeisshit · 28/09/2021 12:56

I'm always amazed at some threads which are left to stand and others zapped. Some of the 'zilla ' threads which are left to run to 2 or 3 threads are ludicrous.

bargelights · 28/09/2021 12:55

Trolls are harmful. A recent series of threads about an abusive husband was obviously a very badly written creative writing exercise. The OP garnered a huge amount of attention and sympathy. But fake threads like that make a mockery of serious situations when women are desperately trying to escape an abusive partner.

Even seemingly harmless threads (e.g., the tiresome attempts to invent “CF” behaviour) can be damaging. When half of all threads are exaggerations or pure fiction, genuine posters may be disbelieved. And don’t get me started on the people who say they don’t care if a thread is fake, they still want to know what happened. Hmm

Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 28/09/2021 12:54

I wonder for the long threads that mnhq can change the title to add "fiction" type warning and then if they still get reports and people believing it all lock commenting but still let it stand for the enjoyment.
Or move it to the pp suggestion of creative writing board.
I can see the deleted message now

We have doubts about the ops posting history so we are just going to move this over to the creative writing/troll board

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 28/09/2021 12:54

I also have no idea what "pirated history" is.

ilovesooty · 28/09/2021 12:53

@Namechangehereandnow

Does my head in too.

I had a comment deleted, was labelled a troll - literally I said ‘the OP’s story has changed a few times, if this is true’ .. then my opinion .. how that made me a troll I will never understand. Mnhq would not respond to me and explain how this made me a troll, or why they were justified in deleting my very valid comment.

You were presumably deleted for troll hunting, not for being a troll.
AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 28/09/2021 12:53

@LouiseBelchersBunnyEars

I once had a post deleted for "troll hunting" (I had no idea that was a thing) because I expressed doubt about the poster's intentions

Trull hunting is Really fucking annoying though.
If you don’t believe it, don’t answer.

No one wants to read Miss marple sleuthing through the posts and smugly pointing out inaccuracies, ESPECIALLY going through pirated history etc.

People might just change bits and bobs to try and not be outing and not remember.

I didn't go Miss Marpling through threads - I expressed doubt about what the person was saying. And, yes, I will continue to do that.
WeAreTheWeirdosMister · 28/09/2021 12:52

But, aren't we ALL trolls? I mean my real name isn't WeAre and anything we say on here that identifies us is flagged, so changing a few details here and there to make a story clearer or even posting reverses to see if you are being unreasonable seem fine to me.

The threads that are deleted after miles of great advice are real losses, even if the OP is a 'troll'.

Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 28/09/2021 12:51

@Namechangehereandnow

Does my head in too.

I had a comment deleted, was labelled a troll - literally I said ‘the OP’s story has changed a few times, if this is true’ .. then my opinion .. how that made me a troll I will never understand. Mnhq would not respond to me and explain how this made me a troll, or why they were justified in deleting my very valid comment.

That's not branding you as a troll that's saying you were troll hunting which is against the site rules. You shouldn't post that on the thread but report it to mnhq
LaBellina · 28/09/2021 12:49

I always wonder that too @Moneysavvymam. For example some threads are fairly obvious like a first time poster opening a thread about stuff like poo.

But does anyone remember the ‘My neighbours puddles saga’?
Apparently that was deleted after several full threads because the OP was a troll. The story sounded very legit to me and I also wonder why it could continue for so long and how they eventually found out that the OP was a troll. Fascinating.

EmmalineC · 28/09/2021 12:49

Some trolls are entertaining but the grief vampires and bereavement trolls make it difficult for posters needing genuine support in heartbreaking situations.

LouiseBelchersBunnyEars · 28/09/2021 12:48

*going through poster history.

Troll hunting is worse than trolling for me

LouiseBelchersBunnyEars · 28/09/2021 12:47

I once had a post deleted for "troll hunting" (I had no idea that was a thing) because I expressed doubt about the poster's intentions

Trull hunting is Really fucking annoying though.
If you don’t believe it, don’t answer.

No one wants to read Miss marple sleuthing through the posts and smugly pointing out inaccuracies, ESPECIALLY going through pirated history etc.

People might just change bits and bobs to try and not be outing and not remember.

LizBennet · 28/09/2021 12:46

I suppose we could have a creative thread writing board, where everyone is in on it. We could even have a scoring system like the AIBU voting options, where you get to mark people on number of buttons pushed etc.

That would be better 😂

DressedUpAtAnIvy · 28/09/2021 12:43

What if people put ‘hairy handed’ rather than ‘light-hearted’ in their OP, perhaps those could be allowed to stand? (On certain subjects only.)

Doglicks · 28/09/2021 12:43

I got deleted once for referring to the Travelling Community, in a respectful way, but apparently you can't mention them AT ALL on MN!

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 28/09/2021 12:40

@burritofan

I don’t mind trolls being deleted but “the OP has real-life privacy concerns so we’re taking this down” when really it’s “the OP has had their arse handed to them and has run away crying” gets my goat.
I agree.

I once had a post deleted for "troll hunting" (I had no idea that was a thing) because I expressed doubt about the poster's intentions.

21782b7 · 28/09/2021 12:38

I think if its a fun thread it should be left up.

But if it is an awful troll thread on a sensitive subject then o think it should be removed