Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you split all expenses 50/50 or proportional to salary?

229 replies

marykitty · 28/09/2021 07:43

My DH and I earned ca. the same salary when we got married, and we were splitting all expenses 50/50.

Few years ago, I dropped to 3 days per week after we had DS1, therefore I now earn a lower salary and have less bonuses etc. During my 2 days off I take care of DC and do all house chores.

My DH suggested, back then, that we kept splitting all expenses 50/50. With Expenses I mean everything:

  • Mortgage
  • Renovation and maintenance costs
  • Phone, TV, water, light, fuel etc.
  • Taxes and insurances
  • Childcare and DC relates expenses
  • Food and commodities (often i pay more than 50 for this since I do shopping on my days off and often pay cash or with my card)
  • Payments to our pension funds
  • All extras such as vacations
  • Etc (i forgot something for sure)

Our childcare costs are now increasing and we need to buy a new car…I will close this year with a negative balance in my bank account. (Not minus, but having less than last year. It is now the second year in a row)

My DH thinks this does not matter because at the end of the day he is saving on his account and his money is my money etc etc.

He thinks me being upset by this is crazy, that it shows I am unnecessarily focused on money and this should not even be a concern in our family.

I know at the end of the day “it is OUR money” but I just feel sad to see I am not able to save after working hard.

how are you organized with your DH?

I know I have to learn to save better, but I wonder how other families are organized and if I am really BU to think we should change the way we split stuff.

OP posts:
marykitty · 28/09/2021 09:50

Thanks a lot for your answers.
I am happy to see i am not completely unreasonable.

We have a shared account for expenses, and we pay into this account the same amount of money each month (therefore 50/50).
I manage this shared account since I pay bills, insurance, foods etc. Don't know what i am doing wrong but after years of managing it without issues, I had now to "top up" this account several times because there was not enough money at the end of the month. Not sure if it's a common issue, are the prices going up or am i just spending more? If I present this issue to DH, he said that I should just be more careful with expenses since I am the "account manager" it's my role to make sure we do not overdo it.

For bigger things, e.g. a new car or house renovation, he pays for them then "send me the bill" for my 50%, which i then transfer to his account. Same for taxes.

Our other bank accounts are personal, so I have no direct access to his accounts.

I feel like at the beginning this was a no issue, because I managed to save anyway at the end of the year so I did not pay too much attention to what this was doing to my finances...

But after struggling now for the second year in a row i am getting more and more frustated to see the "red sign" indicating my decreasing balance at the end of the year.

OP posts:
mobear · 28/09/2021 09:47

We split everything 50/50 but it does bother me sometimes as DP earns 10x what I do. (I am a high earner, but he is a very high earner). That said, now we have DC, he recently bought a house for us and he paid more than 50% for our last holiday so I can't really complain now.

In your situation, as you're married, you're more protected than I am, but if he is using the "what's mine is yours" line, I don't see why he can't pay more than 50% so you don't feel so anxious (and have the liberty to buy yourself luxuries on occasion without having to ask DH for money!).

EezyOozy · 28/09/2021 09:38

All goes into one pot here, all family money, we have two DC (preschool age).

BiddyPop · 28/09/2021 09:35

We have an A N Other approach.

DH always earned more than me (couple of years ahead of me into work, private sector pays better than public sector etc) - although we will be almost equal in the next month when he changes job.

We each covered different expenses -
DH - Mortgage, annual property tax, health insurance, netflix/spotify, his car

Me - electricity, gas, phone, house insurance, house alarm monitoring, groceries, childcare, my car

I generally organised holidays but we tended to end up splitting various elements (he'd book ferry and I would book accomodation etc).

As we paid off the mortgage (which was significant), he took over more everyday bills - phone/broadband (and added premium tv to it), doing groceries much more often (he'd always do some, it just happened I tend to do most), house alarm monitoring, house insurance etc.

And he has often been the person to organise the servicing of both cars (and pay for those), general repairs and maintenance in the house, etc.

While I tend to be the one organising cards and gifts for all occasions.

I used to be the main person buying DD clothes when she was smaller, but as a teen, DH seems to have a better feel for what she now wants (and she will sit and tell him what to order but not me) - which I don't grumble about as she has expensive taste.

We both have savings, DH more than me, but he earned a lot more. And if ever either of us was stuck (mostly cashflow due to lots of spending on work travel and expenses not yet recovered but the relevant credit card bills needing to be paid, and big annual bills coming in the wrong month), we each transfer money to the other (for standing orders/direct debits etc) and take on the more day-to-day cash expenses for a few weeks (groceries etc).

Nanananani · 28/09/2021 09:34

Neither. We each keep the same amount of personal spending then everything goes in joint pot

ErickBroch · 28/09/2021 09:33

Proportionally here. We have no kids, so DP is the higher earner and still gets more disposable income than me, but proportionally so! Doesn't bother me at all, he pays more into the bills and gets a bit more to spend a month on what he wants. Works well.

Summerfun54321 · 28/09/2021 09:28

We pay for everything in an ad hoc way and just check our accounts to see who’s running low and transfer money between us. We have separate accounts but freely share money between them. My DH earns more so puts money into joint savings. There’s no 50/50 split, it’s a free for all but works well for us.

SweetPetrichor · 28/09/2021 09:27

We split it based on salary. I earn more than my DP so I pay a higher percentage of the costs. The aim is to leave us with fair amounts of 'own' money after essentials are paid, and it all works quite well.

qualitygirl · 28/09/2021 09:26

I pay some bills, he pays others. We don't really get caught up on it to be honest. But we don't have many bills to be honest.

Duckschmuck · 28/09/2021 09:26

Also,if he is going down that route, he should pay you for loss of earnings on the days you don't work, for a lifestyle choice you both made for the benefit of your joint child. Not merely paying for childcare and domestic duties, that doesn't cover the value of your contribution.

yellowgingham · 28/09/2021 09:25

We pool all our money but if we were keeping it separate then it would definitely be proportional to salary.

Your DH is being pretty awful.

Kisskiss · 28/09/2021 09:20

That sounds so unfair. Either 1) split all costs proportionately 2) have a joint account with equal ‘fun’ money for each of you or , if he’s really going to be so tight, 3) he should he paying for 2.5/3 ( 85 pct) of the 3 days of childcare, given you do the other 2 days!

TheOpportuneMoment · 28/09/2021 09:18

We split the bills down the middle and pay that into a bills account at the start of the month. Everything we each have left goes into joint account. DH puts in a bit more as he has more left after bills (he works 5 days, I work 4). We then use that to budget for the month and put a certain amount of that into a joint savings account.

Chloemol · 28/09/2021 09:15

Unless you have a joint account and access to the money and can then spend it it’s not ‘our’ money

You split the bills proportionally , all of them in your list

Zilla1 · 28/09/2021 09:15

If 'his' money is 'our' money then he'll be happy if all savings are in your name only as 'your' money is 'our' money. The 'unnecessary' focus on money is purely a deliberate, cynical, emotional debating trick to divert from his unreasonable position because there is no justification for his position. Let him pay you two days salary for the child care so you have 100% of salary equivalent and he has 60% then see what tune he sings about 50:50 splits. Straighten him out, OP.

GabriellaMontez · 28/09/2021 09:14

He says it's your money? So can you access it it to bring yourself put of overdraft?

If not, then its not your money. Suggest totally shared finances in joint names.

If he doesn't want this go back to work full time or charge him for the childcare.

The system you have is totally unfair. He has the best of both worlds. And he's gaslighting you.

MatildaTheCat · 28/09/2021 09:12

If he thinks that way then having his savings in a joint account won’t bother him? If he declines that plan then YANBU and should charge him for your two days of childcare and housework.

CraftyGin · 28/09/2021 09:10

We don't split anything. It all goes into one pot.

"For richer, for poorer", and "for all that I have I share with you".

WhyOhWhyOhWhyyyy · 28/09/2021 09:07

We do the same as you, split 50:50 but Im the highest earner (earn approx £30k more than DH). But I balance this out by putting a regular amount into a joint savings account that is in both our names, and by paying for more of the fun things, meals out, etc. So neither of us is better off at the end of the month.

violetbunny · 28/09/2021 09:06

Well if his money is your money, ask him why it matters to him to keep paying 50/50 then?

The point is that you need equal access to and control over that money. You are joint equals in this relationship. If you weren't working part time, he would either have to pay someone for childcare or reduce his own working days.

DressedUpAtAnIvy · 28/09/2021 09:02

Everything in joint accounts since we got pregnant. Only drawback is that we have to remember to buy presents in cash.
If it’s not important where the money goes, it would presumably be fine for him to have it in an account in your name only, so do that.

moimichme · 28/09/2021 09:01

For tax/legal reasons we don't have a joint account and I am the higher earner. We pay proportional to income. However I agree with PP that this seems to be a very unfair set up for you, OP, and it would be worth considering whether this is a pattern in other areas as well as finances, childcare and chores. You deserve to be treated as an equal partner and not have less money year on year while he keeps ahold of it all. Flowers

MsHedgehog · 28/09/2021 08:59

Proportionate to salary. DH and I are both high earners, but he still earns 3x what I earn, so it wouldn’t be fair for our expenses to be equal.

So your situation is completely unfair, especially as you’ve reduced your hours for the sake of family. In fact, considering you look after the home and family, your husband’s portion should be greater.

Immaculatemisconception · 28/09/2021 08:58

He’s completely wrong. You are caring for his child and clearing up his shit. Things in your marriage are not equal. Stick up for yourself and fix it.

Thriwit · 28/09/2021 08:57

You’re not currently splitting things 50/50 though.

The cost of childcare for the 2 days you’re at home is the amount you’ve lost in wages. So for 50/50 he should be paying half of that. If he’s not, then you’re not currently splitting it 50/50, no matter what he says.

So work out how much you’ve lost, half it, and that’s how much more he should pay (& how much less you should pay).

Or just do like most people I know do - have a joint account for household expenses and each put a percentage of your wages in there proportional to how much you earn.

Swipe left for the next trending thread