Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these changes to the housing waiting list are not “cruel” but simply realistic?

492 replies

Eastie77Returns · 27/09/2021 13:49

Our council has announced changes to the local housing waiting list from next month. There are tens of thousands on the list who will never be housed as they are not deemed to be in urgent need so they will now be removed.

The council has said they will be offered “personalised support to explore their options” which probably means advising they leave London, advances to help with private rent etc. I understand in many cases that is really not helpful but a close relative of mine who works in housing has been on the phone to me in tears because of the level of abuse she has faced from frustrated residents who have been on the list for years and are being removed.

Now a parent from DD’s school is organising a march on the town hall to protest all of this and has asked parents for support. She has been offered a council house 100+ miles outside London and is refusing to leave as her support network is here and I fully understand that. However, I do think a dose of realism is needed. There are 15,000 people on the waiting list here and a few hundred council properties become available each year. This parent has been told she does not fall into the 3 bands that will be kept on the list so she will never get a council house and she has responded by accusing the council of unimaginable cruelty Confused

I don’t understand where she expects the council to magically just find thousands of homes and change that situation?

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 15:31

I'm all for people being paid enough to house themselves. If you can tell me how loads of businesses can afford to keep up with the spiralling cost of private housing?

Small business owners have posted about this on other threads.

It's not just about affordability either. Stability is priceless (although lack of it costs the taxpayer hugely).

Why are you so against people having the stability of affordable and secure housing?

Btw what do people too ill or disabled to work or caring for a disabled child do? How do they house themselves?

sst1234 · 03/10/2021 15:29

@Tealightsandd

No. Two things would happen. Some unviable businesses would go under, because they cannot exist without government subsidy. And people would have to pay more for their coffee and office cleaning (as per examples given upthread).

Supply and demand.

Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 15:26

sst1234

Well then they'd be an even greater demand for state money. If loads of businesses went bust, people wouldn't be getting any wage, low or otherwise.

sst1234 · 03/10/2021 15:23

*dodging

Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 15:23

That loss means your landlord has less to spend on their purposes than they otherwise would have. If the landlord is the government, that might mean they have to raise more tax. If they are a housing association, they have less money to reinvest in housing.

But when it comes to 'government' money aka the taxpayer, it's impossible to look at social housing in isolation. The costs to the taxpayer of not having social housing is much greater.

The public health housing emergency costs the taxpayer money. A lot of money.

sst1234 · 03/10/2021 15:23

@Tealightsandd

It costs billions to house homeless families and vulnerable individuals in temporary accommodation. Billions more on housing benefts for private rentals, and on the knock on consequences of housing insecurity - mental health support, domestic abuse organisations, social services, criminal justice system.
You keep dissing the question, why are you so against people being paid enough to house themselves?
sst1234 · 03/10/2021 15:20

@Tealightsandd

It would be impossible for many businesses to afford to pay wage high enough to meet the spiralling costs of private rented or bought housing.
Says who? Supply and demand. The concept is as old as time itself.
RandomLondoner · 03/10/2021 15:16

@ShinyThingsDistractMe

Why do you believe social housing is a massive cost?

The rent I pay, pays for the services from my landlord (the LA).

My social house was built in 1921, the last century has seen it pay for itself over and over again.

How is my house costing you?

The subsidy on your property is the difference in price between what you pay and what you would have to pay if they let it to the highest bidder, without any restrictions on who can bid.

That difference in price is a benefit to you, and your gain must logically be someone else's loss. That loss means your landlord has less to spend on their purposes than they otherwise would have. If the landlord is the government, that might mean they have to raise more tax. If they are a housing association, they have less money to reinvest in housing.

How many times over past rents cover the building cost of your house has nothing to do with anything.

RandomLondoner · 03/10/2021 15:02

In other words, if 81% of Singapore housing is HDB (social house), 73% of that 81% is owned by the people who live in it.

RandomLondoner · 03/10/2021 15:00

So how does that work for the 81% of the population of Singapore living in social housing? Are you saying the government are subsidising 81% of households?

I don't how housing is allocated in Singapore, so I can't tell you if social housing there is subsidised. However a quick google has told me that more than 90% of the social housing "tenants" own their houses, to I think it's a very different system, and we shouldn't draw any conclusions about it from one-line statistics.

Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 14:48

It costs billions to house homeless families and vulnerable individuals in temporary accommodation. Billions more on housing benefts for private rentals, and on the knock on consequences of housing insecurity - mental health support, domestic abuse organisations, social services, criminal justice system.

Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 14:45

If social housing were not better value for money for tenants than the private sector, no-one would spend extended periods of times on a waiting list trying to get it.

Some things are priceless. Stability and remaining close to support networks, for example.

When looking at costs, it's important to bear in mind all related costs. Such as the knock on consequences of social cleansing.

RandomLondoner · 03/10/2021 14:41

The majority of council houses were built decades ago and the cost of building them has long since been repaid many times over by tenants paying rent to the council. There is no subsidy.

You don't understand what subsidy is. None of the factors you mention, what a house cost to build and how much rent has been collected on it, are of any relevance to the question of whether a house is subsidised.

Here is a short rule-of-thumb that's based on economics. Where there's a waiting list for it, housing is being subsidised.

Wherever market forces govern resource allocation, there is no waiting list, because the price simply rises until demand matches supply.

Waiting lists are literally the alternative resource algorithm that naturally comes into existence as soon as you start trying to defy market forces.

If social housing were not better value for money for tenants than the private sector, no-one would spend extended periods of times on a waiting list trying to get it.

Actually, I need to elaborate a little. Subsidy implies someone is getting more of something than they are paying for. The logical corolllary of that is that the supplier is getting less money for something than it's worth. So, wherever there's a waiting list to be a social tenant, the tenants are on the list because their rents will be less than a market rate. And that means the council, housing association or charity providing the housing is getting less than their asset is worth, decreasing the amount of money it has to spend on the things it thinks are important. Perhaps they think discounted housing is a good use of money. I would say they're better off collecting full rents then spending it on their charitable purposes, then they won't end up subsidising people whose circumstances have changed and who are therefor no longer the best candidates for any subsidy.

Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 14:38

It would be impossible for many businesses to afford to pay wage high enough to meet the spiralling costs of private rented or bought housing.

sst1234 · 03/10/2021 14:36

@Tealightsandd

Social housing tenants pay rent.

There's the massive societal and moral benefts of social housing - secure affordable housing.

But, if you must reduce it solely to financial. It costs the taxpayer hugely to fund the consequences of the public health housing and homelessness emergency. Much much more than the cost of buying and building social housing.

You keep making the same irrelevant point without tackling the issue head on. What is your opposition to paying people a wage that doesn’t leave them reliant on social housing and benefits? Why do you prefer subsidizing low pay?
Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 14:31

Social housing tenants pay rent.

There's the massive societal and moral benefts of social housing - secure affordable housing.

But, if you must reduce it solely to financial. It costs the taxpayer hugely to fund the consequences of the public health housing and homelessness emergency. Much much more than the cost of buying and building social housing.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 03/10/2021 14:31

Hmmmm yeah I can’t afford to live anywhere near where my support network would be ! I had to move away from my family to get an affordable place to rent privately ! That’s real life tbh 🤷‍♀️

sst1234 · 03/10/2021 14:27

@Tealightsandd

The taxpayer wouldn't need to subsidise low pay. If we had more social housing.
Social housing IS subsidized.
Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 14:25

Disabled people always forgotten/erased (ever since Blair's war on them).

They're not rubbish to throw away.

Vulnerable disabled people and families caring for a disabled child need to stay near to support networks.

Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 14:23

The taxpayer wouldn't need to subsidise low pay. If we had more social housing.

sst1234 · 03/10/2021 14:22

@Aspiringmatriarch

False argument. Incomes are low because of the subsidies. The low incomes would be higher if the coffee drinkers and office dweller had to pay proper wages for people to do these jobs, rather than the taxpayer subsidizing their offices to be cleaned.

Even though you've said the net contributors who presumably are buying the coffees etc can't afford to live in London either? How much higher would incomes have to be, and what are people supposed to do in the meantime?

As much as it takes to live in London. Supply and demand is that simple. If you don’t pay people enough, you won’t get the staff, until the taxpayer starts subsidizing low pay of course.
Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 14:15

And of course more people especially women will be unable to work. Particularly lower income parents reply on family support with childcare to be able to work. Paid for childcare is expensive.

Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 14:14

Currently violence against women is high profile. Media, government and opposition, and the public. All expressing concern for victims. Yet 70% of murdered women are killed at home. In many cases, it's because they can't afford to leave. Due to the high cost of housing.

Moving on to mental health (funding increased demand costs the taxpayer hugely). Experts have noted the impact of poverty, homelessness, and housing insecurity. Bad enough for adults but devastating for already vulnerable children who need stability.

There's another thread on here from a few days ago. Someone is moving house long distance. She's being quoted £3-5000 for the removal costs.

It's not so simple as telling low income families and vulnerable individuals to 'just move somewhere cheaper'.

Btw 'somewhere cheaper' won't stay somewhere cheaper if we keep on socially cleansing people there on mass.

Aspiringmatriarch · 03/10/2021 14:10

The importance of support networks to vulnerable families and disabled people is immense. It is absolutely not ok to dump vulnerable people far away from their home, communities, families, and support networks - even more so not ok if it's during a period when they are already experiencing great distress, trauma, or other difficult life circumstances.

Completely agree Tealightsandd. It baffles me why people are so in thrall to free market economic principles when it comes to the frankly insane housing situation in this country and the many many families affected by it.

Tealightsandd · 03/10/2021 14:06

@Aspiringmatriarch

False argument. Incomes are low because of the subsidies. The low incomes would be higher if the coffee drinkers and office dweller had to pay proper wages for people to do these jobs, rather than the taxpayer subsidizing their offices to be cleaned.

Even though you've said the net contributors who presumably are buying the coffees etc can't afford to live in London either? How much higher would incomes have to be, and what are people supposed to do in the meantime?

Well, yes, incomes can only go up by so much. Businesses - the many small and medium-sized sized ones - would face going bust.

But the taxpayer can't afford to keep subsidising employers either.

We need lots more social housing.

It's a financial as well as moral issue.

The public health housing and homelessness emergency costs (the taxpayer) billions and billions.

Directly, with the funding of very expensive temporary accommodation and high housing benefit bill.

And indirectly through the costs resulting from the knock on consequences - increased demand for domestic abuse support, mental health care, social services, the criminal justice system, etc.