Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS age 15 - are limits on daily smart phone time unreasonable?

114 replies

Kermitsolvestheclimate · 27/09/2021 21:09

We have some parental limits on DC's phone - mostly around time he can spend on it each day. Goes off overnight 9pm - 8am. Daily limit of 30mins on various social media (snapshat, instagram, youtube etc) - that together add up to over 2 hrs /day. He thinks we are SOOOOOOO unreasonable to do this. What do other Mumsnetters think? For context, being on his phone is his default activity over homework, helping at home, sleep and any other other essential life activities. If the phone is on he is 'not with us'.

OP posts:
MegBusset · 28/09/2021 07:27

Mine are 12 and 14, our screen rules are:

  • Homework / chores before screens
  • No screens at mealtimes or when doing a family activity
  • At least one extracurricular sport each
  • No screens from approx 9pm (later on a weekend) until the morning

Outside of this we pretty much leave them to it. I would prefer they spend less time on screens but it's where all their socialising takes place and many of their friends have no limits at all.

Ikeameatballs · 28/09/2021 07:21

No limits for my dc, 11 and 15.

11 year old doesn’t use his much anyway. He prefers to play on his PS.

15 year old is on hers loads but I take it away overnight. She’s usually just chatting to friends, listening to music etc.

Both of them go to a phone free school and it is switched off then.

Both sometimes have all electronics removed for bad behaviour but that’s pretty extreme.

HugeAckmansWife · 28/09/2021 07:16

I think using age as a blunt instrument is pointless. One 15 yo is vastly different to another. Some have lots of variety of interests, have developed self awareness around too much screen time and won't care if they are 'out of the loop'. Others won't be there yet and may never be. There are adults on here who admit to being addicted to their phones. OP if you judge that your son needs that help then fine. I teach teenagers. There's a lot of grief about what gets said on social media apps and chats at midnight. My eldest is 12 and wants insta. I've told him no until he can show me he is more able to be honest about various things and I'm convinced he understands how it can work. Other 12 y olds might be fine, but he's not.

Hydrate · 28/09/2021 07:08

YANBU about it being off between 9 pm to 8 am. I would allow a couple of hours after any responsibilities they have are taken care of.

Mumski45 · 28/09/2021 06:55

Sorry I should add. DS1 still has limits set on his phone but that's at his own request and when he asks for extra time now and again I always give it.

Mumski45 · 28/09/2021 06:53

I used to do this when they were younger with both DS1 and 2. They are 15 and 13 now. DS1 has learnt to self regulate and DS2 is getting there. They both get good grades and are willingly active in sports at school so I don't feel the need to control it any more.

They are both in a school 20miles away though so seeing friends outside school time is tricky and time consuming even without Covid restrictions so their phones are important for maintaining and developing relationships.

HelenaJustina · 28/09/2021 06:46

I do this with my 14yr old. I’m also vastly unreasonable according to them but meh. They are achieving their potential academically, their homework is always done and of good quality, they spend time at extra curricular activities. All phone are downstairs overnight. If it works for your family why not? Much easier to start tough and ease up, rather than have to crack down later on.

megletthesecond · 28/09/2021 06:46

Yanbu. My DS is almost 15 and his phone goes off at 9pm on a school night. He's utterly incapable of self regulation.

BigGreen · 28/09/2021 06:45

I can't find the thread right now but there was one here 'what do you regret about your parenting' and a good third of posts were regrets about not putting limits on smartphones.

My kids are only small but I did take note. These things can be toxic - there was a leak from Facebook about Instagram harming girls here]] so YANBU.

PeonyTime · 28/09/2021 06:45

Is it not better than he learns to regulate now, rather than binges when he leaves home, and having to deal with the implications on his own?

I think your evening curfew is early. I'd remove the 30 min blocks.
So, as a first step, phones off at 10pm and upto 2 hrs a day. He will burn through it by lunchtime initially.

All phones in this house are left downstairs overnight. I'm currently dressed and downstairs while typing this. We dont limit time tho (yet).

HalzTangz · 28/09/2021 06:43

At 15 that is unreasonable. 2 hours isn't really that long a day.
What time do they go bed, the phone should be allowed on until they go sleep in my opinion

Nonicknamesforcatapillars · 28/09/2021 06:37

I think those limits would be completely appropriate for an 11 year old who had just started in y7.

By 15 though I would expect them to be able to self regulate better. My dds aged 16 and 13 don’t have limits. They manage to engage with life just fine. I’m a firm believer in letting kids self regulate, how are they supposed to learn to set their own limits if you’re so strict with the limits you impose on them? it just makes life an unnecessary battle, which isn’t even helpful at all in the long run.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 28/09/2021 06:35

I don't limit screen time for my 14yo. It's up to her to make sensible decisions.

FeelingForced · 28/09/2021 06:29

I have limits on my DDs phone and she's fourteen now. She knows she's not very good at self regulating, so we discussed what would be fair and now the social media apps total up to around two hours a day. We use Google Family Link and the apps shut down once the time is up. WhatsApp use is unlimited but because she only uses that to talk to her friends on a group chat, it only gets used when they're all free at the same time every day.
Her phone locks down from 9.30 pm to 7 am everyday and her laptop and phone stay out of her room during those hours.

DeepaBeesKit · 28/09/2021 06:24

PlandeRaccordement
"A few months of gorging" doesnt lead to self regulation for most. Screens are addictive. I'm 36 years old and having gorged myself for 15 years struggle to self regulate. I'll be imposing limits on my kids as long as they live under my roof.

randomuseragain · 28/09/2021 06:23

Yes, try the app OurPact

Bagelsandbrie · 28/09/2021 06:21

15 is too old for limits. Their whole social life is lived through their phones, 9pm is ridiculously early! I think even with the aspergers you need to just ease up and let go. If he’s on it non stop that’s sadly pretty normal at this stage!

Clymene · 28/09/2021 06:18

I have a teenager with autism. I take it away at night but otherwise he's in control. How do you know he has no limits if you enforce a strict 30 mins cut off? Confused

I've never set limits because I don't think you learn self regulation otherwise.

Kermitsolvestheclimate · 28/09/2021 06:07

Really interesting range of tactics and sounds like many DC a lot more sensible and controlled than ours. We'd love to have no limits on it and stop all the grief we get over it but so far he is showing no sign of being able to regulate himself. We know at this age he SHOULD be learning to regulate but he seems addicted to it if there are no limits on it. He would spend literally HOURS on it without a break if we let him. It makes me really sad. Sometimes i wish we didn't have smartphones! He has aspergers, i don't know as I'm not an expert but wonder if that is a factor relating to his self control (or lack of).

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 27/09/2021 23:46

Mine too had no limits once 13 and after a few months of gorging themselves, they settled into self-regulation. This was good because by 15/16 when all their friends had snapchat, tiktok and insta they were not interested and never joined. (Facebook is for old people btw). Never had an issue with poor academic performance. They often used their phones to watch educational videos or listen to podcasts on school subjects anyway.

BiBabbles · 27/09/2021 23:34

I think it depends on the 15 year old and your situation.

Some 15 year olds can be okay with self regulation, some aren't quite there yet and need more support that environmental controls like screen time apps can provide. I do think as a pp said about her 14 year old, they should be part of the conversation on this.

My oldest had similarish limits at 15, though he only used Instagram out of those. It was part of a conversation around how to help him prioritize his time with his GCSEs and other commitments. We did loosen it with lockdown and after his not-exams-but-basically-exams, I gave him the summer to work on self regulation/relax as he pleased. Now he's back at college again, we're having some of those same conversations again and yes, I might -- with his input - be putting in blocks again or at least more of a barrier to help him figure out what sort of balance he wants and will help him meet his goals.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 27/09/2021 23:07

I think it's a bit much for a 15 year old. They're going to have to learn to limit it themselves and take responsibility and preferably before they're adults

MissCreeAnt · 27/09/2021 22:51

Our 14 year old does still have limits, but she was involved in deciding to keep them once she'd turned 13. We would flex on total hours and the time it switches off, but it staying downstairs overnight to charge is staying non-negotiable.

With a different child I might pick different battles though.

Starrycolors23 · 27/09/2021 22:44

I am 27 and have screen time limits on my own phone, I am allowed 40 mins a day on socials otherwise it’s so unhealthy. The issue is I can easily override them! Definitely not unreasonable. DH is a teacher and the amount of kids falling asleep because they stayed up on Snapchat

ItsAChalkengingWank · 27/09/2021 22:42

I think he's at an age where he has to learn to self regulate and understand the consequences of his actions, would you still control his screentime at 16? Because that's not far away

My Ds's 'thing' is gaming online with friends. But he's realised that if he stays up late he's tired and irritable the next day. So now he only stays up late on a fri/sat pm

Ds wouldn't be allowed to 'game' without doing his homework though as he's in a particularly important year. Any jobs I ask him to do need to be done in a reasonable timeframe too