Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is an exercise in trying to control and punish ME and nothing to do with the children

65 replies

Morefuelyou · 27/09/2021 22:50

Long story short I have four DC . 15, 10, 8 and 7 with my exH. We split over 3 years ago. He has convictions and cautions for domestic violence against me and after we split was subject to a 12 month non mol.

He pays maintenance each week without fail. Since the day we split he has never had the children overnight. On a few occasions he's bee asked . Once when I was in hospital and another time when I had no gas or electricity in the house for a 24 hour period. Both times he refused and questioned why an elderly relative of mine who lives an hours drive from me couldn't look after them instead .

I have never stopped him seeing the children. In lockdown he met someone online and moved in with her and her child 7 months into the relationship. She has never met me and has only met my children twice both times on a day out. None of us know his address. I should also add when he moved in with her he moved 100 miles away from them.

This year when we had the January lockdown he used covid and not wanting to mix households as a reason not to see tjem (he his new gf her daughter , me or my children - none of us are clinically vulnerable in any way) and contact between separated parents was also permitted during the lockdowns. Anyhow....

He didn't see them between new year and the middle of April. Nor did he telephone or facetime them during that time it was basically radio silence

A couple of months ago he decided to allow the new girlfriend to call our 15 year old up one night and spend 20 mins being rude and abusive about me, my parenting and the children. She claims they have been turned against him by me. And all kinds of things. Says the children should have called him and he's entitled to his own life which is why they don't do overnights.

Following this phonecall which my son recorded my son blocked his dad and so did I as he was sending rude messages to me . All of my children said at the moment they didn't want to see him. They were very upset. My youngest was crying at bedtimes to sleep and my 10 year old started bed wetting.

I conveyed this to their dad and said I would see if they wanted to facetime at some stage when they felt happier and see where we went from there. Two weeks later they spoke on the phone.

Then this weekend he turned up and knocked on the door without any warning (his parents can still contact my eldest . He has my email address, he could have written a letter.

Basically he's decided he wants pursue court action against me. He said about mediation first (I have looked into it and am fully aware due to previous DV that mediation isn't suitable. 2 days ago he emailed me stuff from the mediation person he made enquiries with along with details of all the costs a copy of a c100 form and so on

Also now aware due to the DV I may well be eligible for legal aid . I work full time but on a low income topped up with UC .

I was still fair and I replied to the email reminding him I have never said he can't see them simply that they didn't want to at the moment, they were very upset and I wasn't about to hurry and force them to go out with him before they were ready.

I offered him every other Saturday between 8.30 and 6pm

Reminded him he would need to factor in taking our 10 year old to football training

Asked that they were fed both lunch and dinner before being returned as many times he brought them home having not been fed dinner

And I offered every Wednesday evening between 5.30 and 8pm where he could take them for dinner

I have in the past said he can see them at mu house even offering to go out. He refuses . He refuses them overnight. He didn't speak to them in 4 months. I have suggested that contact schedule and hes now refused that and says no I will be seeing you in court

This isn't about the kids at all is it ? This is a man who was violent and controlling. Who turned threatening when I dared to file for divorce trying to get at me and control me again using the kids isn't it. All backed up by his family. His mum his new girlfriend. She knows about the violence and told my child on the phone these things happen in relationships and he wouldn't have hit your mum without a bloody good reason.

Disgusting what he's doing and the way he's allowing this woman to speak about me and my lovely children

OP posts:
CityMumma78 · 28/09/2021 11:49

Fantastic email OP.

RealBecca · 28/09/2021 11:35

I would seriously consider reporting his abuse to the police, applying for a restraining order and asking the police if they can notify girlfriend of Claires Law.

timeisnotaline · 28/09/2021 11:32

Great email op.

IntermittentParps · 28/09/2021 11:25

I think the fact that you've had no response means he was just posturing (for the new girlfriend, I agree with others) and now he's seen it all in black and white he's realised he's on a hiding to nothing and a solicitor would probably tell him he's no chance in court.
I think and hope he'll drop it.
Well done with your email, OP.

BananaPB · 28/09/2021 10:22

I think you should stop chasing him and contacting him now. By chasing him, there will be a part of him that just wants to piss you off and keep you hanging and under his control so he'll do the opposite just to spite you without realising that the kids are the ones that will be hurt.

Send one final short message telling him that he can contact you if he wants to see the kids then wait to see if he starts the legal process.

FWIW the 15 year old will be deemed old enough to decide whether or not to see Dad.

bibliomania · 28/09/2021 10:21

You're doing the right things. Sit tight and wait for him to go to court. Don't rise to any provocation - he will try so he can get something from you in writing that makes you sound unreasonable. Blandness is your friend.

I can't see any judge being impressed by him. You're actually in a very strong position - you just have to protect your own wellbeing so you don't feel ground down by it.

Brollywasntneededafterall · 28/09/2021 10:12

Imo it is quite common for exes to start stirring when they get a new gf.. She will be hearing his side only. Amazing you have kept such diligent records of his behaviour.. It will serve your case very well in the unlikely event you get to court...
A judge would likely see absolutely no wrong doing on your side.. I would love to be a fly on the court wall hearing his logic behind not seeing /speaking to or wanting dc overnight....
Keep him blocked in all ways op. Personally I wouldn't give him or his threats a second thought...

mamaoffourdc · 28/09/2021 10:12

Great email and well done for documenting everything x

Lockdownbear · 28/09/2021 10:09

Op given he's been so abusive to you in the past I'd let him fight for access.

I actually question are the kids actually safe with him. Reality is he's putting on a show for the gf and trying to make you out to be the bad one.

Morefuelyou · 28/09/2021 10:03

With all of those factors in mind I am astonished at your urgency to bring court action . Again I remind you that you didn't speak to them once in the first four months of this year !!

Secondly if you have read the attached guidance from the mediator you will see that mediation is not an option in cases where there's been documented domestic abuse.

To recap:

1 conviction for common assault and battery
1 caution for common assault
1 caution for malicious communications
1 Non molestation order which was breached by yourself on two occasions

With all of those factors in mind I propose the following .

  1. Contact every other Saturday between 08.30 and 18.00 (9th October, 23rd October )

And

One evening a week on a Wednesday between 18.00-20.30 (6th October, 13 October, 20 October, 27 October)

  1. X trains for football on a Saturday morning and his matches are played on Sundays . Therefore you will need to factor in taking him to training with the other children between 09.00 and 10.30 on contact days. Training is held in Y PLACE and there is ample free parking onsite
  1. Due to several instances where they were brought home having not been provided with an evening meal they should each be provided with BOTH lunch AND dinner prior to being dropped back to me
  1. None of them will be allowed any form of energy drink or drink containing caffeine as its caused episodes of ill health previously . Eg monster, boost, red bull and such like
  1. Due to the tone and nature of the messages received from you previously all contact from now on will be between ourselves via email at xxxxxx
All messages are synced to my mobile so I have easy access to them
  1. At the time of writing eldest child does NOT wish to have any contact with you either in person or via telephone text message , wattsapp social media etc and this includes contact visits . He does however wish to maintain contact with other members of your family provided you are not in attendance at any point. This will be arranged directly with your mother subject to her availability
  1. The other children will be asked and have the option to chose whether they go out with you on a meet by meet basis according to their wishes
  1. Following the two occasions (new girlfriends name) met them without them being asked if they were happy with it or told she would be present and then later the phone call from her during which the children became very distressed both they and I request she has no contact with them with immediate effect either in person or via telephone text message , wattsapp etc .
  1. Your address details will be provided
  1. You will not come to my home address at any time other than for picking up or returning of the children unless agreed in advance via email

I am confident you will find this more than agreeable and I await your response.

OP posts:
Morefuelyou · 28/09/2021 09:58

@CityMumma78

Hes blocked on mine and my sons phone
I have said email contact only and stated its synced to my phone so I receive all emails

I also stipulated various terms including the need for him to provide an address where he is living

I will edit any identifying details out and copy the email here

OP posts:
CityMumma78 · 28/09/2021 08:43

I would block him on your phone and the kids phones and request all communication is done via email. Also make it explicit clear (on email) that firstly you don’t have an address for hun yet he is able to turn up unannounced to your home and that is to stop. EVERYTHING he is doing is about control, you are no longer with him and don’t have to put up with his shit. All emails are dates and will provide evidence of communication. Please don’t bow down to him and let him get away with this behaviour and protect your kids. Best of luck xx

OldEvilOwl · 28/09/2021 08:40

Tell him you will see him in court. I would bet money on it that he doesn't go through with it. He sounds like a waste of space

Boombadoom · 28/09/2021 08:04

Court will take way over a year. Let him take you.

lifehappened · 28/09/2021 06:17

He doesn't stand a chance. Stupid prick! I know a couple like this and am so sickened that they exist. What the fuck happens to turn them into these vile excuse for humans. Hope you get sorted. You're doing a great job by the sounds of it

RudestLittleMadam · 28/09/2021 05:25

YANBU- this is all about him and his obsession with controlling you, not about seeing his kids. It sounds like you know what you’re doing (like never doing mediation with an abuser). All I would say is keep everything so if he does take it to court they can see not only the abuse he and his girlfriend have chucked around but also what you have already offered and he’s rejected.

His girlfriend at first glance is vile, saying those horrible things to a child but also has victim written all over her: she thinks behaviour like your ex’s is totally reasonable. Her children may well grow up being taught and believing the same. That’s fucking tragic. Thank god your children have you setting them an example.

Sparklfairy · 28/09/2021 04:58

Its great you have evidence of all texts and WhatsApps etc. The only advice I can add is save all of these in a separate place I.e. screenshot and email them to yourself or upload to the cloud. Itll be sod's law your phone will break or die and you could lose this. Same with the recording of the girlfriend, just to be safe!

Let him go to court. Most of the time these men are all bluff and bluster and its pure bullying tactics. I'm sorry you and your DC are going through this, especially your eldest. Its really horrible to come to the realisation that your dad is a cunt, I was twice his age before I accepted it Flowers

SherryPalmer · 28/09/2021 04:09

Him telling your son about your previous sex work is perfect evidence that he is willing to harm your kids to hurt you.

I don’t think court is going to go the way he wants it to.

timeisnotaline · 28/09/2021 02:52

‘Ok’ would be the only appropriate response.
Perhaps
‘Ok, but in the interim if you do want to see your children I will need a minimum of a weeks notice and of course they may be busy as you have refused any regular schedule. Also as I’ve said I certainly can’t make the older children see you if they don’t want to.

VelvetChairGirl · 28/09/2021 01:02

god you really are falling for it hook line and sinker arent you.

first off tell him to get lost and your see him in court, if the kids hate him and are upset you shouldnt be offering him any kinds of visits or contact, let him take you to court if he has the balls, with his track record, your evidence and their feelings he hasnt got a leg to stand on.

this is all playing up for the new victim until hes got her ground down enough to control, he has painted himself as the victim and has to go along with it, he doesnt give a stuff about you or the kids, he gives a stuff about giving her the right impression as the wronged victim woe is him, she is going to help the poor soul see his kids and get justice, he has lied his way into a corner.

what he really hopes is that you will do as you are told, he really isnt interested in court, he is interested in getting the kids to make a good impression it'll last five minutes and then he will slink into the shadows again perhaps leaving her to act as parent.

I wouldnt let either of them near the kids if I was you ones, toxic the other is poisoned, both will be psychologically abusing the kids with BS, have you tried talking to womens Aid for advice.

TheChip · 28/09/2021 00:37

I dont think he will get anywhere with the courts.
Let him try. What you have offered is more than the courts would grant considering how little effort he has made.

His girlfriend is probably questioning how and why he doesn't see his kids, and he is running out of excuses to blame you. She's probably telling him that he needs to take you to court and he is now out of excuses and has no other choice but to at least pretend to go down that route, so to not show himself as the dick he actually is.

Makes sense really now that covid is out of the way. He probably milked that for as long as he could as an excuse with his girlfriend.

PanicPrevention · 28/09/2021 00:35

God I hate men like this.
So entitled and so useless at the same time.
Your poor eldest has had to wise up to that fact, can feel like a win in someways but nobody wants to realise their father is a raging prick.
Just be there for them and ingnore dickheads antics as much as possible.
Sorry you are going through this op these men make me sick.

PanicPrevention · 28/09/2021 00:30

I will bet my life savings this prick wont be taking you to court.
A man who wont even call or FaceTime his own kids for 4 months?.
This is all for the new girlfriends benefit and as you've worked out, to get to you.
Wait for a letter from the court.
Kids are available for more than reasonable contact.
You've done your bit let him do what he wants to next.
Im guessing he will make a tit of himself one way or the other.
But he wont be paying out in money time and effort to get the contact you're already offering .

Morefuelyou · 28/09/2021 00:14

Yes have all texts , wattsapps every visit arranged. If he's brought them back with no dinner a message asking why they have not been fed. So there's been a paper trail and I have gathered evidence for years now and covered every incident . I have never ever said he can't see them. This is the first time in 19 years he's ever been blocked. He can email me . He could have written a letter . His mother can still contact my son and could easily have said can you ask your mum to contact me.. but nope nothing.

OP posts:
Feedingthebirds1 · 28/09/2021 00:09

x post, sorry. You DO have the evidence. Good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread