Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these changes to the housing waiting list are not “cruel” but simply realistic?

492 replies

Eastie77Returns · 27/09/2021 13:49

Our council has announced changes to the local housing waiting list from next month. There are tens of thousands on the list who will never be housed as they are not deemed to be in urgent need so they will now be removed.

The council has said they will be offered “personalised support to explore their options” which probably means advising they leave London, advances to help with private rent etc. I understand in many cases that is really not helpful but a close relative of mine who works in housing has been on the phone to me in tears because of the level of abuse she has faced from frustrated residents who have been on the list for years and are being removed.

Now a parent from DD’s school is organising a march on the town hall to protest all of this and has asked parents for support. She has been offered a council house 100+ miles outside London and is refusing to leave as her support network is here and I fully understand that. However, I do think a dose of realism is needed. There are 15,000 people on the waiting list here and a few hundred council properties become available each year. This parent has been told she does not fall into the 3 bands that will be kept on the list so she will never get a council house and she has responded by accusing the council of unimaginable cruelty Confused

I don’t understand where she expects the council to magically just find thousands of homes and change that situation?

OP posts:
RandomLondoner · 27/09/2021 17:12

Government to build more social housing, stock incredibly depleted. A Conservative govt will not though as against their ideology.

I bloody hope they won't. Social housing should not exist at all, at least not for anyone physically and mentally competent to live without daily help in their everyday life.

There should be one method of allocating housing, ability to afford it in the private market, and the people who need help with that should get it through a rational system that quickly adjusts to changes in circumstances, i.e. housing benefit/allowance.

(I would support changes to the housing market so that secure tenancies are available for whoever wants one, at market prices. I also have no objection to not-for-profit landlords such as housing associations being in the mix. Local government should not be landlords though, as it leads to conflicts of interest. Nobody with an interest in the property market should be in charge of granting planning permission.)

Social housing is an archaic hangover from past political stupidity, politicians can't be seen to get rid of it, but if it didn't exist, it wouldn't be invented, because it's a stupid way to subsidise the poor.

(Yes I know people think some social housing isn't subsidised. My short answer is wherever there's a waiting list, there's a subsidy. Waiting lists are what happen when market forces are not allowed to allocate resources.)

Hogwarts4Christmas · 27/09/2021 17:11

I think it's realistic.

Lots of people have to move away to be able to afford housing; why should it be any different for someone on SH?
I don't know anyone who's been able to 'afford' to stay in the area they grew up in; whether that's due to rent/buying costs or lack of job opportunities, etc.
People move away for many reasons and there shouldn't be a 'right' to stay where you were born.

Clocktopus · 27/09/2021 17:11

Yes, very cruel to give people subsidized/free housing

Social Housing isn't subsidised or free. Rent is due on it just the same as private properties. It's not subsidised either, it doesn't include profit margins for the landlord, in most cases social housing pays for itself, and in many areas of the UK its not that much cheaper than private renting - we have council properties here that are actually more than some private rentals.

MercyBooth · 27/09/2021 17:09

@anniegun Well the more affluent will have to care for Granny themselves then.

MercyBooth · 27/09/2021 17:08

Really? I think the bidding process is inhumane. Cant win though can they. Because they also get moaned at for having a smartphone to do the bidding on.

sst1234 · 27/09/2021 17:04

@Standrewsschool

In the town I live in, offices are being converted to flats. The rumours is that they re being brought by london boroughs to house people.
Makes good sense.
Standrewsschool · 27/09/2021 17:02

About forty miles from london.

Standrewsschool · 27/09/2021 17:02

In the town I live in, offices are being converted to flats. The rumours is that they re being brought by london boroughs to house people.

PearlclutchersInc · 27/09/2021 16:59

If she has a support network lucky her; quite understand why she wouldnt want to leave [missing the point].

I dont know what the solution is as the obvious one is never going to happen (build A LOT MORE council houses).

anniegun · 27/09/2021 16:59

We live in a LA that has done this. They have built zero homes for social rent , just relied on a trickle being supplied by the developers (who have built thousands of private homes on new estates). Then they booted 1000's of people off the waiting list , so if you have kids but live with parents you cant even join the list now. Then they wonder why all the young people are leaving the area and there are no staff for the care homes.

Bigassbeebuzzbuzz · 27/09/2021 16:57

While I agree more sh should be built I cant help but think the whole giving tenants to bid on the property THEY want to live in has given them the impression that they can be picky. Yes that might work in some places where there is ample sh but in places like london I just dont think it works.
I wouldnt say it was the tenants fault either the council/ha have told them to bid on properties they want to live in so they do.
Cant blame them for not bidding on one 100 miles away.

woodhill · 27/09/2021 16:56

@RandomLondoner

Yes, flats are being built left, right and centre but there should be priority for people in the UK not overseas investors.

It's a complete myth that London new-build flats are being left empty, the current Mayor of London commissioned research which proved it wasn't true.

Given the flats are occupied, and that flats are in the UK, the people occupying them are UK people, since they live here. So the flats are occupied by UK people, you already have exactly what you want.

That's reassuring but I still think overseas investment should've limited or even stopped,especially when the person does not reside here at all and it is purely an investment

My db was a resident in a Far Eastern country for several years but he wasn't allowed to buy a property there as he wasn't a national

VaizyCrazyDaizy · 27/09/2021 16:56

It’s all a farce because the councils sit on millions of pounds of investments and could build council houses, some do build small amounts but a hundred or so not the thousands needed. The Government won’t allow mass building of social housing as its not their policy. My London Borough rehouses many from inner London Boroughs council lists while telling local families they have to move away from the area for cheaper private rental. The whole system is rubbish.

sst1234 · 27/09/2021 16:56

@TheFairyCaravan

It’s not a leap of imagination to expect that wages would up for those jobs which are low paid today.

Really? People have been struggling for years however it’s not happened yet.

Because we subsidize low pay. Surely you have not missed that fact.
TheFairyCaravan · 27/09/2021 16:55

It’s not a leap of imagination to expect that wages would up for those jobs which are low paid today.

Really? People have been struggling for years however it’s not happened yet.

RandomLondoner · 27/09/2021 16:51

Yes, flats are being built left, right and centre but there should be priority for people in the UK not overseas investors.

It's a complete myth that London new-build flats are being left empty, the current Mayor of London commissioned research which proved it wasn't true.

Given the flats are occupied, and that flats are in the UK, the people occupying them are UK people, since they live here. So the flats are occupied by UK people, you already have exactly what you want.

MercyBooth · 27/09/2021 16:51

I bet you expect ppl in that "subsidized free housing" to wear masks and have vaccines to protect you. Suddenly all in it together then arent we!!

sst1234 · 27/09/2021 16:49

@TheFairyCaravan

DH has been in the military for all my married life so I’ve never lived near a family support network and it’s utterly shit. My kids have never known what it’s like to call in to their grandparents’ or cousins’ houses after school or on a weekend. I’ve never called in on my mum for a chinwag ‘just because’. A lot of my old school friends are still really friendly with each other, but I’ve not been in that group for 29 years and it makes me feel a bit envious at times. Yes I’ve got friends from postings but it’s not the same.

We’re just about to move again because DH is retiring from the military and has a new job that isn’t really commutable from where we are. I don’t want to go. It’s great when you’re moving for work and you have a job to be in all day, it’s not so great when you don’t or can’t work. A support network isn’t just friends and family either. I’m chronically sick. I’ve got a wonderful relationship with my GP and my hospital consultants who know me and my conditions well. So I don’t blame the school mum for not wanting to move.

It’s all well and good moving people who need social housing out of London but what will happen when there’s vacancies to be filled in the traditionally lower paid jobs and everyone has gone because they couldn’t afford to stay?

It’s not a leap of imagination to expect that wages would up for those jobs which are low paid today.
woodhill · 27/09/2021 16:49

[quote AngelDelight28]@Sciurus83 I agree. I've had to move several times to where the work is, not always necessarily places I would have chosen to live otherwise. It's like when people complain that they can't buy a house in the exact neighbourhood where they grew up. It isn't a god-given right, and neither is living near your support network, although obviously it's nice if you're able to.

I also don't get the hysteria about "social cleansing". This just isn't a thing in the UK. You either can afford to live somewhere, or you can't. No one is being forced to move out of London, they're merely being 0FFERED social housing elsewhere...because that's where there's housing available. They don't have to take it, they can make their own arrangements to rent privately. If they can't afford that then they have to move to a cheaper area that they CAN afford. That's just life, it's what everyone renting privately or buying their own home has to do. [/quote]
Yep, neither of my dds live nearby

I miss my dgd.

I live near dm though which is nice

sst1234 · 27/09/2021 16:47

@Snugglepumpkin

This is cruel because no part of the criteria will be weighted towards people who have family or a support network in the area, so endless crisis situations which may occur for famiies who could actually move away without losing support networks will get to stay on the list while those who have never known anywhere else & would struggle will be moved away.

Of course, the best chances for promotion, training, great careers etc in the country... won't be getting rehoused 100 miles away so the more local people in housing need will be moved away from all that too.
Where I live now, my oldest son (who is doing very well in life & buying a new house so not in social housing) had to move to London after he finished his education to get the career he wanted because down here the only jobs he could apply for were hotel trainee night porter, care worker or factory worker.
Nothing wrong with those jobs, but if he'd stayed to do those he'd need social housing.
When my youngest son leaves education, that is where he will end up too in order to have a decent chance at life.
Sadly, London is where the jobs are.

Very cruel.

Yes, very cruel to give people subsidized/free housing.
TheFairyCaravan · 27/09/2021 16:47

DH has been in the military for all my married life so I’ve never lived near a family support network and it’s utterly shit. My kids have never known what it’s like to call in to their grandparents’ or cousins’ houses after school or on a weekend. I’ve never called in on my mum for a chinwag ‘just because’. A lot of my old school friends are still really friendly with each other, but I’ve not been in that group for 29 years and it makes me feel a bit envious at times. Yes I’ve got friends from postings but it’s not the same.

We’re just about to move again because DH is retiring from the military and has a new job that isn’t really commutable from where we are. I don’t want to go. It’s great when you’re moving for work and you have a job to be in all day, it’s not so great when you don’t or can’t work. A support network isn’t just friends and family either. I’m chronically sick. I’ve got a wonderful relationship with my GP and my hospital consultants who know me and my conditions well. So I don’t blame the school mum for not wanting to move.

It’s all well and good moving people who need social housing out of London but what will happen when there’s vacancies to be filled in the traditionally lower paid jobs and everyone has gone because they couldn’t afford to stay?

AngelDelight28 · 27/09/2021 16:46

@Sciurus83 I agree. I've had to move several times to where the work is, not always necessarily places I would have chosen to live otherwise. It's like when people complain that they can't buy a house in the exact neighbourhood where they grew up. It isn't a god-given right, and neither is living near your support network, although obviously it's nice if you're able to.

I also don't get the hysteria about "social cleansing". This just isn't a thing in the UK. You either can afford to live somewhere, or you can't. No one is being forced to move out of London, they're merely being 0FFERED social housing elsewhere...because that's where there's housing available. They don't have to take it, they can make their own arrangements to rent privately. If they can't afford that then they have to move to a cheaper area that they CAN afford. That's just life, it's what everyone renting privately or buying their own home has to do.

LobsterNapkin · 27/09/2021 16:42

@EvilPea

It is shit not having that autonomy. People have always not been able to afford certain areas so you’d move to the next town, you’d be a bus ride from your family or short car journey and that would be fine. Now your talking of hours. That’s potentially your free flexible childcare gone. Or you popping in on your aging parents and supporting them gone (so an increase in social care cost).

I privately rent and have never got involved with community stuff as I don’t know how long we can stay in this area.

What does happen when your then priced out of the cheaper area?
What happens to the local residents in the cheaper area as rents rise there?

I don’t know what the answer is. It is realistic, but it’s also shit.

Yes, this is a bigger problem that goes back to the mobile workforce. The mobile workforce is mainly a benefit to big business owners as they can move labour around where it's easiest and cheapest.

Overall it's not great for communities and the people in them. While they can absorb some movement, when there is too much the support networks that could take in newcomers start to fail altogether.

This entails a need for additional support in families, especially where there are two workers. And that support either has to be paid for by the workers - which means salaries need to reflect that. Or, it means they have to be paid for by the state, through taxes - this is very much the preference of business of course, it's like a subsidy for their wages.

Every time families need to move away from support systems there are costs in terms of things like eldercare, youth programming, etc.

We're pretty well committed to the mobile workforce now, but when people have to move so far their support system is gone just to afford housing, when they are still in the same jobs it's just stupid. It also means the state paying for more infrastructure like public transport and roads, pollution mitigation, etc.

YouTubeAddict · 27/09/2021 16:40

I hate all these people who moan and grumble and The System isn’t supporting them enough. We own a house but are moving 80 miles away because a house of the size and calibre in our present city would be about another £150k. Sometimes, you just have to cut your cloth and it’s the same whether you own or rent.

Zotter · 27/09/2021 16:39

@AnneLovesGilbert

This sort of cleansing has been going on for years in London, moving the poor out of area. Only the rich are welcome.

What’s the answer?

Government to build more social housing, stock incredibly depleted. A Conservative govt will not though as against their ideology.