Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do seriously indecisive people realise how annoying they are?

85 replies

Loveinthetimeofcoronavirus · 28/09/2021 11:39

I might just be unlucky but I feel like I am dealing with a plague of indecisiveness and it’s infuriating.

I’m not talking about genuinely difficult choices, but rather picking between two options which are both basically acceptable, and turning it into a festival of angst.

I have three people in my life who do this constantly, and involve me in these endless decision trees. Say they have to pick between two restaurants. Both are similarly priced, similarly fancy, they like both, they know they would enjoy themselves regardless of which option they pick. But they still require me to participate in a multi-text conversation about which one to go for. Usually I say ‘both are lovely, no wrong choice’. But that’s not good enough. So I am decisive to help them out - I say ‘ok, go for option B, it looks lovely.’ Then I get back ‘but I prefer the starters at option A’. So I say ‘great! Option A it is!’ Only for them to say ‘but then, option B has more vegetarian options’. And it just goes on and on and on. If I say there’s no bad choice they complain that they can’t decide. If I pick for them, they question my pick.

How do they not realise how exhausting and pointless this is? It’s such a low-stakes decision! Even if they got it wrong, the consequences would be so minor!

A relative of mine once spent THREE WEEKS making up her mind about a decision just as inconsequential as the one outlined above. She must have sent me 20 options and questioned me extensively about each one. I wanted to scream by the end of it.

Is there any way of stopping this from happening short of causing a fallout by saying ‘stop involving me in the tedious minutiae of your life, I couldn’t care less what minor decisions you make and I certainly don’t want to hear about them!’

OP posts:
HarebrightCedarmoon · 28/09/2021 13:46

Anyway Do seriously indecisive people realise how annoying they are?

I dunno, what do you think?

Sorry, couldn't resist

HarebrightCedarmoon · 28/09/2021 13:45

I think it's ok to ask the server @saltinesandcoffeecups, especially to choose between two. They may well have tried it and many waiters are not afraid to offer their opinion.

Sparkletastic · 28/09/2021 13:36

DH can be like this. Comes from having controlling anxious parents who were quick to apportion blame. I alternate between making the decision or forcing him to do it after assuring him that there is no wrong answer. Depends on how patient or invested in the outcome I'm feeling.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 28/09/2021 13:35

Agree.. it is exhausting. I will admit that sometimes in restaurants I get like this deciding what to order. I’ve resorted to this on more than one occasion…

Server: What would you like?
Me: I can’t decide between A or B please choose one and don’t tell me what you chose.
Server: Are you serious?
Me: There really isn’t a wrong choice and I’d be more than happy with either. I’m not kidding, whatever you choose I’ll be happy with.

DH: She’s not lying, she does this occasionally and she really will be happy with either.

I have never been disappointed with the results, I also tip extra when I do this (US). It’s weird, if I knew what the decision was before the meal was at the table I’d want the other one, but if it’s just plonked down in front of me I’m happy. It must be down to my contrary disposition 🙂

HunkyPunk · 28/09/2021 13:34

@Justmuddlingalong

"Let me know how it went." You're disengaging and don't want to hear about it again until after the event.
Yes, even when it’s something you’re supposed to be going to Grin
trevthecat · 28/09/2021 13:34

I'm incredibly indecisive. It is the bane of my life. I don't like having to make decisions. I am getting better and try to make a snap choice so I don't have time to think but sometimes that is not an option. Fortunately my husband is very decisive and so levels me out. He picks if there is a choice of restaurant or something that doesn't need too much thought.
Please understand that not everyone who is this anxious about decision making is doing it to annoy!

1forAll74 · 28/09/2021 13:29

I am a ditherer, but put it down to my old age, and it annoys me, because being an oldie, there is not much point in dithering about things now. I do live alone, so don't bother other people.

I am in the middle of trying to choose a new rug for my living room, looking online for ideas etc. For several weeks now I have been trawling through rug sites, and still cant make up my mind about colours and styles etc.. I know what will happen, I will end up with a similar one to my old one, except it will be new and fresh and a bit larger.

Anordinarymum · 28/09/2021 13:24

I'm in two minds about this Grin

DogFoodPie · 28/09/2021 13:24

One of the characters in the show The Good Place is sent to their version of hell in the afterlife for being incredibly indecisive.

KeepTwirling · 28/09/2021 13:22

@scarpa I hear you. My brain is the same.

Thanks very much, I'll check the app.

UniBallEye · 28/09/2021 13:20

I have a friend who can be a bit like this. She tries to pawn off all decisions onto someone else but then once the plan is made, with her agreement, she'll need to change it last minute.

So she'll message and say 'shall we meet for dinner on the 10th?' I'll say 'sure, that sounds great'.
Immediately she'll get back with 'ok, where will we go?'. I fell for it fir ages and always made suggestions and invariable ended up booking it etc. Until I realised what was happening!
Because if I was the one making the suggestion to meet I'd text to ask if she was free, and once she was I would follow up with something like 'we could go to X or Y unless you have anywhere else in mind? She never did have anywhere in mind....

So i stepped back a lot - now if she suggests dinner / lunch I say sure that that's great, works for me. Then the message comes...where will we go...so I've started replying 'I don't mind, I'm easy - where ever you like'.
There will be silence for a day or so, then she'll ask 'any ideas where we should go? I'm open to all suggestions..' So I reply again, no, totally happy to go where ever you fancy....
and round and round it goes...

Even if I do end up suggesting and booking somewhere, we'll agree 8pm works, I get the booking and INVAIRIABLY on the day she'll message she can't be there till 8,30 as she now has to drop x to Y or some such avoidable nonsense.

I really like her but all the FAFFING really puts me off planning stuff, because even after all the to-ing and fro-ing it either gets cancelled or modified by her...aaargh....

2bazookas · 28/09/2021 13:14

For some people, "being indecisive " and " endlessly asking what YOU want/think, YOU decide" is just a form of attention seeking/manipulation.

That's why they turn down every suggestion you offer. Whatever you say is the wrong answer.

Disengage.
Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/09/2021 13:10

Stop indulging them by conversing with them about it

This ^^

As often as not what they're really after is someone to feed the silliness, so just don't engage. "I'll leave it up to you" covers things quite nicely IME

crispinglovershighkick · 28/09/2021 13:09

It depends on the reason for the indecisiveness. Is the person just handwringing or are they trying to get you to take responsibility so they can make you wrong no matter what your decision?

DH and I sometimes use the 5-3-1 method where person A chooses five options, person B narrows it to three and person A makes the final choice. I've tried this on my mum (v v indecisive!) and she won't stick to the format so it's not foolproof but if you both genuinely want to find a resolution it can help.

My mum gets hung up on the weighing of options and doesn't really want to get past it without testing and remaking her decision a hundred times, and in that sort of scenario there may be no choice but to disengage, ie 'Ok, let me know what you decide.'

Someone once told me that if you're dithering for ages over a decision that means it doesn't matter which choice you make so just pick one, but if it's someone else driving it this may not be useful info.

MakingM · 28/09/2021 13:08

You have my sympathies. I have a relative who does this too...

"Now, come with me and see what I bought at the shop...oooh, beans...do you think I should keep them in this cupboard...or perhaps they'd be better in the this one...this one is closer to the cooker...and the pans... oh but all the other tins are in that one over there and all the tins should be together..."

For my relative, it's some kind of Virginia Woolf type stream of consciousness conversational habit. It has nothing to do with making the actual decision at all as far as I can tell. They are trying to be close to me and do small talk. It's horrible. Grin

I try to get in there first now and speak to them about books which is bearable though tin-talk still occasionally breaks out, which is my cue to leave.

Sittingonabench · 28/09/2021 13:07

Tell them to flip a coin, roll a dice or similar to decide. Far too exhausting if continuous. I do know someone a bit like this but they make hard decisions say to say so when it’s something really small they take their time - they don’t pull others in though.

scarpa · 28/09/2021 13:06

@bert3400

My DH is a bit like this, where restaurants are concerned, especially on holiday . Thank god for Trip Advisor ....cause now I say find somewhere , book it and stick to it . Weirdly big stuff like buying a house or car ....no dithering at all
This is a good point! A food choice will ruin the best part of an hour for me but I've signed 2-year rental leases based off a 2-minute glance round a house in an area I don't even know.

Not only am I annoyingly indecisive, I'm also apparently reckless when the indecisiveness might be useful Wink

scarpa · 28/09/2021 13:04

@KeepTwirling

DH and I have a stupid app where you put choices in (restaurant, weekend plans, what to watch on Netflix) and it spins a little wheel and picks one. Bloody lifesaver.

What app is this @scarpa? I REALLY need it for Netflix. I end up rarely watching anything because there are too many options and I can't keep checking all the info to see if I'd like them or not. I'd like to just choose one and watch - if i don't like it, then I'd go with another.

Decision Roulette! It's a bit garish looking, but it stops me spending 2 hours looking at descriptions, ratings and IMDB pages before I inevitably watch one of three TV shows I've seen 12892898912 times haha.

Like you said, we pick something using that, I haven't 'had' to make the decision, but then if we're not fussed when it's on I've got a 'real' reason to turn it off (for some reason my brain is okay with that then).

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 28/09/2021 12:37

I'm like this. It comes from never being allowed to make a decision as a child. Consequently, my DC have chosen their clothes, what to have for dinner etc from a young age, much to the chagrin of relatives.

StoatMilk · 28/09/2021 12:37

I can’t decide if I’m annoying or not. Yes I am, or maybe I’m not 🤔

FOJN · 28/09/2021 12:37

Also I'm stealing "festival of angst".

FOJN · 28/09/2021 12:36

I would refuse to engage and I have very little patience so if I'd been asked for an opinion and given it then I would probably respond to further requests for input with, "I've already given you my opinion/advice, it hasn't changed since you first asked."

bert3400 · 28/09/2021 12:36

My DH is a bit like this, where restaurants are concerned, especially on holiday . Thank god for Trip Advisor ....cause now I say find somewhere , book it and stick to it . Weirdly big stuff like buying a house or car ....no dithering at all

Ilovedthe70s · 28/09/2021 12:34

I am like this, it annoys me to be that person so I get how irritating it is for everyone else.

I know in my case it’s based on remembered fear.
When my husband was alive I had to make every decision and every one was wrong and an excuse to beat the crap out of me.

KeepTwirling · 28/09/2021 12:34

DH and I have a stupid app where you put choices in (restaurant, weekend plans, what to watch on Netflix) and it spins a little wheel and picks one. Bloody lifesaver.

What app is this @scarpa? I REALLY need it for Netflix. I end up rarely watching anything because there are too many options and I can't keep checking all the info to see if I'd like them or not. I'd like to just choose one and watch - if i don't like it, then I'd go with another.