Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say people are totally over reacting about the fuel issue

439 replies

TikTokNutcases · 27/09/2021 22:54

People adamant they can't go to work, so get a train.

Ride a bicycle.

Use the bus.

Talk of closing schools for god sake, whatever next.

It's ridiculous that people rely so heavily on the use of their car that life appears to stop still when they can't drive it.

You don't see this type of hysteria among non drivers, ever.

I don't drive and never have. I've never flapped like this about not being able to go to the supermarket, work etc.

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 28/09/2021 08:13

So @ivykaty44 if all suddenly started using bikes, trailers, electric cars and public transport, have you thought about how the current infrastructure will cope?

people already use all these modes of transport? The roads are paid for by everyone paying council tax and paye, and motorways are paid fr by central government

poshme · 28/09/2021 08:12

@TikTokNutcases

Was it car drivers bulk buying toilet roll and pasta?

Most probably, given the over reaction I'm seeing from the people for whom this is only a mild inconvenience at best.

I don't doubt that for some people it could be extremely problematic should it continue for too long, this example being one of them:

The only person I know who is really fretting has a husband who is extremely unwell in hospital, while she can get public transport it's an hour each way, not awful as a general rule but awful when you are absolutely desperate to get their quick and are a teary emotional wreck.

But in general, most people can manage without the use of their car for a couple of days.

Actually most people can't survive without their cars for a few days where I live.

Nearest station? 9 miles
Buses to station? NO
nearest bus stop? 2 miles
To get my 3 kids to their schools by public transport would take nearly 1.5 hours (bus into town, change bus, bus to school 1, bus to school 2)
Then a bus to my work place- another 30 minutes. So I'd leave home at 7, take 2 hours travelling and get to work late. Then leave home early to do it in reverse.
OP does you job just allow you to reduce your hours like that?

My parents (in their 70s) live 7 miles from the nearest shop. There is NO bus. The nearest station is 15 miles. Do you suggest they walk?

PrincessPaws · 28/09/2021 08:11

A 20 minute drive to work would require a 2 hour journey on several (unreliable) buses, or 2.5 hours on trains (going into, across and out of the nearest big city) costing approx £40 one way. YABU and a bit naive to think it is so easy everywhere

ToykotoLosAngeles · 28/09/2021 08:11

I used to work in Frome with colleagues 12 miles away in Shepton Mallet. Both small north Somerset towns so hardly the arse end of nowhere. The nearest train station to SM is 7 miles away and the last bus out used to be 5.20 when we finished at 5.30. There are whole counties where, if you don't drive, you have the choice of working in 2 cities and have to live along the one train line.

maddening · 28/09/2021 08:11

Whilst there are some people who have been badly affected I think the majority are quite enjoying the panic, it was just like in the food panic buying of 2020, I was in an aisle with yes shelves that were not stacked.high, bit there was meat on the shelves, plenty of choice and a.lady said to her friend, "omg there is NO meat! Everyone is so SELFISH" and in the sandwich meat section which had plenty another man shouted at his wife that it is "ridiculous, everyone is so SELFISH there is no corned beef and stormed off" I pointed.the corned beef out to her. There was genuinely plenty of food, yes there had been a run on some items in the canned aisle but most shelves had plenty available, but people were going round sounding like an outraged daily mail piece. I think they enjoyed being part of this crisis, and I def get the feel of that.at the moment. And in doing so they are impacting genuine cases and causing some actual harm.

ivykaty44 · 28/09/2021 08:10

Yesterday rainy morning there was much more school run traffic than usual. We all know people who might usually walk places but will Not walk in the rain

but just because you don't walk in the rain doesn't mean you drive every day - a happy medium, and if people walk 4 days and drive one - thats much better for fuel consumption

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/09/2021 08:10

Yes it is @LST

Xenia · 28/09/2021 08:10

My son lives in the countryside (city house prices were too high) and he had to scrap his car earlier this month. He has not bought another yet as they are very expensive. He is cycling at the moment and he drives a work van delivering food for a living (full time PAYE employee) - he is a fit young man but he finishes his shift after mid night and is now cycling on unlit roads for miles every night up to 1am. I don't think that is very safe and I hope he replaces the car.

Not everyone is rich enough to live in cities or near a bus!

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/09/2021 08:10

So @ivykaty44 if all suddenly started using bikes, trailers, electric cars and public transport, have you thought about how the current infrastructure will cope?

And where will they obtain said bikes, trailers and cars… let alone the various vehicles used for public transport? We are in the middle of a pandemic and your suggestion would cause all manner of logistical issues from acquirement of raw materials to production and transport when the world is already not coping with current demand.

LST · 28/09/2021 08:09

@Stellaris22

I agree with you OP and the nasty bullying you are getting is just people being defensive about their lifestyle choices.

Yes, NHS staff are going to need their car. Your average person being this reliant on private car use not so much.

I've lived very rurally as a child, I'd cycle 15 mins and get a train to school or to go meet friends. I don't buy that this isn't possible for adults.

A lot of people don't have cars because, like house ownership, it just isn't financially possible. Even driving lessons are unaffordable. It is possible to be a non driver and function perfectly fine. It's not being smug, it's being practical.

To say you can't do a combination of walking/public transport isn't true, it requires more planning, but it's not impossible.

Brilliant being able bodied isn't it
OakPine · 28/09/2021 08:09

I'm astounded that people have set up their lives so badly that they fall apart without a car.
Yes of course the disabled, and scaffolders can't get the bus.
The rest of us, unless we live in the arse end of the arse end of beyond have options.
Unless of course you live in the middle of the countryside with 3 children all going in opposite directions to school and parents who commute to the city, in which case I despise your choices. Do you think the climate crisis doesn't apply to you! Why don't you set up your life better!

Underamour · 28/09/2021 08:09

80% of people live in or around cities with good public transport.

Stellaris22 · 28/09/2021 08:09

I agree with you OP and the nasty bullying you are getting is just people being defensive about their lifestyle choices.

Yes, NHS staff are going to need their car. Your average person being this reliant on private car use not so much.

I've lived very rurally as a child, I'd cycle 15 mins and get a train to school or to go meet friends. I don't buy that this isn't possible for adults.

A lot of people don't have cars because, like house ownership, it just isn't financially possible. Even driving lessons are unaffordable. It is possible to be a non driver and function perfectly fine. It's not being smug, it's being practical.

To say you can't do a combination of walking/public transport isn't true, it requires more planning, but it's not impossible.

Brokeandtired3 · 28/09/2021 08:08

*You don't see this type of hysteria among non drivers, ever.”

Well yes, but presumably non drivers don’t take on jobs that have driving as an essential part of role?...*

Loool this. This alone. It's easy to pick back relax and watch the chaos unfold when you dont have a job that solely depends on driving. So you do you op. But just because you dont understand it doesnt mean people are being irrational.

You say you get that ambulances, delivery drivers ect need fuel for majority of the big services to keep running yet your original post was to go on about how the world would seemingly end and tried to make a point that that is ridiculous. But it's the truth and even you have acknowledged that. So to answer your post yes without driving lots of things wouldnt be available and people would rightfully so be stressed. Give over with your biggot attitude towards it all because you are a "non driver"

Sally090807 · 28/09/2021 08:07

This thread is clearly a wind up. From a safety aspect I would not want to finish a late shift somewhere rural and then walk home for miles. Many buses to our local villages stop at around 5.30pm.

The OP probably sits home all day stoking their cat waiting for the Waitrose food delivery van.

Imnothereforthedrama · 28/09/2021 08:05

People are overreacting and it’s the media fault again . Yes there is a shortage of drivers and yes there has been a supply shortage for a few weeks for certain but we’ve not all rushed out buying certain things .
We had the same at the start of pandemic with toilet rolls , bread , medicines etc but was quickly rectified it was a mass panic short term problem that suppliers couldn’t keep up with demand. If people just got their fuel as normal the last few days fuel stations wouldn’t have had to close . I suspect most people that filled up last few days won’t need to for a bit so I think this next few days will quieten down .
There is a problem of course but I doubt it will be we run out completely. But typical mumsnet if your not running around panicking your denying there is a problem which is not true it’s how you handle it . It’s the same with Covid if your not panicking about the cases rising your a Covid denier .
The cynic in me is this whole ‘fuel crisis’ has deflected media attention away from Covid .

DroopyClematis · 28/09/2021 08:03

Just hanging around to see more gobshite from OP.
Doubt they will be back now.

Onairjunkie · 28/09/2021 08:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

tigger1001 · 28/09/2021 08:03

It really can't be so hard to understand that different people have different transport needs and different areas have very different public transport provisions.

I cannot get a bus to work. There simply isn't one. I could spend an hour getting the bus to the train station then wait for the train. But I would be hours late for work every day. Despite it only taking 30 minutes to drive.

The kids get the school bus though as their school is 10 miles away and on a main busy road with no cycle path.

If I lived somewhere with a great public transport system I would happily use it, but for lots of people that simply isn't the case.

lljkk · 28/09/2021 08:03

A lot of people could try a lot harder to be less dependent on their cars. This would help everyone -- improve air quality and make journeys faster for people who must depend on their cars.

I dunno why so many people don't want to less dependent on their cars. They don't think about public transport or walking distances when deciding what job to take or where to live, they just plan to use their car. I meet people all the time who could live anywhere but moved to this area from many miles away, knowing their job is 1 hour drive away from new home, and with no personal links here: they moved here simply because they "like" this village. So then they get locked into a car-dependent lifestyle.

Yesterday rainy morning there was much more school run traffic than usual. We all know people who might usually walk places but will Not walk in the rain.

My corner shop: I recognise a lot of customers in their cars there as people who live within half a mile of the shop. Leaving the car empty and engine idling if it's before 7am

My mother used to drive to the store quarter mile away -- she was simply too lazy to walk.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 28/09/2021 08:02

Many bus drivers use....cars to get to work! You only need a few off to really disrupt services.

Same with train drivers

Same with delivery/lorry drivers who need fuel to even move at all

That's without even going into emergency services

I agree that many people can cycle or walk and don't, but you can't suggest public transport as a solution to not having petrol or cars because they depend on them!

FirewomanSam · 28/09/2021 08:02

I’m a non driver too and I’m still affected because the queues for petrol around here are so bad they’re holding up traffic, which means buses aren’t going anywhere either.

I agree that people need to calm down because it’s the panic buying that’s actually causing the problems now, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t currently genuine problems for people trying to get around, be it by car or public transport!

ivykaty44 · 28/09/2021 08:00

Onairjunkie

im sorry to hear your father is having cancer treatment

perhaps if everyone hadn't over reacted then your father wouldn't be house bound as petrol would be plentiful

supermoonrising · 28/09/2021 08:00

OP' post is obviously a bit silly and OTT, though our society is obviously dysfunctional in some aspects with regards to over reliance on millions of people hauling themselves 50 miles to work and back every day, children all being carted on the >1 mile school run etc.
The one that makes me puzzled is why the majority of teachers seem to insist on living "wherever their school isn't", I choosing to live in a town 10-20 miles away when the town in which the school is based is equally nice and equally affordable.

wombat1a · 28/09/2021 07:59

Nearest train station is 18 miles away, one train each direction every hour. Four busses out a day - one direction only, out at 7am, 10am, 2pm and 4pm. In at 10am, 2pm, 4pm and 6pm.

Cycling not really an option as the roads are too narrow, dark and potholed.