Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these changes to the housing waiting list are not “cruel” but simply realistic?

492 replies

Eastie77Returns · 27/09/2021 13:49

Our council has announced changes to the local housing waiting list from next month. There are tens of thousands on the list who will never be housed as they are not deemed to be in urgent need so they will now be removed.

The council has said they will be offered “personalised support to explore their options” which probably means advising they leave London, advances to help with private rent etc. I understand in many cases that is really not helpful but a close relative of mine who works in housing has been on the phone to me in tears because of the level of abuse she has faced from frustrated residents who have been on the list for years and are being removed.

Now a parent from DD’s school is organising a march on the town hall to protest all of this and has asked parents for support. She has been offered a council house 100+ miles outside London and is refusing to leave as her support network is here and I fully understand that. However, I do think a dose of realism is needed. There are 15,000 people on the waiting list here and a few hundred council properties become available each year. This parent has been told she does not fall into the 3 bands that will be kept on the list so she will never get a council house and she has responded by accusing the council of unimaginable cruelty Confused

I don’t understand where she expects the council to magically just find thousands of homes and change that situation?

OP posts:
Kendodd · 28/09/2021 19:40

*@Eastie77Returns
Thank you for the explanation.

onlychildhamster · 28/09/2021 19:31

@ellyeth 100%. And people who move away for work/larger home often have number crunched and realized they could afford it. They would have saved up enough for the move and would hopefully have back up savings if the move did not work out and things weren't as planned. Very different for council tenants who are living hand to mouth.

mel71 · 28/09/2021 19:29

I moved out of London 15 years ago as a single parent as I couldn’t afford it. I moved to a cheaper area that has now become desirable and is experiencing rapid gentrification. I moved away from my friends and family - started again and it was really hard. Should I move and start again? What happens when we run out of cheap areas to move to? We need more social housing.

ellyeth · 28/09/2021 19:26

Most people who own their homes move away out of choice - to take a better job, to move near to family, to buy a bigger house in a cheaper area, etc. etc. - not because you have no option if you want a half way decent home to live in.

My husband and I have moved several times - from Essex to West Sussex, from West Sussex to Lancashire, from Lancashire to London. In all cases, it was for a better job and more money. It can be a wrench at times but you have the security of your own home, which is gradually being paid for and, usually, increasing in value.

It is quite different if you can only afford social housing and you are told that in order to get it you will have to move many miles away from where you are currently living - or else remain in sub-standard, cramped and damp accommodation.

Stop wasting money on ridiculous projects like HS2 (and now Johnson is talking about our own space programme) and make sure our citizens are properly treated.

AnnieSnap · 28/09/2021 19:22

@Waferbiscuit

I really do support the need for SH but as someone from N America, I was really struck by the way so many people I encounter in the UK believe that (a) the govt has a duty to house you and an expectation once housed to be housed forever no matter how good much your circumstances improve and by the belief, backed up by policy that (b) the idea of community and staying in one's network is only of value to those in poorer areas but not at all relevant or considered for the lower-to-middle classes and above. They have to move hours away for work but, on the other hand, it's critical that Jane down the road and her three children live next door to her mom and across from Auntie and cousins. If anything that kind of thinking encourages a kind of tribalism and ultra-reliance on family networks that I find a bit strange.

David Goodheart's book The Road to Somewhere is a really illuminating book about the ideological divide in the country between those who are rooted in 'somewhere' and those who are less rooted, the sort of more metropolitan, international nomads. It helps to explain why some people feel they must live in Islington where they grew up even if most of London can't afford to.

I’m in the UK and I agree with you.
Loulablake · 28/09/2021 19:18

There’s a lot of hard working people that are struggling to save 10% to get a mortgage and then they announced it’s now 15% for some the security of council SH is better than private. I have to rent have a child and it’s very difficult to save that extra when private rental is a lot more. The people who get priority aren’t always the most deserving they can be and some are the stereotypes. There’s nothing wrong in wanting security and to not be penalised cause you work and can pay the rent. If you think about it if they flipped some of who got it. Would councils have better areas.

jwpetal · 28/09/2021 19:14

Why not support her? You don't have to agree with her side. I love that she cares enough to take a stand. That she is asking people to support her cause. That she sees that she can mane a difference and I hope you at least support the tenacity that takes.

onlychildhamster · 28/09/2021 19:14

@Waferbiscuit its because the middle class sends their children to childminders/nurseries and the rich have nannies. Poor people have unpredictable shift patterns, perhaps even zero hour contracts. Night shifts even. Many may not have supportive partners or perhaps even no partner. So they might rely on mum to do the majority of childcare so they can work. Low housing costs mean nothing if you have no income.

I mean, I wasn't born in London but I believed very strongly that I must live in London. In fact I felt so strongly about it that I bought a flat in London instead of moving miles away like most of my peers were doing because I was acutely aware that as a couple with below average income, it was cheaper for us to stay in london with some childcare help from family than to move to a town (where houses are technically cheaper) and have to pay for additional childcare as well as commute. If that is the case for us, what more for a poor person who cannot afford a car or private childcare.

Dudewheresmypetrol · 28/09/2021 19:13

Plenty of people have to move away from their support networks and hometowns, obviously the ideal would be to keep people local but if they can't then surely a home elsewhere is better than nowhere at all?

riceuten · 28/09/2021 19:12

I do wonder if the kind of idiot who thinks only rich people should live in London considers where the people who will be working in their shops, delivering their groceries and cleaning their streets and homes should live? Outside of London and pay a small fortune to commute in ?

Yes, I know, they should have tried harder at school and they should be grateful they have a job

MrsFin · 28/09/2021 19:08

I really don't understand people's reluctance to move if would mean getting a suitable family house.
People move for work all the time, and to downsize/upsize and all kinds of reasons.
You make new friends and develop new support networks.
I'm not suggesting it's always easy, but if it means getting a decent home, it's a no brainer for me.

Waferbiscuit · 28/09/2021 19:05

I really do support the need for SH but as someone from N America, I was really struck by the way so many people I encounter in the UK believe that
(a) the govt has a duty to house you and an expectation once housed to be housed forever no matter how good much your circumstances improve
and by the belief, backed up by policy that
(b) the idea of community and staying in one's network is only of value to those in poorer areas but not at all relevant or considered for the lower-to-middle classes and above. They have to move hours away for work but, on the other hand, it's critical that Jane down the road and her three children live next door to her mom and across from Auntie and cousins. If anything that kind of thinking encourages a kind of tribalism and ultra-reliance on family networks that I find a bit strange.

David Goodheart's book The Road to Somewhere is a really illuminating book about the ideological divide in the country between those who are rooted in 'somewhere' and those who are less rooted, the sort of more metropolitan, international nomads. It helps to explain why some people feel they must live in Islington where they grew up even if most of London can't afford to.

FancySomeChips · 28/09/2021 19:05

I was in a council house. I would have moved away to improve the 4 year wait, but I didn’t qualify as I didn’t have “local links” to anywhere else.

However I do think people should have the choice. Why not offer anyone the chance to move out of area, whether they qualify for a London property or not, no matter where on the list they are??

ellyeth · 28/09/2021 19:02

the year of small things I actually meant to put half their income/salary - I agree, at least in London and other major cities you would not find anything for a quarter of your income.

onlychildhamster · 28/09/2021 18:55

@ComtesseDeSpair and 1 million is a 20% increase in Singapore's population!

onlychildhamster · 28/09/2021 18:55

@ComtesseDeSpair
Public housing in Singapore isn’t social housing as we know it in the UK. A significant proportion (I think even the vast majority of it nowadays) is owner occupied and sold at a slight subsidy to middle-income households, and apartments in major cities can still cost upwards of the equivalent of half a million pounds. It’s more akin to the UK’s Help to Buy and Affordable ownership schemes. It’s also only available to Singaporean citizens, among whom birth rates are among the lowest in the world, so public housing isn’t required to house thousands of non-native poor people.

The difference is that HTB and affordable ownership properties are still built by the private sector and the prices are set by them. So if the government HTB loan is 40%, the price also goes up by 40%. I could not afford a HTB flat but I could afford to buy a 1930s flat in zone 3 london for 400k. This was because I could save a slightly larger deposit. In Singapore, the government sets the prices. Someone who worked in government once told me that they pegged it to average salaries.

Also our flats in Singapore do cater to foreigners because the government has invited over 1 million foreigners to Singapore to do jobs that the locals don't want to do or simply to help the economy grow. Many have now become singaporean, particularly those from third world countries. They are therefore eligible to buy government flats. So while most are not poor as they would have needed to be able to hold down a job to get PR and later citizenship, a lot of them are not rich either! Esp in the earlier years before the backlash against foreigners, the criteria was fairly loose and plenty of lower paid workers managed to get citizenship.

Lifetheuniverseandeverything · 28/09/2021 18:45

Thousands of people who have grown up as children in rentals will be telling their stories about this selfish decade. It’s easy to judge others when you’re well fed and well housed in a safe place.

Fizbosshoes · 28/09/2021 18:43

Even though there is obviously a severe lack of social housing (does the money from right to buy go back into building new homes - although clearly buying a home is quicker than building one) its clear from recent stories that the council are not properly maintaining the existing properties. There were some shocking reports earlier in the year detailing the horrendous state some LA tenants were expected to live with, for months. (I think that was Croydon Council but I've seen other examples)

FreddieMercurysCat · 28/09/2021 18:41

It’s shit, but until we have a government that DO something about it, it’s just how it’s going to be sadly. A few years ago we were in the priority housing band and on the emergency list, but still ended up having to move miles out of area where we had no one. Fast forward 4 years and we finally got offered a flat in our original area. And that was in a really crap area, but we took it and we’re grateful. Fast forward another 4 years and we are fortunately now in my home town and no longer in need of LA housing, but I feel for those who are still battling away with very difficult lists and bidding processes.

Baaba · 28/09/2021 18:39

The original intention for social housing was to help people get on their feet and move on. That's not been the case. Constantly creating more social housing with little infrastructure and insisting the 'rich' pay is also not the answer

onlychildhamster · 28/09/2021 18:39

@TheYearOfSmallThings oh and singapore top tax rate is 20%. 60% of the population pay no tax. Its a lot cheaper to help people have a stable roof over their heads when the government owns over 90% of the land.

The government here has to spend so much on housing benefit because it mainly goes to private landlords who expect to make a profit. Its always cheaper when the government owns the infrastructure. Pity we sold it all off during the thatcher years.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/09/2021 18:35

I wonder how people would feel if they were expected to move 100 miles or more away from the area they have always lived in

Most of us have done it. It is not an abnormal or unusual thing to do. At all.

ERFFER · 28/09/2021 18:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ERFFER · 28/09/2021 18:33

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

onlychildhamster · 28/09/2021 18:33

@TheYearOfSmallThings social housing in Singapore is completely different to the social hosuin system in the UK.Singapore has 92% home ownership rate due to its social housing system, almost all flats are owner occupied with only a tiny number of rental flats for the vulnerable.

How it works: the government builds new flats every year for Singaporean citizens and permanent residents. Most of these flats are family flats measuring 1000 square feet and with 3 bedrooms. They need to be family units of husband/wife; parent and child, singles above the age of 35. There is an income ceiling of the equivalent of £84k combined household income but anyone can buy resale flats. Of course if you subsequently earn more, you can still continue to live in the flat as you own it so high flying graduates would try to purchase a property as soon as possible so they can benefit from the subsidy before upgrading to a private condo at a later stage. The prices are wide ranging - you can pay as little as £200k for a new build in a suburb that is further away from the central or you can pay as much as £550k for a more central flat. Location is key. I have a cousin who bought a more upscale condo which was technically under the 'social housing scheme' but developed by a private developer to cater to the market that earns too much for a vanilla basic flat but too little to buy £1 million condominiums- it had a swimming pool, karaoke room, tennis court, jacuzzi, spa. He paid the equivalent of £400k for this condo which was roughly the same as what I paid for my London flat. There are restrictions around sale, you can only sell to other Singaporeans and you can only rent it out after 5 years unless you go overseas. Also you can't own any other property at the time of buying so even though I am Singaporean, I can't buy government flats as I own a london flat. Minimum deposit is 5% and you can get a mortgage from the government or from the bank. Benefits of getting a mortgage from the government- they are more likely to forgive loans in exceptional circumstances; my aunt got half her loan forgiven after her husband died..

So while it is technically a social housing scheme, it is probably more akin to a national housing scheme. I actually think it would work quite well in London but sadly British people would rather dream of the freehold houses with gardens that they could theoretically own even if statistics show that 1/3 of them never would and this number is only going to increase. I have the distinction of owning the second or third most expensive property amongst my cousins despite being far from the richest simply because I bought in London even though Singapore is one of the most densely populated and expensive cities in the world!