Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS age 15 - are limits on daily smart phone time unreasonable?

114 replies

Kermitsolvestheclimate · 27/09/2021 21:09

We have some parental limits on DC's phone - mostly around time he can spend on it each day. Goes off overnight 9pm - 8am. Daily limit of 30mins on various social media (snapshat, instagram, youtube etc) - that together add up to over 2 hrs /day. He thinks we are SOOOOOOO unreasonable to do this. What do other Mumsnetters think? For context, being on his phone is his default activity over homework, helping at home, sleep and any other other essential life activities. If the phone is on he is 'not with us'.

OP posts:
YouCantBeSadHoldingACupcake · 28/09/2021 16:47

My dc's phones are locked 8pm to 8am, with WhatsApp as an exception so they can contact their friends. I don't set limits during the time they are unlocked, except they have to be put away for mealtimes.

RavingAnnie · 28/09/2021 16:41

All those saying YABU need to watch The Social Dilemma.

You definitely NOT being unreasonable limiting use and you should also be monitoring his use (the latter more for online safety).

CatsArePeople · 28/09/2021 14:28

the sensible limit we had is no contract, just PAYG top ups. So only access to internet when at home. So that really limited mindless youtube and tiktok.

frazzledfragglefromfragglerock · 28/09/2021 14:19

I control the time on different apps and have downtime from 8-8 but they always have access to messaging apps so they don't miss out on their friends chats. Nothing worse than being the one who doesn't know what's going on! Also eldest has access to read as she likes to read manga and there's loads online and she wouldn't sit and read anything else!

I can tell the difference in their attitudes if they have unlimited phone time!

Mine are girls aged 14 and 12.

SecretWitch · 28/09/2021 14:19

My 13 yo has no limits. She knows if class work is not completed or chores not done we will shut her phone off otherwise we leave her to it.

MaidEdithofAragon · 28/09/2021 14:15

OP I'd say he can't self regulate because he isn't having the chance to learn how. I don't regulate my teens apart from bedtime/ mealtime / doing some kind of exercise etc. If you let him be, he'll go crazy for phone time for a bit, then it'll calm down. You're making it forbidden fruit which is always alluring for teens.

BiBabbles · 28/09/2021 14:10

Also, consider a transferable allowance like 25 hours a week (with possible carry over so he doesn't feel a need to use up 100% of his remaining allowance every Sunday), which will let him make choices about how to manage his time - he can spend a whole day messing around on his phone if he likes but in doing so he's chosing to have less phone time left for the rest of the week. Or conversely, chosing to use his phone less one day creates the reward of having more phone time to use later in the week.

I think this is an interesting idea and could work better for some teens and adults, though I don't know of any apps that work that way -- and I do think for most 15-year-olds, having to come through a parent to get any screen time would a bit much and likely lead to extra conflict, even for those who know they need more support in this area.

Even for those apps used for adults, I've only seen daily ones, so if someone can recommend one that works on a week or longer, that would be great.

Sgtmajormummy · 28/09/2021 12:05

15yo DD has agreed with me to have internet blocked on her phone from 3-7pm Sunday to Thursday in order to concentrate on homework.

Even after 2 years of owning a phone she (like me) has problems self regulating. The messaging with school friends is relentless and she needs to give 100% focus to her demanding coursework.

seaandsandcastles · 28/09/2021 11:51

so far he is showing no sign of being able to regulate himself.

That’s because you’ve allowed him to get to age 15 without the ability to moderate himself.

Bbq1 · 28/09/2021 10:45

@HelenaJustina

I do this with my 14yr old. I’m also vastly unreasonable according to them but meh. They are achieving their potential academically, their homework is always done and of good quality, they spend time at extra curricular activities. All phone are downstairs overnight. If it works for your family why not? Much easier to start tough and ease up, rather than have to crack down later on.
My ds is achieving academically etc etc doing all the things that your ds are doing but still has no limits on his phone because he self regulates. Would your dc not achieve if you didn't impose limits on them?
Crazycakelady17 · 28/09/2021 09:10

My older two are 20 and 17 now eldest at uni second at college we had the rule phones off downstairs at 10pm on school nights but as long as they did there Homewoek extra curricular then that was the only limit we had
Our youngest is just 12 just started high school she has to come off at 9pm and has no social media but with her I find she spends hours on FaceTime to her friends I was worried at first till my mum said remember you at her age hours on the phone in the hall (before mobiles) and realised it was the modern day equivalent
I’m a nightmare on my phone can be on it 8/9 hours a day my DC have way more self control than me

bsc · 28/09/2021 08:48

My DD completely can self regulate, and puts her phone downstairs on kitchen table by 8pm every night. She only picks it up as leaving the house to school.
DS cannot self regulate in any way, and will actively try to extend any limit he is given for anything on principle. He has limits set in his phone (3 hours per day), and it can't be used between 8pm and 7am. (They're allowed phones in school, so he spends all break and lunch on it)
Age is irrelevant- DD was like this at 7yo! I can see DS being like this at 40...

Bonusjonas · 28/09/2021 08:37

I’m of the opinion that if they’ve done they’re homework and chores then it’s their free time so they can have their phones. But they have to put them away on school nights when I go to bed.

toastofthetown · 28/09/2021 08:36

@Kermitsolvestheclimate

Really interesting range of tactics and sounds like many DC a lot more sensible and controlled than ours. We'd love to have no limits on it and stop all the grief we get over it but so far he is showing no sign of being able to regulate himself. We know at this age he SHOULD be learning to regulate but he seems addicted to it if there are no limits on it. He would spend literally HOURS on it without a break if we let him. It makes me really sad. Sometimes i wish we didn't have smartphones! He has aspergers, i don't know as I'm not an expert but wonder if that is a factor relating to his self control (or lack of).
Is this a chicken and egg situation, in that he can't control it because it's so strictly limited? That because he's never had the chance to self regulate and his limits feel so small to him, that he'll want use his phone more. Have you spoken to him about what he thinks? It might surprise you if you have a conversation about how much screen he should have, why he thinks he should have more and you think he should have less. He's more likely to stick with limits he helped set than were imposed on him. At the very least I'd stop controlling each app and leave it up to him to manage his time.

How much time do you (and you husband/partner if relevant) spend on your phones around the house? Might not be an issue, but I do know families who try to massively restrict their children's access to technology, but are often on their phones themselves.

nosyupnorth · 28/09/2021 08:33

Limits are fine and reasonable but yours are NOT.

30 minutes per app per day isn't just not going to teach him about regulating his own time, it's going to actively discourage it! Such a highly restricted set up means he never has reason to think about his phone useage or make decisions, and pushes him to make the most of his allowances each day or lose out.

Setting a time limit and letting him choose how to use it will encourage him to think about what his priorities are and in doing something like chosing to talk on snapchat he is also making the choice not to watch a youtube video.

Also, consider a transferable allowance like 25 hours a week (with possible carry over so he doesn't feel a need to use up 100% of his remaining allowance every Sunday), which will let him make choices about how to manage his time - he can spend a whole day messing around on his phone if he likes but in doing so he's chosing to have less phone time left for the rest of the week. Or conversely, chosing to use his phone less one day creates the reward of having more phone time to use later in the week.

IsabelBeck · 28/09/2021 08:15

I think using age as a blunt instrument is pointless.

I agree. It's like 15 is the new 18 on this thread.

Some teens simply cannot self regulate at 13, 14, 15 (and beyond!) so they need some parental guidance as their young brains develop. Obviously you can't enforce this as they get older but that doesn't mean you should have no limits if they're letting homework and other things slide.

MissCreeAnt · 28/09/2021 08:12

Have you actually asked him if he would like to set a limit? He might surprise you. Just because he doesn't "self-regulate" (and I am not sure everyone even can, let alone teens) doesn't necessarily mean he won't take help if it's offered, and presented as support not discipline.

Like @Mumski45 we give extra bits of time if needed. It's just giving them a little barrier so they pause and think, like putting the chocolate on a high shelf when you're dieting.

KangarooSally · 28/09/2021 08:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn deleted by MNHQ

MilduraS · 28/09/2021 08:05

I'm terrible for always being on my phone so I'd be a bit hypocritical to set a limit on apps. The night time lockdown seems reasonable though. As a teenager I was terrible at regulating my bed time but as an adult I do because I struggle at work if I don't have enough sleep.

Bbq1 · 28/09/2021 07:59

@Kermitsolvestheclimate

We have some parental limits on DC's phone - mostly around time he can spend on it each day. Goes off overnight 9pm - 8am. Daily limit of 30mins on various social media (snapshat, instagram, youtube etc) - that together add up to over 2 hrs /day. He thinks we are SOOOOOOO unreasonable to do this. What do other Mumsnetters think? For context, being on his phone is his default activity over homework, helping at home, sleep and any other other essential life activities. If the phone is on he is 'not with us'.
Wow, you're treating your 15 yo like a 5 yo, Op. My ds has just turned 16 and has no limits. He's sensible and mature enough to self regulate, works hard, is out with friends a lot, has other interests and even spends time with us. All that will happen here is your ds will never learn to regulate himself and when finally allowed unrestricted access will be on using his phone constantly as you have made it the forbidden fruit
IWishIWasABaller · 28/09/2021 07:56

I allowed/ allow my teens to self regulate their phone usage. Of course at first they were glued to it but after a few days they only dipped in and out of it . Times have changed , I would have stayed up late secretly reading for hours nowadays they stay up on their phones. A few late nights and trying to crawl out of bed early for school ,they soon learned to switch off the phone and go to sleep. I do think you are being a little strict with such rigid time allowances but you know your child best

Wondergirl100 · 28/09/2021 07:53

I think people need to be serious about the idea of a teen 'learning to self regulate'. The reality is that probably the majority of adults are not properly self regulating their own tech so it's just not true that all teens will magically develop this gift if you let them.

While their brains are developing and they are so vulnerable in other ways I think you are just doing them a favour not letting them waste hours on it

By the way - the tech giants who invented this stuff absolutely don't let their kids use it. You can google that lots of articles - they design phones and apps to make you addicted, it is literally part of the way they are intended to function.

uggmum · 28/09/2021 07:52

Yep totally unreasonable and draconian.

My dc are now 18 and 22

I never had limits. I would talk openly to my dc about usage and over usage. But ultimately left it for them to self regulate.

They are now mature adults, both at university. Productive members of society

So no harm done.

Wondergirl100 · 28/09/2021 07:50

OP - I don't think you are unreasonable to acknowledge that the majority of teens AND ADULTS are not able to properly control their use.

I spend far too much time on my phone - don't many adults?

The idea of a 15 yr old 'self regulating' seems far fetched to me. We are their parents and there to stop them doing things that are bad for them - to a certain extent and sadly we have to let go as they get older!

I think it is naive to think a 15 yr old will self regulate - how about you sit down in a calm moment and do a deal - you give him more time in exchange to an end for the complaining - you give him articles to read baout phone addiction and its impact on the brain (negative!) and make him engage in some discussion aroudn it.

reluctantbrit · 28/09/2021 07:46

DD's rule are that no electronics are kept upstairs in her room overnight. She brings everything down when she goes to bed, that can be up to 9.30pm. Otherwise the family rule is that no one uses mobiles during mealtimes unless a discussion asks for a check on some facts or to control music but we try to minimise it. I would say it happens 1-2x a week.

But - DD has a range of hobbies where the mobile is not on or not with her. Also, the school is trying to teach them to leave the mobile away from the desk when doing homework or revision. Difficult if you need the laptop then and YouTube is at your fingertips.