Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't trolls allowed?

116 replies

Moneysavvymam · 28/09/2021 12:09

I bloody hate reading a thread and then half way through, when its just getting juicy, it turns out its been deleted for being a troll. Honestly the trolls are better than real life and I'm here for the drama anyway. Aibu? Lighthearted!

OP posts:
Lockheart · 28/09/2021 15:38

@Billandben444

I'm really gullible and naive and never think oh, it's a troll. How did you find out that the one about the twins was a troll? Are we meant to be suspicious of anything heartbreaking when it could be true! There are some on here atm that are quite painful to read - what are the giveaways?
New posters with no history, inconsistent facts in posts, constant updates at odd times (for example, if you're packing your car and fleeing your abusive husband at that very moment then you don't have time to update and post photos to MN every 5 minutes), continual rebuttal of helpful suggestions and why that couldn't possibly work (hint hint - the only thing that could help is someone sending them cash), persistent refusal to ask anyone in real life for help or take any steps to actually deal with whatever the problem is, ramping up of drama to the point of ludicrousness in subsequent updates (people will still lap it up and turn on anyone who points out that maybe it's getting a bit silly).

They usually post about very sensitive topics e.g. ill children, dying H, no money for food / Christmas / heating, abusive relationships, or topics that will whip up the froth and keep threads running and running (parking, cheeky friends etc). Sometimes a combination.

Whilst I'm not saying there aren't people in truly dire situations out there - we all know there are - they crop up on MN with alarming regularity.

EmmalineC · 28/09/2021 15:37

Anyone who sends money or gifts to a random poster on the internet, who is claiming to be down to their last 14p with no electricity, no family, no friends, chuck in a hungry child or two, needs to have a word with themselves.

If a friend of mine was struggling, I wouldn't hesitate to help out financially or materially. But I am very suspicious of new posters who turn to Mumsnet for help in these circumstances.

PegasusReturns · 28/09/2021 15:34

I’m fine with trolling about parking and ridiculous MILs etc

I’m not fine with emotional vampires who make up dead babies, horrific abuse or other tragedy in an effort to get people to disclose.

I’m ambivalent about begging threads - if you’re old enough to use the Internet you should always proceed with caution.

Basically if I found out Mexican House Thief/luxury
Teens in a chalet/small korean lady or any other number of entertaining threads that have seen me through my own ups and downs were fake I couldn’t care less.

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 28/09/2021 15:31

Are we meant to be suspicious of anything heartbreaking when it could be true! There are some on here atm that are quite painful to read - what are the giveaways?

I don't think it's suspicious as much as thinking critically: Is it a little too painful and dramatic and heartbreaking? Are there all sorts of reasons why the poster can't take any action? Does the poster have no posting history? Is the poster hostile when challenged?

All of those ping possible troll to me.

EmmalineC · 28/09/2021 15:27

The twins troll posted photos of someone else's premature babies in SCBU, she'd taken them off Google images and were tracked back to a South African woman's blog about her own journey with her babies.

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 28/09/2021 15:25

Kudos to MNHQ for taking down a damsel in distress thread a few minutes ago.

First time poster writes how her fiance has just left her with no warning, she's pregnant, they were engaged, a relative of his told her never to contact her again, to get out of their shared house, she lives in a rural area, has no money to rent a new place, there have been men tapping at her window and leering at her, etc etc (ok, I might have made that last point up) etc etc.

Seriously? In that situation you don't ask a friend or relative for advice but you create an account on MN? And of course there were the people who fell for it...

Billandben444 · 28/09/2021 15:16

I'm really gullible and naive and never think oh, it's a troll. How did you find out that the one about the twins was a troll? Are we meant to be suspicious of anything heartbreaking when it could be true! There are some on here atm that are quite painful to read - what are the giveaways?

ambereeree · 28/09/2021 14:48

I love a troll thread. Some of the replies and arguments between posters...brilliant.

Geamhradh · 28/09/2021 14:31

@MaenadsJustWannaHaveFun

Of course troll posts have to be deleted. I don't want to give some horrible little Herbert his kicks, or see other people painfully relive their own tragedies when sickos post fake bereavement or abuse threads - do you?
They clearly do. And yet it's the people spitting them, and trying to warn others off who are the bad guys. You couldn't make it up. Except, of course, they do.
Geamhradh · 28/09/2021 14:30

@ManifestingJoy

Troll hunters are another side of the same coin in my opinion.

Asking ''are you very young?'' when the op hasn't said anything to suggest that she is ''very'' young. I think it just makes the person asking the question feel superior. Like they have all this wisdom and would never find themselves wondering whether or not to dump an asshole boyfriend. That is a question that a woman any age can find herself asking.

What is thinking that a poster seems young got to do with trolls or troll-hunting?
EmmalineC · 28/09/2021 14:26

I remember the twins - both born prematurely, both with lots of medical issues. The poster had so much support, help and advice - whether any of it was carried over into real life, I don't know.

I also remember the student mum claiming to have postnatal depression, unable to bond with her newborn son, she also got lots of support, help and advice.

Both posters (maybe even the same one?) were fabricating their stories for attention.

MaenadsJustWannaHaveFun · 28/09/2021 14:15

Of course troll posts have to be deleted. I don't want to give some horrible little Herbert his kicks, or see other people painfully relive their own tragedies when sickos post fake bereavement or abuse threads - do you?

scarpa · 28/09/2021 14:13

@JesusInTheCabbageVan

I suppose we could have a creative thread writing board, where everyone is in on it. We could even have a scoring system like the AIBU voting options, where you get to mark people on number of buttons pushed etc.
I'd love this! I love a well-done troll post - nothing too emotive of course, but something that pushes people's buttons subtly and doesn't jump the shark too soon... it's an art haha.
ManifestingJoy · 28/09/2021 14:12

@JesusInTheCabbageVan I think that does happen

I sometimes see 2/10 or 3/10 as the only comment in a post

ManifestingJoy · 28/09/2021 14:10

Troll hunters are another side of the same coin in my opinion.

Asking ''are you very young?'' when the op hasn't said anything to suggest that she is ''very'' young. I think it just makes the person asking the question feel superior. Like they have all this wisdom and would never find themselves wondering whether or not to dump an asshole boyfriend. That is a question that a woman any age can find herself asking.

KissedintheDark · 28/09/2021 14:09

@JesusInTheCabbageVan

I suppose we could have a creative thread writing board, where everyone is in on it. We could even have a scoring system like the AIBU voting options, where you get to mark people on number of buttons pushed etc.
Absolutely this. ^

I don't get the hysteria over trolls either - they can be bloody entertaining and they put the effort in, so give them a platform to do their thing on.

ManifestingJoy · 28/09/2021 14:07

Any time I post anything I"m told I'm trolling. It's bizarre. Some sanctimonious article declares that nobody would ask this/do this/be in this situation Confused

Obviously the people who lie about having had a baby that died, wow, those people need help. What sort of vacuum do you have to be to only exist when you're getting a reaction. There are a lot of people like that though, to a lesser degree. To invent a story that your baby died though to gain something from the reactions Shock Confused that is really pitiful. The truthful people who share on those threads should not feel bad. What they shared was TRUE. They are the ones that make the thread have any value.

OneTC · 28/09/2021 14:03

They are allowed

About 50% of humorous classics are obvious trolling

SecretWitch · 28/09/2021 13:49

I’ve been taken in once or twice by trolls. I’ve learnt to avoid any thread asking about your teenager’s periods or anything poo related.

The emotional vampires are the worst. Many years ago a troll posted about the death of her twins which turned out to be completely untrue. How unhinged do you have to be to lie about the death of your babies?

Burgerqueenbee · 28/09/2021 13:41

@PearLime

I think the thread you were talking about was really interesting - about whether pressuring someone for sex in a relationship is acceptable.

Very Interesting discussion around consent / coercion / abuse.

I think that the thread should have been allowed to run because despite being started by a troll it was super interesting!

Was that the thread about the husband who turned into a sulking sex pest at 8:30pm? I thought it was legit and was quite upset at women having to go through crap like that Blush Other than obviously outlandish stories, how do you know when it's a troll?
YvanEhtNiojYvanEhtNioj · 28/09/2021 13:38

I reported a troll thread yesterday and it turns out it wasn’t a troll! (Well mn decided they weren’t). There’s just some right weirdos in the world.

I don’t think troll hunting is that bad. Sometimes people are giving serious advice or fighting with each other and you just want to point out they’re wasting their time getting worked up about something fake.

Occasionally I do want to see where the hell a troll is going with something eg the window cleaner shit in my garden (why? Just why would you think to come up with that?!)

Geamhradh · 28/09/2021 13:36

@beastlyslumber

The threads that are deleted after miles of great advice are real losses, even if the OP is a 'troll'.

Agreed.

Also threads that get taken down because people are debating and disagreeing on politics or issues. Why can't people get into it on here? It always seems to be when a woke particular point of view is getting destroyed in debate.

That all sounds a bit "not racist but" Which "woke" issues do you have a problem with? Racism being called out? Sexism? Disablism? Feminism?
MargaretThursday · 28/09/2021 13:36

@burritofan

I don’t mind trolls being deleted but “the OP has real-life privacy concerns so we’re taking this down” when really it’s “the OP has had their arse handed to them and has run away crying” gets my goat.
Agree.

I think trolls and begging threads are normally fairly obvious so it surprises me when people try posting serious advice.
If you think it's a troll don't feed it. Let it grow bored and find somewhere else.
If it's a begging thread please don't say "I've got some X you can have... I've Pm-ed you" or whatever. It may feel nice and heart-warming, but really it's encourages others to beg, and also, more importantly, stops people who might like to ask for advice genuinely from posting because it comes over as begging.

AquaPandora · 28/09/2021 13:26

more "funny" is when people are questioning the troll opening poster on details (because their posts just dont add up) and are blocked bc of "troll hunting".

Troll opening posts are very inconsistent and when people ask obvious questions they are deemed as trolls instead of the opening poster. (I am sure Daily Mail correspondents do troll posts very often)

but as you said, its quite entertaining :)

and long entertaining threads are deleted bc of "to many agressive posts" or something.

The last good topic I read which was deleted was about a mum who invited her family to a pub celebration and was not happy with future DIL having 3 coctails :) It got like 900+ very balanced responses, it was very educational and yet, deleted.

One other post (about a guest who was invited to visit and then when wanted to bring a friend was charged for the stay) was "picked up" by some local newspaper.

It is interesting that troll opening posters are okey, but people asking any legit questions related to the opening post are deemed as troll hunters and are blocked.

If the troll opening poster wanted to do a research, for their column , wouldnt it be good to get some legit questions and reactions, to see the different sides and opinions? Or they do their "research" to get a specific result (so they can refer to the MN reactions and quote only what is supporting their initial quest?)

I wonder....

beastlyslumber · 28/09/2021 13:25

The threads that are deleted after miles of great advice are real losses, even if the OP is a 'troll'.

Agreed.

Also threads that get taken down because people are debating and disagreeing on politics or issues. Why can't people get into it on here? It always seems to be when a woke particular point of view is getting destroyed in debate.