Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do seriously indecisive people realise how annoying they are?

85 replies

Loveinthetimeofcoronavirus · 28/09/2021 11:39

I might just be unlucky but I feel like I am dealing with a plague of indecisiveness and it’s infuriating.

I’m not talking about genuinely difficult choices, but rather picking between two options which are both basically acceptable, and turning it into a festival of angst.

I have three people in my life who do this constantly, and involve me in these endless decision trees. Say they have to pick between two restaurants. Both are similarly priced, similarly fancy, they like both, they know they would enjoy themselves regardless of which option they pick. But they still require me to participate in a multi-text conversation about which one to go for. Usually I say ‘both are lovely, no wrong choice’. But that’s not good enough. So I am decisive to help them out - I say ‘ok, go for option B, it looks lovely.’ Then I get back ‘but I prefer the starters at option A’. So I say ‘great! Option A it is!’ Only for them to say ‘but then, option B has more vegetarian options’. And it just goes on and on and on. If I say there’s no bad choice they complain that they can’t decide. If I pick for them, they question my pick.

How do they not realise how exhausting and pointless this is? It’s such a low-stakes decision! Even if they got it wrong, the consequences would be so minor!

A relative of mine once spent THREE WEEKS making up her mind about a decision just as inconsequential as the one outlined above. She must have sent me 20 options and questioned me extensively about each one. I wanted to scream by the end of it.

Is there any way of stopping this from happening short of causing a fallout by saying ‘stop involving me in the tedious minutiae of your life, I couldn’t care less what minor decisions you make and I certainly don’t want to hear about them!’

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KT727 · 28/09/2021 18:01

It's nearly always driven by anxiety. Being chronically indecisive is more painful for the person who is unable to decide than for those around them. I know from experience!

HateJudgmentalPeople · 28/09/2021 18:00

Mmmn I’m not sure about that, do they? Or don’t they? Grin just kidding.

Indecisive person here and can’t help it but I get why it pisses you off although I can’t change it!

sammylady37 · 28/09/2021 17:56

I am very indecisive, but usually happy if someone just picks for me. If I feel unhappy at that decision, them I'll know which one I preferred

This is making my head explode. In this case, you clearly have a preference. So just express that from the outset instead of getting someone else to decide and then expressing your preference.

CecilieRose · 28/09/2021 17:53

I am a bit like this but it's the result of growing up with a mother who called me selfish and spoiled for expressing any kind of a preference about anything. I'm well into my thirties now and still feel like I'm being selfish and overbearing by stating what I want. So if I'm at a gathering and someone asks me what takeaway I fancy I'll often be like "oh I don't mind, whatever you'd like" because in my mind that's being unselfish. I understand it's often taken as immature and annoying, though.

GoWalkabout · 28/09/2021 17:39

The thing that bothers me about my ditherers is that they constantly make such bad decisions - like agonise over which builder to choose, be unhappy with them and super demanding complainers wanting something for nothing and then wonder why the builders stop communicating! Or worried about going on holiday during covid but sunk costs fallacy rather than lose £200 deposit end up going on a complicated holiday in a pandemic risking losing money or getting stuck. They never make choices that make their lives easier!

Chloemol · 28/09/2021 17:06

Just dont engage

Them, Which restaurant A or B

You, either they are both good let me know when you have decided

Disengage from the conversation

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 28/09/2021 16:28

@DogFoodPie

One of the characters in the show The Good Place is sent to their version of hell in the afterlife for being incredibly indecisive.
I came on to ask if the op knew a Chidi! Grin
Suspicioussam · 28/09/2021 16:27

I'm like this. Believe me it's just as annoying being the ditherer. I can spend an hour choosing a selection of children's clothes online for example, and at the last minute I can't decide whether to buy them or not and I get so stressed deciding that I buy nothing.
I'm currently trying to decide about moving house and it is impossible.

PartyPotato · 28/09/2021 16:21

Argh my husbands family are like this. I love my in-laws like my own family but MY GOD they are infuriating ditherers. If we are away with them I end up having to just go right we’re doing this then and be the bossy one otherwise nothing would ever get organised.

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 28/09/2021 16:06

@1forAll74

I am a ditherer, but put it down to my old age, and it annoys me, because being an oldie, there is not much point in dithering about things now. I do live alone, so don't bother other people.

I am in the middle of trying to choose a new rug for my living room, looking online for ideas etc. For several weeks now I have been trawling through rug sites, and still cant make up my mind about colours and styles etc.. I know what will happen, I will end up with a similar one to my old one, except it will be new and fresh and a bit larger.

We are the same @1forAll74. I’ve just replaced the big (12ft x 10ft) rug in my living room, it took me 3 months to decide. It’s a big feature and expensive to change so I want to get it right. Like you said, after all the endless to-ing and fro-ing, I’ve ended up with something not a million miles from what it’s replacing Hmm
BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 28/09/2021 16:01

I’m a ditherer, often paralysed by indecision in my personal life (fine professionally). I apologise for my annoyingness, it isn’t intentional.

YouBelongHere · 28/09/2021 15:58

I feel you OP. Was also gonna mention the 5-3-1 game however I've always known it as the 5-2-1 game. I thought it would solve all my problems until I sent five places to eat to my dithery friend and she replied "Can I pick three instead? Because I'm not sure you'll like the two I've chosen." BUT I CHOSE THE FIVE?? I'M HAPPY TO EAT AT ANY OF THEM??

Loveinthetimeofcoronavirus · 28/09/2021 15:51

I totally appreciate that for people who are neurodiverse this may be an inescapable part of your neurodiversity, and I would definitely cut you some slack. Same for people conditioned into indecisiveness by abusive parents or partners - that’s obviously not your fault.

That’s not the case for the people I mentioned. I think they just like the process of it - maybe the attention?

The worst is when these decisions don’t affect me in any way. On one occasion the decision was which one of about 12 sofa beds should be purchased. A sofa bed for a house I don’t live in and will likely never sleep on. It took about 9 conversations over three weeks for the choice to be made! WHYYYY.

I stopped going for dinner with one friend completely after she sent a waitress away 4 times because she couldn’t decide what to eat in a restaurant. Now I only see her for walks and things, so I’m never in that position again.

OP posts:
Darker · 28/09/2021 14:52

Ask them to toss a coin.

Hardbackwriter · 28/09/2021 14:30

@number87inthequeue

My MIL appears indecisive but I have come to realise that she actually fears making the wrong choice and therefore being held responsible for it (if only in her head). I've realised that she invariably knows exactly what she wants to do, but wants someone else to have made the decision so it's not her 'fault'. Eg. using the OP's restaurant example, she will know she wants to go to B but will ask where we want to go, refuse to suggest anywhere and say she is happy with anything. We suggest A. She questions/points out problems but won't suggest anything else. We suggest C. Same again. Either we suggest B or she will eventually mention it in passing. She will compare with A but say it's up to us. If we choose A she will leave it for a while then 'check' that we still want to go to A . Repeat until we realise she wants to go to B and say we'll go there. She repeats that it's our choice, she'd be happy with anywhere.

I have no idea why she has this fear of being responsible for making a 'wrong' choice. It's rarely about anything where there will be any real consequences of making a bad choice. However, if anything minor does go wrong (eg. slow service, menu choice we wanted not available etc) she gets almost panicky and goes on for ages about the fact that it was everyone else's choice.

We now start the conversation by telling her that we will take full responsibility for the decision, even if we take her suggestion.

This was exactly how I was before I had counselling for anxiety. I was obsessed with the idea that I'd do something 'wrong' and ruin things for everyone so couldn't bear making decisions that affected others, even stupid things like what film to watch, in case they didn't like it and had a bad time and it was All My Fault. I had quite a lot of counselling to change my mindset but the most helpful single insight for me was realising that this kind of anxiety is a type of narcissistic behaviour - that I was massively overstating my own importance and impact (I was just doing it in a negative way, not in a way that assumed I was brilliant). I wasn't going to ruin other people's lives with my bad decisions because I wasn't actually all that important in the grand scheme of their lives, and nor was my film choice! I found that a really helpful reframing because until then I'd struggled to let go of my idea in my head that this behaviour was a positive trait of modesty and putting others first. Seeing that it was actually selfish behaviour really helped to change it.
tcjotm · 28/09/2021 14:22

@Indecisivelurcher

Oops, this is me Blush Would happily pay for someone to decide things for me.
I used to do it for free. I had some dithering friends hand over decision making power over little things to me. One I knew really well and could order for her, the other was too easy going. Improved my life considerably, especially when deciding on lunch in food courts.

No more differing over over what goddamn flavour of muffin (bloody muffin break and their gazillion varieties). “You’re having apple cinnamon. He can have choc chip. Share if you want”. “You can have a coffee, I don’t care if you’ve had one already, I know you want another. And you, get an orange juice”

I also chose movies and picked between social options as required. Oh and outfits, FFS. Had to wear what I said if they felt compelled to ask.

And in return they were grateful not to hear “chop chop, time’s a wasting’” from me.

It’s amazing how easy it is to make unimportant decisions for someone else. And how freeing it was for them to just stop agonising over them.

KevinTheKoala · 28/09/2021 14:21

I am seriously indecisive but I am well aware of how annoying it is and I hate it about myself, I am perfectly happy for someone else to choose for me though. In my case it is a trauma response from childhood that I haven't been able to unlearn so far.

ChargingBuck · 28/09/2021 14:19

@purplecorkheart

My brothers partner is like this and I cannot stand it. She is never on time because she is dithering about what to wear. Her ordering in a restaurant (if she actually manages to get there) is awful.
I stopped eating out with one specific chum who had form for this.

She'd turn up late, then hold up the entire table while she chose her food. Not anxiety-related - a full performance, engaging the wait staff, sending them away, asking them back, requesting changes to the menu ... finally ordering then changing her mind in the same breath, asking for just another 10 minutes, & constant updates about how she couldn't help it, was just more sensitive than other people ... blah blah. She didn't care who was hungry, or that we'd now been bumped under a larger table's order so would have an extra 20 minutes wait - it was all about being precious & milking her audience.

I cottoned on to how deliberate it was when we were on holiday together. The production she made about her (home cooked - no ordering to manage) breakfast was enraging - the woman needed applause for eating a boiled egg.

Sorry to all the anxious people who genuinely suffer over their decisions. This was not that - it was attention seeking & a wish to promote herself as worthy of special attentions while keeping everyone else waiting & clapping along to her tune. Gah, I've come over all sour-faced at the memory!

ChargingBuck · 28/09/2021 14:06

Is there any way of stopping this from happening short of causing a fallout by saying ‘stop involving me in the tedious minutiae of your life, I couldn’t care less what minor decisions you make and I certainly don’t want to hear about them!’

Not really ... but given the amount of annoyance your ditherers have caused you long term, I don't see why you wouldn't just deploy this nuclear option by now.

If it causes fallout, ask them if they are sure they are upset, & present them with a list of optional emotional responses. You can tiptoe away while they re-enter analysis paralysis ...

QueeniesCroft · 28/09/2021 14:06

I used to be horribly indecisive- I think it came from being brought up in a very rigid, military family (where there were 2 choices- do as you are told or get hurt) and then boarding school (a less extreme version of the same thing), and not being really equipped for having to organise my own life and decide stuff for myself.

I cured myself fairly easily, once I worked out how few choices can only be made once. There will be other dinners, other films, other holidays etc. It was very liberating, especially when I also worked out (very late!) that I'm not responsible for making everyone around me happy.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 28/09/2021 13:58

I think that sufferers of genuine, clinical Anxiety have been done a real disservice by the flocks of twittering ditherers across the internet who use anxiety as an excuse for a failure to behave like an actual adult.

Quite, and I say that as someone who has struggled with clinically-diagnosed-and-treated anxiety for large parts of their life. I still can’t bear ditherers and if they want to take an age to make a decision that’s up to them but they can do it on their own time and with their own emotional energy, not mine. Just let me know when you’ve decided.

“Anxiety” is not an explanation for any negative behaviour Hmm

Indecisivelurcher · 28/09/2021 13:55

Oops, this is me Blush Would happily pay for someone to decide things for me.

number87inthequeue · 28/09/2021 13:53

My MIL appears indecisive but I have come to realise that she actually fears making the wrong choice and therefore being held responsible for it (if only in her head). I've realised that she invariably knows exactly what she wants to do, but wants someone else to have made the decision so it's not her 'fault'. Eg. using the OP's restaurant example, she will know she wants to go to B but will ask where we want to go, refuse to suggest anywhere and say she is happy with anything. We suggest A. She questions/points out problems but won't suggest anything else. We suggest C. Same again. Either we suggest B or she will eventually mention it in passing. She will compare with A but say it's up to us. If we choose A she will leave it for a while then 'check' that we still want to go to A . Repeat until we realise she wants to go to B and say we'll go there. She repeats that it's our choice, she'd be happy with anywhere.

I have no idea why she has this fear of being responsible for making a 'wrong' choice. It's rarely about anything where there will be any real consequences of making a bad choice. However, if anything minor does go wrong (eg. slow service, menu choice we wanted not available etc) she gets almost panicky and goes on for ages about the fact that it was everyone else's choice.

We now start the conversation by telling her that we will take full responsibility for the decision, even if we take her suggestion.

MargaretThursday · 28/09/2021 13:52

It depends.

If they're "I don't mind" and genuinely don't, then it's not a problem. My dd can be like that. She'd rather you said "we'll go to X" than said "would you like X or Y". If she has an opinion then she'll tell you.

My df on the other hand used to be the master of: "Do you want X or Y?" "I don't mind." "We'll have X then." "Actually I think Y would be best..."
Eventually dm called him out on it, he denied it, so she promptly asked him whether he'd like cheese on toast or boiled egg for dinner. "Don't mind," he said. "I'll do boiled egg then," she replied. "Actually I think cheese on toast.... Oh, sorry!" he said. 🤣🤣🤣
Tbf to him he has been pretty good in the last 35 years or so after that happened.

EatYourVegetables · 28/09/2021 13:52

I highly recommend watching “The good place”. American TV, on Netflix.