Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these changes to the housing waiting list are not “cruel” but simply realistic?

492 replies

Eastie77Returns · 27/09/2021 13:49

Our council has announced changes to the local housing waiting list from next month. There are tens of thousands on the list who will never be housed as they are not deemed to be in urgent need so they will now be removed.

The council has said they will be offered “personalised support to explore their options” which probably means advising they leave London, advances to help with private rent etc. I understand in many cases that is really not helpful but a close relative of mine who works in housing has been on the phone to me in tears because of the level of abuse she has faced from frustrated residents who have been on the list for years and are being removed.

Now a parent from DD’s school is organising a march on the town hall to protest all of this and has asked parents for support. She has been offered a council house 100+ miles outside London and is refusing to leave as her support network is here and I fully understand that. However, I do think a dose of realism is needed. There are 15,000 people on the waiting list here and a few hundred council properties become available each year. This parent has been told she does not fall into the 3 bands that will be kept on the list so she will never get a council house and she has responded by accusing the council of unimaginable cruelty Confused

I don’t understand where she expects the council to magically just find thousands of homes and change that situation?

OP posts:
MakingM · 27/09/2021 17:57

Tbh, YABU.

A council should not be artificially cutting its waiting list because it has decided it won’t be able to house everyone. Councils should want to know how many people in their area want or need more secure and affordable housing so that they can plan to provide it - and the easiest way of gauging this is by having a waiting list for affordable, secure housing. Sounds like they are trying to hide their heads in the sand tbh.

And, no, no one should have to move 100 miles to find an affordable home.

The reality is London will find itself running into difficulty with recruiting key workers if it doesn’t get to grip with its housing problem, as will other places.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 27/09/2021 17:54

I can understand why people who have been on any waiting list for years and are now being removed might be pissed off. If they'd known waiting on the list was pointless then they could have been making other plans rather than hanging on.

I don't get the idea that you have a god given right to live in any particular place, if you can't afford it you can't afford it. Many of us have moved away from family, to towns/countries where we knew nobody for a work promotion or first step on a career ladder, or for Uni.

RedToothBrush · 27/09/2021 17:52

I think tenancy for life is ridiculous and at the expense of those who also need that break. It should be outlawed.

In terms of 'can't move out cos I need support' what about anyone else who is in private accomodation or who own their own home who are priced out and don't have the luxury of this?

I can understand the argument being put forward about needing to stay in London for certain jobs which provide a critical role, and they should be prioritised to stay in London.

But if you haven't got that as a reason, and its only for social reasons - even if thats support, then no I don't think its a fair justification to think you get priority over everyone else who has to make those kind of tough decisions.

Clocktopus · 27/09/2021 17:51

Tenants would also quickly learn what would get them "moved on" meaning tenants would "stagnate" for want of a better word. Because keeping a roof over your head is number one priority.

This is another reason why councils encourage long term tenancies and don't reassess circumstances. If you knew that you would be evicted if your income went over a certain level then where is your incentive to progress at work and to climb the ladder? Your children are settled in school, you have roots in the community, you are happy in your home, why would you take that promotion if you knew it meant losing all of that?

Clocktopus · 27/09/2021 17:48

I agree tenancy for life is ridiculous. It's social housing why should you just be allowed to stay there forever. I'm afraid if you want to benefit from state subsidised housing you don't get to choose where that is

It's not subsidised.

Councils and Housing Associations want longterm tenants because they want people to build communities and all that goes alongside with that, people who will put down roots, take pride in their home and their area. They don't want a lot transient/short term tenants because it goes against that idea.

Social housing is for anyone who meets the criteria for that particular Local Authority l, how long you'll wait will depend both on your need and that area. My entire street is social housing in a nice area, none of us were on the list for longer than a few months, all of us bid on the properties we are in so took them by choice, and all of us have at least one adult in the house who is working with me and Mrs Next Door being exception but our husbands both work. The only person under-occupying is the very elderly lady on the corner but she has lived in her two-bed house since 1953, likely couldn't cope with a move, and she has occasional overnight carers who use the second bedroom so a one-bed would be no use to her anyway. We don't all live in ghettos while claiming all the benefits, you know.

bobsholi · 27/09/2021 17:43

It's devastating not being able to live within even 100 miles of where your children have gone to school, where your friends and family are and where your job is. I was born in London and it's where my roots are. It's my home yet I can't afford to live there so we moved to another of the country. Funnily enough, the locals in this part of the country get a great deal of sympathy for not being able to afford homes. It's just Londoners that are selfish and entitled for wanting to live in the place that they've grown up in and put down roots Hmm

Rosebel · 27/09/2021 17:43

They made this situation. They should never have sold off council houses and those in a council house should be reassed every few years.
It's ridiculous that a single person or couple can stay in a 3 bed council house after their children have moved out and even if they can afford to rent privately.
If they had a decent system in place there wouldn't be so many problems.

ShinyThingsDistractMe · 27/09/2021 17:43

Because a secured tenancy is better long term for housing and the tenants mental health. Otherwise you might as well just call all social housing stock "temporary accommodation".

You would be saying to some of the most poorest people "your housing isn't secure". Change anything to better yourself and you are out on your ear.

This also leads to tenants not taking care of social housing stock "because it's not forever". So I'm not improving or caring for it.

Tenants would also quickly learn what would get them "moved on" meaning tenants would "stagnate" for want of a better word. Because keeping a roof over your head is number one priority.

You don't build communities and policing/ securing mass estates where tenancy is fleeting would be a nightmare with "temporary accommodation".

Social Housing was always for those who could not afford to buy or let from reputable landlords. And to a certain extent they still are. Low income families and elderly/disabled.

For instance mass amounts of our housing stock was built in 1919 post WW1 as "homes for heroes". The city demolished the slums and moved the Tennant's to "park estates" where health outcomes were better, schooling and communities were born. Children had better outcomes in these garden estates than they did in slums where cholera was rife and childhood illness.

It's an industrial town, so if you weren't tenanted working in the copper works you were in the slums. If you weren't gentry and land owning/house owning you were in the slums.

Tenancies for life are crucial for communities, they are crucial for children who live in these houses. Children with parents with secured accommodation have better outcomes.

Ylvamoon · 27/09/2021 17:41

I think if you have to rely on the council to house you and you are unable to work but perfectly healthy, you need to take what you are given. Even if it's 100's of miles away.

It's shit to move away from friends/ family but unfortunately we just can't make social housing re-appear after it has been sold.
Building more is great, but again, in a city like London there is a slight space issue. New (social) housing will be built in outskirts or in run down areas marked for redevelopment. People on housing lists will have to move areas as the population grows.

AngelDelight28 · 27/09/2021 17:36

@Upamountain43 Yeah that worked so well in communist countries, forcibly taking away people's property.

MercyBooth · 27/09/2021 17:28

If owning your own home is not a privileged position to be in then give it up and rent. Then you can have the same privileges yeah?

ComtesseDeSpair · 27/09/2021 17:27

I think the single biggest thing the government could do to relieve poverty and provide some security in the UK is a massive expansion of social housing. And before people start with the 'we can't afford it' bollocks, housing generates rent, how do you think so many buy to let landlords got rich?

Housing might generate rent, but social rents are too low to provide a sustainable business model for obtaining lending in parts of the country where land is expensive. Over 20 years, a standard loan term for development, the average one-bedroom unit in a London borough will generate around £125,000 in rent. It costs far in excess of that to develop the unit in the first place, which is why social units are cross-subsidised with shared ownership and outright sale properties.

sst1234 · 27/09/2021 17:26

@flippertyop

I agree tenancy for life is ridiculous. It's social housing why should you just be allowed to stay there forever. I'm afraid if you want to benefit from state subsidised housing you don't get to choose where that is
This is the bit that people simply cannot answer when complaining about social housing situation. If you are not reliant on social housing, you cannot pick and choose like those wanting subsidized housing in London want to. Basically, if you pay for your own housing, you do not have the privilege that London social housing tenants seem to be demanding. It’s bizarre and makes no sense.
MercyBooth · 27/09/2021 17:25

Some of these attitudes here are what led to Grenfell

www.theguardian.com/society/2018/jun/02/doreen-lawrence-grenfell-tenants-faced-institutional-indifference

gogohm · 27/09/2021 17:24

I have very limited sympathy for those having to move away because like many I did to afford a decent home for my family. I grew up in south London, my brothers and I have all left. If you are not working (for whatever reason, I'm not judging) then expect to be housed somewhere cheaper, only those in key occupations should be prioritised for housing where there's a huge shortage.

Some parts of the country have lots of houses (and few jobs - that's an idea, incentivise businesses to move!)

Rhubarbsoup · 27/09/2021 17:23

The ideal would be for social housing to be expanded, but as sadly that is very unlikely to happen, it does seem pointless having people lingering on a waiting list for decades.

MercyBooth · 27/09/2021 17:23

Perfectly good social housing has been pulled down and replaced with less SH and more expensive housing. Its all in the book i mentioned.

Dont let it get in the way of your prejudices though. These attitudes are why i never bought the "all in this together" bollocks with regards to Covid. What they really meant was that we should protect our "betters"

Rhubarbsoup · 27/09/2021 17:22

@Powertothepetal

This sort of cleansing has been going on for years in London, moving the poor out of area. Only the rich are welcome. Look at Grenfell, they knew the cladding was hazardous but didn’t care and when it all burnt down hardly any, if any, of those residents were rehoused in London.
Actually all of them were offered housing in London, just not all in the same Borough so some declined. The same cladding was used on many buildings across the country, and is a national scandal and tragedy. Misinformation doesn't help, but I do think someone or various people should have been accountable for Grenfell, and punished accordingly.
Viviennemary · 27/09/2021 17:21

I don't agree with social housing except for people who can't manage. It encourages dependency and entitlement. And certainly not for folk who can afford to buy their own homes. Why should brand new houses be built for social tenants.

ComtesseDeSpair · 27/09/2021 17:19

@MercyBooth

Really? I think the bidding process is inhumane. Cant win though can they. Because they also get moaned at for having a smartphone to do the bidding on.
Choice Based Lettings were introduced under Labour as best practice, because they provided at least some illusion that people had a choice in where they might want to live. Formerly, in most council areas, you reached the top of the list and were just allocated whichever property of the correct size was available, with little thought given to whether it was near your place of work or children’s school etc. That was generally thought to be inhumane and ignorant of people’s needs.
NailsNeedDoing · 27/09/2021 17:19

It’s a sad situation, but it’s not cruel. Plenty of people who own their own houses in London and other expensive areas are having to watch as their children, friends and family members move away because they can’t afford to live in the area they grew up in. It’s normality now. Living in London has become a privilege, so if someone is in a situation where they’ve been offered subsidised housing in London and turned it down, I can’t find much sympathy at them having to move away.

I think the single biggest thing the government could do to relieve poverty and provide some security in the UK is a massive expansion of social housing. And before people start with the 'we can't afford it' bollocks, housing generates rent, how do you think so many buy to let landlords got rich?

I agree we need more social housing, but it’s not bollocks that we can’t afford it. Buy to let landlords quite often don’t make any profit until they sell their properties because they have mortgage, tax and maintenance expenses to pay for. The profit only comes from a sale after house prices have continued going crazy for a few years, in the meantime it can make no profit or make losses, but that’s why people do it as a (risky) retirement plan. Even then they can only do it by charging market rate, if they charged social housing rent there’s no way they’d ever generate profits. Unless the government plan to build a whole load of social houses to eventually sell off, it can only cost taxpayers to build large amounts of social housing, it will never pay for itself.

flippertyop · 27/09/2021 17:18

I agree tenancy for life is ridiculous. It's social housing why should you just be allowed to stay there forever. I'm afraid if you want to benefit from state subsidised housing you don't get to choose where that is

Hogwarts4Christmas · 27/09/2021 17:16

What started this was the right to buy, which both the Tories and Labour have endorsed, and no one seems strong enough to abolish, although it should be stopped.

Same with tenancy for life; it shouldn't be allowed. SH should be kept for those in need; not their dependants, etc, and if circumstances improve they should have to move into private housing.

MovingSchmoving · 27/09/2021 17:16

As someone has already said upthread, the issue is that once you have “won” a council house you can keep it for as long as you like, even if the reasons that you initially qualified are no longer applicable. Eg. Children grow up and leave home, previously vulnerable people are no longer characterised as such, etc. There should be a review every 5 years to see whether people still fit the criteria. Otherwise there is no incentive for people to ever leave and move back into the private rental market. This was sort of the idea behind the bedroom tax, that it would incentivise people who were living in properties bigger than they really needed to move to smaller places and free up space for families etc. It was just a massive shit show and didn’t actually work in practice.

zafferana · 27/09/2021 17:14

Of course it's realistic. Not everyone can live where they want and that includes people who require council properties. Those of us who pay for our own housing outright, with no subsidy, have to live where we can afford to live and it should be the same for council tenants. No one has 'the right' to live anywhere. Just because you were born in London doesn't mean you can afford to stay there. That's life and anyone who thinks differently is an entitled arse IMO.