Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dyslexia mocking

31 replies

Idiotbasher · 28/09/2021 10:05

Is it ever ok to publicly mock the spelling of a dyslexic person or someone who has poor spelling for any other reason really?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jollygreenpea · 28/09/2021 14:34

I'm dyslexic and I'm not offended when someone corrects me, I have learnt and improved because of it.

If I had to write a sign I would make sure I spelt it correctly, I can't see any reason not to check how to spell the words.

Ozanj · 28/09/2021 14:23

@Latecomer131

I am dyslexic, and generally just find it a little bit pathetic when people correct spelling and grammar in an OP's post. I tend to assume that any poster who does this must not have much else going on in their lives (if that's the only way they can feel superior).

The only exception would be where the spelling or grammar error is so serious as to create ambiguity about the post, but that's almost never the case.

What many don't realise, is that your ability to spell is unrelated to your intelligence, and many dyslexics actually have 'spiky' cognitive profiles with some aspects of their IQ being in the gifted/exceptional range.

I'm not exactly going to cry into my cornflakes if someone on Mumsnet picks me up on a typo, as I have a PhD.

The fact that I'll never be a natural born editor or proofreader has been completely irrelevant to my professional success.

If your dyslexia has never impacted you in your personal or professional life then I imagine there are a lot of people in the background able to fix your gaffes or your work is ultimately not ‘customer facing’. My severe dyslexia doesn’t allow me to take offence & I will take corrections as feedback rather than some perceived slight to my intelligence.
Latecomer131 · 28/09/2021 12:56

I am dyslexic, and generally just find it a little bit pathetic when people correct spelling and grammar in an OP's post. I tend to assume that any poster who does this must not have much else going on in their lives (if that's the only way they can feel superior).

The only exception would be where the spelling or grammar error is so serious as to create ambiguity about the post, but that's almost never the case.

What many don't realise, is that your ability to spell is unrelated to your intelligence, and many dyslexics actually have 'spiky' cognitive profiles with some aspects of their IQ being in the gifted/exceptional range.

I'm not exactly going to cry into my cornflakes if someone on Mumsnet picks me up on a typo, as I have a PhD.

The fact that I'll never be a natural born editor or proofreader has been completely irrelevant to my professional success.

21782b7 · 28/09/2021 12:10

I have dyslexia/learning difficulties . I think its horrible when spelling/grammar is pointed out. Especially when someone is reaching out for support.

Also when we talk about children behave learning difficulties etc everyone seems to be kind give good advice empathy and understanding . That child then grows into an adult posts on MN and its apparently fine to point out that persons dyslexia. Its like people think that child grows out of it then when their an adult mn can just say what . People seem to forget that adults have learning difficulties as well 🙄

I think it also shows the mentality of the person saying it .

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 28/09/2021 11:58

Ozanj, the default though must be that posters are not corrected because some will take offence. Presumably people who know you in real life are aware of your stance and do let you know of any inaccuracies?

I don't mind being corrected myself but I wouldn't want that convention applied to others willy-nilly, however much I might welcome it for my own posts because it can be extremely hurtful for people who are cognisant that they make errors.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 28/09/2021 11:53

Lockheart, I agree it's important but correcting posters who haven't asked for feedback and critique on their content is just rude. We can ask questions or clarify what they meant if it's that unintelligible - or just move on and let somebody else who can fathom the post's meaning, help.

I think that some posters feel so ashamed when they're unexpectedly picked up on their SPaG that they say they are dyslexic as some sort of talisman to get posters to back off. Nobody should be put in that position, not ever.

Ileflottante · 28/09/2021 11:51

You don’t know the signwriter was dyslexic though…? You’re projecting that. It could just be they have poor spelling and vocabulary as they don’t read enough.

I once corrected a glaring apostrophe mistake on a sign inside a bar. It was a chalk-written sign and they gave punters chalk to draw with on the tables as a gimmick. So it was bound to happen. Anyway once I’d corrected it (because it was irking me) I got told off by the people who worked there as the person who wrote it was ‘really, really dyslexic’.

Apparently, “well maybe don’t let them write the signs” wasn’t the right answer. 😬

Ozanj · 28/09/2021 11:48

I am severely dyslexic and believe I should be corrected if something is wrong. But I do personally think the people who are most defensive about their condition (and discourage improvement) tend to have mild / moderate diagnoses.

Orangejuicemarathoner · 28/09/2021 11:45

Im dyslexic. By far the largest amount of mockery I have ever had in my life has been on Mumsnet.

It normally means someone has nothing constructive to say

Lockheart · 28/09/2021 11:42

Clear language does matter. Usually you can discern what someone means but sometimes you can't. I remember a post on here complaining about a man "gorping" in the gym.

Now either that's a typo for "groping" or someone can't spell "gawping". But two very different scenarios. One would be a police matter for starters.

It was the latter, for those who are wondering!

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 28/09/2021 11:39

StrictlyAFemaleFemale, why wouldn't it be? That's a completely different scenario, isn't it?

Disclaimer then; if somebody welcomes the correction, knock yourself out.

OchreBlue · 28/09/2021 11:30

I'm on the fence with this. No-one should be mocked but I'm dyslexic and really struggle to read things that are spelt wrong. If signs are spelt incorrectly I can't always make sense of it even if it's obvious to others because I don't read phonetically. The "no fule" example made me laugh because I read it as "no fools" it took me a while to realise it intended to read "no fuel". I have spent a lot of my life learning to spell and checking my spelling and I use software to help me so I do find it irritating when people don't double check things and produce something I can't read. I really appreciate that Mumsnet takes spelling and grammar seriously because I've actually been unable to use many other forums because I just could not read other people's posts at all because they didn't follow the rules of standard English I've painstakingly learnt.

Cocomarine · 28/09/2021 11:30

@Idiotbasher

It's a hand written sign saying ' No fule' with the heading 'in the UK the crisis continues'
That doesn’t sound like holding up an individual to be mocked, but making a political joke to highlight their perception of a crisis in the U.K. education system.

The national average for leaving school with Maths & English C grade GCSE is around 45%. So more than half our kids are in education for 12 years and don’t pass those 2 GCSEs. Is our education system supporting them or failing them? I’m not teacher bashing, I’m government bashing.

I don’t think it matters that the “fule” sign may have been written by a dyslexic, someone with SEN, someone who is “just” crap at spelling… or possibly someone with English as a second, third, fourth language… I mean, piss off with criticising the spelling of someone speaking more languages than you!

I don’t think that matters if the point is to highlight issues in education and our schools needing more funding and our giving teachers more support and and appreciating their value.

It’s not the beet joke for that though - that’s a perfectly good attempt at an unusually spelled word.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 28/09/2021 11:28

Generally I think the level of literacy and comprehension is pretty poor, but that's not the fault of the individual, rather the education system. As long as I can understand what they mean then Im good. Having said that I dont always understand some posts on mn.

I have once pointed out a grammatical mistake on MN but 1 she had asked for feedback and 2 it rather undermined the point she was making. She replied saying thanks and good point, so my conscience is clear Smile.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 28/09/2021 11:17

No it's not ok. I see it here from time to time. If somebody feels that strongly they should private message the poster to correct them, not humiliate them on the thread.

Pathetic, and they should be pulled up on it every time they do it.

PlanDeRaccordement · 28/09/2021 11:10

@Idiotbasher

There is a Facebook page about making the world a better place and they have posted a picture of someone's spelling mistake on a sign. It's really shocked me
So long as they haven’t identified whose sign it is, I don’t think that counts as public mocking.
WellLarDeDar · 28/09/2021 11:06

My husband is very dyslexic, and I had to admit it is sometimes funny what he comes up with and we will have a giggle together. But I don't mock him for it though, he often asks me to spell things out for him and I try to help and be supportive if he asks. He's very intelligent, remarkable at mental arithmetic. It's an intimidate dynamic between us though, I don't think I'd feel right having a giggle at someone I didn't know well unless they encouraged that kind of dynamic. In my experience some people like to joke about it and others prefer when people move on as fast as possible from it when it comes up. I think it's okay to have sense of humor but to actually mock someone is very cruel and you really need to read the situation. I'm not dyslexic myself but I don't always hit the bullseye with spelling and pronunciation and have been made to feel like an idiot and it's really not a nice feeling. Spelling doesn't always translate well into pronunciation and vice versa. Just be kind really.

Neonplant · 28/09/2021 11:06

Well you can't know if someone is dyslexic or not can you? So perhaps we shouldn't mock anyone's spelling and grammar?

I've always thought spelling and grammar wankers must have really sad empty lives if I'm honest. But I'm aware people need to feel superior so...

Idiotbasher · 28/09/2021 10:59

The shock is because its from a group claiming to be kind and wanting to make a positive change in the world. The description they have of their page
'A page to encourage... a page to inspire...ideas to make the world a better place'

OP posts:
owlbethere · 28/09/2021 10:50

No it’s not.

maddening · 28/09/2021 10:50

What has shocked you? The spelling or the mocking?

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 28/09/2021 10:48

Mocking spelling appears to be 'fair game' everywhere. Including Mumsnet. Be it a translation error, dyslexia or someone who cannot spell for any reason. Or just a typo.

Lockheart · 28/09/2021 10:45

@Idiotbasher

There is a Facebook page about making the world a better place and they have posted a picture of someone's spelling mistake on a sign. It's really shocked me
You haven't spent much time on the internet have you?
FAQs · 28/09/2021 10:43

People only do it to put others down, that can never come from a good place.

Idiotbasher · 28/09/2021 10:41

It's a hand written sign saying ' No fule' with the heading 'in the UK the crisis continues'

OP posts: