Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you split all expenses 50/50 or proportional to salary?

229 replies

marykitty · 28/09/2021 07:43

My DH and I earned ca. the same salary when we got married, and we were splitting all expenses 50/50.

Few years ago, I dropped to 3 days per week after we had DS1, therefore I now earn a lower salary and have less bonuses etc. During my 2 days off I take care of DC and do all house chores.

My DH suggested, back then, that we kept splitting all expenses 50/50. With Expenses I mean everything:

  • Mortgage
  • Renovation and maintenance costs
  • Phone, TV, water, light, fuel etc.
  • Taxes and insurances
  • Childcare and DC relates expenses
  • Food and commodities (often i pay more than 50 for this since I do shopping on my days off and often pay cash or with my card)
  • Payments to our pension funds
  • All extras such as vacations
  • Etc (i forgot something for sure)

Our childcare costs are now increasing and we need to buy a new car…I will close this year with a negative balance in my bank account. (Not minus, but having less than last year. It is now the second year in a row)

My DH thinks this does not matter because at the end of the day he is saving on his account and his money is my money etc etc.

He thinks me being upset by this is crazy, that it shows I am unnecessarily focused on money and this should not even be a concern in our family.

I know at the end of the day “it is OUR money” but I just feel sad to see I am not able to save after working hard.

how are you organized with your DH?

I know I have to learn to save better, but I wonder how other families are organized and if I am really BU to think we should change the way we split stuff.

OP posts:
Helporhindrance07 · 28/09/2021 22:01

When we first moved in together we split it 50/50 despite me earning a little bit more than my (now) DH - at his insistence. Around when we got married I got a big promotion and would have earned about 3 times what he did. At that point I suggested a shared pot because otherwise we would have been limited by his wage for what we could do etc so what would be the point in the promotion! So we both pay our salaries into a joint account and send “spending money” into each other’s sole accounts, works well with us and we have never argued about money. I’m now on maternity leave so DH is the main earner, he just sends anything I ask for, I think I am fortunate!

JaninaDuszejko · 28/09/2021 22:00

Married 20 years, 3 DC. We both worked PT when the DC were small, now only DH does. We have our own accounts and pay into the joint account that covers all bills. We each save the same amount and pay money into the joint so we have approximately the same amount of 'fun money'. But that fun money covers some essentials so every so often one of us says 'I'm skint because I've just paid for 'X', can you transfer some money to my account?'. We're not tight for money, have lots of savings and have always earnt similar amounts so can be fairly relaxed about it.

Summerrain123 · 28/09/2021 21:57

Wow. You should bill him the child care costs if the mariage is so transactional. I would insist on all joint accounts and then each of you having the same amount for leisure/ personal buys. Your DH ibvu!

Starseeking · 28/09/2021 21:52

Interestingly in our situation, it was me the higher earner who suggested a joint account that everything went into, but EXDP refused saying I might run off with his money Confused

ComeTheFuck0nBridget · 28/09/2021 21:48

This is unfair on you. I can't believe he said you were unnecessarily focused on money - that sounds borderline gaslighting to me.

You're putting yourself in a precarious position. If he's not worried about money and all money is family money then it doesn't matter if it's sitting in your savings account as much as it doesn't matter that it's sitting in his.

I'd be really firm about this, too many posts on here about women who end up in financial difficulty with shit partners.

seaandsandcastles · 28/09/2021 21:48

All goes into one pot, both have free access regardless of employment status. We just talk to each other if we want to make a “big” purchase.

notanothertakeaway · 28/09/2021 21:45

We pay bills in proportion to salary, and keep the rest for ourselves

If I had my time again, I would probably suggest all £ goes into joint account and have the same amount of £ for discretionary spending

Starseeking · 28/09/2021 21:44

Assuming you still earn a similar gross salary, he's earning 5/8 of the money, and you 3/8, so it should be split proportionally accordingly.

When I was with EXDP, I earned double what he did, so we split bills 2/3 me and 1/3 him. As I'm female and him male, this built up resentment over time, and contributed to the relationship breakdown, so I'm not sure I'd do this again with a future partner.

catfunk · 28/09/2021 21:43

Is he paying you for 2 days childcare then if he wants to be fair ?

ByThePool2021 · 28/09/2021 21:42

We do 50/50 because we both have the right to chose how often we work and what we earn and it’s not fair for one of us to push ourselves to earn more just to substitute the one who wants to work/earn less. Was going 3 days your choice? If dh wanted to also drop to 3 days that’s ok too? You can’t say you are only going to work 3 days so he has to pay more. You chose that knowing what your expenses are.
My landlord won’t decrease my rent because I decide I don’t want to work full time no more, I know I have to earn x amount to cover my bills (50% of household bills) and how I do that and any excess I earn is up to me, and likewise for dh. He often asks me if he should go self employed and my answer is always as long as he can pay his share of the bills he can do what he likes I fully support him. Do you have a similar set up?

SilverGlassHare · 28/09/2021 21:36

Joint account - everything goes in, everything comes out. We can both spend what we like from the joint account, within reason.

HaveToSaySomethingHere · 28/09/2021 21:35

You are subsiding his savings with your past earnings. He says that his money is equally yours but clearly it's not.

PetticoatSoldier · 28/09/2021 21:27

@DifficultBloodyWoman

Everything goes into one pot. We each take the same amount of ‘pocket money’ for personal expenses such as lunches with friends, haircuts, presents etc.

If your DH thinks it doesn’t matter, he won’t mind changing your system, will he?

We do this too. All income goes into one pot and is considered household/family income. After bills are paid, we each get the same 'pocket money' into our own accounts that's for us to spend as we please. Family expenses inc days or meals out, or any activities with the DCs, come from joint.

RosesAndHellebores · 28/09/2021 21:23

When I earned 100k and DH earned about 26k he insisted on 50/50 except for my mortgage on my house. Then his career catapulted and we had a baby and we had moved house and it was in both names with a caveat re my equity. And he paid half the mortgage. Then I gave up work and he paid everything. And never questioned a single penny of expenditure.

DressedinStars · 28/09/2021 21:17

Also when you say 'for taxes' what taxes is this? Are you both self employed? If he earns more, why would you pay half his tax?

Or do you mean like council tax?

DressedinStars · 28/09/2021 21:15

We split in an odd way. But that's because the kids are mine, not dp. I own the house and I earn more. And we aren't married and don't want to join finances.

I pay for all work on the house. Again, because its mine.

So I pay a lot more. I would be happy paying all the bills and living expenses. As my wage has gone up, we have stayed in the same house so bills are quite small so I wouldn't mind. But dp insists on paying some. So it's proportional. We also pay proportional amounts into savings I a joint account.

The set up here, seems very odd.

Its all well and good saying savings are shared, but if they are only in his name (which it seems like they are) then while technically, they are shared. If he left tomorrow a bank won't give you access to an account in his name only. You would need to wait for the divorce to access it. Not much help paying bills until the divorce. And he could have spent it by then.

Even in a joint account, he could clear it out if he was planning on leaving. The only secure money is what's in your name.

This really sounds unpleasant and as though he resents you work PT so is, almost, punishing you for it.

I assume he agreed to the part time working, so it seems odd. This set up seems really unfair.

MajorCarolDanvers · 28/09/2021 21:03

We don't have his and her money - we have 'our' money.

Both salaries into a joint account and all expenses paid out from that. We also put into joint savings.

Sometimes he has earned more, sometimes I have earned more. Currently I earn a lot more. Doesn't matter. If you are a family then you should pool your resources. IMO

MrsTerryPratchett · 28/09/2021 21:01

This thread is depressing.

JoeyMuzzo · 28/09/2021 20:59

Get a joint bank account which all incoming money goes into and then each person has their own personal account which receives a regular deposit from a joint account. Your personal accounts are full just for fun stuff that the other person can't comment on being frivalous

speakout · 28/09/2021 20:57

I couldn't be bothered with all that stuff.

All money is shared- no matter who earns it.

One central pot.

Iloveabourbon2 · 28/09/2021 20:57

@FreshFreesias

Any women who are fed up being single need to read these threads and count their blessings.
That's me! Cheers Smile
KentuckyCriedFricken · 28/09/2021 20:55

It’s our money. Both waves go into our joint account, the only account we have, and all bills come out of it. We are married, not flat mates.

doodleygirl · 28/09/2021 20:55

You sound like a switched on person, why on earth did you agree to this unfair arrangement? And more importantly why have you not changed the system?

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 28/09/2021 20:51

I have always earned more (he came close a few years ago but then I move jobs).

We just pool the money. We each have savings accounts in our own names, so as to maximise returns/amounts, but it’s not ‘his’ and ‘mine’ - it’s ‘ours’. He works out the budget for us every 6 months and keeps track of where things are. I just keep earning the cash.

FreshFreesias · 28/09/2021 20:49

Any women who are fed up being single need to read these threads and count their blessings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread