Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Horrible abusers in the music industry - R Kelly verdict [title edit by MNHQ]

170 replies

RickJames · 27/09/2021 21:17

Well, R Kelly is off to jail. Thank goodness. He was evil! But he made some great music. Like Chris Brown, Michael Jackson and to a certain extent James Brown. Ike Turner, Phil Spector, Gary Glitter.. even David Bowie was after it in the 60's. Jon Bonham they were all at it. Either or both abuse of women and children. Even that chap from Kasabian beat his wife up. It seems to be a thing. Loads more examples possible.

AIBU to expect that despite the enjoyable music they created/ sang on they shouldn't be played on commercial/ public radio anymore. Maybe if we protested then (im not innocent, I know it would be purely for the money) record companies would insist on non-criminal behaviour. In much the same way that say, for example, Siemens or Haringey Council would as employers.

Part of me feels like the music should stand for its musical value. A larger part of me feels like 'this is why we can't have nice things' and we shouldn't tolerate any part of their legacies.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Mantlemoose · 28/09/2021 08:16

And come on, just because someone is good at something doesnt mean they are perfect. Imagine, David Johnson is such an excellent gas boiler fitter, all his crimes against children are rendered null, let's celebrate Dave! It just wouldn't happen!

Umm, my plumber actually is called David Johnson, assuming you've just made up that name? Like Joe Bloggs or Freddy Pumpernickle?

Marguerite2000 · 28/09/2021 08:12

@RickJames

David Bowie (and his wife at the time), apparently, had a 14 year old girlfriend. It's fairly well documented although when I googled, some Internet scrubbing seems to have taken place.

He also went through a phase of keeping all his wee in the fridge but I suppose he was only hurting himself with this habit. I believe it was when he lived with Iggy Pop in Berlin.

Iggy's MN AIBU would have been fantastic- AIBU to think my flatmate shouldn't be using our fridge to store his wee?

You do realise you're just repeating a load of scrambled up gossip here? That's why you think the internet was 'scrubbed'. It's a shame people can't stick to actual established facts.when it comes to sexual offences. R Kelly, Gary Glitter and Ian Watkins were properly investigated and convicted. That's why they were banged up, and David Bowie wasn't.
PinkDahlias · 28/09/2021 08:08

For years, I’ve shuddered at the intro to R. Kelly’s ‘Bump and Grind’.

“My minds telling me no
But my body…
My body’s telling me yes”
🤮🤮🤮

zafferana · 28/09/2021 08:07

There is a documentary on Sky at the moment called Look Away about the sexual abuse of women and girls in the music industry in the 1970s and 1980s - Steve Tyler and Axl Rose don't come out of it looking good at all, plus others. Give people a bit of power and influence, access to young women and girls, and an industry that's making huge amounts of money and it's a recipe for disaster. I'm just sad it took so long to bring R. Kelly to justice - his crimes have been well known for a good decade or two at this point.

Orpheline · 28/09/2021 08:06

@StylishMummy

I would ban their music from being paid and also pay a portion of royalties to rape/victim charities.

Women-only music is clearly the way forward, Aretha Franklin never raped anyone

I've just seen her bio film, Respect. I was shocked to see that she was being raped by one of her churches gospel singers, and had her first of 2 children with him when she was about 12. Her preacher father seemed to turn a blind eye.
AtillatheHun · 28/09/2021 08:02

@WotgunShedding there was a big furore over a G Glitter song being used in Batman (?) a few years back. Turned out that he didn’t receive a penny anyway based on the deals he’d done previously. There are of course a lot of band members / c writers who suffer badly from that approach too - I have felt very sorry indeed for the othe members of Lost Prophets who must need a lot of therapy to deal with having lived so closely with Watkins (not that they can actually afford it on the basis of having had their income entirely cut off). Poor sods. They must have lived cheek by jowl on tours for years.

RickJames · 28/09/2021 08:01

@AtillatheHun

Good point. I think how I see music as different is that with books or movies or consumer products, I actively choose to engage with them. So if I read Orwell, I know he was "a nasty fucker" and I'm mentally prepared for that. Or I just don't read it if its too obnoxious for me.

Music gets blasted at me in shops, on TV commercials, sports events etc. I often don't get a choice. I've chosen to go and buy a pint of milk or watch a football match but I haven't chosen or consented to have to listen to Gary Glitter or MJ.

Maybe a compromise could be keeping the music out of public broadcasting but still being available to buy for those who don't mind about the crimes. In much the same way that many dodgy books are available to buy but not really spoken about or promoted.

OP posts:
faithfulbird20 · 28/09/2021 07:59

Yeah shouldn't be played. I shudder every time I hear Michael Jackson's crap.

jillandhersprite · 28/09/2021 07:58

@ohfook

It's a hard one. I stopped listening to the lost prophets after it all came out about Ian Watkins. I loved that first album but I couldn't see past the crime if that makes sense - and I do understand that it's unfair to the other people who made the album but it's marred for me now. Yet I do still listen to The Rum Jacks.

I think I agree with you, but I know I'm guilty (with the rum jacks) of separating the art from the artist too. I wonder if subconsciously it's because of how I view the different crimes - ie paedophilia in unacceptable but dv is a bit more common place? Either way I think your point is interesting and valid and has given me a bit of food for thought.

I also mourn the fact I can't listen to the Lost Prophets anymore - I loved that album so much and agree that perhaps its the nature of the crime that for me makes me unable to separate it as art and i don't wish to listen to it anymore. Which is strange because I don't have quite the same revulsion hearing Billie Jean and yet MJ was accused of similar crimes - is it because he wasn't convicted, but then you feel was that to do with money and power talking... Or is it because establishment is comfortable with MJ and continue to play it so I don't feel the same revulson as I do with Lost Prophets I don't know the answer to this issue - but it does make me feel uncomfortable and it should be discussed like this
QueenOfCatan · 28/09/2021 07:56

I was talking about this with my sister the other day and reading interesting conversations on comments sections of social media regarding Ian Watkins. I think lost prophets is the only band I absolutely cannot listen to and will turn off if they come on (unlikely though). I loved them when I was younger, but I cannot disassociate the music from Watkins. I'm not comfortable with some others but it's not at the forefront of my mind when the music starts iyswim?

AtillatheHun · 28/09/2021 07:48

Are we going to “lift the lid” on tv presenters and ban those great bastards because of Jimmy saville, frank bough and his coke n jokers, Ant and his “prescription” drugs and drink driving, Philip Schofield etc etc?

WotgunShedding · 28/09/2021 07:47

*They’re

WotgunShedding · 28/09/2021 07:47

Is there a case to be made for avoiding abuser products while they’re alive but then resuming use once their dead?

This would avoid them profiting off their music, art etc during their lifetimes but then also allows for music etc to be enjoyed. As a previous poster said, lots of artists have had unsavoury lives and committed abuse and crimes so would this drawing of a line allow a compromise?

BettysGotMoxie · 28/09/2021 07:46

@isleofrum I think the difference is that the Weinstein connection isn’t instantly visible in the same way. He’s not actually in the films.

AtillatheHun · 28/09/2021 07:45

@longwayoff do you work in the music industry? (The BBC have been trying for over a year to make a follow up to their music industry expose. They have tried and tried to dig dirt and didn’t manage to get anything- hundreds of women lying and too scared to talk about what happened 20 years ago, or the reality doesn’t fit the narrative?)

SmallPrawnEnergy · 28/09/2021 07:45

I think if you banned bands who had committed dodgy acts you’d have very little music to chose from, underage groupies were / still are a frequent occurrence for many many bands, especially in the 70s.

RickJames · 28/09/2021 07:45

@CanofCant

That's incredible. Really disappointing attitude.

OP posts:
AtillatheHun · 28/09/2021 07:43

Weinstein was a producer. It’s hardly his creative legacy, so you’d be cutting off the income and air from the people who actually made it because of who funded it. And then you’re of course not driving a Mercedes,using BASF tapes or chemicals, buying Bally shoes etc. Samuel Pepys and George Orwell were pretty awful fuckers. Are we burning books too?

longwayoff · 28/09/2021 07:42

All heroes have feet of clay. If the lid ever comes off the music industry it will make all other scandals look like a walk in the park.

IsleofRum · 28/09/2021 07:40

And yet we see movies by Weinstein. No banning, no withdrawal, no removal odd, no?

BlakeDreary · 28/09/2021 07:38

newspunch.com/tom-jones-rape/

Not sure what came about from the investigation. Most probably "lack of evidence" as usual!!

CanofCant · 28/09/2021 07:38

The new head at our local school was all set to use one of R Kelly's songs (while he was awaiting trial) as their school anthem, having the children learn the lyrics and sing it at assembly until parents starting complaining.

The head sent the worst non apology email basically stating that they had done the same in previous schools, all is fine, it's a good song, separate the art from the artist etc. Very depressing response and really changed my opinion of them, what a terrible show of lack of judgement.

BalthazarImpresario · 28/09/2021 07:36

I’m not sure if it’s the case but lost prophets music was removed from Spotify after his convictions so I wonder if other artists will suffer the same fate, however I’m unsure if that was a label/rest of the band decision rather than a Spotify one.

BlakeDreary · 28/09/2021 07:35

@RickJames

What has Tom Jones done?

I understand he was pretty rotten to his wife, shagging around etc. but I haven't heard of anything criminal.

It's insane how many there are, isn't it? @tttigress I'm sure that's true, unfortunately.

Do you think bad people join the music industry or people join the music industry and 'go' bad?

There was a story that has been hidden very well. He supposedly raped a minor in his hotel room back in the 70's. He was never investigated for it as far as I know. If you dig deep enough on the internet you should find the story. There's a photo of him with the girl on the hotel balcony (he's in a dressing gown).
billyt · 28/09/2021 07:32

Sick enough these 'stars' think they can own people to do with whatever they want. in their little minds money can buy anything, even depravity.

Just as bad are the sycophant followers who enable the sick acts. I saw Managers, Security team etc. Did none of them have any morals, doubts? Did their employment mean that much to them that anything goes?

I've walked away from a job when my employer kept lying to customers. Christ knows what I'd have done if he was abusing them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread