Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it is ever the front car's fault.

82 replies

DownToTheSeaAgain · 27/09/2021 18:21

Someone drove into the back of me today as I was stopping at a crossroads.

Swapped numbers etc etc submitted insurance claim and all that is progressing. It's not a lot of damage but some.

Anyway I was wondering if there were ever a case when it could be construed as my fault for stopping rather than the other person for not stopping. The light was on amber, switching to red. If I'd driven across then I'd have been driving on red.

OP posts:
gamerchick · 28/09/2021 19:53

@gogohm

Generally yes front car is at fault though there's cases of people deliberately causing crashes by slamming on the brakes (claiming whiplash) so there are exceptions
Yeah I'm pretty sure it's a case by case thing because of all the scammers.

The only time I can think of, is if a car smashes into the car in front, which bumps into the car in front of that... while stationary, in a traffic jam

Aren't you supposed to use the handbrake in such a situation to try and prevent that?

EmoIsntDead · 28/09/2021 19:48

I really must but myself a dashcam... 🤔

takingmytimeonmyride · 28/09/2021 19:40

My friend was stopped (at a junction I think) when the car in front went into reverse and slammed into the front of her car. Then claimed she'd driven into them and they'd got whiplash injuries etc. Hmm No witnesses so it was their word against hers.

JellyfishandShells · 28/09/2021 19:27

I was waiting at a red light once behind a van. To my horror, it suddenly reversed back- I barely had time to reach for my horn before it hit me. He stopped and got out - totally shocked, saying that he hadn’t seen me behind him and made the manoeuvre so that he could make a last minute decision to move to the left hand lane. He really can’t have looked in his side mirrors at all ( no rear as there were no rear windows) as I was not tucked up closed behind him (he had ladders on the top and I was giving them a wide berth ) and my car wasn’t small.

Fortunately there were witnesses, who were nearly as astonished as me, and he was very, very apologetic. We exchanged details and it turned out he lived next door to a friend of mine.

I received a note of apology from him the next day, saying that he’d rather pay directly rather than go through his insurance - which I passed onto my insurance company as they were already involved in arranging the repair to my front.

The insurance company said I was very fortunate to have had good witnesses and his written admission in the form of the note, since he could otherwise have later challenged my version of events, no matter how nice he seemed at the time, and it would have automatically been deemed my fault as that is the standard position.

Thisyearcandoone · 28/09/2021 19:01

Yes! I was driving once and went around a corner to find a car stopped talking to someone on the pavement. My insurance fought it and she accepted liability in the end

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/09/2021 18:57

My mum won a court case after she drove into a car in front. It was because they have overtaken her, pulled in and then immediately slammed on their brakes. If you were just stopping at a light it was the car behind's fault for not keeping their braking distance.

Herecomesthesun70 · 28/09/2021 18:45

@30kgtogo

Someone did a “cash for crash” in front of me couple of years ago - she did an emergency stop on a freely moving 40mph dual carriageway…. I also did emergency stop, but our number plates just made contact. No damage to hers, slightly cracked my number plate. Small children in car with me, so v scary. Clearly I had not left quite enough stopping distance. We got out, had a look agreed no damage on hers, all unhurt, v relieved. She became quite agitated when saw children were with me… we did exchange details and I stupidly didn’t take photos. 10 mins later receive a text saying her boot and bumper have significant damage, and she has whiplash. My insurance company didn’t even contest it on the basis of me going into her - so my fault. I know that technically it is, but still makes me angry. Lost over 20 years no claims bonus and doubled my premium. I had no choice but to report it as insurance void otherwise. A friend’s driving instructor husband in a big city says it is rife. Grrr - as you were.
You could have contested this. Surely your insurer inspected both vehicles. You should have only lost 2 years bonus
DeepfriedPizza · 28/09/2021 18:20

Dh hit a car in front in traffic lights. His fault and accepted such at time of accident and would have been fine if other party hadn’t lied about it. They lied about their injuries, claimed an ambulance was called, lied about who was driving etc. After investigation it turned out it wasn’t the first time they’d tried it on and they ended up In court. Dh had a no fault claim on his policy.

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 28/09/2021 18:16

Never. You always leave enough distance for the speed you're doing to be able to stop. They didnt. Their fault.

Technically they weren't driving with due care and attention.

mogsrus · 28/09/2021 18:10

Undue care & attention is used when someone bumps you from behind,just been through this myself,at a roundabout

KingsleyShacklebolt · 28/09/2021 18:07

@DownToTheSeaAgain

Someone drove into the back of me today as I was stopping at a crossroads.

Swapped numbers etc etc submitted insurance claim and all that is progressing. It's not a lot of damage but some.

Anyway I was wondering if there were ever a case when it could be construed as my fault for stopping rather than the other person for not stopping. The light was on amber, switching to red. If I'd driven across then I'd have been driving on red.

Not unless it's one of those "crash for cash" scenarios where someone is happily making progress along a clear road and slams on the anchors for no reason.
WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld · 28/09/2021 18:02

I was on the motorway coming up to roadworks and in the outside lane. A van came from the slip road, crossed all the lanes then slammed on in front of me and I went into the back of him. A copper was standing in the central reservation and had a right go at him when he jumped out shouting and blaming me
If the cop hadn't been there I would have been considered to be at fault

Myusernameisnotmyusernameno · 28/09/2021 17:42

Yeah I once crashed into an accident that had already happened and people had stopped and were exchanging details. It was round a bend on a 40mph road, I was doing about 35-no warning triangle. It ended up being my 'fault' and I had to pay for the man who crashed into the others. He also was about to have a go at me until he saw my 7 months pregnant bump Hmm.

Purplewithred · 28/09/2021 17:29

I've only had a couple of prangs, variously my/the other person's fault, and have always found the insurance companies amazingly kind and helpful even when I drove into the stationary car in front on a roundabout because I was pointing a lovely magnolia out to my mum

30kgtogo · 28/09/2021 17:24

@JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon, just seen your post - I didn’t know that scammers disable the brake lights! I wonder if that was the case with my crash? Kept wondering why I didn’t react in time….

LakieLady · 28/09/2021 17:23

@Sickening

The only time I can think of, is if a car smashes into the car in front, which bumps into the car in front of that... while stationary, in a traffic jam.

Happened to me! Mind you, even with that, they might argue stopping distance wasn't long enough, even though nobody was driving at the time (well, other than the back driver who started it all!).

A friend I know was driving along when the car in front stopped suddenly (to let a duck and ducklings cross the road!). Friend stopped fine, but the car behind ran into him and shunted him forwards into the car in front.

The damage to the car he hit was paid for by his insurance, even though the driver behind caused it.

30kgtogo · 28/09/2021 17:22

Someone did a “cash for crash” in front of me couple of years ago - she did an emergency stop on a freely moving 40mph dual carriageway…. I also did emergency stop, but our number plates just made contact. No damage to hers, slightly cracked my number plate. Small children in car with me, so v scary. Clearly I had not left quite enough stopping distance.
We got out, had a look agreed no damage on hers, all unhurt, v relieved. She became quite agitated when saw children were with me… we did exchange details and I stupidly didn’t take photos.
10 mins later receive a text saying her boot and bumper have significant damage, and she has whiplash.
My insurance company didn’t even contest it on the basis of me going into her - so my fault. I know that technically it is, but still makes me angry. Lost over 20 years no claims bonus and doubled my premium. I had no choice but to report it as insurance void otherwise.
A friend’s driving instructor husband in a big city says it is rife.
Grrr - as you were.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 28/09/2021 17:17

Only in very very limited circumstances.

Generally "induced accidents" which are a form of fraud. Often the front car will have its brake lights disabled and the car will slam on at a clear junction.

Other circumstances that aren't fraud related might involve a mechanical fault that causes the car in front to stop suddenly without showing brake lights. That happened to my ex and the police confirmed in writing that he was entirely blameless, he made a full recovery from the insurer of the front vehicle.

Tangletester · 28/09/2021 17:17

The car behind is definitely to blame in your case. Even a small bump can shake you up, hope you are ok.

When I reversed back at a junction into a car I was definitely to blame Confused! The guy behind was really worried I would tell the insurance that he had driven into me as it would have been very hard to disprove. He was so kind though that he made me cry.

PleaseReferToMeAsBritneySpears · 28/09/2021 17:13

A few years ago my dad was driving and came to a stop as the bridge ahead was single lane only. The van in front of him reversed into him. Dad beeped and tried to reverse himself, but didn't get back in time. They exchanged details but there was minimal damage.

Anyway, the arsehole van driver claimed my dad rear ended him. Claimed his van was totally fucked up and they had whiplash. Dad's bloody insurance company settled. Angry

DotBall · 28/09/2021 17:07

The only time I can think of, is if a car smashes into the car in front, which bumps into the car in front of that... while stationary, in a traffic jam

This happened to me (I was stationary in the middle and got shunted into the car in front) - we both claimed off the guy at the back, no issues.

raspberrymuffin · 28/09/2021 17:03

I very slowly rear ended someone who had started then changed her mind going onto a roundabout. Totally my fault as I should have been looking at her rather than checking traffic coming on to the roundabout to see if there was a gap for me. Though admittedly it was a bit frustrating when she said it happened to her all the time - maybe it was your friend @Faevern!

DixonD · 28/09/2021 17:00

A car once crossed lanes on a roundabout so that a family member of mine went straight into the back of him. There was a witness so his insurance had to pay out as it was clearly deliberate. He had tried repeatedly up to that point to get my family member to collide with him.

LaundryForever · 28/09/2021 16:59

Nope, car went into the back of me and apparently it was 50/50 according to my insurance company🙄

DixonD · 28/09/2021 16:57

@nokidshere

Yes, this. I had an old friend who was a terrible driver, would start to pull out then stop or suddenly slow down to a stop to turn a corner, no indicators. She was rear ended 4 times and it was always the driver behind at fault even though her actions caused it contributed to it massively.

Doesn't matter if she suddenly stopped, or slowed down to look at flowers, or whatever. The car behind should have room to stop.

Yep. Sorry, your friend, although driving poorly, it is still the fault of the driver behind for not a) staying back far enough (can’t abide tailgaters), and b) not paying attention.
Swipe left for the next trending thread