Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it is ever the front car's fault.

82 replies

DownToTheSeaAgain · 27/09/2021 18:21

Someone drove into the back of me today as I was stopping at a crossroads.

Swapped numbers etc etc submitted insurance claim and all that is progressing. It's not a lot of damage but some.

Anyway I was wondering if there were ever a case when it could be construed as my fault for stopping rather than the other person for not stopping. The light was on amber, switching to red. If I'd driven across then I'd have been driving on red.

OP posts:
GreenTeaBlackCoffeeAndRedWine · 28/09/2021 16:55

They could be, it happened to my sister where the driver in front reversed into her and he tried to claim it was her fault. Even though he reversed into her.

But yes, usually it's the driver behind - after all, they should be paying attention.

thinkfast · 28/09/2021 16:42

I was once on a bus which was over taken by a speeding car which then slammed on its brakes right in front of the bus. Bus crashed into the back of the car. Loads of people in the bus fell over / were shaken /hurt. I was sitting on the front seat of the top deck so had a very clear view of the incident.

The people in the car jumped straight out with their phones to take photos and exchange details.

I'm confident it was an extremely dangerous scam. I can't see how the bus driver could've avoided the collision. Can't see how bus driver could be to blame for it.

Snowpaw · 28/09/2021 16:41

I was once driving behind someone who decided to stop completely unnecessarily and suddenly at an empty zebra crossing; there was a chap walking up the pavement on the far side who she thought “might want to go across the road” - he wasn’t at the crossing at the time and there was even an island separating the two halves of the road (I.e it is classed as two separate crossings): he wasn’t on any part of the crossing, let alone at the middle island. I went into the back of her and it was of course considered my fault, but it felt unfair to me at the time!

Chloemol · 28/09/2021 16:36

It’s possible if they can prove it’s a crash for cash scam. However in your instance no, the driver should have been taking more notice

Footprintsonthemoon1 · 28/09/2021 16:32

I was in this situation years ago when I was quite young

Driving along country roads I didnt know, quite fast 45/50 looking for a certain address with a car behind me. Still going at speed around a corner I slammed the breaks on as I found the turn I needed to take, it was all so fast and the car behind went into the back of me. My boyfriend at the time said it was my fault and 100% believed it was but the other drivers Dh blamed her and I felt awful. I guess technically she was in the wrong but morally I know I was

PineappleWilson · 28/09/2021 16:18

Yes, they can be, for example if you accidentally put the car into reverse rather than 1st gear (I know someone who did this when she moved from her manual car into her husband's automatic and put it "in gear" in auto pilot) but generally the rear car is classed as being at fault unless there is concrete evidence to the contrary e.g. dash cam footage, CCTV etc.

VelvetSpoon · 28/09/2021 16:17

Usually not.

There can be exceptions - a deliberate slam on (often as part of cash for crash type frauds), front vehicle rolls back, or changes lane so cuts in front of the driver following, faulty brake lights on an unlit road late at night, or even a Gussman v Gratton Storey type scenario. But these don't happen that often.

Emmelina · 28/09/2021 16:14

I was the front car stopped at traffic lights a few years ago when someone slammed into the back of me. Nobody hurt, but my car had a significant dent in the back so I stopped at the police station (a few streets over) and asked if someone could just pop and check I was safe to go as I was out on my own at the time.
I asked the policeman who checked the car over and he said always the car behind unless very exceptional circumstances- they should be observing what you’re doing from a safe stopping distance!

Sickening · 28/09/2021 16:12

The only time I can think of, is if a car smashes into the car in front, which bumps into the car in front of that... while stationary, in a traffic jam.

Happened to me! Mind you, even with that, they might argue stopping distance wasn't long enough, even though nobody was driving at the time (well, other than the back driver who started it all!).

Faevern · 28/09/2021 16:08

@nokidshere

Yes, this. I had an old friend who was a terrible driver, would start to pull out then stop or suddenly slow down to a stop to turn a corner, no indicators. She was rear ended 4 times and it was always the driver behind at fault even though her actions caused it contributed to it massively.

Doesn't matter if she suddenly stopped, or slowed down to look at flowers, or whatever. The car behind should have room to stop.

Yes, as I said, it is the driver behinds fault.
Herecomesthesun70 · 27/09/2021 21:45

@HarrisonStickle

I drove into someone. It ended up in court as I disagreed with some of what they said and the amount they were claiming. The judge found in my favour. Can't be specific as it could be outing. But they didn't really help themselves at any stage, and I think because I'd driven into them they assumed the judge would find in their favour so made no effort with their case. The driver was insured so I think that meant his premiums went up. The passenger wasn't insured so would have had to shoulder their own costs. Ooops!
It won't be out insures deal with cases where quantum is disputed in court every day. The passenger would likely have entered into an agreement with the solicitor or the drivers insurance company will have paid up
HarrisonStickle · 27/09/2021 19:12

I drove into someone. It ended up in court as I disagreed with some of what they said and the amount they were claiming. The judge found in my favour. Can't be specific as it could be outing. But they didn't really help themselves at any stage, and I think because I'd driven into them they assumed the judge would find in their favour so made no effort with their case. The driver was insured so I think that meant his premiums went up. The passenger wasn't insured so would have had to shoulder their own costs. Ooops!

Boombadoom · 27/09/2021 19:00

Nope. A car in front of my stopped incorrectly which meant I had to perform an emergency stop. Driver behind me not paying attention and went into me. He was at fault despite the fact that really the accident was caused by the person in front of me. Insurance company weren’t even interested in the person infront. Who drove off anyway!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/09/2021 18:58

There are nearly always exceptions - in that most things in driving are case specific and not a blanket rule- but yes it’ll nearly always been the fault of the car behind.

Hellocatshome · 27/09/2021 18:54

Not in that situation. I had a crash where it was the front cars fault as they stuck it in reverse at a roundabout. Elderly driver got confused and admitted it rather than a crash for cash incident.

DownToTheSeaAgain · 27/09/2021 18:51

Thank you. I'm worried that the insurance company will somehow find a reason not to pay up for the garage investigating the repair/ the courtesy car and somehow land it back on me. It sounds like it is not likely in this case so thank you for the reassurance.

OP posts:
IvySneezes · 27/09/2021 18:44

There are exceptions.
I was once in a 50mph dual carriageway and a young driver suddenly switched from left hand lane into right hand lane just a few feet in front of me and slammed on the brakes to stop fully - he was then going to wait to turn right.

Because he’d basically pulled into the gap I’d left for safe braking whilst doing 50mph and slammed his brakes on, the insurance determined he was at fault fully.

He also fled the scene and I had to chase him down until he stopped! His mother then screamed on the phone about it being my fault as I was behind. Luckily the insurance saw that it was fully his fault, that he’d done something incredibly dangerous, and that even at safe distances I couldn’t have stopped due his reckless driving and him pulling out & then braking just feet off my front bumper.

So yes there are exceptions, but I believe not many.

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 27/09/2021 18:39

Maybe if they reversed or rolled back. Or maybe if they had no working brake lights?

Herecomesthesun70 · 27/09/2021 18:35

There are exceptions, this is isn't one of them however.

There won't be any issue with both insurers dealing swiftly with this for you. I'd be surprised if the other insurers don't contact you and offer to sort it out for you.

nokidshere · 27/09/2021 18:35

Yes, this. I had an old friend who was a terrible driver, would start to pull out then stop or suddenly slow down to a stop to turn a corner, no indicators. She was rear ended 4 times and it was always the driver behind at fault even though her actions caused it contributed to it massively.

Doesn't matter if she suddenly stopped, or slowed down to look at flowers, or whatever. The car behind should have room to stop.

DownToTheSeaAgain · 27/09/2021 18:35

Sorry this was in reply to the am I ok question. Brain a bit fuzzy!

OP posts:
DownToTheSeaAgain · 27/09/2021 18:34

@icedcoffees

I think it is possible, but unlikely.
Yes fine. But much more shaken up than I'd have expected. It wasn't a big bump. Thank you Smile
OP posts:
gogohm · 27/09/2021 18:33

Generally yes front car is at fault though there's cases of people deliberately causing crashes by slamming on the brakes (claiming whiplash) so there are exceptions

Faevern · 27/09/2021 18:32

@Purplecatshopaholic

I don’t think so because even if the car in front did something wrong, the car behind should have been far enough behind to stop without hitting the car in front.
Yes, this. I had an old friend who was a terrible driver, would start to pull out then stop or suddenly slow down to a stop to turn a corner, no indicators. She was rear ended 4 times and it was always the driver behind at fault even though her actions caused it contributed to it massively.
icedcoffees · 27/09/2021 18:32

I think it is possible, but unlikely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread