Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say people are totally over reacting about the fuel issue

439 replies

TikTokNutcases · 27/09/2021 22:54

People adamant they can't go to work, so get a train.

Ride a bicycle.

Use the bus.

Talk of closing schools for god sake, whatever next.

It's ridiculous that people rely so heavily on the use of their car that life appears to stop still when they can't drive it.

You don't see this type of hysteria among non drivers, ever.

I don't drive and never have. I've never flapped like this about not being able to go to the supermarket, work etc.

OP posts:
TuftyMarmoset · 29/09/2021 16:29

All you need for public transport is the money for that journey. For a car you need to save hundreds or thousands up front. It's much more difficult to do that if you are scrabbling for money each week. Lessons are so expensive, you have to work 4+ hours as a teenager just to afford one hour lesson. It's just not an option for everyone.

FanGirlX · 29/09/2021 16:28

That's why rural parents focus so much on getting their children behind the wheel before they leave home. Most kids here have lessons as soon as they turn 17 and are on the road six months later - because their lives will be impossibly difficult if they don't learn or put it off until adulthood.

Most people get free lessons from parents first and then go to a driving instructor to learn how to pass their test. At least that's how things worked when I was learning.

icedcoffees · 29/09/2021 16:26

Imagine being on a strict budget and barely making ends meet. How do you then afford driving lessons, insurance, the purchase of a car. You can't. Saying 'public transport' is expensive isn't the answer. Public transport is the ONLY option to a lot of people and saving for a car WHILST HAVING to use public transport isn't possible.

That's why rural parents focus so much on getting their children behind the wheel before they leave home. Most kids here have lessons as soon as they turn 17 and are on the road six months later - because their lives will be impossibly difficult if they don't learn or put it off until adulthood.

Of course being an adult learner is different but that's why I think it should be a priority as a teenager/young person. It's much easier to pay for lessons and insurance/a car if you live at home and fund them out of your part-time job.

I see so many threads on here from adults whose lives are really bloody difficult because they don't drive and they really, really wish they'd done it sooner.

FanGirlX · 29/09/2021 16:24

It might be difficult to understand, but not everyone has the privilege to have had driving lessons (cost or time), and car ownership is as difficult financially as home ownership.

Can you show me where I can buy a house for £1,000? Appreciate there is insurance, tax, petrol maintenance involved in car ownership but public transport isn't free either.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 29/09/2021 16:24

[quote ivykaty44]@MolyHolyGuacamole

If someone doesn't want or need what you want, then you can have what they don't want, unless that is other do want what you want and get to it first[/quote]
Still don't know why you quoted me as what I said and what I replied to has nothing to do with wanting or not wanting something, it has to do with smugness and superiority

tabulahrasa · 29/09/2021 16:24

“you're over complicating the difference between a company van for a plumber and a family saloon car, for no actual reason”

I’m not - I’m pointing out that the company van for the plumber often doubles up as a family car... and in fact I know trades people who use an estate car instead and just take their tools out as well.

Because some people seem to think no fuel just means, find another way to take kids to school or commute on public transport when there an awful lot of people who literally can’t do their job without fuel.

Stellaris22 · 29/09/2021 16:22

I think a very key point is being missed here by a lot of people.

Imagine being on a strict budget and barely making ends meet. How do you then afford driving lessons, insurance, the purchase of a car. You can't. Saying 'public transport' is expensive isn't the answer. Public transport is the ONLY option to a lot of people and saving for a car WHILST HAVING to use public transport isn't possible.

Having access to a car yourself and the luxury of affording lessons doesn't equal people relying on public transport (and living in urban areas) as being rich or privileged.

FanGirlX · 29/09/2021 16:21

I live in greater Manchester and if you want to go to or from the city centre, the public transport is brilliant, but want to go round the outskirts and it's dreadful.

I agree and Manchester is a major city.

icedcoffees · 29/09/2021 16:20

@TuftyMarmoset

That doesn't make it not a luxury *@FanGirlX*. If anything it makes living rurally a luxury. If you couldn't afford a car or had a disability that meant you couldn't drive then you wouldn't be able to live in that place.
Many people who can't afford cars or who have disabilities live rurally, and do you know what? They struggle. Massively.

Public transport costs mean it's out of reach for many (especially families) so their lives are very limited.

They can't afford to move to the nearest town, either, because their rent/mortgage would nearly double. Rural poverty is a real issue for many people.

JoborPlay · 29/09/2021 16:19

[quote TuftyMarmoset]@fangirlx It simply isn't true that only London has good public transport. I live in a town and there are excellent buses here. We can't afford for me to run a car which means we can't afford to move more rurally which is what DP wants. I'm not saying that people who live rurally should give up their cars or move, what I'm saying is that actually some people can't afford them and by extension a lifestyle that requires one.[/quote]
And the public transport near me would cost me more than double the cost of running my car!

JoborPlay · 29/09/2021 16:18

[quote TuftyMarmoset]@fangirlx It simply isn't true that only London has good public transport. I live in a town and there are excellent buses here. We can't afford for me to run a car which means we can't afford to move more rurally which is what DP wants. I'm not saying that people who live rurally should give up their cars or move, what I'm saying is that actually some people can't afford them and by extension a lifestyle that requires one.[/quote]
But even in places with good public transport, it can still be a nightmare to use. I live in greater Manchester and if you want to go to or from the city centre, the public transport is brilliant, but want to go round the outskirts and it's dreadful.

icedcoffees · 29/09/2021 16:15

It is a luxury. You might not view it as one, but it's an expensive asset that not everyone is able to afford.

It's often much, much cheaper to own and run a car than it is to ferry a family around using a mixture of bike, taxi, bus and train, though.

We have no bus station, a train line that only goes in one direction and no taxis unless you book weeks/months in advance (and you won't get one at all during rush hour).

It is much, much more convenient (and cheaper) to run a car than it is to try and get around on the train.

My old commute to work was a great example. £35 worth of petrol got me to and from work each week - a journey of around 45 minutes each way. To do the same journey by public transport would take at least three HOURS each way, and would cost £40 per person, per day.

I remember googling it once when my car was in the garage - it would have involved getting up for work at 5am, I'd then have arrived for work over an hour late, and would have needed to leave again two hours later in order to arrive back home on the same day Grin

TuftyMarmoset · 29/09/2021 16:14

@fangirlx It simply isn't true that only London has good public transport. I live in a town and there are excellent buses here. We can't afford for me to run a car which means we can't afford to move more rurally which is what DP wants. I'm not saying that people who live rurally should give up their cars or move, what I'm saying is that actually some people can't afford them and by extension a lifestyle that requires one.

FanGirlX · 29/09/2021 16:14

Living rurally isn't the excuse you think it is. Living rurally is an option when you can drive and have ready access to a car.

So people who grow up rurally should move to cities as soon as they are able and give up their local jobs in agriculture, as carers, police, teachers? Who should do these jobs instead? Or should we just abandon huge parts of the country and cram people into cities?

FanGirlX · 29/09/2021 16:12

If you didn't have a car would you be living rurally?

That's the first time I've heard suburban Manchester described as rural Grin

FanGirlX · 29/09/2021 16:11

It is a luxury. You might not view it as one, but it's an expensive asset that not everyone is able to afford.

DPs sister is a carer she drives around in a 12 year old Honda, worth less than a grand. She needs it for work. She earns NMW.

Not every car on the road is a brand new luxury car. This is particularly noticeable in rural areas.

Stellaris22 · 29/09/2021 16:10

Living rurally isn't the excuse you think it is. Living rurally is an option when you can drive and have ready access to a car.

It might be difficult to understand, but not everyone has the privilege to have had driving lessons (cost or time), and car ownership is as difficult financially as home ownership.

If you didn't have a car would you be living rurally?

And bus services outside of London are actually quite good. Not giving away where I live, but bus services are perfectly usable.

Stellaris22 · 29/09/2021 16:00

@FanGirlX

It's easy to forget car ownership is a luxury.

Not if you live rurally with limited / no public transport.

It is a luxury. You might not view it as one, but it's an expensive asset that not everyone is able to afford.
FanGirlX · 29/09/2021 15:58

@TuftyMarmoset

That doesn't make it not a luxury *@FanGirlX*. If anything it makes living rurally a luxury. If you couldn't afford a car or had a disability that meant you couldn't drive then you wouldn't be able to live in that place.
Actually, living in London with good public transport is a luxury. You either have to be a high earner or have won the council house lottery to be able to afford the rent / mortgage.

Only London has a good public transport network. I live in suburban Manchester and while getting into the city is easy on public transport, getting around the suburbs without a car isn't easy. I'm going out for dinner tonight in a suburb that is about a 15 minute drive away. If I wanted to go by public transport I would have to go into the city and out again making it a 1 hour journey. The same thing applies to my job, I would have to take the metrolink and then 2 trains to get there on public transport, which would double my commute time.

I grew up rurally and a car is essential. If everyone who currently lives rurally got rid of their car and moved to London, who would do the essential jobs rurally like teaching, care work, policing? Do you consider people doing these jobs and earning lower than average salaries to be living in luxury because they own a car to get to work? You realise not every car is brand new Audi don't you? Plenty of older cars on the roads in rural areas.

TuftyMarmoset · 29/09/2021 15:48

That doesn't make it not a luxury @FanGirlX. If anything it makes living rurally a luxury. If you couldn't afford a car or had a disability that meant you couldn't drive then you wouldn't be able to live in that place.

FanGirlX · 29/09/2021 15:32

It's easy to forget car ownership is a luxury.

Not if you live rurally with limited / no public transport.

CynsterBitch · 29/09/2021 15:30

I don’t live super rurally, but without my car i couldn’t Get to work. It takes 30 min to drive, there are no buses to take me from my town to work town (or nearrby), train would take about 2hrs each way (3xhsnges)
Cycling would be possible but iy’s along a busy (and frankly scary) A road so not really for me.
If i was still a non driver none of this would be a problem though but that’s because i would never have got a job in the same location

People’s needs are different, this should not be hard to understand

marchingtotheend2021 · 29/09/2021 15:06

When people become so reliant on a car and suddenly you can't use it is a massive pita! I was like you once couldn't/ didn't want too drive always used to say oh ill just get a train or a bus or whatever. So much more freedom with a car even though it most times comes with a big cost, I couldn't dream of not having one now. Obviously some people are quiet happy to live the lifestyle car free etc everyone has options/different ways of transporting them self's around. Smile

ivykaty44 · 29/09/2021 15:01

Newkitchen123

why would it matter which brand of supermarket the op shops at?

ivykaty44 · 29/09/2021 14:58

tabulahrasa

you're over complicating the difference between a company van for a plumber and a family saloon car, for no actual reason

Swipe left for the next trending thread