Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say people are totally over reacting about the fuel issue

439 replies

TikTokNutcases · 27/09/2021 22:54

People adamant they can't go to work, so get a train.

Ride a bicycle.

Use the bus.

Talk of closing schools for god sake, whatever next.

It's ridiculous that people rely so heavily on the use of their car that life appears to stop still when they can't drive it.

You don't see this type of hysteria among non drivers, ever.

I don't drive and never have. I've never flapped like this about not being able to go to the supermarket, work etc.

OP posts:
maddening · 28/09/2021 08:30

But if everyone had not engaged in total panic we would not have had the shortage, people living rural would not have the worry of impossible public transport etc.

But people love a.good panic and have now created a crisis for some people. It is the initial overacting that has caused all those actually impacted to be impacted.

Mumwithbaggage · 28/09/2021 08:29

I teach 22 miles away. By public transport, it would take me over 3 hours to get there. The first bus to the town in the middle is at 7.30 (the bus stop is over a mile away with no footpaths). Lots of doctors/nurses near me have a similar commute. Good for you if you can get to work by public transport.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/09/2021 08:28

Absolutely OP. Everyone should move to the cities, have a small commute to work and make sure they have no mobility problems or child-care issues which mean they only have a small amount of time to get to work. Such a big fuss over nothing.

WeAllHaveWings · 28/09/2021 08:26

You are incredibly narrow minded if you cannot work this one out all by yourself.

SmileyClare · 28/09/2021 08:25

*having

Brokeandtired3 · 28/09/2021 08:25

@Stellaris22 it's hardly people being defensive at all Hmm

Ironically enough its these "rural villages" that depend on drivers the most for produce and products so come off your high horse.

There are more things that would come to a stop than just the nhs without vehicles, alot of services that you so mindlessly use day to day unless you bloody pick your own vegetables from the ground

Fire fighters, ambulances, out of hours drs, Hermes, usp, DHL, amazon, supermarket delivery, postmen, cars that transport special needs children and disabled people, funnily enough even BUSES require fuel le shock, so unless your gonna jump on a horse or cycle everywhere even non drivers would suffer, coaches, cabs, Van's (lots of independent business depend on) tractors (that harvest the food YOU eat) I could go on...

But I'd hope you get the point by now.

So seemingly yes the world would actually stop and be a mess if petrol and driving wasnt a thing

Onairjunkie · 28/09/2021 08:24

@ivykaty44

Onairjunkie

im sorry to hear your father is having cancer treatment

perhaps if everyone hadn't over reacted then your father wouldn't be house bound as petrol would be plentiful

Where we are, no one has really ‘overreacted’. We all get isolated every winter with snow and ice so we’re use to mild peril! We normally use the tractors to help people when they’re stuck. It’s just our small rural petrol stations haven’t been prioritised for fuel deliveries and so we haven’t had any. So they’ve had to close. I’ve had to put red diesel in my RR. I’ll have to deal with the fall out when it’s due an MOT.
Stellaris22 · 28/09/2021 08:24

A lot of people I know can't afford to own a car, or to pay for driving lessons. These people are far from privileged, but make things work because they have to. The idea that people use public transport because they're rich and live in expensive city houses is laughable.

SmileyClare · 28/09/2021 08:24

The majority are quite enjoying the panic really? Confused the people I know are very frustrated, upset and worried about loss of earnings.
I can't imagine anyone enjoying having not having fuel.

Hopeisnotastrategy · 28/09/2021 08:23

To be fair, OP doesn't sound old enough to drive.

TurnUpTurnip · 28/09/2021 08:22

I agree op, I’m a single parent to 4 including a child with a disability and I don’t drive and never have yet I manage to get around! And I don’t just say in the local area either. I’ve never relied on lifts due to having 4 we can’t get lifts anyway as no room for us! I know people that drive to the corner shop that wouldn’t dream of walking, so yes I agree people are too heavily reliant on cars, And I live in London I don’t know anyone that lives rural let’s not act like people in London aren’t the same as they are.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 28/09/2021 08:22

I still don't get how many bus drivers are supposed to get to work at 5am or whenever the first bus is running! To facilitate public transport, and work unsociable hours, many bus/train drivers rely on cars! It's not an either/or situation.

Mufflette · 28/09/2021 08:21

I've just had a look at how I'd get to work if I couldn't drive or get a lift to the station. After a 2.5 hour journey I would actually be able to get there an hour late, but then I'd have to wait til 3.50AM to start the 4.5 hour journey home over 5 buses Grin
I'm not even as much in the middle of nowhere as a lot of people, in a village with about 1000 people here.

escapeyou · 28/09/2021 08:21

@Stellaris22

I agree with you OP and the nasty bullying you are getting is just people being defensive about their lifestyle choices.

Yes, NHS staff are going to need their car. Your average person being this reliant on private car use not so much.

I've lived very rurally as a child, I'd cycle 15 mins and get a train to school or to go meet friends. I don't buy that this isn't possible for adults.

A lot of people don't have cars because, like house ownership, it just isn't financially possible. Even driving lessons are unaffordable. It is possible to be a non driver and function perfectly fine. It's not being smug, it's being practical.

To say you can't do a combination of walking/public transport isn't true, it requires more planning, but it's not impossible.

It is illegal to cycle on the motorway to get to public transport. Perhaps you can advise how I get to public transport and then go back the way I came to get to work and school with 3 kids?
Bluebellforest1 · 28/09/2021 08:21

@TikTokNutcases
“I lived in rural Lincolnshire for 23 years, there were train stations dotted about.

Where do all of these super rural people live? The arse end of where?“

I live in rural Lincolnshire now. It is the arse end of where.

Nearest small train station 12 miles away, nearest train station to actually get anywhere, 30 miles away.

Nearest small shops 3 miles, bus every 2 hours (If you’re lucky!) service stops at 4.30pm. No chance of working around here if you need to use public transport.

MilkRunningOutAgain · 28/09/2021 08:19

We’re quite rural. Bus stop is 20 minutes walk away down a dark deserted road, service is poor and none in the Evenings or weekends. So, driving is essential, for school for the kids and to the train station for his commute for my DH. I am wfh since last March, so I don’t need to do so much driving.

Xenia · 28/09/2021 08:18

We hoped to live where the older 3 children went to school but they all ended up at different schools! yes they went on the school buses but to get there we had to leave home at 7.15am with baby twins all ready and in the car to get them to the school bus stops. I don't think people realise that not everyone is rich enough to live in cities. This is the issue with ER and those people on the M25 - they are rich privileged types who have no understanding of the lives of most normal people.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/09/2021 08:18

@ivykaty44

Mummyoflittledragon

as an aside did you know there are already more pedal cycles in this country than cars and more bikes are sold each year than cars = plus the bikes take less raw materials

What about other forms of transport? How many years does it take to build a train and railway network?
Hillary17 · 28/09/2021 08:17

People are panicking but it will be fine. I usually drive into work - which takes around 80 minutes on a good day. A train would be 3 changes due to the route, a bus and a ten minute walk. It would take around 3 hours. That’s six hours a day commuting… and yes I live in the arse end of nowhere! It’s not as easy as saying “use public transport” to everyone.

PlumeMoth · 28/09/2021 08:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

recededpronunciation · 28/09/2021 08:16

I’d love it if we had a transport network here that meant I could get to work. But the first bus available from the village gets to the town ten minutes too late for the train service I need to get to my early shift on time. And that’s without factoring in the shambolic stagecoach service that has had so many unannounced cancellations lately that kids have been strong at bus stops waiting for two hours to get to and from school.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/09/2021 08:16

@ivykaty44

So @ivykaty44 if all suddenly started using bikes, trailers, electric cars and public transport, have you thought about how the current infrastructure will cope?

people already use all these modes of transport? The roads are paid for by everyone paying council tax and paye, and motorways are paid fr by central government

Now tell me exactly how that would work. I think you forgot to look at the second paragraph.
ivykaty44 · 28/09/2021 08:16

Mummyoflittledragon

as an aside did you know there are already more pedal cycles in this country than cars and more bikes are sold each year than cars = plus the bikes take less raw materials

poshme · 28/09/2021 08:15

@OakPine

I'm astounded that people have set up their lives so badly that they fall apart without a car. Yes of course the disabled, and scaffolders can't get the bus. The rest of us, unless we live in the arse end of the arse end of beyond have options. Unless of course you live in the middle of the countryside with 3 children all going in opposite directions to school and parents who commute to the city, in which case I despise your choices. Do you think the climate crisis doesn't apply to you! Why don't you set up your life better!
@OakPine do you like having food to eat that's grown locally? As in - British food?

Because you've just said you despise people who live rurally. Like FARMERS

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/09/2021 08:15

@OakPine

I'm astounded that people have set up their lives so badly that they fall apart without a car. Yes of course the disabled, and scaffolders can't get the bus. The rest of us, unless we live in the arse end of the arse end of beyond have options. Unless of course you live in the middle of the countryside with 3 children all going in opposite directions to school and parents who commute to the city, in which case I despise your choices. Do you think the climate crisis doesn't apply to you! Why don't you set up your life better!
We moved very close to dh’s former employment. Trouble is they managed him out. So he got a job commensurate to his skills and experience. Trouble is, it’s 40ish miles away. Do you think he should have just stayed unemployed or we should have moved?

Moving away from the support structure I have set up in terms of physical treatment is not an option as I have a physical disability. Had he decided to be unemployed, we would have to move to a small house. Can you explain why we should have to do that because I’m ill?