Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it is ever the front car's fault.

82 replies

DownToTheSeaAgain · 27/09/2021 18:21

Someone drove into the back of me today as I was stopping at a crossroads.

Swapped numbers etc etc submitted insurance claim and all that is progressing. It's not a lot of damage but some.

Anyway I was wondering if there were ever a case when it could be construed as my fault for stopping rather than the other person for not stopping. The light was on amber, switching to red. If I'd driven across then I'd have been driving on red.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Herecomesthesun70 · 29/09/2021 07:54

@Getmoveon14

My grandmother had an accident at a time in her life when she really shouldn't have still been driving. She pulled out of a side road in front of a lorry. The gap was too small and he went into the back of her. Although it technically didn't count as her fault, she was sent on a driver awareness course.
That is technically her fault. If she pulled out of a side road in front of a lorry who would have had no chance of braking it's definitely her fault.
Getmoveon14 · 29/09/2021 06:58

My grandmother had an accident at a time in her life when she really shouldn't have still been driving. She pulled out of a side road in front of a lorry. The gap was too small and he went into the back of her. Although it technically didn't count as her fault, she was sent on a driver awareness course.

30kgtogo · 29/09/2021 02:04

@Herecomesthesun70, thank you for that info - I will check my records tomorrow and query the no claims 👍

Herecomesthesun70 · 28/09/2021 22:36

[quote 30kgtogo]@Herecomesthesun70, thank you - I thought the same, and vociferously said this with my insurer. It was so clearly a scam. Their view was that it was my fault as the driver behind, and were not willing to defend my stance. They refused to inspect my vehicle (I took photos of mine an hour after the collision), and just believed what the other driver claimed for.
I’m sure in professional scammers, they either cause damage later, or have a mechanic in on the scam, willing to confirm or fix the “damage”… who knows?

@SudokuWillNotSaveYou good idea. I’ve never bothered as I have an old banger, but realise now could still save me from claim for damaging someone else’s expensive car.[/quote]
Your insurer would be able to tell if the damage was consistent. My thoughts are that they settled it economically for a couple of hundred because taking it to court would have cost thousands.

Still doesn't explain 20 years off your bonus however.
Maximum bonus is generally 5 years so you would have gone down to 3 after the accident

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 28/09/2021 22:34

@30kgtogo Yes, I think people don’t realize what a huge deal it can be until it happens to them or someone they know (or hear about personally)? But someone getting in a minor bumper scrape, and then the other party making some claim that can ruin your insurance without hurting your car at all, is happening more and more, and it’s hard to refute without some kind of proof. So many people forget to take pictures or think they won’t possibly need to.

And yes, even a few years ago, it might not have been worth it for a banger but now they have them for under £20. And it’s for your protection too; someone could hit you and then claim it was your fault.

They even have backup camera kits you can install on older cars that are so cheap now (compared to what they charge you as an “extra” installed on a new car). Drives me bonkers seeing used cars, same number plate, where the only difference is that it was an “ultra” package that came with a backup camera so the price goes up by £100s when you can get one of those off Amazon and install it yourself. Ugh. Don’t get me started.

30kgtogo · 28/09/2021 22:04

@Herecomesthesun70, thank you - I thought the same, and vociferously said this with my insurer. It was so clearly a scam. Their view was that it was my fault as the driver behind, and were not willing to defend my stance. They refused to inspect my vehicle (I took photos of mine an hour after the collision), and just believed what the other driver claimed for.
I’m sure in professional scammers, they either cause damage later, or have a mechanic in on the scam, willing to confirm or fix the “damage”… who knows?

@SudokuWillNotSaveYou good idea. I’ve never bothered as I have an old banger, but realise now could still save me from claim for damaging someone else’s expensive car.

Kendodd · 28/09/2021 21:38

Driving along in the same lane behind one another, I can't see how it could be anyone except the driver behind fault, maintain a safe distance. I suppose if both the brake lights were out in the car infront maybe?

DownToTheSeaAgain · 28/09/2021 21:29

@MrsArchchancellorRidcully

Sadly even if it all goes as expected op and it's deemed you're not at fault, be prepared for your premiums to go up. Even admitting you've had an accident makes the actuaries nervous and seem you more risky.
Yes but not reporting it to the insurance would be illegal. Even if we didn't make a claim. We've got a protected no claims but I have absolutely no doubt that when we come to renew the price will go up.
OP posts:
MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 28/09/2021 21:16

Sadly even if it all goes as expected op and it's deemed you're not at fault, be prepared for your premiums to go up. Even admitting you've had an accident makes the actuaries nervous and seem you more risky.

HuhWhatNow · 28/09/2021 21:15

@thinkfast

I was once on a bus which was over taken by a speeding car which then slammed on its brakes right in front of the bus. Bus crashed into the back of the car. Loads of people in the bus fell over / were shaken /hurt. I was sitting on the front seat of the top deck so had a very clear view of the incident.

The people in the car jumped straight out with their phones to take photos and exchange details.

I'm confident it was an extremely dangerous scam. I can't see how the bus driver could've avoided the collision. Can't see how bus driver could be to blame for it.

It's a very common crash for cash scam where I grew up in Lancashire. The car that swings in front of the bus would be full of people. As many as could legally fit. All would have "whiplash". The bus would also have many of their friends and family on board who would also make a claim for whiplash and other injuries.

As a result, all buses have cameras EVERYWHERE. Dash cams, side and rear cams and internal ones too.

The police saw too many incidences occurring and started doing checks on the passengers and found that they tended to be related to the people in the cars. Most ended up on fraud charges.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 28/09/2021 21:14

@GrouchyKiwi

What about in a case like this?

We were on a motorway going 70, DH indicated to pull into the middle lane from the right lane after passing someone, and moved across. As he did the driver from the left lane pulled into the middle at the same time without indicating.

Thankfully both drivers swerved and avoided crashing, but it was bloody terrifying at that speed. If we had crashed would DH have been considered at fault?

(I realise at that speed it would have been a terrible, horrible accident and maybe they don't bother about blame in those situations?)

That would be a 50:50 between insurers. Unless witnesses said otherwise.
MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 28/09/2021 21:13

I've always viewed it as..... if a child ran out, could I stop in time?... and adjust my speed, distance from car in front accordingly.

MaisyMary77 · 28/09/2021 21:08

After having someone try repeatedly to get me to crash into them on a very large but quiet roundabout, I got a dash cam. That was a scary couple of minutes!!
It’s really reassuring to know it’s there.

ilovemydogandmrobama2 · 28/09/2021 21:08

worked in insurance and mostly it's never the fault of the driver in front with very few exceptions, i.e. 'slam on,' where a driver will intentionally drive in front of vehicle, and suddenly and without warning slam on brakes, get hit and passengers will claim personal injury.

GrouchyKiwi · 28/09/2021 20:53

Sorry - left lane car was slightly ahead.

GrouchyKiwi · 28/09/2021 20:51

What about in a case like this?

We were on a motorway going 70, DH indicated to pull into the middle lane from the right lane after passing someone, and moved across. As he did the driver from the left lane pulled into the middle at the same time without indicating.

Thankfully both drivers swerved and avoided crashing, but it was bloody terrifying at that speed. If we had crashed would DH have been considered at fault?

(I realise at that speed it would have been a terrible, horrible accident and maybe they don't bother about blame in those situations?)

PenOrPencil · 28/09/2021 20:47

Somebody drove into the back/side of my car on a roundabout while trying to undertake me. Insurance settled on 50/50 and she claimed for whiplash.

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 28/09/2021 20:35

I really, REALLY recommend getting a dashcam, front and back. They are so dead cheap on Amazon, do not require a mechanic to connect, and it could save your 20 year no claims bonus or years of elevated claims in the future or save you from someone backing into you and claiming you rear-ended them (someone reversing into you is often an accident fraud now so I wouldn’t count on them being honest and it often might happen when there are no witnesses or they have one and you don’t! My friend had it happen, pointed to his dash cam, and the other driver ran back to his car and scarpered off!). Some insurance policies will even give you a discount for having them, like a speed black box. If the OP had dashcams, there would be no worry - it would show that she wasn’t doing any dangerous driving when hit, and other driver is 100% at fault (if he or she claims otherwise).

BurntO · 28/09/2021 20:13

I remember reading on here about a woman pulling off a slip road onto a pretty quiet motor way. No traffic so she checked her blind spot and started to pull out but the car infront of her had put its breaks on and stopped at the end of the slip road despite their being no cars coming. She was checking her blind spot so rear ended them. Not sure what happened but it seems unfair.

itsgettingwierd · 28/09/2021 20:11

Shouldn't think so.

I was driving behind a van today as lights turned amber. We were both about to go through and I'd have carried on.

He stopped suddenly and had stopped at line before it even went red.

I know it would have been my fault if I'd gone into the back of him even though he stopped very quickly and very unnecessarily!

Bonbon21 · 28/09/2021 20:06

Take it easy for a few days... emotional and physical reaction may well hit you later on.

Bonbon21 · 28/09/2021 20:05

Car in front of me did emergency stop because car in front of him suddenly braked and turned right at the last moment.
I did emergency stop.
Woman behind me admitted she was chatting and looking at her passenger when she drove into me and shunted me into the car in front.
£4500 damage ( front and back end damage to my 6 month old car ) and £1400 whiplash payment (which I didnt actually ask for but accepted gracefully) paid by her insurance company without any hassle.. also got a courtesy car for the 6 WEEKS it took to fix my car....

Starrycolors23 · 28/09/2021 19:59

Not true - you can be forced into 50/50 if the rear driver argues that you rolled backwards, especially easy if bad weather. Happened to me.

DownToTheSeaAgain · 28/09/2021 19:59

Good point @KrisAkabusi. I was actually a lot more shook up than I realised yesterday even though I wasn't hurt at all.

OP posts:
KrisAkabusi · 28/09/2021 19:56

@DownToTheSeaAgain

Thank you. I'm worried that the insurance company will somehow find a reason not to pay up for the garage investigating the repair/ the courtesy car and somehow land it back on me. It sounds like it is not likely in this case so thank you for the reassurance.
Even if it was 100% your fault, you're still insured!