Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up of not being able to make any sort of mess?

106 replies

Veggieseverywhere · 27/09/2021 17:38

We both work full time with young kids so DP decided on a cleaner. Fine, except he is now obsessed with the fact no one can make a mess so that the cleaner can clean.

I am getting a bit sick of bowls and plates being whisked off me two seconds after I’ve finished eating, kids toys being doomed to obscurity seconds after they’ve finished playing and even ordinary household items being constantly put away.

It’s really stressing me out. AIBU?

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 28/09/2021 09:25

Have you asked him not to?

NewlyGranny · 28/09/2021 09:21

I knew a family where the house became a sort of clean shrine which nobody could actually live in. The teenage boys and their DF decamped to the garage with an old sofa and TV and basically lived there most of the time. The boys and visiting friends (not many came twice!) were not allowed to pee in the toilet but were sent out to pee in the garden.

This is where it could wind up if OP's DH isn't reined in promptly. Ask him if having a lanyard or pile of half-marked books in view makes him feel anxious. He might need a chat with his GP if he doesn't calm down a bit soon.

Houses are for people to live in; mealtimes are for family togetherness. It is indeed the height of rudeness to begin clearing the table while anyone is still eating, even if it's masticating their final mouthful. Has he never eaten at a decent restaurant? What happens there?

He risks triggering eating disorders in his DC if he hovers to snatch plates away. A meal is not a race and your family are not pigs at a trough. 😡

CaptSkippy · 28/09/2021 08:38

Ignore the trolls, OP. Your husband is either being passive aggressive or he has developed some kind of obsession.

I assume talking isn't helping. I think, just kick up a fuss. Papers of school work gone? Just demand he returns them or hide the keys to your car, so he can't remove anything or put anything inside.

Do you have your own office in the home? I'd say lock that too.

Otherwise, let him have the moment he touches your plate. It may sound extreme, but I can't think of anything else. IF the trouble of swiping stuff from undeer your nose is not worth it anymore, he'll surely stop.

ToadstoolBubbleMaker · 28/09/2021 07:46

YANBU. I'd like my DP and kids to be a bit tidier, but this level is not enjoyable to live with at all.

violetbunny · 28/09/2021 07:41

Could you ask for a compromise? Tell him that anything that you personally leave lying around (dishes, marking etc) will be put away before you go to bed / by 9pm / whatever deadline makes sense. If it's not done by then end of the evening, then he can go to town on clearing up.

PennyWus · 28/09/2021 03:17

I'm with you OP. My DH is like this it drives me a bit crazy. I'm not an untidy person but I like to "live" in my house. My children like to play, and when toys are immediately squared up, often while they are still aying (!) it disrupts their play and removes the chance from them to tidy up themselves.

My DH immediately starts clearing the table the second he has finished eating, even when other people are still eating. I was brought up to find that rude.

I've discussed it with him and we have found ways to compromise over the years. When he gets too obsessive about it I chide him.

The irony is that he doesnt have good housekeeping practices. We have so much junk it is madness - a whole drawerfull of cables no one knows what they are for, another drawer stuffed with random things like visitor passes and unneeded receipts from business trips and shopping, whole cupboards full of sports kit he no longer uses or fits into, heaps and heaps of clothes he doesnt wear so that he has now entirely taken over the walk in wardrobe. He literally never does his paperwork, I have always had to file everything for him . Oh yes the house is beautiful and he has vacuumed the same perfectly clean patch of carpet three times this week, but never in a million years would he tidy up a drawer and everything is stuffed away.

Argh.

SandAndSea · 28/09/2021 01:43

It sounds over the top but could just be a phase. We've had a few here over the years. Wait for a cool moment, have a chat and see if you can come to some kind of agreement about it all.

toomuchlaundry · 28/09/2021 00:07

@EatYourVegetables which bit of the OP’s posts gives you the impression that she is messy. The bit where she still has the bowl out when eating from it? Should she put it in the dishwasher and eat from there! When she has a pile of books out that she is working from. Should she just sit in the car and mark them so not making any mess in the house. Is she messy because she doesn’t tidy up whilst sitting on the toilet?

Snowdropsandbluebells · 27/09/2021 23:42

I love a tidy and clean clutter free home but I would actually scream if someone controlled and followed me around to the toilet or put books I was marking away. Its so weird. Totally horrible.

WomanStanleyWoman · 27/09/2021 23:33

The monitor?! The minute Grin

WomanStanleyWoman · 27/09/2021 23:32

This would drive me absolutely mad. I can’t stand having to wash up the monitor I’ve finished a meal - it makes it feel like eating was just one more chore to get out of the way, and now that’s done it’s on to the next job… just keep ploughing through… where’s the enjoyment?

All these ‘This sounds like an absolute dream!’ posts are so over the top. OP’s husband isn’t tidy; he’s obsessive.

melj1213 · 27/09/2021 23:28

So many willfully obtuse posters in this thread.

There is a difference between "a tidy husband" and a husband that is hovering over you 24/7 to tidy something the literal second that it is put down. One is the dream and the other is an overbearing nightmare.

I am a tidy person, my flat is super organised and I hate mess ... I have still yet to whisk a plate away from DD the second the last forkful of dinner is removed from it, and she is allowed to play with her toys without me hovering to put stuff away the second she stops playing with each item.

HeddaGarbled · 27/09/2021 23:26

How long have you had the cleaner for? With any luck this will just be a temporary obsession and he’ll relax soon.

EatYourVegetables · 27/09/2021 23:22

YABVU, and messy by the sound of it. Please thank your partner, apologise for the mess and help clean up.

slightlysnippy · 27/09/2021 23:15

I can see why your getting annoyed.

Do you think since this isn't his normal level of cleaning most likely his over enthusiasm will wear off soon?

PhoboPhobia · 27/09/2021 23:06

I think everyone saying they would love this is being a bit obtuse.

It’s obvious from the OP that he is being over the top. Following her to the loo with her lanyard? Bonkers. Yes it’s nice to tidy as you go but it’s also nice to chill and not run round like a loon whipping things out from under people’s noses every time they stop what they’re doing.

Honestly, I’m not a slob but is it not exhausting being so uptight about putting things away the second they’re finished with?

Embroidery · 27/09/2021 22:57

I would hate this and feel very stifled.

The more I hear about men the less I want one. I really couldnt bear it.

NewlyGranny · 27/09/2021 22:47

Make some "Police Aware" signs with post-its, and put them on things in progress you don't want touched, or some "crime scene" tape.

Anyone appearing in the loo when you're occupying it needs to be yelled at, as in "Out! What do you think you're doing!!!"

As for the rest, I hope he'll calm down a bit when the novelty wears off. 🤞 Or perhaps you could stage a series of deliberate messes to keep him distracted.

parietal · 27/09/2021 22:39

that would infuriate me. I hate people moving my things around when I expect them to be in the place I left them.

luckily my DH is even messier than me, and we manage just fine in a messy & liveable house.

Innovationstandard · 27/09/2021 22:35

Sounds like a nightmare, yes great to do it but not whisking stuff away whilst you're still using it.

TimeForTeaAndG · 27/09/2021 22:35

I think some people are being willfully obtuse. It's not him tidying, it's him not checking that OP is finished with things and asking her to tidy when she's clearly in the bathroom, that's not tidying that's fucking annoying. Especially if he's usually the one to dump stuff wherever.

Tell him he is being a twat and to pack it in. And don't take any sulking and huffing about only trying to keep the place tidy.

Toddlerteaplease · 27/09/2021 22:33

Sounds exactly like my mum! The washing up is done before we've finished eating!

EmeraldShamrock · 27/09/2021 22:31

He needs to calm down around toys they're easily gathered up and dumped in the toy box.
If he wants to put dishes in the washer tell him to do it quietly when people are finished.

Open a box of cereal chuck it on the floor, be a rebel. 💪

GreatPotato · 27/09/2021 22:27

Gosh toys and pots are put away when they're finished with and everything's put back where it's supposed to be? That must be awful.

gospelsinger · 27/09/2021 22:22

YANBU OP. This is annoying behaviour. The marking being put in the car aaaagh!