Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS age 15 - are limits on daily smart phone time unreasonable?

114 replies

Kermitsolvestheclimate · 27/09/2021 21:09

We have some parental limits on DC's phone - mostly around time he can spend on it each day. Goes off overnight 9pm - 8am. Daily limit of 30mins on various social media (snapshat, instagram, youtube etc) - that together add up to over 2 hrs /day. He thinks we are SOOOOOOO unreasonable to do this. What do other Mumsnetters think? For context, being on his phone is his default activity over homework, helping at home, sleep and any other other essential life activities. If the phone is on he is 'not with us'.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StartSelect · 30/09/2021 12:13

Two boys here 15 and 10, eldest with ASD. No time limits except no phones at bedtime, both phones are removed at lights out until the morning.

MissCreeAnt · 30/09/2021 11:56

@Sgtmajormummy

A parents’ seminar I went to through DC’s school asked the audience:

“What age would you be happy for your children to have access to unlimited porn? 12? 14? Because that’s what you’re giving them if they have no parental controls on phone use.”

And it’s not just porn…

This one will really stick in my head!

OP your later posts are saying he really does need help and he is not going to magically "self regulate" any more than I do when chocolate makes me fat. I do think it's important to try and build some buy-in, maybe give some concessions and opportunities for him to make sensible decisions and prove himself or, as PPs said, do more of the "WHEN you have done your homework THEN..." thing. But I know that can be difficult with autism - sometimes you need the fun thing first to calm down so you can do your homework.

I think having a more flexible total time rather than 30 mins here, 30 mins there might actually be less stressful for him to manage. My son goes through phases of doing different things, and opportunities to increase flexible thinking are often valuable for autistic children. You could also say Eg you can watch YouTube on the TV sometimes. This would take the pressure off him having to squeeze everything into his phone time, and also give you more opportunities to see what he's watching and be able to talk to him. I have watched a lot of Minecraft and pop commentary YouTube with my son. I can only stomach it for a little while :) But he loves being able to talk to me about redstone and his favourite artists. It's a way to reach him, and it's a good social skills practice thing negotiating what to watch next /when to turn it off. Plus it genuinely has given me more respect for what he is into.

It is hard to convince teens you are on their side sometimes.

VestaTilley · 30/09/2021 11:48

YANBU. Keep doing what you’re doing.

cardamomtea87 · 30/09/2021 11:01

@Kermitsolvestheclimate

We have some parental limits on DC's phone - mostly around time he can spend on it each day. Goes off overnight 9pm - 8am. Daily limit of 30mins on various social media (snapshat, instagram, youtube etc) - that together add up to over 2 hrs /day. He thinks we are SOOOOOOO unreasonable to do this. What do other Mumsnetters think? For context, being on his phone is his default activity over homework, helping at home, sleep and any other other essential life activities. If the phone is on he is 'not with us'.
You are more than reasonable, sounds perfect for that age to me. Hold the line OP, they'll thank you in years to come.
Cheeseplantboots · 30/09/2021 00:44

I have a 14 and 15 year old. There are no limits on their phones.

whiteroseredrose · 29/09/2021 23:28

Mine never had set bedtimes, screen times, phone limits or anything like that, but I never needed to. Both were capable of self regulating and wanted to do well at school so prioritised their work.

I think it depends on the child really.

littlebilliie · 29/09/2021 23:04

m.independent.ie/life/family/parenting/the-tech-moguls-who-invented-social-media-have-banned-their-children-from-it-37494367.html

If this doesn't make you think about the burden we are putting on kids with these phones. And no, they won't die if they miss something on Instagram or Snapchat

KurtWilde · 29/09/2021 23:02

YABU. I've raised my DC in much the same way @mathanxiety describes - two of whom are now young adults - and agree there's absolutely no need to be so controlling and constantly setting limitations.

littlebilliie · 29/09/2021 23:00

@Chickychoccyegg

I can't believe there's a 16 year old who gets locked out of their phone at 8.30!!! That is just so unreasonable it's unbelievable! I don't know op, I dont have restrictions on my dd15 phone, only rule is no phone at the dinner table, and we all sit and chat for a good hour/1.5 hours, she usually in the evening will facetime a friend, or be on a group chat, but she's never on it particularly late, she's always asleep by about 10.30, maybe see if there's a compromise somewhere?
Parents are parenting their kids it's refreshing. In silicone valley the makers of these apps do not allow their kids to have phones or social media
CatsArePeople · 29/09/2021 22:50

YABU, you will have him excluded from his mates because you take his phone off him. He won't be in the loop with group chats, snapchat updates and the like.

It's not U if he's snapchatting and youtubing while there is homework or housework not done.

mathanxiety · 29/09/2021 22:41

The details you supplied - obsessiveness, poor sleep (sleep support services involved), immaturity, lack of self control - were mentioned for the first time in your more recent post. All of that makes a big difference. Aspergers expresses itself in many different ways.

You may well find that your younger DC won't need the same level of watchfulness when he gets to 15.

Many millions of teens manage to do fine with unlimited phone access, even using phones as alarm clocks, for homework reminders - as tools to keep them on track in other words, and learn to manage time and allocate priorities.

MissCruellaDeVil · 29/09/2021 22:39

YABU, you will have him excluded from his mates because you take his phone off him. He won't be in the loop with group chats, snapchat updates and the like. Maybe have "phone free times" such as dinner time, watching a movie with the family etc, and take it away before bed.

Kermitsolvestheclimate · 29/09/2021 22:33

Mathanxiety I did mention the aspergers in one of my early responses in this thread but not in the first post so fair enough, I was keeping first post brief.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 29/09/2021 22:28

I am not sure why so many parents think phones are so important and special and that children need unlimited acceas to learn to self regulate. Don't you limit/control other things? Like sweets, soft drinks, alcohol and crossing the road?

No, no limits, and they learned to regulate themselves. I discouraged alcohol, and the age limit to buy your own and be served in a bar or restaurant here is 21, but they were all off to university at 18.

If I wanted to limit sweets or soft drinks I wouldn't have bought them. I didn't in fact buy soft drinks regularly, and didn't model consumption of either soft drinks or sweets.

They had phones from the earliest time they were available (early 2000s) and watched as much TV as they wanted to, both in the sitting room and in their rooms. We had wii, various Play Stations and other platforms. I never got cable TV, but we had DVD players and lots of DVDs.

They also got to regulate their own social lives, with the condition that if their grades started slipping they would have to sit down and make a plan to ensure recovery. Kids learn to drive at 16 here, and if you haven't managed to transmit your values and priorities to them by then it's hard to do it after that, when their friends have cars and not all of their peers are as focused on getting into good universities as they are.

The same rule went for extra curricular activities - if the grades slipped or homework was being done at 3am regularly, then it was time to revisit the decision to do a sport or take part in the spring musical, or whatever.

Chickychoccyegg · 29/09/2021 22:23

I can't believe there's a 16 year old who gets locked out of their phone at 8.30!!!
That is just so unreasonable it's unbelievable!
I don't know op, I dont have restrictions on my dd15 phone, only rule is no phone at the dinner table, and we all sit and chat for a good hour/1.5 hours, she usually in the evening will facetime a friend, or be on a group chat, but she's never on it particularly late, she's always asleep by about 10.30, maybe see if there's a compromise somewhere?

Charles11 · 29/09/2021 22:20

My 16 yr old still has limits. He needs to leave his phone downstairs while he does his homework and overnight. Otherwise he’s free to spend time on it as he wants. He often comes and watches tv with us instead.

mathanxiety · 29/09/2021 22:14

You would have had some very different responses is you had revealed the Aspergers, obsessive trait, and immaturity from the getgo.

It's an important element of this.

Kermitsolvestheclimate · 29/09/2021 21:43

Lots of really interesting comments and food for thought here, interesting so much variation between families and children of course. Some good suggestions and we are reviewing what we do going forwards to improve things. We have discussed sensible phone usage and talked about options etc with him LOADS of times! He doesn't think he should have any limits at all. Also thinks he should have it in his room all night. For context and re some of questions people asked above, our DS didn't always have these limits, we've brought them in due to overuse of his phone to the detriment of other parts of his life. By the end of last term at school he had over 30 pieces of homework not completed and a lot of major issues around that to do with not wanting to go to school etc. (He had been hiding homework backlog from us). He was doing zero to help at home. We had let him have loads of phone access due to lockdown and staying in touch with friends. In reality he uses it mostly for games, tic tok and Youtube from what we can see on family link, he 's not reading, looking the at the news, doing other 'worthwhile' useful activities like some have given examples of above that their DC do. He has Aspergers syyndrome and can be obsessive about things like certain Youtube posters etc. Interesting some posters above seem to not know about professional guidance re phone use (or choose to not follow it). Its well known guidance NOT to be on screens at least an hour before bedtime (adults and children). I've been told that by various professionals through school and childrens support services as well as reading up on it. Our DC has problems with sleep anyway so we try and stick to that guidance. I'm really surprised some people let their DC have phones 'up until they go to sleep' and unlimited when they are still youngish teens (ie 13, 14) . Our DS is supposed to go to bed by 9.30/45 as he's up early for school with him asleep by 10pm /10.15ish is the goal. Thats following a routine set by children's sleep support service who recommended no phone or gadgets for him after 8.30 for that bedtime. Its really tricky, we'd love to have no controls and not all the bloody hassle of it but if he ends up being on it 3-5 hours a day (doing non 'useful' things) I think we'd be remiss as parents. Just like we wouldn;t give him free access to other potentially harmful things. He IS quite immature, he DOESN'T show much natural self control so we have to work with the kid we have. His brother as it happens (younger) it totally different, sits and does all his homework every night without us even mentioning it, reads books, practising his music every night and spends very little time on his phone in comparison (he's 12 and also has a smart phone). Older DS does also have TV time and Xbox gaming (latter at weekends only, not school nights for all the reasons covered above).

OP posts:
ItsNotMeAnymore · 29/09/2021 21:03

That sounds about right to me OP. I might add a bit of time for social media as 30 min is a bit short but YANBU. Does he have separate time fir on line gaming?

Sgtmajormummy · 29/09/2021 20:53

A parents’ seminar I went to through DC’s school asked the audience:

“What age would you be happy for your children to have access to unlimited porn? 12? 14? Because that’s what you’re giving them if they have no parental controls on phone use.”

And it’s not just porn…

Bitofachinwag · 29/09/2021 17:35

@LobsterNapkin

YANBU.

Sure, some kids self-regulate (though I've known a few whose parents think they do but are on at all hours of the night wheile their parents are asleep.

But lots can't, and no wonder, they are designed, just like gambling, to make self-regulation difficult. It's not controversial to think letting kids gamble at 15 is a bad idea so I'm not sure why letting kids develop the same issues with a phone is controversial, but it seems to be.

I agree. And I said before, as parents we "control" many aspects of our children's lives, as so we should. What makes phones so special that we should not control their use? It is seen as right and normal to stop children from gambling, sex, drinking alcohol, staying up too late, not wearing a coat on the snow, not having sleep overs at the houses of people they barely know etc.
LobsterNapkin · 29/09/2021 17:03

YANBU.

Sure, some kids self-regulate (though I've known a few whose parents think they do but are on at all hours of the night wheile their parents are asleep.

But lots can't, and no wonder, they are designed, just like gambling, to make self-regulation difficult. It's not controversial to think letting kids gamble at 15 is a bad idea so I'm not sure why letting kids develop the same issues with a phone is controversial, but it seems to be.

allsorts1 · 29/09/2021 16:07

The problem is is that these apps aren't possible to learn to self regulate. They're designed to keep you hooked. OP can you come to my house and take my phone off me at night as that sounds dreamy 🤣

SueSaid · 29/09/2021 08:58

Restrictions when younger yes, by 15 no.

Seeline · 29/09/2021 08:29

I think your limits are unreasonable.

Teens use their phones for so many different things - whilst they look as though they are on them all the time, they are using different functions.

My DD uses hers
check public transport to get home from school
access her homework app
to help with homework (if something quick, she doesn't bother getting her laptop up and running)
communicating with friends - maybe just a chat, but often in the early evening checking school tasks, working together on projects etc (usually Snapchat rather than actual talking!)
watching YouTube/tiktok to relax
checking news
reading articles
helping to learn her dance routines
clock/alarm
weather
games

In the old days, I did all these different things, but had to use a variety of different methods in order to achieve them. Nowadays it's all at their fingertips. Your DS will be missing out on social interaction with such draconion limits. Everything is done through Snapchat these days.

I would give far greater access. Perhaps enforce downstairs charging overnight, from 10pm/11 at weekends. With the caveat that time will be lost if school work suffers or chores not done.